A better Leatherman, Tim Leatherman?
-
Thanks for the info

-
@CallsignBadger said:
Thanks for the info

Thanks all...
part 2 tomorrow... -
Edit:
Oh, nevermind

-
Bear Jaws 155 Review (part 2 of 3)
Visually, the 155 is polished to an almost mirror-finish. Turning the 155 in your hands reveals its party-trick; the outside-opening tools. There’s no doubt that this patented feature gives the 155 a real advantage over the PST. While it’s not possible to open a tool with one hand, it’s easy to quickly select and deploy any one, with no handle or plier head to get in the way.
But there are a few unwanted consequences of reversing the C-channel handles to face outwards. The first consideration is that more dirt will enter and get trapped between the tools compared to the PST that closes around its tools. The second consideration relates to the geometry of the tools relative to the plier head. Because the plier head enters the handle on the opposite side to the tools, the 155 needs a stop plate midway inside the handle to prevent the head dropping through the handle and pushing the tools to the outside. These stop plates take up valuable space and are not needed in the PST where the plier head can push up directly against the tools, and everything folds up against the spine of each handle.
The 155 sample I have does not keep a tight closed position, which appears to be a result of the plier pivot-handle geometry. Maybe they fixed this in later versions, or maybe not, as it would require a retool of the head or stamping of the handles. Either way, this is a small design quirk that gives the 155 a little bit character that matches its slightly industrial feel.
Turning our attention to the plier head, it looks like it came out the same factory as the head on the PST, but looks can be deceiving as there are some significant, and possibly critical differences.
The 155 and PST plier heads are both 56mm (2.2in) long, and the profile of the 155’s head is a clear copy of the PST, with near-identical needle-nose, normal pliers and wire cutters design. The 155’s head is slightly narrower (by 0.3mm, 1/100in), because the head has to drop through a gap between the rolled edges of the handle, while the PST has no rolled edge where the head folds back into the handle, so is overall a lot thinner across the handle (11.7mm vs 14.8mm / 0.46in vs. 0.58in).
The 155 has a little more flex visible around the plier’s central pivot under load, more than can be explained by the slightly narrower (lower cross section) design alone. The longer pivots that link the plier head to the handles may be creating additional flexing under gripping load, but it’s also easier to apply much more grip pressure with the 155 because of the wider and more comfortable handles.
While we’re on the handles, the 155 uses standard torx button-head screws to secure the pivots, making user servicing a lot simpler that the knurled rivets Leatherman uses on the PST, and to this day on many of its multi-tools. The plier pivots of the 155 span an outside surface distance of 13.2mm (0.5in), which is a little more that the PST pivots that only need to span a distance of 9.3mm (0.35in), so theoretically, stronger.
Like the Leatherman PST, the 155 has ‘USA’ cast into the plier pivot, but facing outwards. ‘MADE IN USA’ is also stamped into the handle, long before the rule regarding material/component sourcing made this mark a little more difficult to use.
The ruler stampings are clear and sharp, and because of the thicker gauge steel, more stable than those on the PST that tend to distort the surface. Also, the 155’s metric and inch rules are on opposite sides of the handle, making it a lot easier to read off the markings compared to the PST that squeezes both scales on the narrow spine (in my sample).
(…the final part will follow tomorrow)




-
Part 2 was worth the wait and I thank you again for taking the time to do these
Can't wait for part 3 now :ahhh :D -
Nice write up

-
excellent read

-
@ThePeacent said:
excellent read
Thank you all for the feedback. I’m pleased it’s of interest!
-
Very attentive and well written! Thank you, Max!

I'm only saddened that part 3 will be the finale.

-
Great job on this


-
@gerleatherberman said:
Very attentive and well written! Thank you, Max!
I'm only saddened that part 3 will be the finale.


Thank you for taking the time to write this.

-
Very attentive and well written! Thank you, Max!

I'm only saddened that part 3 will be the finale.


Thank you for taking the time to write this.

Yes
:ahhh -
Bear Jaws 155 Review (part 3 of 3)
While Bear MGC changed the handle/plier pivot bolsters in later designs, this early 155 reviewed here features the welded ends that secure the pliers. This is another consequence of the outside-facing C-channel handles, as the plier head would otherwise have nothing to stop against when opening. Bear MGC lapped a short, reversed C-channel section to capture the plier mounting points and provide a hard stop when folding open the multi-tool. The PST has no need for this additional piece of metal, as the spine of the C-channel handle forms the stop, as it does for all similar Leatherman designs.
While the plier heads are close copies, the tool loads are quite different:
Bear Jaws 155 Leatherman PST
PE Knife Yes Yes
SE Knife Yes No
File Yes Yes
Phillips Screwdriver Yes Yes
Small Screwdriver No Yes
Medium Screwdriver Yes Yes
Large Screwdriver Yes Yes
Awl No Yes
Bottle/Tin opener Yes Yes
Lanyard Folding tool Outside on rivetThe folding tool count is 8 on each, however the 155 has the advantage of the wider handle that can accommodate longer tools both sides of the plier head in both handles, while the PST is limited to just one long tool per handle, as the handle only widens asymmetrically on one side.
Comparing the PE blade, they are both near identically shaped clip points 67mm (2.6in) long, although the PST is very slightly thicker. Both hollow-ground, while the PST is better finished with a higher polish. None of the tools lock, however the 155 has the more positive detent – most likely a result of the stronger spring, a consequence of the thicker gauge metal. In fact, Bear MGC added a hole to the handle in later versions to reduce the high spring pressure.
The SE blade on the 155 is a chisel sheepsfoot with combo-edge (a repeating pattern of one wide serration followed by two thinner serrations), a very close match to what’s found on the modern Rebar.
The file appears coated and has a fine pitch, single-cut on one face and one edge, and double-cut on the second face. The tip is squared-off (cut as opposed to stamped-off like the PST). Thickness is about the same in both, around 1.8mm (0.07in).
The 155’s Phillips screwdriver is a serious chunk of cast steel, taking up 7mm (0.27in) of the pivot base and serious overkill. This is a full three times wider than the Phillips on the PST and undoubtably the strongest Phillips driver I’ve seen on any multi-tool, ever. The Phillips tool is so wide, there’s only room for a knife on one side and the tin opener on the other. The tool ‘stack’ is 11.8mm (0.46in) per handle, which is easily a tool width more than the 9.5mm (0.37in) of the PST. Incidentally, the 155 stack is almost the same as the Rebar’s 12mm.
The tin opener is a standard affair, but with a sharply milled edge and sharp tip that will pierce bottle tops. The medium and small screwdrivers are standard 5.3mm and 7.3mm drivers (0.2in and 0.3in), similar to the PST and similar 2.3mm thickness, but the 155’s medium driver has less reach (30mm/1.2in), by 5mm (0.2in). What the 155 lacks is the PST’s small screwdriver that tapers to a tiny 1.8mm (0.07in) blade size, fine enough for glasses.
The 155 is also missing the awl found on the PST. Something they could easily include if they reduce the generous width of the Phillips tool to a more standardized size. Even though Bear & Son continue to manufacture the 155 (in locking 155L format), the features and design remains faithful to the original, and they market it as having 18 functions. But using Leatherman’s more conservative tool count, the 155 has a low 12 tools compared to the PST’s 13 (pre-hardwire notch).
Strangely, Bear MGC saw fit to include a folding lanyard strong enough to lift a small car. The lanyard matches the full internal height of the handle (12.5mm, half-inch), and 2.3mm (0.09in) thick. The lanyard hole is almost 5mm (0.2in) diameter, so with a 4mm steel cable, you could support over one ton of weight on this lanyard! Positioning the 155’s two handles into an ‘L’ makes it a good pulling tool, like you find on some SAK products. By comparison, the PST’s lanyard is a small stamped affair included under one of the knurled rivets, just large enough to take a split-ring. To be honest, probably nothing more than you need. As a side-note, if you open the 155’s lanyard tool and attached a cord or split-ring, the adjacent screwdrivers cannot open fully – oops!
So do I think Bear MGC made a winner? Yes, in its day. The Bear Jaws 155 appears over-engineered with enough tool gaps and escape holes to ignore dirt and grime and keep working. What initially appears to be just a Leatherman clone is clearly an effort to offer an improved product. Stronger, easier to use and more comfortable, yet still immediately identifiable as a full-size tool in the tradition of Tim Leatherman’s first PST.
Now I wonder if Ken and Matt’s current Bear Jaws 155L lives up to its vintage predecessor?
Footnote: Let’s see your Bear If you have one (or more)! What are your impressions?




-
An excellent finale. Thank you again, Max!

It seems Bear addressed two of the issues since the early tools. Added awl instead of SE blade and reasonable lanyard loop that moves far enough out to allow drivers to be used.

Edit:
I should add that Bear shortened the usable area of the file(to save money on machining I guess). The lock levers would be a good system if they would grind the lever tang-bumps down enough to have them level with the handle edges. I may do this to one as an experiment at some point. -
Great read, thanks for sharing!

-
Great series, Max
The review and pics, plus the differences to the PST make this part 3 a really great read
The original Bear Jaws is a great design but dated, I wished they would update this version a bit and find a solution around the unlocking tabs that they use :D if they did this I think that they would still have a winner
I am gonna miss these reads :ahhh are you sure there isn't a part 4 that could start with the Super Bear Jaws
:D -
Excellent information

-
@Poncho65 said:
...I am gonna miss these reads :ahhh are you sure there isn't a part 4 that could start with the Super Bear Jaws
:DThanks Poncho65
I don’t have one I’m afraid! I think I got this example on a USA trip I did many years ago. There are certainly no Bear Jaws agents where I live (South Africa)...they seem to be difficult to find in retail shops even in the US! -
@Max Stone said:
...I am gonna miss these reads :ahhh are you sure there isn't a part 4 that could start with the Super Bear Jaws
:DThanks Poncho65
I don’t have one I’m afraid! I think I got this example on a USA trip I did many years ago. There are certainly no Bear Jaws agents where I live (South Africa)...they seem to be difficult to find in retail shops even in the US!Yes, they are hard to find :ahhh I only know of one place that sells them in store and that is a couple hour drive for me still
I just thought you might happen to have a Super Bear Jaws is the only reason I said that ;) The review was great though and I appreciate the time you took to write them 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login