Any love for the Craftsman?
-
@Kamakiri - Pretty confused with your posts mate
In the Wiki - The main factors for distinguishing separate pages is:
- Toolset
- Length
Currently we have pages for:
A. Master Craftsman - A 91mm five layer SAK - That is a Ranger with Phillips not corkscrew
B. Craftsman - A 91mm six layer SAK - That adds one layer to the Master Craftsman (hence my comment) had a tool change (fish scaler --> pliers) around 85
C. Master Craftsman Small - A 84mm five layer SAK - That is the 84mm version of the 91mm MCWe also refer to the Space Shuttle and Astronaut variations - which as they had the same toolset share these pages
- And I agree the naming and dates here is a bit confusing - If you can clarify (see comment below) - Great
In the WIki we usually, or at least often, refer to the corresponding 84mm/91mm version in 'Related Tools' section of the 91mm/84mm page
- Although not in this case - So that is easily fixed
We rarely refer to the old numbering system eg 136k - Which we probably should - This can be updated over time.
We also know that Victorinox did not always use the descriptive names and often re-used some descriptive names
- And we also know that some importers and/or markets gave the models different names....
Both of which of course are quite confusing when looking back over time and across the globe.
*.............. All of this is explained in the Wiki
Are you saying these pages are incomplete / not correct ? ???
@kamakiri said:
It never was. At any point in production history, it was bigger than the Craftsman (mistakenly called an Artisan). Literally bigger when you consider it was 84mm and the Master Craftsman was 91mm. <u>All</u> the US catalogs support this thinking, back to the early 50's. And I suspect earlier.Are you saying there was no six-layer 91mm Craftsman and it was always 84mm
Because if so - I have a six-layer model with that toolset !! (... and a five layer 91mm* 'Master Craftsman' *) ......So that is not correct- And also if there was a six-layer 84mm Craftsman - It is missing from the Wiki - As we only have the five-layer 84mm Master Craftsman in the Wiki - Can you clarify what you mean please ?
Also please can you be very explicit about what changes you believe need to happen
@kamakiri said:
........... but that page needs LOTS of fixin'...........eg Replace incorrect section * " text text text "* with * " new text new text new text "* - Ideally showing evidence of the reason for the change - eg catalogue screen shot or point to a webpage
-
@Kamkiri - Right - Just realised that you were probably referring to the 84mm model in the Wiki which is labelled as the Artisan/Small Fieldmaster
... which the History section mentions was referred to as a Craftsman in some markets/at one timeSo to my model list I will add:
D. Artisan / Fieldmaster Small - An 84mm four layer SAK - That is the 84mm version of the 91mm Fieldmaster - Known as a Craftsman in some marketsFinal point in my post still applies - Please suggest explicit changes that you think need to be made!
-
I could do that, but it would take time, and I'm not going to re-draft the entire page(s) on thin hopes that people understand and accept them. I already see a fair amount of resistance for an explanation that covers your original question about the Craftsman and Master Craftsman relationship. And this isn't over a brief time in history or 'one time' like you suggest...decades as far as I can tell from the catalogs available.
The other problem is that any edits I propose may require more than just single page edits, but major structural change for the site. I don't think anyone is interested in that.
Perhaps something more like this could be done for the 136ka:
SAKWiki | Victorinox Handyman 7236maU
SAKWiki - The online Swiss Army Knife Encyclopedia. Information and Identification on Swiss Army Knives by Victorinox and Wenger.
SAKWiki (sakwiki.com)
And the Handyman page that it points to:
https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Victorinox+Handyman...though it doesn't 'point back' at it (the 7236maU).
-
From the 50's 8 model catalog:

-
From the '54 brochure:

-
From the (early) '60s catalog:

-
The later '60s 26 model catalog just changes prices from the above to $18.50 and $16.20 respectively.
From the '76 dealer catalog:

-
@kamakiri said:
Because it's clearly and repeatedly called a Craftsman over decades in the known US catalogs.These "known US catalogs" also use the name Camper for the model 234U that most of us currently call Spartan. So? Also, the following page from a 1979 Hoffritz catalog shows that they used the name Craftsman for the model that we now call Explorer, the name Tinker for the 58mm model that we now call Classic, etc. Are we somehow obligated to adopt this as well? How?

So I'm not sure how this mistake was made
It's not a mistake. I'm sure that whoever introduced the name Artisan for the model 136k knew very well that this model was called Craftsmen in the "known US catalogs." They adopted a variation of that name to avoid confusion with the other models called Craftsman.
or propagated
It seems to have been adopted by the community because it makes sense.
-
I believe the Hoffritz models should be mentioned. As well as the BSA renaming examples. Isn't that what a Wiki is for? ...ALL the relevant and available info?
And I'm sure it is a mistake. On purpose or not. Mistake.
-
All right - Thanks for all the piccies - Great
And I reckon you have answered my question on Craftsman vs Master Craftsman - I never knew the 4 layer 84mm 'Artisan' was called a Craftsman in the US
In terms of Wiki changes this look fairly easy to fix for me - ..

You are right I would not want to completely restructure the Wiki pages - But these changes would at least partially *'fix' *and at least be a big improvement ...-
Explain that the model that we have listed as the Artisan was known as a Craftsman in the US - This is already there - But we could wordsmith it a bit!
-
Add in the old model numbers
-
Add in a some more cross references from the 84s to the 91s and vv
-
Add in some more references to the dealer catalogues and names!
-
Maybe put in some Name Disambiguation statements, like we have elsewhere, in the Craftsman/Artisan pages
The super confusing picture is this one
@kamakiri said:
The later '60s 26 model catalog just changes prices from the above to $18.50 and $16.20 respectively.
From the '76 dealer catalog:As this shows the six layer model - which we currently know as the Craftsman as the ***Master ***Craftsman - Oh Boy
As some of us have pointed out before - Don't you just love Vic's renaming!!I have thought about this before a bit, and it's only a problem now that 1.The world is a global market 2. There are us SAK collectors and enthusiasts around
At the time it probably made perfect sense to rename or reuse models
-
-

Sounds like reasonable changes without modifying the page structure. Thanks for taking the time to review what I posted.
@Huntsman said:
I have thought about this before a bit, and it's only a problem now that 1.The world is a global market 2. There are us SAK collectors and enthusiasts around
At the time it probably made perfect sense to rename or reuse models
Understood. This is one area that it makes it hard to organize or reorganize based on the various names. Knowing that some of the names were reused for both upgrades/layer additions and outright changes makes it difficult to keep the names straight when organizing by toolsets/layers/lengths and using name pages. I think the '79 Hoffritz info can be incorporated the same way.
Cross-referencing everything should work with the existing structure in the manner that you outlined. And should minimize the confusion going forward.
-
@Huntsman said:
All right - Thanks for all the piccies - GreatAnd I reckon you have answered my question on Craftsman vs Master Craftsman - I never knew the 4 layer 84mm 'Artisan' was called a Craftsman in the US
In terms of Wiki changes this look fairly easy to fix for me - ..

You are right I would not want to completely restructure the Wiki pages - But these changes would at least partially *'fix' *and at least be a big improvement ...- Explain that the model that we have listed as the Artisan was known as a Craftsman in the US - This is already there - But we could wordsmith it a bit!
- Add in the old model numbers
- Add in a some more cross references from the 84s to the 91s and vv
- Add in some more references to the dealer catalogues and names!
- Maybe put in some Name Disambiguation statements, like we have elsewhere, in the Craftsman/Artisan pages
I think the layout and revisions should mirror the Champion page as it deals with the history in a similar manner. Various layer configurations and about the same history range for the known catalogs.
https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=ChampionMight be easier to start there as a lot of the same info applies regarding History, Model Names and Numbers.
-
From the bottom, c. '72 Master Craftsman, Early '60's Master Craftsman, c. '76 84mm 'Master Craftsman (Small)'

Has the SW29ARNB saw and an aluminum bird head spacer:


-
Wowzers, I never even knew that small '76 Master Craftsman even existed. I imagine they're ridiculously rare.
-
@Thunderpants said:
Wowzers, I never even knew that small '76 Master Craftsman even existed. I imagine they're ridiculously rare.And I have two... that one is a Hoffritz with a H/VSSR tang stamp. The other one I have is older with a Hoffritz (HSS/VOS) tang stamp and the forged+file phillips.
.....
Two more:
'46-'51 136ka Craftsman:




'61+ 136ka Craftsman:



with aluminum birdhead spacer and polished/angled/35 tooth saw -
Two more 136ka Craftsman mid and later '60s:

One with machined finish/angled 35T. Both have nickel silver bird head spacers.
-
@Huntsman said:
https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=CraftsmanHistory section - If anyone knows better let me know and we'll update
Latest one I've found is '05+:


Stainless metal saw, 2.0mm tang, and the newer non-crossbow OS tang stamp with the 'big R' to end OFFICIER. So it could be as new as '11 afaik.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login