Firearms...the original multi tool?
-
Different countries have different laws and different constitutions (and interpretations of them)- Unless they join an international convention etc. on a topic/issue whatever is legal or illegal in another country does not matter. People vote for their governments and are thus in general agreement/responsible with/for their current policies.
A common assumption, by many posters, seems to be that MTO is US based or that most posters here live in the US (possibly), like for example Bladeforums.
It is unusual for a dominant forum on tools/knives etc. not to be under US ownership.
Usually we end up with US posters being shocked at UK laws and trying to guide them on what to do. I lived in the UK for many years, and never felt like I was being oppressed or that the laws needed to be drastically changed. This is true, from my experience, in many countries.
-
@dks said:
Usually we end up with US posters being shocked at UK laws and trying to guide them on what to do. I lived in the UK for many years, and never felt like I was being oppressed or that the laws needed to be drastically changed. This is true, from my experience, in many countries.dks, it's not clear to me that everyone is currently happy with the firearm (or knife) laws in his or her own country. I hear rumblings. So, I'm not sure I'm buying your picture of domestic bliss with local laws.
Many US citizens are not happy with the current set of firearm laws we have here. It is something we like to fight about. The USA was founded with human rights and the rights of citizenship as it's primary focus. Most other nations were not so established. I suspect this is one reason we like to squabble over rights so much; it's in our national DNA.
I'm sure most people are capable of adapting to their local laws, true. Perhaps over time, that becomes the new normal. Normal often seems 'right'. Here in the US , many of us think the RTKBA is 'right' as well as being a right. You'll have to forgive us our perspectives.
Shocked? I don't know. But when normally sensible countries start restricting the ability of a citizen to carry a multitool with OHO or locking blades.....yes, that does raise an eyebrow here. To us it does indeed seem absurd. When countries start restricting the import of OHO knives by classifying a 'tool' as a 'weapon', again, it is worrisome. But, yes, you are right, that might just be me being a provincial 'American.' Arrogant smurfs, aren't we?
-
Population density is key I think. The more people you have crammed into a small space, the more laws you need to keep them satisfied, partially due to news media making uncommon things seem common.
-
Usually we end up with US posters being shocked at UK laws and trying to guide them on what to do. I lived in the UK for many years, and never felt like I was being oppressed or that the laws needed to be drastically changed. This is true, from my experience, in many countries.
dks, it's not clear to me that everyone is currently happy with the firearm (or knife) laws in his or her own country. I hear rumblings. So, I'm not sure I'm buying your picture of domestic bliss with local laws.
Many US citizens are not happy with the current set of firearm laws we have here. It is something we like to fight about. The USA was founded with human rights and the rights of citizenship as it's primary focus. Most other nations were not so established. I suspect this is one reason we like to squabble over rights so much; it's in our national DNA.
I'm sure most people are capable of adapting to their local laws, true. Perhaps over time, that becomes the new normal. Normal often seems 'right'. Here in the US , many of us think the RTKBA is 'right' as well as being a right. You'll have to forgive us our perspectives.
Shocked? I don't know. But when normally sensible countries start restricting the ability of a citizen to carry a multitool with OHO or locking blades.....yes, that does raise an eyebrow here. To us it does indeed seem absurd. When countries start restricting the import of OHO knives by classifying a 'tool' as a 'weapon', again, it is worrisome. But, yes, you are right, that might just be me being a provincial 'American.' Arrogant smurfs, aren't we?
Let's be careful that this does not become a US VS the World thread. It has remained civil and sensible so far, and I don't see any reason for that to change.
You are correct about the OHO and locking blade laws, but then, let's not forget that the US has banned Kinder eggs for being too dangerous, and California allows automatic weapons but not double edged blades. From a certain perspective, any place can seem oppressive, especially when the view you are getting is from the media. Given that we have a huge international representation here, I would think we should put more stock in the perception of members here than in what we see on TV.
Def
-
Many members have views on many other countries - we just choose not to discuss them here. The same with internal discussions within countries.
)
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
... let's not forget that the US has banned Kinder eggs for being too dangerous, and California allows automatic weapons but not double edged blades.
California's laws worry me far, far more than those of Japan or Lithuania. :ahhh
But, now you mention it, most states permit ownership of automatic weapons (with a Federal Tax stamp). California doesn't....there may be some exceptions possible.
California doesn't actually prohibit the ownership or carry of a double edged knife. It does, like most states, prohibit the concealed carry of a "dirk or dagger". Any such weapon must be worn openly.
Here in Montana, you can carry or conceal whatever you want.....with the exception of a "switchblade". I suspect that the switchblade definition will be challenged at some point (no pun intended). And, of course, here in Montana we can own full-auto firearms.
-
I don’t think that it’s a coincidence that Cali has more people than Montana.

-
A lot more people.
-
@Don Pablo said:
I don’t think that it’s a coincidence that Cali has more people than Montana.

That goes all the way back to the goldrush days. Thousands of people were sure they would get rich in California.
Thanks.

But what I mean is that: greater population density=more laws. IMHO of course. -
@Don Pablo said:
@Don Pablo said:
I don’t think that it’s a coincidence that Cali has more people than Montana.

That goes all the way back to the goldrush days. Thousands of people were sure they would get rich in California.
Thanks.

But what I mean is that: greater population density=more laws. IMHO of course.Agreed, that is why I contend that more than 2 people for 100 square miles constitutes overpopulation.

-
Just some information about 'firearm multi tools' that some may interesting and others may be looking at it thinking 'I need one of those'. AR-15 multi tool Features: Broken shell extractor, Wire brush for bore cleaning, Ampule for oil for one field lube, Cable to pull the brush through the bore, Carbon scraping tool, Flat blade screwdriver, Feed lip adjustment tool, Gas key cleaning tool, Cotter pin hook, Strike Plate, Front sight adjustment tool, Magazine feed lip gauge.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/QwreaG" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4840/31849541838_f8b87369f9_q.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>firearmmultitool_01 by Grandpa Patch, on Flickr
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/QwreaS" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4903/31849541848_d17d451f4d_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>firearmmultitool_02 by Grandpa Patch, on Flickr
-

<a href="https://flic.kr/p/NU1jGg" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4882/30780932007_c0ede910dc_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>firearmnultitool_03 by Grandpa Patch, on FlickrThis is a excerpt from 19th century 9lb, 100-blade multitool with a pistol
The Smithsonian acquired the knife in 1986 after it was donated by James F. Parker. While alive, Parker was well known in knife collection circles—he owned his own cutlery company and served as the first president of the Knife Collectors Association. Miller says the first time he saw the object he couldn’t believe it was real. “I was particularly impressed with the revolver,” he recalls. “If you bring this knife to a gunfight, you’re OK.” -
I have a few AR multitools in my collection...but no AR rifles...go figure.
I do know that the Canadian government is considering a handgun ban. That would kill IPSC in a heart beat...not to mention a big financial loss for folks like me. Waiting to see which way the wind will blow. I do know a lot of wrong assertions on how criminals get their illegal handguns were bandied about whenever Toronto gang members get press time whenever they shoot a firearm.
-
I'd be disappointed if Canada banned handguns.
I've never carried a handgun into Canada, but I sometimes entertain dreams of flying to remote bear-infested territory to fish and camp. I know bear-spray is the preferred defense, but I have more faith in a well-placed .44 round.
There was an incident nearby, a few miles to the South-East of me, where a grizzly attacked a bow hunter. He carried bear-spray, but, in pulling it out, the can got turned around and he shot himself in the face.
At least he didn't see what was coming.
He did survive his mauling, and now is planning on making some adjustments to his pepper spray carry.
It's a toss up for me which will be more effective. I went out hiking yesterday and carried only bear spray. When I go out hiking, hunting, or fishing with my buddy, he carries bear-spray, I carry a .44. I'm seriously hoping we 1) never run into a cranky griz, 2) he deters it with a blast of pepper spray, and 3) I ignore my soiled pants long enough to shoot the bear cleanly.
The few encounters I've had with bears, I haven't had enough time to use either bear spray or a handgun. I think they were more freaked out by me than I was by them. (And, yes, I do shower regularly.) So, maybe it's mostly a moot point. But I'd feel better if I at least had the choice to carry a handgun when out chasing wild trout or salmon.
-

<a href="https://flic.kr/p/2byLnKy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4826/45003046194_c03d522b5d_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>Apache_revolver by Grandpa Patch, on FlickrMore information about the Apache pistol is available via Wikipedia.
-
That is a good thing Nix. Your handgun would never cross the boarder with you. Up here, you can only use them at a qualified range. You cannot bring a handgun into the wilderness unless you meet stringent requirements such as being a professional trapper. Reason why very short shotguns carrying slugs are very popular among the outdoor crowds. Oddly enough, our shotgun laws are laxer then those of the US. In Canada, you are allowed to carry a 9 inch shotgun for wildlife protection. :salute:
-
Another amusing difference between the US and Canada is being able to ship a knife. In the US you are required to ship a firearm through a bonded courier to a firearms dealer in the recipient's area, at which point they have to go to the dealer and show appropriate identification, licensing etc. In Canada I can mail someone a pistol directly... through Canada Post.
Maybe for not much longer, but it is currently legal.
Def
-
@Nix said:
**
There was an incident nearby, a few miles to the South-East of me, where a grizzly attacked a bow hunter. He carried bear-spray, but, in pulling it out, the can got turned around and he shot himself in the face.At least he didn't see what was coming.
**well, bear ( :D) in mind that if that bow hunter had carried and grabbed a handgun, and the gun got turned around, he'd have shot himself in the face and he'd be dead now, but he is alive today, so maybe he in *partifular *was better carrying a spray can than a gun

PS: that ^^^^ is meant as a joke
-
@Chako said:
That is a good thing Nix. Your handgun would never cross the boarder with you. Up here, you can only use them at a qualified range. You cannot bring a handgun into the wilderness unless you meet stringent requirements such as being a professional trapper. Reason why very short shotguns carrying slugs are very popular among the outdoor crowds. Oddly enough, our shotgun laws are laxer then those of the US. In Canada, you are allowed to carry a 9 inch shotgun for wildlife protection.
I thought it was more permissive. (Maybe it was?) I once looked into for a motorcycle trip. Back then....you could file paperwork with customs in advance and get a temporary permit. And the barrel had to be....4" or more....or something like like.
Bummer.
Digging through the website, it looks like a visitor could not even borrow a shotgun for purposes of self-defense in the wilderness while fishing.
Looks like visitors need to depend on the forbearance of the bears.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







