The Great Burgers thread....you'll need a napkin....
-
@Nix said:
Mrs Nix loves a good burger....but she usually takes her burger without a bun. Who am I to gainsay her?
(Although, this does raise the tricky issue of trying to establish a difference between a bunless burger and the old* Salisbury Steak*. I may be inviting disaster here, but let's consider the bun classic, but optional, especially for the wheat-intolerant.)
What about a Patty Melt ;)
-
Yep... Stevey you are indeed Scottish, aren't you. A patty melt is pretty much what you get in any Scottish pub if you ask for a burger.

-
Mrs Nix loves a good burger....but she usually takes her burger without a bun. Who am I to gainsay her?

(Although, this does raise the tricky issue of trying to establish a difference between a bunless burger and the old* Salisbury Steak*. I may be inviting disaster here, but let's consider the bun classic, but optional, especially for the wheat-intolerant.)
What about a Patty Melt ;)
Who doesn't love a patty melt? :ahhh
But I'd call that a variation of a burger.Now, if you guys want to insist that a burger must include a bun....I'm open to tightening the rules up. I think we'd need at least three members to say "A burger must include a bun". And, I'm going to disqualify Blackbeard from being one of those three members since, as the only active challenger, he has a conflict of interest.
-
Well... if I asked for a burger in any decent self-respecting greasy spoon cafe and it didn't come in a bun, I'd be pretty disappointed. So, I say bun.
-
If you wanted to order a burger without a bun....how would you do it?

Certainly it's reasonable to have the expectation of a bun....or some sort of holding device. But that doesn't necessarily mean a burger without a bun isn't a burger.....
-
Yeah, but, if you asked for a burger and it didn't...
-
Well, I'm afraid the debate is over.....
Mrs Nix has resorted to the nuclear option.
As she has a personal view on this matter, and generally prefers a "No Bun Burger" (see additional posts below), she has unilaterally declared that meat or veggie patties served without buns shall be considered "Burgers" for the purposes of this contest.
You guys don't want to be on Mrs Nix's list. So the current rules stand. Sea Monster, your burger is admissible (assuming you've met the other requirements. ;))
(And Fuzzy, you are now on her list. I tried to defend you, but....sorry...you're on The List.)
-
Well... I'm going to have to confer with Mrs Fuzzy about this, which means waking her up, she ain't going to be happy about that, just saying... This could well turn into something nasty...
-
Blackbeard’s post pretty much covered the tutorial I was going to write. If you are worried you can’t make a great burger, re-read his post above. I thought I’d add a few small tips to what he said, for those who are just getting started.
I’m no chef, and can only offer up what I do, so take my advice with a grain of salt.* (Sorry, couldn't be helped.)* We do have some talented cooks in our midst, and I hope they will chime in here and offer improvements to my techniques or corrections to any misinformation I may inadvertently pass along.
The burger I made this evening is about as simple a burger as I make—I don’t think it gets much easier. Still, it tasted great!
Making a burger is no more complicated than 1) forming a patty, 2) cooking a patty, and 3) putting said patty on a bun (or not). Nevertheless, there are few ways to make a better burger:
Beef is the classic meat for a burger, use what ever you want, but some meat with some fat in it will make for a tastier and juicier burger. An 80% lean is great, 85% lean is fine, 90% lean can start to get dry.
Fresh ground beef is the best. I’m using regular beef out of the meat case here, but you may get your butcher to grind some meat for you. Either chuck or a chuck and brisket blend works well for me.
Keep your ground beef cold. This is contrary to the usual advice for grilling a steak where it’s better to let the steak come up to room temperature. With burgers, keep your meat cold until it hits the heat. This way it won’t lose fat or juices.
In general, when forming up the patties, try to use a light touch. This isn’t bread, you don’t need to knead it or mash it. Gently coax the patties together and shape them to the size you like. Here are my patties, honestly I think they got a bit overworked, but they turned out just fine:

Note that with these patties, I tried to make the center a bit thinner or cupped. As the burgers cook, they will shrink and puff up a bit and even out on their own.
It’s a good idea to form up the burger patties and then put them back in the refrigerator for 30-60 minutes. This lets the newly formed patties come together and set up. This will help keep your burger from falling apart in the pan or on the grill.
In general (there are exceptions), I don’t season my burgers until right before they go on to the grill or into the pan. With steak, you definitely see some benefits from pre-seasoning. With burgers, you’ll get a better crust if you season at the last minute. But do season, at least with salt!
Here my patties have just come out of a 30-minute rest in the fridge. They got sprinkled with salt (nothing else!) and are going to go into the pan.

I like using a cast iron pan, but use what you have. I like a medium-high heat. You want to have that burger start to sizzle when it hits the pan. I put a little butter (olive oil works well , too) in the pan and it immediately started sizzling and started to brown: time to get those burgers in!

In the above photo you can see the one burger is sizzling nicely. The other not as much. Don’t be tempted to mash down on the burger! You’ll only squeeze the good juices out.
Instead, I moved the pan over a bit to heat the slower burger up, and shifted the slow burger over a bit. After a couple of minutes I also gently rotated the burgers about 180º to ensure even cooking.
Doneness can be hard to judge with a burger. On a hot grill, I’ve found that I only need about 3 minutes a side. It takes a little longer in a skillet. When you start to see clear juices rise up from the top of the meat, that burger is done! Remember, a very thin burger will cook through more quickly than a big fatty.
Some red juices started coming up for me now, so I flipped my burgers over. These have a good crust. That crust comes from a good hot pan and some salt right before they went into the pan.

Again, I started looking for those juice to start coming up (sometimes out the side). The juices were starting to clear, and a poke with the spatula told me the meat had firmed up. Now I put my cheese on (sorry no pic, but you know what cheese looks like.) To help the cheese melt, I put a wok lid over the burgers—the steam formed by those juices will melt the cheese. This step is not needed, but I like to do it.

So that’s it!
Burger done!
Put that lovely cheeseburger on a bun….or not….

Mine: beef burger with American cheese, pickles, onions, and mustard on a ciabatta roll.
Mrs Nix: beef burger with Swiss cheese, catsup and pickles. -
Good infoCan also put a sheet of aluminum foil over the pan to melt the cheese and save on cleaning the lid,
-

*- ...goes to clean wok lid....**
-
I couldn't camera & cook at the same time, but here's my burger.
I forgot about the proof-of-date thing, so you can see a receipt from the shop that bought the ingredients in a photo after I've started eating it, (with my beloved spidey) and a close up of the date.
Bottom left of the burger-shot is the nose of someone who did nothing at all to help, but seemed to feel entitled to reward.
As a concession to the bun crowd, I topped it with a hashbrown.
Burger includes fried egg and beetroot, however I forgot bacon, so it does not meet the standard to be codified as "Australian"
patty is beef, secret spices, egg and coconut flour.



-
That's not a burger!!
Spoiler:
It looks more like heaven to me

-
I'd say it is a burger only because I'm on this cut. But if it ain't I'll have to sacrifice a day
-
Stuff...
... catsup and pickles.
What an excellent post... especially for you Nix!

I woke up Mrs Fuzzy last night and I was right she was pretty angry!... particularly when I told her that you made me do it. Anyway, I asked her about the whole burger bun thing and she reckons that a burgers definitely not a burger without a bun... so there! Now you're on her naughty list!
ps. I agree about the butter thing, it's great for cooking beef. Also, very interesting re info about fat percentages... I didn't know that... thanks...
-
Only one question, Sea Monster: where you able to finish that whole thing off?

Looks fantastic, and I love the inclusion of a fried egg. Growing up, I always heard a cheeseburger + fried egg referred to as a "Truck Burger". Not sure why.

What's the definition of an "Australian Burger"?

Mrs Nix approves of the inclusion of beets and the sensible omission of a bun: you are in!

Burger challengers:
- Blackbeard
- Sea Monster
-
Fuzzy, send Mrs Fuzzbucket over here, please.

I will make her a lovely bunless burger. I'll include a nice glass of cabernet and a side-salad. Perhaps a slice of chocolate cheesecake to finish. (Chocolate cheesecake goes shockingly well with a second glass of cab.) I'm sure she will see the light, and I'll be off the list in just the time it takes her to chew one bite.
However, don't count on her returning to damp and grey Britain with it's soggy buns and flavorless burgers....... just fair warning....
Still, I don't want to stay on her naughty list, do I?Does she have a cheese preference for her burgers?
-
Monterey Jack apparently, I've just asked her.
Also, you pay for the outgoing flight, right and I'll get her the return journey... sound fair?

-
Hmmmm...let's do it the other way 'round. I'll get her return fare....if necessary. :D
Monterey Jack...nice...melts well, mild flavor. A good choice for a burger.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login