New Style Magnifying Lens Issue
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
These are just my thoughts on some of the comments above, I still think it might only be a low precentage of SAK's with the magnifier that have this problem since they sell a lot of them (read: A LOT !!!).But it's clear Victorinox should address this problem
.I was going to add my own thoughts at the end of the post, but since I'd already spent too long of a sunny morning researching and writing the thing, I ran out of interest! :ahhh
As well as trying to find out how much of a problem this is, I also wanted to see how often "user error" came into it, as suggested earlier in the thread. I bought my Explorer used, but in almost new condition, just a few scratches on the scales, so there was always the possibility of previous damage. I always expect functional issues with used knives (and nearly always find them!). Still, there was something odd about the knife arriving with the lens loose inside and the lens falling out repeatedly, even after I was careful in reseating it and opening slowly. But here are a number of reports of lenses in brand new knives reported in the reviews as falling out on the magnifier's first opening, and no nothing suggesting abuse.
I do agree about the rarity. The vast majority of buyers won't have a problem. It reminds me of electronic items like phones and laptops. Most failures occur at the start and end of their expected working lives.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curveStill, it's a small cloud Victorinox can do without.
I think Syph makes a good point about housing tolerances. I can see defective magnifiers occurring in batches. The customer who had a faulty knife replaced with another with the same problem. Vicman of this county who had three defective magnifiers in quick succession.
Finally, I like the new magnifier a lot and will never let it stop me buying a knife with it. If the lens fell out and didn't get lost I'd just glue it back in and stop worrying! :D
-

The new magnifier is the bomb. The old gray housing definitely inspired more confidence, but on the working 'champ (the new one was a backup) the magnifier sees a lot of use.
Since we're discussing it anyway, what are everybody's glue recommendations?
-
I wonder if the possible reason is environmental. Perhaps a factor such as plastic shrinkage at high altitudes might effect the magnifier housing. I'm not sure how it would work though. The higher altitude might shrink the housing, causing the lens to actually sit tighter, and then expansion of the inner diameter of the housing at lower altitudes might cause the magnifier to slip.
-
@Intorikata said:
Since we're discussing it anyway, what are everybody's glue recommendations?Well, as above, 5 minute epoxy did the job for me. The best glue for bonding two different rigid materials together, permanently. With a paperclip, I applied two tiny drops opposite each other on the inside edge of the housing, before reseating the lens.
A single drop might be enough. I wanted to take no chances.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ [That was Louis Blackpaw, seconding the method while he checked out the animated emoticons.] -
Some time ago, I had a Champion C Plus that was a user for someone before I got it. It had the opaque housing and probably the plastic lense. I never had a problem with it but after cleaning it up, it rested in my day pack.
I've since given it away and got another, old school Champion. It does not have Plus Scales, and it doesnt have the extra tools on the backstrap, but it is solid. Grooved corkscrew, no half stop bottle opener, a reprofiled blade and most importantly, the grey mag lense housing.
Also, i have an equally old Explorer with grey mag housing
My thoughts on this are that if you make something that it meant to be utilitarian and used outside, then it should not contain any important parts that could "pop out" and become lost in the field.
Vic has screwed the pooch on these magnifyers because they are either:
-flimsy
Or
- flimsy AND can pop out.
Either way, it's a fail. It doesnt matter if the new lense itself is better, if the device cant even be opened without worrying and having a$$-pucker factor.
I have NO FEAR that the grey housings are going to drop their lenses on me, so I was sure to go old school on mag lenses.
Sure , this is anecdotal, but I have heard of lenses popping out of the opaque housings, and I personally have never heard of this happening with the grey housing.
Let's say only between 1 and 4 percent of lenses are popping out. Does that sound bad? Maybe not.
Is it bad if compared to, say, 0.05% of lenses in grey housings popping out. Yeah. That would be terrible. That number is pure conjecture, but I think if we want to be fair, we cannot ONLY count what percentage of new style lenses pop out. We would have to comapre that to the percentage of old lenses popped out.
Either way, I'm sticking with old school for reliability. If the metal saw and file were of extreme importance to me, I might have a different opinion but this is a mag lense thread, so...
-
Well said, Thundah.

I know the number(for grey frames) is anecdotal, but that brings up a question, if I may?
Has anyone ever had or heard of an old-style grey frame ever failing to retain the lens? Barring breakage of the implement itself of course.
Can't say I have had it happen or read about it yet.

-
I for one have never heard of the lens popping out on the grey plastic lens holder. And no matter how small of a percentage of the new lens holders have this issue, it does seem to be a recurring thing, so Victorinox should really look into it and fix the issue.
The new lens holder failing or braking on the other hand has only come up once here, and the person who had this problem apparently didn't want to go in on the details of how and when, just that it broke of at the joint, which seems very unlikely to happen during normal use.
I mean, we all know that one person who broke the knife on a ST300 or a Swisstool because he tried to pry a brick out of a brick wall with it ::).
If more people have this kind of breakage on their new style lens holders it could also be a potential problem, but for now I believe the lens popping out is the issue at hand.
Just my 2 cents ;).
-

The frame integrity seems to be acceptable for the application. But, the tolerances look to be the culprit in the popped out lenses. As many stated, a bit of epoxy or cyanoacrylate glue is a great solution. Seems Vic could start doing this at the factory. I ended up using 3 dots of cyanoacrylate(preference thing), though two is sufficient from what has been written so far.
-
The frame integrity seems to be acceptable for the application. But, the tolerances look to be the culprit in the popped out lenses. As many stated, a bit of epoxy or cyanoacrylate glue is a great solution. Seems Vic could start doing this at the factory. I ended up using 3 dots of cyanoacrylate(preference thing), though two is sufficient from what has been written so far.

Okay, it's one step extra in the production progress (adding a bit of epoxy in the factory, I mean), but I guess that would still be a lot easier (and cheaper) than to find the cause of (and deal with) the lens tolerance ...
And even if they want to go after the initial cause, the epoxy thing is a good solution until they fix the core of the problem.
-
How do I tell if my Explorer has the glass or plastic lens?
Mine was definitely sold new in 2017, as it has a company logo showing 50 years... 1967-2017.
No, mine hasn’t fallen out and I haven’t tried to remove it. Just wondering how to tell what magnifying lens is in mine?
Thanks!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Could this be a repair case by VICTORINOX : <a href="/topic/82091 SAK that is not in the Victorinox catalogs</a>

-
Edit:

The magnification level is one way to determine the lens material. Another way is to tap it with a piece of glass like a marble. The glass will have a faint "tink" sound, while the plastic will have a faint "thud" sound. :ahhh
-
@zrxoa1 said:
How do I tell if my Explorer has the glass or plastic lens?Look at the attached Victorinox documents. There are some differences in the shape of the holder, the spring and the associated Phillips screwdriver.
-
@MiniChamp said:
Look at the attached Victorinox documents. There are some differences in the shape of the holder, the spring and the associated Phillips screwdriver.Very interesting PDF's my friend, thanks for sharing them
.When comparing my "third generation lens" SilverTech Swisschamps with my "second generation lens" ones I always thought the spring action felt different. When you close the lens on the "second gen lens" Swisschamps you only notice the spring closing it at the very end, while on the new ones the spring takes over a lot earlier during the closing of the lens (hope this makes sense).
All three of my new lens SilverTech Swisschamps feel this way, while both of my "second generation lens" Swisschamps, and my Explorer with the same lens have the "weak" spring action.
I can only speak about the examples I own, which are three of the new ones, and three of the "second generation" ones (and one or two old grey ones, but those don't really matter here).
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Very interesting PDF's my friend, thanks for sharing them
.
-
The 3 lenses that I have had fall out of SwissChamps were all the glass ones in the 3rd generation version.
-
The frame integrity seems to be acceptable for the application. But, the tolerances look to be the culprit in the popped out lenses. As many stated, a bit of epoxy or cyanoacrylate glue is a great solution. Seems Vic could start doing this at the factory. I ended up using 3 dots of cyanoacrylate(preference thing), though two is sufficient from what has been written so far.
I agree it would probably take considerable force to break the housing, which I suspect is made of polycarbonate.
CA (superglue) is definitely the easier way to keep the lens put than epoxy, and might be strong enough. Did it cloud the housing?
-
@zrxoa1 said:
How do I tell if my Explorer has the glass or plastic lens?Mine was definitely sold new in 2017, as it has a company logo showing 50 years... 1967-2017.
No, mine hasn’t fallen out and I haven’t tried to remove it. Just wondering how to tell what magnifying lens is in mine?
Thanks!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
To add to G-man's and MiniCamp's tips, there's also a ribbed effect on the inside of the housing, barely noticeable. I bought my Explorer knowing it had the glass lens because I was able to see this ribbing in the seller's pictures.
I'm looking at it right now... and wouldn't you fugging know it, the freaking lens fell out again!!!
I must have contaminated the edges with my fingertips when I glued them, I don't know. :ahhh -
With these opaque/ clear housings, the thing to remember is not how much force is needed to break them. Only how little force is needed to deform them enough to allow the lense to pop out.
This is just NOT a robust design. That's all there is to it.
We dont buy our Swiss Army Knives so that they work most of the time. We expect them to work. Whether or not they are up to a given task or not is a matter of reasoning it out, but if there were virtually no known instances of lenses spontaneously popping out of grey housings, and there are at least a few popping out of the newer housings, then that's just not acceptable.
Only things I can think of are
-of course, cost to produce
And
-maybe something in the grey housing is of a material that is no longer available or legal to produceAnd of course, the cost of a new Explorer vs the cost of mailing and repair makes us decide we are better off applying our own home-grown fix. And that sucks if you have to do that to a brand new knife. Especially a Vic. Unheard of. Until now
-
...the shape of their MAC, no doubt.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login