Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
@kamakiri said:
I'm trying to use it as a tool to date knives in the mid-'60s. Use of aluminum seems pretty consistent for indicating early 60's and nickel silver used exclusively after some date. It seems to differ enough from other mid-'60s features like saw teeth and polishing and the earlier tweezer head material change over.In the taxonomy I developed for my collection, I call the time period from 62-69 the "late vintage" or LVNT period. In the LVNT period there is a change from thin 1.0mm aluminum pen blade spacer to nickel silver. In general this coincided with the change from polished to machined saws and silver > black scissor springs.
Thin aluminum spacers come into being in the last part of the "mid vintage" (57-62) period. Prior to that they used a thicker 1.5mm spacer that was either aluminum or nickel silver in no way that seems to indicate preference. The thicker spacer goes away when the main/pen blade backspring is redesigned c 1960 to go from a design that was thicker at the pen blade side to one that was of uniform thickness (roughly 2.75mm).
-
@MiniChamp said:
??? I'm a little confused by this statement. Are you proposing that they actually did something else? If so, what?Is it my odd naming that is confusing? Or the chronology? AFAIK, the chronology of the 84mm wood saw goes like this:
c. 1955: 35TAP
c. 1963: 25TAP (this is the rare one)
c. 1963: 35TAM
c. 1966: 25TSMI find it interesting that they tried the 25TAP saw very briefly after about a year into the LVNT period, but then got rid of it almost immediately in favor of the older 35T saw (this time machined and not polished). I'd love to know why they didn't like the 25TAP version.
-
In the mean time a little bit of vintage alox ones: Old Cross ELINOX with bail, "the whole nine yard" instant vintage collection... :)



-
@jazzbass said:
In the taxonomy I developed for my collection, I call the time period from 62-69 the "late vintage" or LVNT period. In the LVNT period there is a change from thin 1.0mm aluminum pen blade spacer to nickel silver. In general this coincided with the change from polished to machined saws and silver > black scissor springs.I already understood that much. I'm trying to assign/estimate dates for these smaller changes, like I have done for the '70s/91mm.
I'd like to refine and reorganize this list for 91mm main line production:
c. '63 End - Nickel Silver tipped tweezers
c. '63/'64 End - Silver scissor spring
c. '63/'64 End - Aluminum 'birdhead' spacer
c. '64-'66 End - Polished Wood Saw
c. '66 End - Angled Wood Saw teethI have a tendency to use start and end dates in my chronology since they do not always coincide but overlap like clip and drop point small blades.
@jazzbass said:
Thin aluminum spacers come into being in the last part of the "mid vintage" (57-62) period. Prior to that they used a thicker 1.5mm spacer that was either aluminum or nickel silver in no way that seems to indicate preference. The thicker spacer goes away when the main/pen blade backspring is redesigned c 1960 to go from a design that was thicker at the pen blade side to one that was of uniform thickness (roughly 2.75mm).I don't have very many of my own notes from this period, but broadly understand that all. I would like to eventually work more on that period. On the list are the transition dates from nickel silver liners to aluminum - for both 91mm 'sharp' transition and 83/84mm where parts may have been more mixed as MiniChamp has suggested. Use of the thin ~0.52mm aluminum liners.
-
Let's do some serious vintage - probably the favorite knife in my collection, the 1905 Model 290:

It's quite large. Here is a comparison of the screwdriver between other models:
[pic removed for bad info - will repost later]
-
Great knife in excellent condition. Nice to see it again here.
-
Cool!!!

It's quite large. Here is a comparison of the screwdriver between other models:

I'm a bit puzzled. Ulli's table lists 1901 as the end year of the "Gesetzlich Geschützt" SD stamps. Also, as was recently discussed in Ulli's pictorial evolution thread, he thinks that Victorinox moved to three visible rivets around 1909. Are you sure about the dating estimate for the model 234k in that image?
There seem to be somewhat different opinions concerning SAK evolution in the very early 20th century. Any light you can shed here (When did they move to three visible rivets? When did they introduce the groove in the corkscrew? etc.) will be greatly appreciated.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Cool!!!

I'm a bit puzzled. Ulli's table lists 1901 as the end year of the "Gesetzlich Geschützt" SD stamps.Oh man, that’s a brain fade mistake on my part that I forgot about. I originally took that pic with a 3 rivet Tourist but didn’t like the way the lighting came out. When I retook the picture I used a new-to-me 1890s Tourist and forgot to change the text overlay. :-[
Going to delete that one and repost with the correct info. Thanks for catching that!
-
-
@jnoxyd said:
Three wood saw types:
Cool pics (as usual), Jnoxyd.
I attach an image of the fourth type of wood saw from the 1960's that was mentioned by JAZZBASS.@jazzbass said:
AFAIK, the chronology of the 84mm wood saw goes like this:c. 1955: 35TAP
c. 1963: 25TAP (this is the rare one)
c. 1963: 35TAM
c. 1966: 25TSMI find it interesting that they tried the 25TAP saw very briefly after about a year into the LVNT period, but then got rid of it almost immediately in favor of the older 35T saw (this time machined and not polished). I'd love to know why they didn't like the 25TAP version.
If I understand correctly, this proposed chronology relates only to Victoria SAKs. AFAIK, things were a bit different for the Elinox line. I believe that the unpolished saws with 35 asymmetric teeth were first introduced on Elinox SAKs in the late 1950's and then when they started using them on the Victoria line, they didn't really make any new type of saw, but rather just adopted the Elinox saw variant for use on the Victoria line. It's possible that these saws with 35 teeth also lasted longer on Elinox SAKs, because they can be found on model 1240kU SAKs with a keyring. (So either these saws lasted longer on the Elinox line, or that the keyring was introduced on the Elinox line before it was introduced on the Victoria line, or both.)

-
@MiniChamp said:
Cool pics (as usual), Jnoxyd.
I attach an image of the fourth type of wood saw from the 1960's that was mentioned by JAZZBASS.
If I understand correctly, this proposed chronology relates only to Victoria SAKs. AFAIK, things were a bit different for the Elinox line. I believe that the unpolished saws with 35 asymmetric teeth were first introduced on Elinox SAKs in the late 1950's and then when they started using them on the Victoria line, they didn't really make any new type of saw, but rather just adopted the Elinox saw variant for use on the Victoria line. It's possible that these saws with 35 teeth also lasted longer on Elinox SAKs, because they can be found on model 1240kU SAKs with a keyring. (So either these saws lasted longer on the Elinox line, or that the keyring was introduced on the Elinox line before it was introduced on the Victoria line, or both.)Seems to me that the 35TAP saws lasted past '63. It's easy to find ones with black scissor springs, aluminum tweezers and either birdhead material.
What tweezer, scissor spring and 'birdhead' go with that 25TAP? Machined main blade tang?
-
@MiniChamp said:
Aluminum spacer, no tweezers (missing) and no real scissors spring (there is a small relic suggesting a silver spring).Perfect, thanks. That does confirm c.'63 production and not outside of '62 to '64 possibility. I actually think the broken scissor spring attachment is somewhat stronger proof of OE status. Especially if it's the preceding/earlier material. The rest of the knife should be able to confirm earlier or latter on that date range.
I have a 136ka Craftsman with a broken black spring with the 35TAP saw. Aluminum spacer and tweezer makes it close to yours, but overall polish on mine put it in the latter part and I estimate c. '64/'65, or shortly after your 25 TAP.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Cool!!!

Also, as was recently discussed in Ulli's pictorial evolution thread, he thinks that Victorinox moved to three visible rivets around 1909.This is one change I'm still not sure about. I haven't seen any sources for the 1909 date other than the "official" Victorinox timeline, which has so many errors that I question all of it. But I have seen (and own) several stainless steel 4 rivet knives and I believe them to be original. That said, these knives were all hand made at the time, so it would have been no big deal for a knife maker to make one with 4 rivets post 1923 despite three rivets being the "standard way. "
The other thing that makes me think that 4 rivets lasted longer are sales numbers. Knives made pre-cap lifter with the large screwdriver fall into what I call the "Original" era. I divide the Original era into two periods - Early Original (EORG) knives with 4 rivets and Late Original (LORG) knives with 3 rivets. If the EORG period really only went from 1897-1909, then the LORG period would span from c. 1909-1930. This means that the LORG period lasted 2x longer than EORG, as thus you should see many, many more LORG knives for sale than EORG. Esp since as a growing company during this era, any later period would always be biased to show up more in online sales.
But the numbers don't back this up. Of all the Original era knives sold in the last 10 years online, 42% were EORG and 58% were LORG. This is one of the main reasons I tend to think the EORG period pushes out until at least 1920. There are too many EORG knives sold to represent such a small time window of manufacture.
Of course, this is all basically archeology. Looking at various bits of evidence and trying to draw conclusions on it all, and there's going to be a lot of guesses that are wrong. The 4 rivets knives could very well have disappeared in 1909, but there would have to be another explanation for their over-representation vs 3 rivet knives in knife sales.
-
@Huntsman said:
Yay
I very well remember the fascinating thread when JB first found this model
Thanks- Some interesting tools too
BTW - What is the wee tool between the saw and opener? And are the scales are glued on?
I believe it to be a leather punch. Here's a closer detail of it along with a detail view of the hoof pick w/ file and drill tool.

The interesting thing about it is that it's hollow - if you look at the end it's not a solid awl like we're all used to. It's more like one of these:

- Some interesting tools too
-
Ah - Thanks for the detail JB - Much appreciated - I wondered if it might be one of those - A hole making punch - but normally hit with a hammer - which would not be good for a SAK!
And a cut out on both sides of the handles ... unusual !Wonderful knife - Not just the age and size - But also all the unusual/whacky tools - Thanks again for showing us
Another Q - Do you ever think of a little cleaning up your older models?
You see some old models completely transformed and polished and shiny - which I think looks ridiculous for what is an antique!
But sometimes a little cleaning makes it look a lot better - eg a bit of wire wool on the black bits around the joints - which is probably just hardened old oil and muck!
I can also understand the 'leave exactly as is' approach!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login