Gathering thoughts/tools/materials for first mod
-
On that latter note, I have bad experiences with pre-made holes... better drill yourself
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
On that latter note, I have bad experiences with pre-made holes... better drill yourselfDo you want to talk about it? :) The holes of an EDM electrode should be exactly in the center throughout.
Edit: Just curious of the issues? Come to think about I might have some EDM electrodes around here somewhere. Probably not 3mm though.
-
@Vidar said:
Do you want to talk about it? :) The holes of an EDM electrode should be exactly in the center throughout.Edit: Just curious of the issues? Come to think about I might have some EDM electrodes around here somewhere. Probably not 3mm though.
I did some sourcing for brass tube that is 3.0mm OD and with threaded hole of 2.0mm (for M2 screws) in Chinese websites, but almost 99% of the time, the tube I see are not smooth outside, but with grooves. And the real 'diameter' with grooves are usually around 3.2mm. I have seen MTO member trying to smooth out the outside by sanding it down. However, I just have no data whether those pivots did hold up in a long run. Follow this link here.
That lead me thinking...what if the 'sanding' down is done by a lathe? That's should be far easier to trying to tapper thread into a long rod, is it?
-
My bad experience was in trying to enlarge a hole to 1.5 mm, it must have been around 1.1 or 1.2 to start with. Drill bit broke off. The rolling process they used for that type of brass tube (3 mm outer diameter) must have caused a harder inner surface in places. I had some rod stock and that worked better ;)
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
My bad experience was in trying to enlarge a hole to 1.5 mm, it must have been around 1.1 or 1.2 to start with. Drill bit broke off. The rolling process they used for that type of brass tube (3 mm outer diameter) must have caused a harder inner surface in places. I had some rod stock and that worked better ;)Just for reference, I remembered reading Syph too were saying the same thing regarding drilling threaded tubes, and mentioning it might be easier to do it from a solid rod.
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
My bad experience was in trying to enlarge a hole to 1.5 mm, it must have been around 1.1 or 1.2 to start with. Drill bit broke off. The rolling process they used for that type of brass tube (3 mm outer diameter) must have caused a harder inner surface in places. I had some rod stock and that worked better ;)The biggest electrode I have is 2.5mm. I think these are made by extruding brass so they should be fairly even. I might drill a slightly bigger hole just to get a feel.
@comis said:
Just for reference, I remembered reading Syph too were saying the same thing regarding drilling threaded tubes, and mentioning it might be easier to do it from a solid rod.Electrodes are not threaded in any way. Just a small smooth hole in the center.
@comis said:
I did some sourcing for brass tube that is 3.0mm OD and with threaded hole of 2.0mm (for M2 screws) in Chinese websites, but almost 99% of the time, the tube I see are not smooth outside, but with grooves. And the real 'diameter' with grooves are usually around 3.2mm. I have seen MTO member trying to smooth out the outside by sanding it down. However, I just have no data whether those pivots did hold up in a long run. Follow this link here.That lead me thinking...what if the 'sanding' down is done by a lathe? That's should be far easier to trying to tapper thread into a long rod, is it?
Making threads isn't actually difficult. Just make a nice setup and do the steps. Easiest way with a drill press might be to fasten a piece of wood or something. Then just don't move the wood for the following: Drill a hole of 3mm, make the wood hole clampable, stick the rod end in and clamp it, change drillbit to 1.6mm, drill hole, change drilltip over to tap and tap hole. That way they should all line up perfectly. (In a lathe just clamp it directly instead of in the wood).
That said removing some outer grooves could work fine as well. I would have gone for threading a rod I think, but then I again I do have tools handy.
-

Looks like you are in good hands comis

-
Looks like you are in good hands comis

No doubt about that!

Next is to find myself a drill press for the 93mm mods, it may take sometime. Meanwhile, I would have the hand drill soon which should allow me to do the 91mm mods(project A, Mountain Explorer), and practice on dummies/donors on cheap bids. I will probably make a new thread if I run into any trouble, or share the DIY experience. :D
-
Hi, all!
Just wanna share a quick update after all these posts. :D
Finally gotten a drill press and am quite happy with it, nothing state of the art, but from a traditional well-known brand which has been making drill press for last 50 years. In case anyone is curious, it's called the "Wesk Lake", model ZQ4113. It's a 370W B-taper drill press and weights around 70kg.

For the past week or so, I had taken my own sweet time disassembling two SAKs from beat up lot sale--a 91mm Climber and a 93mm Alox (it's a weird combination of openers and large blade+electrician blade), making drawings and scanning the liners etc. Up until then, everything was like dream, easy pants.
Then yesterday came, I started trying peening the 93mm...and that's where my nightmare begins. There were three pins, and I figured I will try different hammers/concave punch/technique on different ones. First pin I used a 10+ oz hammer just bent rather quickly.

Second and thrid pins, I was counting on those "concave punches", and did mod them a little bit to fit the top shape of alox rivet. But despite my best effort with a 2 and 4oz hammers, it felt like it is not moving any metal, and they were merely pushing very modest material down the side of pin, form a thin layer of muchroom. The shape of it looks good from the outside, but upon drilling them out for inspection, the brass didn't fully fill up the countersink hole, so those concave punches seem like are only good for the cosmetic?


Today, I figured I will redeem myself with doing something simpler, the 91mm. I left around 0.5mm material above each side of the bushing, and just peen away with a 4oz ball peen hammer, then 2 oz hammer...everything went kinda well up until the final stage of peening away a very small play. Then I realized I somehow managed to put the tools in the wrong order in the mist of all things. No smurf, there I thought I gonna pretend I was half good at peening, and something else got the better of me. No smurf!


Everything looks orderly, on a jig...

Then this smurfing dumb move happens, and I was busying taking photo documenting my dumbness...


The small blade supposed to be closest to the liner...then the large blade with space. I should have checked and played with all tools earlier, that might have prevented that.

A comparison between original pins(bottom two) and my own peened pins(top three), I was still about 5-10% away from no play, but at least happy to see the ball peen did move some material down into the countersink alright.Few questions and observations after these peening practices:
-
How much material should I leave on each side of my 93mm alox before I start to peen? I tried 1mm each side, it's kinda ok, but 0.7mm each side don't seem to have enough material to fill the countersink and form a decent 'dome' shape
-
I found concave punches are not doing me any good for peening, anyone using them instead of ball peen hammer? It's not really 'moving' the metal like the ball peen hammer, and I worry it doesn't move enough material down the countersink on the Alox rivet hole...
-
While leaving material on each side, I tried this one technique to push the entire knife flat against the anvil before peening(so any extra pin materials will be pushed up thru the holes), but I was wondering whether I should tried to keep the pin material equal on both sides of the knife while peening. Is there any difference?
Thanks for reading!

-
-
Yay! A drill press - congrats!

As for the riveting I'm sure others here have more experience with SAK rivets than me.
-
@comis said:
While leaving material on each side, I tried this one technique to push the entire knife flat against the anvil before peening(so any extra pin materials will be pushed up thru the holes), but I was wondering whether I should tried to keep the pin material equal on both sides of the knife while peening. Is there any difference?]I did that myself, which led to my backside peening to be larger than the front ones.
I'm sure you can get it exactly the same if you switch the side you're peening, alot.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login