Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
We live in an age where cups of coffee have to warn the person who ordered it that the contents may be hot, and bags of peanuts say "Warning: Contains nuts". Even among tool enthusiasts, there are people who consider non-locking blades to be unsafe. No matter how foolproof you make something, there's always a higher calibre of idiot waiting just around the corner, but with this, they didn't even try. Making tools that accidentally deploy this easily, is not acceptable for a tool maker today, no matter how you try and window dress it.Interestingly the coffee thing was quite serious. I found out the real story behind it recently and feel bad for what I thought of the woman before...who was a passenger....elderly....and nearly died....from 3rd degree burns to thighs and lady parts... She spend nearly a month in the hospital I believe. She wasn't the only one, and the coffee at nearly all the McDonald's was approaching 190 degrees F.
As far as the free goes..yeah, the magnets were the easiest possible solution, and likely wouldn't have needed to be that much stronger. Also contact area of the tools to the magnet... The more steel there is in contact...the stronger the bond could be fixed by removing some steel at bottoms of the tool to make more surface area contact.
Cheers
-
The flat on each tool is the same size as the magnet. I don't think removing any metal would help. The gap between the tool and the magnet is tiny. Just enough to ensure the magnet doesn't get slammed into the tool upon closing.
I don't know if the magnets inside are the highest strength or not, but one easy mod would be to replace them with maximum strength N52 class magnets.
-
@ZapWizard said:
The flat on each tool is the same size as the magnet. I don't think removing any metal would help. The gap between the tool and the magnet is tiny. Just enough to ensure the magnet doesn't get slammed into the tool upon closing.I don't know if the magnets inside are the highest strength or not, but one easy mod would be to replace them with maximum strength N52 class magnets.
That could cause other potential issues. I'd try to add a small amount of metalic putty to the bottom of the tools to allow more contact but have some give from the putty. Also not voiding warranty
-
Guess I'll begin the actual usage/club photos of the Free P. Lots of conjecture and opinion flying around, and no action. :D
Been using the P4 today. So far so good. :)







-
Great uses GLBM

What happened on your last pic wouldn’t it cut
-
@Wspeed said:
Great uses GLBM

What happened on your last pic wouldn’t it cut
Thanks, W!

Cutters work great. The end I cut off is facing me. :ahhh
The pliers head geometry works well for the crimping section. Those yellow butt connectors are a bear to squeeze. The Surge does a bit better job with the crimping section, but it is nice the Ps have it.The OHO tool selection has already proven useful.

-
Nice to see some action pics of the Free P

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
I had to carry my Skeletool or Charge at work this week because I was working with gear with torx screws. Maybe I can play with it this weekend. Looks like the lack of the bit driver may keep this tool from working well for an EDC.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
-
Gadgetman7,
My solution for the testing phase.
Small bits fit snug in the back of the jaws. Larger bits don't fit snug, but could be used in a pinch.
Smaller bit fit.



Larger bit fit. Not good, but would work in a pinch.

-
In the Cedric & Ada vid the tools that were popping out when flipping the pliers out were also popping out when he used hard wire cutters on a piece of fence, maybe they need to increase the magnets strength or size?
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Gadgetman7,My solution for the testing phase.
Small bits fit snug in the back of the jaws. Larger bits don't fit snug, but could be used in a pinch.
Smaller bit fit.



Larger bit fit. Not good, but would work in a pinch.

Interesting idea but looks a little to fiddley to have to tighten 15 or 20 screws.
This tool has such potential. I hope they just fix the issue with the tools popping out and add the bit driver and a decent file.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Indeed, not ideal, but until there is a slip over adapter, it'll have to do.
I'd like to see the SE blade replaced with a longer file, but that said, that little file can eat up some material. Have you tried that thing yet? It is similarly as aggressive as the Rebar file, which is the most aggressive file on an MT right now, due to the width and aggressiveness. The Rebar file would be the one I want in the P4. :)
-
Had the chance to use my P4 at home for the last two days and I must say that it hasn't failed me yet.
Okay, I haven't used it for any hard-wire cutting or other "heavy duty" work, so must of the use was from the screwdrivers and the prybar. The screwdrivers (and especially the Phillips) work better than I expected, I still prefer the Phillips on the ST300 and Rebar (best Phillips screwdriver on a multitool ever, in my opinion), but it did what it had to do. Used the prybar to open some cans of wood varnish that had been standing in the garage for quite some time and it got the job done, and was fun to use (for some reason I like a prybar on a multitool, like the one on the P4, or the Spirit, oversized and very sturdy).
About the tools popping out, well, I can't say anything about them popping out during the cutting of hardwire, since I haven't done that (yet), but they do occasionally pop out when the pliers locks open. But I do have to lock the pliers harder/faster than I would normally do to "make" it happen. And weirdly enough, it happens more on the side of the Phillips/prybar than on the other. When I hold the side of the awl in my hand while flipping open the pliers and locking them in one fast motion the Phillips/prybar pop out (a bit) like 50% of the time. But when I hold the side of the Phillips/prybar in my hand while doing the same thing, the awl and the other (thinner) tools only pop out like 10% of the time (maybe even less).
Don't know if the torx screws on this side have been tightened a bit more (I don't notice them being tougher to open, so I doubt that this is the reason), or that these tools stick better to the magnets since they are thinner, and therefore have less weight "pulling" them out while swinging and clicking the pliers open ...
Anyways, can't say that it has bothered me much, I mean, I've seen a lot worse on other tools ... (the drivers on the Juice KF4 poking my finger right above my fingernail for the 4th time in 10 minutes spring to mind
).I'm still not very handy at using the locking mechanism, I mean, I've been using the Wave (or Charge) platform for many years now and the locking on those tools (inside and outside tools) just feels way more natural than the locks on the P4, but in all honesty, I'm comparing years of usage against days of usage, so that might not be completely fair towards the P4 ... ::)
Biggest let down so far has been the tiny file, when you're used to the file on the Wave/Charge, this one is just too small. But, I knew this when I bought it, so technically this isn't really a let down ...
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Indeed, not ideal, but until there is a slip over adapter, it'll have to do.I'd like to see the SE blade replaced with a longer file, but that said, that little file can eat up some material. Have you tried that thing yet? It is similarly as aggressive as the Rebar file, which is the most aggressive file on an MT right now, due to the width and aggressiveness. The Rebar file would be the one I want in the P4. :)
I have used it. It’s aggressive but in my experience, the diamond file works better for metal if you need to do some detail work.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
:D :D :D :D :D :D mine is in my hands today.

Just some initial thoughts. Played around with it. Have not really put it to real use yet.
Pros. -
The QC on this thing I must admit is really really good. I cant find anything wrong with it at all. All the tools locks up perfectly. Surprising light when I first picked it up. A very fresh design indeed. Its a well constructed tool with pretty decent material. Tool set looks pretty functional. They are really thin on one side but the width of the tools should make up for the strength. The scissors are a big improvement over the previous designs. Second only to the mighty Surge. The file is actually a big surprise for me. I never thought I would say this, while it is short, it is very aggressive. Perfect for rounding off metal or ad-hoc filing. Its way way better than the ones on the wingman. The awl while not really pointy, should work as they are pretty sharp.


Cons. -
Hotspots. Many of them at the handle ends when using the pliers. And they do dig into the palm..... I do not feel the alignment stubs but the ends of the handle is pointy, the lock tab is also pointy and the edges are a little sharp. Enough to shave off fingers nails. Also, my pliers came too tight than I like. It also tightens a little more when I give it squeezing pressure. Its along time since I bought a new leatherman so I really hope it will loosen soon. Hope.

The above are really just my observation on the physical construction. I generally do not have much complains.
Handling is a whole different story.
The pivots that attaches the handles to the pliers moves. While it should not post any issues, its gives the feeling like when we are using undersized pivot posts and there are freeplay. It just doesnt feel nice. I do not like the magnetic closure for the handle. Now I need addition action to dig my fingers between the tool to break the handles apart to using the pliers. I can balisong my wave or charge all day long and the handles still stays shut when I need them to. Internal tools will deploy occasionally when snapping the handle together. The oho deployment of the tools with the thumb? Clumsy. I hope its just because its a new extraction method so there is the learning curve for my thumb and fingers. I say extraction and not deployment because they are just a way the tools comes out easier for you to chose what you want, then fumble to lock that and close back the rest. Its not as easy as they do in the advertisement. I almost laughed at myself trying to do it single handed with my left hand ready to come to my rescue. And there are 2 sharp blades in there, the awl and the large sharp flathead. I am struggling not to brush my finger across them when trying to spread them out. Like many, I never had problems with leatherman nailnicks.

Overall experience, its clumsy to use one handed, the way they touted as "Free". I am not convinced it is a improvement over the wave platform yet. Construction no doubt is excellent but they are using regular material, charging $119 for it is pretty off putting. $90 sounds better. Let's not forget that this is how the quality of a leatherman should be like in the first place.
Purely my own personal opinion in this half any hour of playing with it.. It may change for the better or worse on further usage. Right now, I am just very irritated by the tight pliers......

-
We all know LM puts out tight pliers. Sorry to read that they are doing it with the Free, but they will work in eventually. Took months to get my Surge reasonably easy to open. :ahhh
I'll make a video on techniques I've experimented with opening/closing one-hand, left and right, at some point. Once I figured it out, it was easy as cake. :)
-
Folding one handle out for a real driver experience works a treat since I tightened the pliers mounts pivots up a bit.

Removed the top cover for a Brunswick phonograph. Doing another veneer job.
-
Nice job GLBM

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login