Any Jeepers out there?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Last week as I was driving down the pier in the freezing rain, alternating between hitting sheer ice and 8-10 inch deep puddles, many of which were hiding potholes and rail lines all I could think of was "smurf I am glad I have a Jeep."
This was largely reinforced in my mind when I saw a car on the back of a flatdeck truck with a completely buckled front suspension and the fender sitting directly on the tire. I was reminded of all the times that I have seen that situation. If normal conditions around here kill IFS in a normal car then I will stick to my solid axles.
Def
Same here. Lorries don't have IFS, do they?

Most pickups nowadays have IFS, but I have yet to see any of them fail. Still, I will take a solid axle any day of the week. The front end of my Jeep would have been on the ground long ago if it had IFS.
And no, most vans don't come standard with a solid axle, nor do they usually come as a 4x4, but luckily there are kits for both, and they usually go hand in hand. That's why I'd be looking for a used van versus a new one, as I would end up spending a lot more money once I got it.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Last week as I was driving down the pier in the freezing rain, alternating between hitting sheer ice and 8-10 inch deep puddles, many of which were hiding potholes and rail lines all I could think of was "smurf I am glad I have a Jeep."
This was largely reinforced in my mind when I saw a car on the back of a flatdeck truck with a completely buckled front suspension and the fender sitting directly on the tire. I was reminded of all the times that I have seen that situation. If normal conditions around here kill IFS in a normal car then I will stick to my solid axles.
Def
Same here. Lorries don't have IFS, do they?

Most pickups nowadays have IFS, but I have yet to see any of them fail. Still, I will take a solid axle any day of the week. The front end of my Jeep would have been on the ground long ago if it had IFS.
And no, most vans don't come standard with a solid axle, nor do they usually come as a 4x4, but luckily there are kits for both, and they usually go hand in hand. That's why I'd be looking for a used van versus a new one, as I would end up spending a lot more money once I got it.
Def
I'm not talking about pickups; I'm talking about commercial trucks. My point is that there's a reason they don't have IFS. I have seen IFS fail. Solid axles last longer, are more rugged and work much better offroad.
-
100% agreed.

Def
-
IFS strikes again!
Def

-
You do have a VW golf too, right Grant ? :)
-
Nope.
I used to, back when I also had a wife.
The difference is mass- a Jeep has a lot more of it than a Golf. The Jeep is somewhere in the neighborhood of 4,400lbs versus the Golf which is under 3,000lbs. The difference in the impact of hitting a pothole at 100kms/hr with almost 1,500lbs in the difference is significant. IMHO, they can only barely make IFS strong enough for a small car, but they would have to scale it up exponentially for my Jeep. At that point, why bother, why not just put in a solid axle instead? There would be no weight savings by the time they made a strong enough IFS.
Further, I have a paranoia that IFS can potentially cause a lot more damage to valuable engine and drive line components. Look at this diagram I lifted from a Hilux site:

With a solid front axle your precious engine is always off the ground. If you bottom out your suspension it just means that the chassis hits the axle and stays off the harsh and unfriendly rocks.The fragile mechanical bits will never be lower than your axle, unless of course you have a serious mechanical issue, in which case you aren't driving home anyway.
The same situation with IFS can potentially allow things like your soft and easily destroyed oil pan to hit the ground. That seems like a really bad thing, and it's not really limited to off road concerns.
:D
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Nope.I used to, back when I also had a wife.
The difference is mass- a Jeep has a lot more of it than a Golf. The Jeep is somewhere in the neighborhood of 4,400lbs versus the Golf which is under 3,000lbs. The difference in the impact of hitting a pothole at 100kms/hr with almost 1,500lbs in the difference is significant. IMHO, they can only barely make IFS strong enough for a small car, but they would have to scale it up exponentially for my Jeep. At that point, why bother, why not just put in a solid axle instead? There would be no weight savings by the time they made a strong enough IFS.
Further, I have a paranoia that IFS can potentially cause a lot more damage to valuable engine and drive line components. Look at this diagram I lifted from a Hilux site:

With a solid front axle your precious engine is always off the ground. If you bottom out your suspension it just means that the chassis hits the axle and stays off the harsh and unfriendly rocks.The fragile mechanical bits will never be lower than your axle, unless of course you have a serious mechanical issue, in which case you aren't driving home anyway.
The same situation with IFS can potentially allow things like your soft and easily destroyed oil pan to hit the ground. That seems like a really bad thing, and it's not really limited to off road concerns.
:D
Def
Solid axles also have much better articulation, which might not be important onroad but is very important offroad. And by offroad I mean seriously rough terrain; not just dirt roads. -
:D
Def

-
:o

-
Don't knock IFS completely! I would not want one for what I do off-road, but they are very well proven in off-road racing.

-
Unfortunately most road going vehicles are not overbuilt like a racer like that- and those are not built with longevity in mind either!
Plus the average driver can't afford the level of maintenance that something like that receives! :P
Def
-
I have had IFS on all the vehicles I have used a lot off road, since the early 90s, with no issues. They were all Japanese, so that helped. (Isuzu, Mitsubishi) Skid plates help. Avoiding to crash too quickly onto things also helps
IRS is a pain but it seems to be popular with new offroaders, so they must have it under control in some way.
The only solid front axle smaller vehicles we see here are old LR and G-Wagen, but there are very few around and even fewer go offroad (mainly used by the army or rich Russians) you also see some older toyota pickups (bone shakers).
The main offrad vehicle here is the Mitsubishi Pajero 1st and 2nd generation, with some Nissans
-
Popular Mechanics seems to think the 4 cylinder turbo diesel is pretty good:
Here's the Best $1,000 You Can Spend When You Buy a Jeep Wrangler
The new turbo four-cylinder is the best Wrangler powerplant yet.
Popular Mechanics (www.popularmechanics.com)
I have to wonder if it is good enough to justify the cost, given that diesel (here at least) is about 20% more expensive than gas?
Def
-
Or you could swap in an Isuzu 4 cylinder for much cheaper if you can pull it off well

-
I think if I was going to go to the effort and expense of an engine swap I'd probably put in something better, like a Hemi.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login