Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
It seems they did a bit of a nasty trick to that poor fellow they placed in a burned down area. Maybe the fishing is great there at least.
They (the show) makes excuses that all sites are more or less equal........as long as that participant can find the abundant resource in his area......does seem like a bit of a low blow.....
Speaking from complete inexperience, if I was preparing that Muskrat I'd flame grill it nice & crispy then cook the living smurf out of it.....his leftovers looked underdone and seemed to have a lot of meat left on them.
There is still a lot they do that I don't understand, I'd be fishing a lot more.....
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
They (the show) makes excuses that all sites are more or less equal........as long as that participant can find the abundant resource in his area......does seem like a bit of a low blow.....All locations will be different by nature, literaly speaking, but the other participants seemed to have fairly similar areas. Making one person the odd one out might turn out to be unfair - one way or the other. I assume they could find 10 similar areas in that huge landscape, so I guess there is some purpose or logic behind it.
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Speaking from complete inexperience, if I was preparing that Muskrat I'd flame grill it nice & crispy then cook the living smurf out of it.....his leftovers looked underdone and seemed to have a lot of meat left on them.Something sure seemed to have survived and given him a hard time over it afterwards. I've been food poisoned once, and I've also had a distinct preferance for overdone cooking ever since.
@Gerhard Gerber said:
There is still a lot they do that I don't understand, I'd be fishing a lot more.....I assume they do a lot (unsuccesfully) outside of the alloted TV time. I guess equipment sets some limits too? If I got it right they get to bring 10 items, and that might not give many options? That said if a fishing net and fishing hooks both counts as one (?), I think I would have gone with the net.
What do they all typically bring? From the top of my head: Tarp, sleeping bag, knife, firerod, saw and or axe, bow, multitool, kettle, line, rope - not much room left to play with there? .
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Speaking from complete inexperience, if I was preparing that Muskrat I'd flame grill it nice & crispy then cook the living smurf out of it.....his leftovers looked underdone and seemed to have a lot of meat left on them......
It may have not been the muskrat or how it was prepared that was the cause of his TAP.
I read on his profile he had a heart attack, and was allowed to bring his medication (s).
The muskrat was his first meal. If he had been taking his meds as prescribed, but without food, he could have cause irritation in his digestive track and when meat was then consumed, the acids to digest the food could have inflamed his stomach and intestines causing severe pain like he described.
Most meds require you to take with a meal, for that reason.
I did like his shelter and thought he was to be a contender.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Henry said:
So do they need a 1 week competition to qualify for the chance? I wonder if they'd even have enough people entering...Bit of a risk to quit your job indefinitely!
I bet very few have a job, actually. They get 7000 or so entrants every season. They pick the ones least likey to make it, for at least 7 of the picks. 2-3 have to be female and at least on has to be a minority, if any apply. I think it will be wonica or Ray, since they are getting the most exposure. By day 30, if you haven' fed yourself well and have at least 50 lbs of preserved food, you wont win unless you're the fattest guy on the show.
-
@Vidar said:
All locations will be different by nature, literaly speaking, but the other participants seemed to have fairly similar areas. Making one person the odd one out might turn out to be unfair - one way or the other. I assume they could find 10 similar areas in that huge landscape, so I guess there is some purpose or logic behind it.Something sure seemed to have survived and given him a hard time over it afterwards. I've been food poisoned once, and I've also had a distinct preferance for overdone cooking ever since.
I assume they do a lot (unsuccesfully) outside of the alloted TV time. I guess equipment sets some limits too? If I got it right they get to bring 10 items, and that might not give many options? That said if a fishing net and fishing hooks both counts as one (?), I think I would have gone with the net.
What do they all typically bring? From the top of my head: Tarp, sleeping bag, knife, firerod, saw and or axe, bow, multitool, kettle, line, rope - not much room left to play with there? .
they supposedly are fishing but not catching anything. Every location I've seen, there's been ducks, and gulls. Take 25 BIG fishhooks, and convert them into 50, and then make 16 treblehooks, via the snarewire and the multitool. They can't START with barbed hooks this year, which might be why they are not catching any fish. I'd fix that shortage with a charcoal fire a couple of hard rocks and the file blades of my Crunch
-
@LoopCutter said:
I was rooting for Britt to catch a fish, he did try. If he had he was good for another few days.Sam was having issues vacating his waste. Once he announce the problem was resolved, I felt he was the one to beat as he continued to demonstrate his resilience and keep his mind and hands busy, including snow shoes for when the snow got deeper. He was not exiting soon as he continued to look for ways to beat the weather. Unfortunately he did not have success gathering fish or larger (than mice) animals. His drop trapped appeared effective, but did not appear along a travel path or had bait and funnel to force his intended targets to be caught. It was strange yet effective strategy. I even questioned his item selections.
I really did enjoy his comment after learning he won and greeted his wife, - " Which one of you guys have food?" repeating the question to each person present.

if I win this and my wife doesn't bring me Mounds bars or something similar, we're getting divorced as soon as I get home.
none of them knew to make lots of netting, Sam finally got off of his butt a little bit and made the tiny amount possible wth a mere 20m of paracord (using the inner strands but didn't even know to weight down the bottom strands with stones. He won because he was the fattest and britt came second because he was the second fattest. Unless somebody makes a lot of netting and knows how to use it, the fattest guy at day 30 will always win, barring a pure luck thing of snaring or arrowing a big critter. How many of them would know to braid four segments of the 20 ga wire into a cable strong enough to snare a moose's hoof to a drag log, or strangle a deer or caribou?
-
@downt said:
How many of them would know to braid four segments of the 20 ga wire into a cable strong enough to snare a moose's hoof to a drag log, or strangle a deer or caribou?From what I've seen of this show they pick people with pretty varied and relevant backgrounds. I've been impressed by quite a few, actually maybe even most of them over the seasons. And I'm fairly certain most know how to braid and trap - I think the issue earlier seasons were more a ban against hunting bigger animals?
What I find somewhat interesting about the approach to fishing is that most adopt sport fishing methods. Which is fine as such, and usually the only allowed option for recreational fishing. Which might be what they are used to for that very reason. But if the goal isn't sport, but actually to get dinner, then most methods banned from sport fishing is likely more effective. (Usually the reason why they are banned in the first place).
-
I am pretty sure that the barb restriction is due to local fishing laws. Also, only allowed to take species in season most likely.
I now from one episode a lynx was observed, and it was said it was protected.
They are in Canada, the laws may varied to ours and even have greater restrictions for that territory.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Vidar said:
From what I've seen of this show they pick people with pretty varied and relevant backgrounds. I've been impressed by quite a few, actually maybe even most of them over the seasons. And I'm fairly certain most know how to braid and trap - I think the issue earlier seasons were more a ban against hunting bigger animals?What I find somewhat interesting about the approach to fishing is that most adopt sport fishing methods. Which is fine as such, and usually the only allowed option for recreational fishing. Which might be what they are used to for that very reason. But if the goal isn't sport, but actually to get dinner, then most methods banned from sport fishing is likely more effective. (Usually the reason why they are banned in the first place).
As of yet, I've not been impressed by anyone's ability,( 5 seasons) nor their awareness of what to take or do. I've been impressed by some of them's toughness, like Carleigh and Fowler. but that's it.
-
@LoopCutter said:
I am pretty sure that the barb restriction is due to local fishing laws. Also, only allowed to take species in season most likely.I now from one episode a lynx was observed, and it was said it was protected.
They are in Canada, do laws may. E varied to ours.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
they can get the same "subsistence permit" given to the Innuit and indians, which lets them take any game or fish, as needed for FOOD. They wont be arrowing any lynxes, from what I've seen of the way they walk on the show. Like cattle, clunk clunk.
FAR more likely, it's because of dummies getting a hook in their hands., cause they aint got brains enough to make a dip net out of a chunk of tarp and wood (takes half an hour and only an issue if they're in a boat, which only 2 have been. :-) I learned at age 13 to alwys drag the fish up onto the bank man. Then you either club it, or put it onto a stringer. 15 ft up on the bank, you can't lose it, and you can put your foot on the fish while you remove the hook.
-
@downt said:
FAR more likely, it's because of dummies getting a hook in their hands., cause they aint got brains enough to make a dip net out of a chunk of tarp and wood (takes half an hour and only an issue if they're in a boat, which only 2 have been. :-) I learned at age 13 to alwys drag the fish up onto the bank man. Then you either club it, or put it onto a stringer. 15 ft up on the bank, you can't lose it, and you can put your foot on the fish while you remove the hook.I see no need to call them dummies or question their intelligence. They made it onto the show which means they already surpassed the wast majority of applicants, and a big part of that will be due to their abilities and experience. You simply can not cast any random guy and drop them off alone in the wilderness - let alone in the arctic.
Sure they do mistakes, have accidents and go about their stuff in different ways. They all try to adapt strategies based on their particular skillset, but there is enough happenstance to kill off even the best of plans - which force them out of their comfort zone and expose their weaker areas.
I might do better than some at a few tasks, but I also know that most of those people would easily outlast me overall - and that is what counts. The technical survival skills need to be at a certain level, but I think the real challenge and deciding factors in the show are more at a mental level.
Age 13 sounds about 10 years late..
:D -
@Vidar said:
What do they all typically bring? From the top of my head: Tarp, sleeping bag, knife, firerod, saw and or axe, bow, multitool, kettle, line, rope - not much room left to play with there? .Well the one guy left the ferro rod so he could take a net.......almost flopped with the fire but did catch a fish......
I've fished for many species and strangely enough even rivers, but not that cold and not those species. Just can't help but think there should be a lot of fish in those waters....
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Well the one guy left the ferro rod so he could take a net.......almost flopped with the fire but did catch a fish......I've fished for many species and strangely enough even rivers, but not that cold and not those species. Just can't help but think there should be a lot of fish in those waters....
When it freezes over they can do ice fishing and no longer be limited to the shoreline. Snow also makes it easier to track prey, and the animals that don't change fur color will be easier to spot against the white. Some will also be attracted to remaining open water holes. So the cold isn't all bad. Should be an interesting season.
Wonder if any of the contestants brought a white sleeping bag?
-
Regarding fishing, the two fish I saw caught this season were Lake Trout.
When the lake freezes these will go to deep water (50 feet or more).
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Vidar said:
When it freezes over they can do ice fishing and no longer be limited to the shoreline. Snow also makes it easier to track prey, and the animals that don't change fur color will be easier to spot against the white. Some will also be attracted to remaining open water holes. So the cold isn't all bad. Should be an interesting season.Wonder if any of the contestants brought a white sleeping bag?
which guy is that? the only one I noticed took a bow drill instead of a ferrorod, so that gained him nothing at all. In fact, it's a pita big mistake. I can see not taking a ferrorod if you're just going to fire-roll a chunk of your bandnna to get your first fire, bed your coals, get a primitive shelter over your fire and probably never need to start another fire "from scratch". Once you have ashes and charred punk wood, as well as pine resin, feathersticks and shredded duct tape, kept dry in you tarp and tape watertight bag, you can start fires with any hard rock and any carbon steel tool.
-
@Vidar said:
I see no need to call them dummies or question their intelligence. They made it onto the show which means they already surpassed the wast majority of applicants, and a big part of that will be due to their abilities and experience. You simply can not cast any random guy and drop them off alone in the wilderness - let alone in the arctic.Sure they do mistakes, have accidents and go about their stuff in different ways. They all try to adapt strategies based on their particular skillset, but there is enough happenstance to kill off even the best of plans - which force them out of their comfort zone and expose their weaker areas.
I might do better than some at a few tasks, but I also know that most of those people would easily outlast me overall - and that is what counts. The technical survival skills need to be at a certain level, but I think the real challenge and deciding factors in the show are more at a mental level.
ge 13 sounds about 10 years late..
:Dthey apparently take anyone that's female, transgender or a minority, cause they get so few such applicants, I guess? anyway, if they are your "expert instructors" God help you if you ever actually need to do this sort of thing, because they can't.
-
The traditional stuff and tactics has NEVER worked. They've all just starved. Every last one of them has lost at least an average of half a lb per day. That's 1500 calories that they fell short of getting, EVERY day. The only one of the 10 things that most people take, that I agree with, is the snarewire. Everything else is less than optimal. Even the fishing kit. I'd take it, but I'd take 25 BIG hooks, and use the fire, a couple of hard stones, and the modified Crunch tool to convert them into 2 hooks each, with barbs. Then I'd use the Crunch and the snare wire to convert them into 16 treblehooks and set at least half of them for mammals and birds. There's no need of the axe, saw and belt knife, when the Crunch and the Cold steel shovel (modified to have 8" of saw edge) can do more than those 3 items and it saves you a pick. You dont need the paracord or the gillnet, if you take the hammock. There's far more cordage there, and it can make you 400 sq ft of 3" mesh netting, on top of the cordage you need for lashings. The gillnet is restricted to 60 sq ft in size, so it's not worth taking. It's also 1.5" mesh and a gillnet cant catch fish that are bigger than the mesh size. Seines and weirs CAN. Weirs can be baited, gillnets cannot. Netting can be used to trap waterfowl, crows, magpies, pigeons and mammals.
Why take the 2 qt pot limit, when you can have a 5 qt skillet with lid? No rule says that you can't, you know. Why take a bow, when you can have the greater versatility and handiness of a slingbow? I'd take the 12x12 tarp and make netting out of it. I'd skip the sleeping bag to do so, too. There's plenty of debris that you can use for insulation and they are given lots of heavy winter clothing, too. I'd tke the duct tape, the 3 lb block of salt. Dont take stuff that other stuff can do the job of (ie, the Crunch and shovel replace the saw, belt knife and axe) and dont take stuff you can make on site (sleeping bag, gillnet, paracord, fire-starter). The rations are just 2 lbs each, so they will give you only 1 more day of staying power each. They used to be 5 lbs and that was marginal. So they are no longer worth using a pick in order to take.I'd set netting-wrapped box traps for small game and birds (other than the above ground weir type net for baited-in ducks, using boiled then fried cambium as bait) Reserve the snare wire for the treblehooks set for predators (coons, possums, etc) for making the treblehooks, and for braiding into cables that can strangle a deer or caribou, or hook a moose, wolf or bear to a drag-log. Cordage will not suffice for such things. Get into ketosis 2 weeks before you go and pig out your last couple of meals. Getting fat for the show is cheating, no different than smuggling in a knife or ferrorod.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
