New Style Magnifying Lens Issue
-
I was just trying to understand how big of an issue this was, how many people have had this problem with the lens falling out, nothing more ...

Like I said, I own three SAKs with the new style lens and none of them have this issue, I wanted to know whether I just got lucky or this problem is more of a 1 in a 1000 (or 10.000) problem. Just to see if I should think about this when I decide to buy a SAK with the new style lens in the future. Which means, only buying them at a store where I can check the lens first, so no online buying anymore, if you know what I mean.
That's also why I wanted to know if there were any other known problems with the new style plastic lens holder, like breaking or cracking, just as I asked ? No hidden agenda behind it, no Vic promo for whatever reason I would do such a thing ...
I did find it strange that you made this comment:
@gerleatherberman said:
I would bet my left foot that Victorinox is fully aware of the issue. I've personally sent several emails to them about it. But, I am not paying the shipping to send mine back and wait weeks for another one. Shipping costs a lot more than super-glue. :PKind of funny, that when Vic has a quality issue, they don't get lambasted like most other companies do.

But I decided not to go into that, just to make sure not to stir things up. But since SHTF now, I might just ask ...
You have an issue with a SAK but are not willing to ship it to Victorinox and wait to get a replacement, right ?
Then what is it you expect Victorinox to do exactly ?
Send you a tube of glue/epoxy to fix it ?
Send you a new SAK without you having to send yours to them ?
Send over a technician to come and fix it at your home ?I mean, isn't that how warranty works, you send in your broken/flawed product, they examine the problem and either fix it or send you a replacement, right ?
I know that's the way I did it when I had to get something fixed under warranty, and in one case I even had to pay shipping twice (20 Euro each time) because the replacement tool they send me was used way more than the one I send in ...
Warranty claims suck, and you have to do things you shouldn't have to do when you've bought a brandnew tool, but sometimes, sh*t just happens ...
I still hope to get a better view on just how much of a problem this lens issue is, since it has me a bit worried.
-
For the record, with two straight weeks of carry, and a ton of use, my new Warthog SwissChamp has had no issues with the glass magnifier lens popping out. I also greatly prefer the optical quality of the new glass lens. It’s soooooooooo much nicer to use.
With that said, my outdoor SwissChamps are all of the older variety. My need for DEET based insect repellents kind of rules out the newer SwissChamps, since the clear plastic magnifier housing reacts to DEET. The older grey nylon magnifier housings are immune to my greatest wilderness machinations.
-
@Buzzbait said:
For the record, with two straight weeks of carry, and a ton of use, my new Warthog SwissChamp has had no issues with the glass magnifier lens popping out. I also greatly prefer the optical quality of the new glass lens. It’s soooooooooo much nicer to use.With that said, my outdoor SwissChamps are all of the older variety. My need for DEET based insect repellents kind of rules out the newer SwissChamps, since the clear plastic magnifier housing reacts to DEET. The older grey nylon magnifier housings are immune to my greatest wilderness machinations.
That's the stuff I wanted to hear, so another one without the "lens popping out" problem, and a good reason to prefer the grey lens housing over the new one
.Thanks for sharing your experiences Buzzbait
. -
@ulzhan said:
How about a layer with the old and the new philips together?:D
They won't fit, even with a modified spring to make each side 'work'.
And the old style is never coming back...especially not the old phillips length. Too much was done to make the light module, mag and phillips fit in with any combination and for the phillips to fit in either side. I only choose the newer parts for a mod if the light is going to be one of the tools.
The gray mag might be able to fit in the space of the new glass mag. I think the dimensions are pretty close, not like the plastic mag which was much larger on the round end.
...
FWIW, I haven't had any of my new '12+ glass lenses pop out. Most spin freely. I like it enough and generally prefer it, but don't care for the short phillips that go with.
-
@kamakiri said:
They won't fit, even with a modified spring to make each side 'work'.And the old style is never coming back...especially not the old phillips length. Too much was done to make the light module, mag and phillips fit in with any combination and for the phillips to fit in either side. I only choose the newer parts for a mod if the light is going to be one of the tools.
The gray mag might be able to fit in the space of the new glass mag. I think the dimensions are pretty close, not like the plastic mag which was much larger on the round end.
...
FWIW, I haven't had any of my new '12+ glass lenses pop out. Most spin freely. I like it enough and generally prefer it, but don't care for the short phillips that go with.
So, another one without the "lens popping out" issue, and yes, I understand how the short phillips can be a dealbreaker for some.
Thanks for sharing your experiences Kamakiri
. -
@Top-Gear-24 said:
So, another one without the "lens popping out" issue, and yes, I understand how the short phillips can be a dealbreaker for some.**Thanks for sharing your experiences Kamakiri **
.
You're welcome, Top-Gear. Best reason to be part of the forum! -
I rarely use the magnifier on my Champion Plus (bought new on Amazon just a couple of years ago), but lately I needed it a couple of times, and both time the lens popped out when I opened it. :(
- FiL
-
Second time was a charm with Amazon. I sent back the "new" Explorer that arrived with a plastic magnifier, and got a new glass magnifier model this time. Unlike my Warthog SwissChamp, the glass lens in this newest Explorer doesn't rotate within the housing. It's a very tight fit.
From an optical perspective, I don't see much difference between the new glass and the plastic magnifier. The glass may distort a bit toward the edge, where the plastic does not. But overall, the new glass lens is very nice. I hardly notice any difference in level of magnification between the two. If I didn't already know they were different levels of magnification, I'd probably never suspect.
-
Been carrying my 'champ more often, so I did the logical thing...and ordered a backup.

First time I opened the magnifer...bloop, out it fell. Both my current carry and the new are the new style lens. I noticed the box had tape over the unstickered end - was this one already a return? I'm sending it back, so hopefully the new one won't have the issue. Just another data point for those who are interested...
-
Unbelievable.
The factory videos have us believe every tool is opened in QC before packing it up and sending it out... -
Well, I'm sure it was opened at the factory. It came from that river 'site and, like I mentioned, there was tape on the unstickered side of the box. I suspect it got returned, somwbody popped the lens back in, was satified that it stayed, taped it up and put it back on the rack.
Unrelated, but that river 'site lists the swisschamp as "discontinued by manufacturer"...?
-
I wonder if heat from shipping the new style tools with the clear frame is partly responsible for the frame warping and allowing the lens to come out. I am not very familiar with different plastics and their heat resistances, but just a thought.

I just don't see Vic QC not checking the lens retention at the factory.
-
Whatever it is that causes this issue, I hope Victorinox will look into it and fix it.
Since this lens problem is becoming a bit of a blemish on the Swisschamp's reputation.
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Whatever it is that causes this issue, I hope Victorinox will look into it and fix it.Since this lens problem is becoming a bit of a blemish on the Swisschamp's reputation.
I agree TG!
I found it odd that I could have 3 SwissChamps that were ordered at different times and all had this problem. Each time the lens fell out as the magnifier was being opened.
-
Imagine taking your new SC out in the field, opening the magnifier to inspect an unusual insect on a leaf, and seeing the lens fall out to be lost in the long grass. :ahhh
Then having to be without your shiny new knife - that you've spent weeks or months saving for - while your warranty claim is sorted and your faith in the replacement magnifier (and Victorinox) is tested.
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Imagine taking your new SC out in the field, opening the magnifier to inspect an unusual insect on a leaf, and seeing the lens fall out to be lost in the long grass. :ahhhThen having to be without your shiny new knife - that you've spent weeks or months saving for - while your warranty claim is sorted and your faith in the replacement magnifier (and Victorinox) is tested.
Or worse, you throw it into a drawer and forget about SAKs. :(
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Imagine taking your new SC out in the field, opening the magnifier to inspect an unusual insect on a leaf, and seeing the lens fall out to be lost in the long grass. :ahhhThen having to be without your shiny new knife - that you've spent weeks or months saving for - while your warranty claim is sorted and your faith in the replacement magnifier (and Victorinox) is tested.
@Don Pablo said:
Or worse, you throw it into a drawer and forget about SAKs. :(Yep, first impressions can last a long time...
I've said the same thing in topics about other brands. For collectors or tool fanatics like most of us, such QC issues can be a nuisance, but most of us have more than one tool (understatement :P) and have a back up to use while the warranty repair/trade is in progress.
But if that SAK/tool is the first and only one you own... ::)
-
Sorry about throwing another thought out here. Just trying to put some possible reasons it is occurring out there. :ahhh
The idea is that if we can assertain possible reasons the mag frames aren't as strong as we would expect, we could send some ideas to Vic CS. I know they have chemists on call to check these things, but have they factored in the tools being stored in possibly airtight environments with factory lubricant applied? Maybe so, but it never hurts to check.
But, could there be a possibility that the lubricant used at the factory is weakening the clear mag frames?
Seems some of the instances of mag lens ejection are from tools bought at 'lower prices'. May be related to how long the tools have been stowed away with the factory lubricant leaching into the frame and weakening the structural integrity.
Any thoughts from members with information/ideas about chemical lubricant interactions with certain types of plastics would be much appreciated.

-
I went through all the 4-1 star reviews on Amazon of the Explorer and Swisschamp to find reports of the lens falling out. Note the frequent disappointment and distrust in current Vic quality. Some purchasers thought the lens was plastic. One even thought the knife was fake.
Explorer: 6 reviews of 155 = 1 in 26 :o
"Bought this for my dad and the magnifying glass ended up falling out. Can't return it because it's over 30 day limit."
Two consecutive failures here:
"This knife used to be the best knife Victorinox made. They have changed the design of the magnifier. It is now the worst. The new lens is now plastic instead of glass and it falls out after a few uses. I replaced the first one because it failed immediately. Amazon would not let me return the second one because it failed after the return window closed. Do not buy this knife!!!! Also the picture being used by Amazon is misleading because it pictures the previous version of the Knife that had the glass lens. I ended up purchasing a used knife , with the glass lens, on Ebay. I had my previous Knife for more than 20 years and used it daily. Was a great product."
"Bought my Explorer 2.5 years ago at Amazon. Was cleaning it earlier this year and when I pulled out the magnifier I noticed the plastic lens was completely gone. I also noticed that the "warrantee" by Swiss stipulates that "normal wear and tear" is not covered. Plus the [repair or replace] process on their website is confusing so I didn't even bother to request service. Overall, I might buy another Swiss knife but with the expectation that if parts break I'd just have to buy another one to replace it. Manufacturer warrantees just aren't what they used to be. And getting service and replacement isn't worth the hassle involved even though I have proof of purchase, they could easily claim the loss of the lens was just "normal wear and tear". Oh, one more thing; even though their ad indicates they are "made in …" that doesn't mean they are actually assembled in "...". Truth is, now a days you can't trust anyone to give you the straight dope on any of their products."
"The lens of the magnifying glass was already detached when I opened the box. I am very disappointed since I expected a very good quality from this company."
"The redesigned magnifing lens is garbage. The lens looks to fall out and get lost. There old design worked for 35 years till I shattered the Philips driver trying to break loose a lisence plate screw. Finally lost the new lens at scout camp this summer after having the knife for less than s year."
Not a failure, but Vic offers to swap out the plastic lens for the grey one:
"The knife shown in the image is not the one that you will get if you order this item. Victorinox has made what they call a "running change". They have replaced the 8x magnifying lens surrounded with gray plastic by a 5x lens surrounded by clear plastic. Not only is this new lens flimsier and more likely to break off, but also it will be harder to start a fire with it in an emergency survival situation. Definitely this change is a change for the worse. I don't why Victorinox made this change except to save a few bucks in manufacturing the knife? Luckily, I called Victorinox customer support and they are aware of this problem and said that they will gladly switch out the clear plastic-surrounded lens with a gray-plastic surrounded lens if I send the knife to their Repairs department."
Swisschamp lens falling out. 8 of 1,070 reviews = 1 in 134
"I bought this knife as sold by Amazon in December 2018 and I received a knockoff. If I bought from a third party seller, I would realize I might be getting a knockoff, but I expect Amazon to do a better job getting the real thing. The first clue was that the magnifying "glass" fell off as soon as I opened it. And it was a cloudy piece of plastic, not glass. I am expecting a replacement from Amazon, so I'll update if that one is better."
"I already own this item for 30 years. I wanted an extra one. The plastic frame around the magnifier is flimsy clear plastic. My old one has a tough resin type plastic frame. The first time I used the magnifier on this new one, the lens popped out. Returned."
"I was given a Swiss Champ knife about 15 years ago and have literally used it many times every single day. The springs eventually broke, I lost the corkscrew screwdriver, the side panels both came off a few years ago, and I have still been using it every day since. I finally decided to buy another one and was ecstatic when I opened a brand new one. BUT...when I opened the magnifying lens the first time, the lens came out of the holder. I've used the lens probably 10,000 times (without exaggerating) from the old one and it is still intact.
I am waiting for a replacement, and if everything works I will change my rating to where it should be: 5 stars. I'm not getting my hopes up, though, because nothing seems to be made as well as it used to be made."
"I thought this was pretty cool, and it's what my husband wanted for his birthday.
The magnifying glass broke within the first month he had it. I hope it's just a glitch, and the rest of it will work and last as long as his other knife did.""I had a classic red Swiss Champ for around 30 years. Time did its job on my knife so I wanted to buy a new one. All is perfect and quality is fine BUT the magnifying glass is really a joke on this new models. The first time I used the magnifying glass the lens popped out. I will not return it because I live in another country and the shipping cost is very high. I used to be very happy and confortable with the Victorinox knife quality but I'm very disappointed with this issue."
"Great Knife. I would have given it 5 stars but the magnifying lens is not secure and has popped out.
Likely I was able to reinsert it but be careful when using that feature.""Everything works great except the magnifying glass broke out in my pocket somehow. All in all a versatile tool which I use a lot."
"Overall, I really want to love this model from Victorinox. But, a day after having it, the magnifying lens fell out of its deployment arm/holder. Should just return it, but too much of a hassle for me. Other than that, all the other tools are great and work well. From all it's stampings and markings, it seems to be the real thing. Just this one fail slipped through their quality control checks."
-
A report of the transparent housing breaking, first I've seen.
/topic/81047
@craggus2000 said:
Hi,
I'm looking for a SAK grey magnifier unit please to replace a broken transparent newer version....
@Sawl Goodman said:
I can't help you with a part, sorry. Can I ask about the nature of the breakage? Does it have the plastic lens or the glass lens? Did it come already broken on a used knife?
@craggus2000 said:
Yes it was broken off at the joint so just a little grey stump! I guess glass but not going to know for sure?I then asked him why he wanted a grey magnifier, but he didn't want to continue the discussion.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login