Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
@Happy Gilmore said:
I am one of those people that does feel the overwhelming need to modify my tools, but I really appreciate what LM was trying to do. As long as they keep the surge,st300, and charge/wave as real tools with real implements I'm cool with having two different types of tools. What I look for in a tool is as few substitutes as possible. The P series just has too many for my liking.Honestly if they hadn't trash talked the wave and made it out to be better (which it def isn't), I would have been a lot more excited about the novelty of this tool.
Fantastic points, Happy G!

Indeed, LM really screwed up with throwing the Wave under the metaphorical bus.

Why couldn't they have compared it to the SOG PowerAccess, Gerber Truss, Victorinox Spirit, etc. in the promotions? That seems to be the market they intended to go after with the P2/P4. And even I, not being a marketing expert, could make a case for the P2/P4 against those tools.
High-end knife makers produce multi-hundred knives all of the time that have competition at 1/4 of the price(same blade steels, handle material, fit & finish, etc). Leatherman was unwise to compete within their own production.
As much as I lament the Gerber sales tactics, at least they go after their actual competition(CD vs. OHT for example). -
Maybe they set the Wave as competition on purpose, as a win-win safety. People who would not like the P series would buy the Wave, which is also made by them.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Fantastic points, Happy G!
Indeed, LM really screwed up with throwing the Wave under the metaphorical bus.

Why couldn't they have compared it to the SOG PowerAccess, Gerber Truss, Victorinox Spirit, etc. in the promotions? That seems to be the market they intended to go after with the P2/P4. And even I, not being a marketing expert, could make a case for the P2/P4 against those tools.
High-end knife makers produce multi-hundred knives all of the time that have competition at 1/4 of the price(same blade steels, handle material, fit & finish, etc). Leatherman was unwise to compete within their own production.
As much as I lament the Gerber sales tactics, at least they go after their actual competition(CD vs. OHT for example).To be honest, I'm starting to understand why Leatherman put the Free up against the Wave during the promotions.
I mean, it's a win/win situation for them, if it turns out the public likes the Free more, Leatherman wins. If on the other hand, the public ends up prefering the Wave... Leatherman wins :D.
Let's say they put it up against the Spirit and the public decided against the Free, Leatherman ends up "promoting" a tool of a competing brand.
How many times has it been said on this forum alone that the Wave is a better tool than the Free, and that the Wave still rules this size tool-class.
Is there a better way to promote a tool that's been on the market for just over 20 years...?
I would say, well played Leatherman, well played
. -

For those who think the spring force is too high: You could modify the tool to use only one spring arm. The spring would have to be moved to the center of the tool to ensure even force on it.
The springs are 0.030" (0.75mm) thick. You could alter the stack to use just one washer, or two thinner washers to replace the missing spring.
I may try this out myself as I have some other parts to order from McMaster. -
@gerleatherberman said:
Nobody is going to look at my grey sheath, the way it looks now, and think "he has the best MT out there."

-
For those who think the spring force is too high: You could modify the tool to use only one spring arm. The spring would have to be moved to the center of the tool to ensure even force on it.
The springs are 0.030" (0.75mm) thick. You could alter the stack to use just one washer, or two thinner washers to replace the missing spring.
I may try this out myself as I have some other parts to order from McMaster.Thanks! That's really helpful. Wish I had access to a mill to make some of these custom parts. Would love to have the Signal in 3D..I always felt there is potential for other tools to be slotted in for the whistle/rod and the sharpener.
-
For those who think the spring force is too high: You could modify the tool to use only one spring arm. The spring would have to be moved to the center of the tool to ensure even force on it.
The springs are 0.030" (0.75mm) thick. You could alter the stack to use just one washer, or two thinner washers to replace the missing spring.
I may try this out myself as I have some other parts to order from McMaster.Hey Zap! Really like what you have done on the other thread for the parts ideas.

Wouldn't moving of that spring to the centre further hinders the "easy" extraction of the tools? That will also bring the tools closer to the outer tools, making the rolling action to be more painful than it already is. There are reviews mentioning rolling the implements out hurts the thumb because of the 4 outer tools does not roll. I felt the same way on mine. Longevity of a single spring is a little questionable though it have to be tested in the long run.
-
I did the one spring thing, and many other arrangements.
problem is, when you move it to the middle the implements are harder to open, AND the main tools, due to clumping (finnaly understood it) open the smaller implements.
See why they used 2 springs. It makes sense. -
What i taught, is moving the springs next to the scales, put a stronger magnet to avoid toold clumping and... Honestly given the situation, seems LMN did it the best way.
Altough, i believe they over complicated the solution -
As l was traveling to the US from Australia, l decided to buy the new Free P4 online from LM before l left home in order to give myself plenty of time for delivery.
A day or so after l arrived l got an email asking me to contact the Sales team. Basically they needed a room number before they would ship it to my hotel. l paid for the expedited shipping and in the end they got it to me Alabama in about 24 hours which l thought was very impressive.
Obviously l haven't given it any real use but my first impressions are that l think l'm going to like it.
Overall l rate the concept, design and quality as a 9.5 out of 10.
However overall the tool selection is not ideal for my needs and l would score it 8/10.
My main issue is the lack of a problem file. As others have suggested they should off a version wigh a full length diamond file instead of the poor serrated blade. A compromise could have been to at least have one surface diamond coated on the current file
A secondary complaint is the phillips screwdriver.
Cheers
George -
@george1 said:
As l was traveling to the US from Australia, l decided to buy the new Free P4 online from LM before l left home in order to give myself plenty of time for delivery.
A day or so after l arrived l got an email asking me to contact the Sales team. Basically they needed a room number before they would ship it to my hotel. l paid for the expedited shipping and in the end they got it to me Alabama in about 24 hours which l thought was very impressive.
Obviously l haven't given it any real use but my first impressions are that l think l'm going to like it.
Overall l rate the concept, design and quality as a 9.5 out of 10.
However overall the tool selection is not ideal for my needs and l would score it 8/10.
My main issue is the lack of a problem file. As others have suggested they should off a version wigh a full length diamond file instead of the poor serrated blade. A compromise could have been to at least have one surface diamond coated on the current file
A secondary complaint is the phillips screwdriver.
Cheers
GeorgeThank you for taking the time to share your thoughts and experience with your P4, George!

Couldn't agree more with dumping the long SE blade and getting a Wave-style file. I would go a step further and want a newly designed file with a diamond coated side and a precision cut cross-cut side like the Rebar(same kind of cut the small P file has).
I can live with the phillips driver. It works very well on most phillips screws. :)
Just want LM to make a slip-over adapter to fit their proprietary bit-kit bits. :) -
Gerleatherberman,
Totally agree about LM needing to sort out a bit adapter for the Free models.
Hopefully this will happen in the next 3 months otherwise l will need to make something up myself.
My thoughts are that the design for such a bit adapter is not complicated and that this would be a perfect 3D metal printed item. -
& 
I am considering grinding the phillips down to accommodate an adaptor. Only problem is, that if I screw it up, parts aren't available. :ahhh
But, as you said, hopefully within a few months there will be an option. :)
-
I also forgot to mention that l also enquired about purchasing the pocket clip and was told that all the P4's now ship with the pocket clip.
However there was no lanyard attachment with mine; no big deal as l don't use the the lanyard attachment but just thought l'd mention it in case someone wants one. -
I havent been around here for a while and really stopped by to see what people were saying about the Free series. I'm a bit surprised that alot of members here seem to like it? i just cant get on board with the tool selection, the metal filing attracting magnets and the locking tabs sticking out on the handle. i wear a Surge on my side 50hrs a week so i may be a bit jaded...i'm always comparing other tools to it, and they all fall short for my needs. maybe if they had one with replaceable bits and/or file/saw socket i would think differently, but if feel like the Free series are far from the best they have made like they are advertised.
-
@Walley said:
I havent been around here for a while and really stopped by to see what people were saying about the Free series. I'm a bit surprised that alot of members here seem to like it? i just cant get on board with the tool selection, the metal filing attracting magnets and the locking tabs sticking out on the handle. i wear a Surge on my side 50hrs a week so i may be a bit jaded...i'm always comparing other tools to it, and they all fall short for my needs. maybe if they had one with replaceable bits and/or file/saw socket i would think differently, but if feel like the Free series are far from the best they have made like they are advertised.Indeed. Many members mirror your feelings about the Free series. LM really did a bad job with promoting the Free P series. They went after the Wave-user market and the Free P2/P4 isn't going to replace a Wave in a work environment. I feel the market for the P series the same as high-end knives. Not all that practical, but well appreciated, for the design and quality. The tool is really awesome to use, but isn't very practical relative to the Wave in work environments.
I carried mine for several weeks and with minding where I laid the P4 down, managed to avoid a lot of metal debris and dust(I restore antiques, so steel wool and I are best friends..haha). The little bit I did get in/on the tool was easily blown off/out with compressed air or removed with packing tape.
And....The Surge is in a class of its' own. Can't really think of a tool that is more capable.

-
I have made bit adapters to fit my Wingman, Vic combo tool and straight screwdriver. They are easy and cheap to make. I am getting my P-2 tomorrow. I will check it out and see if they will work on it.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Bear and Son had an adapter for their rectangle shank Phillips.
So did the Harley Davidson BuckTool.One of them might actually fit the Free Phillips, but they're impossible to find.

And they might not fit anyway.
-
When the tool came out I thought "WOW" I want it! I waited for I while also because here in Italy it was not available and still it is..... Then I started to read the first comments and aside the fidget factor, the tool is pretty standard! I mean is absolutely awesome in its class but I can make the same thing with all other multis...... It has not interchangeable bit, that flat phillips not so nice compared with that one on super tool..... So now I wait a bit (probably more than a year.) to see reasonable price, than I will take my decision. For now the winner could be the charge for sure
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
