Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
What else can they say?

They can't say it's not meant to happen, or they'll be inundated with warranty claims, or people wanting their money back. They also can't fix it, or the tools will become difficult to deploy. The only thing that will change anything, is if people start suing for injuries occurring as a result, and then it's recall time.
-
If someone gets injured from that, they need their license to use tools revoked. IMO
The cutting blades don't pop out and couldn't if they wanted.
Tried to see if I could hurt myself doing that in several different ways, but haven't been able to.
Not saying it is ok that the drivers play peekaboo, just saying it probably isn't a serious problem. Most likely why they put a flat driver tip on the awl, since that would have been the only poking culprit. The opener/flat edge, and awl/driver edge face inwards to the handles, so the likelyhood of cutting oneself that way would be virtually impossible, unless someone intentionally set it up. -
Considering the time spent on this tool, I can think a number of solutions off the top of my head that might fix this. No idea why they are saying "as intended" which makes no sense.
Frankly I'd be less critical of the tool if they hadn't trashed every other tool in their marketing. Bad idea, especially when it's not true..."strongest pliers we ever made" ummm surge and ST300 say hi.
-
@Aloha said:
Passion makes great members. Perceptions, well..... we all have them and so I like to remember that we all come here to discuss these wonderful tools called Multitools. Moving forward and continuing forward I am happy these tools are in the hands of you passionate members.I am happy that LM for all our sake has decided to show us that they can produce a quality tool regardless if it is for everyone. Heck we all know there is no perfect tool unless its a modded one

I love a lively discussion even to the extent of one side getting ruffled, so long as both sides respect each other. I believe this continues to be very true within these pages of discussion.
I cannot wait for you GLBM to test the living smurf out of these tools. It serves all of us, LM included. Breaking it or damaging it however wont tell the whole story. We've seen tools break. I just want to see the limits to which the tool can be pushed. Yeah a little sadistic ::)
Well said... Aloha

-
@gadgetman7 said:
So...out of curiosity I emailed Leatherman about the tools popping out when you cut hard wire or snap the pliers open too hard. They said, “It’s a normal function of the tool.”Accidental deployment of implements while using something else is a normal function?

I would have asked for details.
-
@Happy Gilmore said:
Considering the time spent on this tool, I can think a number of solutions off the top of my head that might fix this.Stronger magnets would be an easy one. The implements seem rather easy to deploy as it is now, I do not think they'd be difficult to deploy if the magnets were a little stronger.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
If someone gets injured from that, they need their license to use tools revoked. IMO
The cutting blades don't pop out and couldn't if they wanted.
Tried to see if I could hurt myself doing that in several different ways, but haven't been able to.
Not saying it is ok that the drivers play peekaboo, just saying it probably isn't a serious problem. Most likely why they put a flat driver tip on the awl, since that would have been the only poking culprit. The opener/flat edge, and awl/driver edge face inwards to the handles, so the likelyhood of cutting oneself that way would be virtually impossible, unless someone intentionally set it up.We live in an age where cups of coffee have to warn the person who ordered it that the contents may be hot, and bags of peanuts say "Warning: Contains nuts". Even among tool enthusiasts, there are people who consider non-locking blades to be unsafe. No matter how foolproof you make something, there's always a higher calibre of idiot waiting just around the corner, but with this, they didn't even try. Making tools that accidentally deploy this easily, is not acceptable for a tool maker today, no matter how you try and window dress it.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
We live in an age where cups of coffee have to warn the person who ordered it that the contents may be hot, and bags of peanuts say "Warning: Contains nuts". Even among tool enthusiasts, there are people who consider non-locking blades to be unsafe. No matter how foolproof you make something, there's always a higher calibre of idiot waiting just around the corner, but with this, they didn't even try. Making tools that accidentally deploy this easily, is not acceptable for a tool maker today, no matter how you try and window dress it.Interestingly the coffee thing was quite serious. I found out the real story behind it recently and feel bad for what I thought of the woman before...who was a passenger....elderly....and nearly died....from 3rd degree burns to thighs and lady parts... She spend nearly a month in the hospital I believe. She wasn't the only one, and the coffee at nearly all the McDonald's was approaching 190 degrees F.
As far as the free goes..yeah, the magnets were the easiest possible solution, and likely wouldn't have needed to be that much stronger. Also contact area of the tools to the magnet... The more steel there is in contact...the stronger the bond could be fixed by removing some steel at bottoms of the tool to make more surface area contact.
Cheers
-
The flat on each tool is the same size as the magnet. I don't think removing any metal would help. The gap between the tool and the magnet is tiny. Just enough to ensure the magnet doesn't get slammed into the tool upon closing.
I don't know if the magnets inside are the highest strength or not, but one easy mod would be to replace them with maximum strength N52 class magnets.
-
@ZapWizard said:
The flat on each tool is the same size as the magnet. I don't think removing any metal would help. The gap between the tool and the magnet is tiny. Just enough to ensure the magnet doesn't get slammed into the tool upon closing.I don't know if the magnets inside are the highest strength or not, but one easy mod would be to replace them with maximum strength N52 class magnets.
That could cause other potential issues. I'd try to add a small amount of metalic putty to the bottom of the tools to allow more contact but have some give from the putty. Also not voiding warranty
-
Guess I'll begin the actual usage/club photos of the Free P. Lots of conjecture and opinion flying around, and no action. :D
Been using the P4 today. So far so good. :)







-
Great uses GLBM

What happened on your last pic wouldn’t it cut
-
@Wspeed said:
Great uses GLBM

What happened on your last pic wouldn’t it cut
Thanks, W!

Cutters work great. The end I cut off is facing me. :ahhh
The pliers head geometry works well for the crimping section. Those yellow butt connectors are a bear to squeeze. The Surge does a bit better job with the crimping section, but it is nice the Ps have it.The OHO tool selection has already proven useful.

-
Nice to see some action pics of the Free P

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
I had to carry my Skeletool or Charge at work this week because I was working with gear with torx screws. Maybe I can play with it this weekend. Looks like the lack of the bit driver may keep this tool from working well for an EDC.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
-
Gadgetman7,
My solution for the testing phase.
Small bits fit snug in the back of the jaws. Larger bits don't fit snug, but could be used in a pinch.
Smaller bit fit.



Larger bit fit. Not good, but would work in a pinch.

-
In the Cedric & Ada vid the tools that were popping out when flipping the pliers out were also popping out when he used hard wire cutters on a piece of fence, maybe they need to increase the magnets strength or size?
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Gadgetman7,My solution for the testing phase.
Small bits fit snug in the back of the jaws. Larger bits don't fit snug, but could be used in a pinch.
Smaller bit fit.



Larger bit fit. Not good, but would work in a pinch.

Interesting idea but looks a little to fiddley to have to tighten 15 or 20 screws.
This tool has such potential. I hope they just fix the issue with the tools popping out and add the bit driver and a decent file.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login