Experiences with WORKPRO tools
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Got this one on the way. Looking forward to trying this one out. Should arrive Tuesday. :):ahhh I have ordered one and I blame u Gman!

On a side note, this is a 4in tool. It's should be very interesting. I dun like of that scissors though.. Looks and should work/not work like the ones on Sogs...
-
I own a few of the scissors tool other guys have posted, with the Craftsman branding. Bought one new (and cheap) out of curiosity, got a couple more in a a used tool lot I bought just to get a specific tool I was hunting. The scissors are good enough to make a decent set of folding scissors for EDC, fishing, etc. Though, as RP first mentioned, the other implements are decidedly below average. Seems like it might be a good move to remove those and save the weight.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Got this one on the way. Looking forward to trying this one out. Should arrive Tuesday. :)That might be the best of both worlds, the design of their Heavy Duty tool, with most of its tools, but 4" long, and with scissors. As long as the scissors are decent. But in any case it's nice to see the HD tool platform scaled down to 4" at least.
I look forward to your thoughts!
-
@ReamerPunch said:
That might be the best of both worlds, the design of their Heavy Duty tool, with most of its tools, but 4" long, and with scissors. As long as the scissors are decent. But in any case it's nice to see the HD tool platform scaled down to 4" at least.
I look forward to your thoughts!
Totally agree! I cancelled my order from amazon but ordered from another source.. So mine is going to take a while. Rarely do a good C&C tool come in a 4in package. Usually they are blocky and unwieldy.. Looking forward to your review.

-
Sorry guys. As is came from the factory, it is closer to the junk end of the scale than to the cheerful end.
Scissors are pure smurf crap(barely cut paper), fit and finish are about 50% of the heavy duty 4.5" version. Pliers have so much play that I have trouble cutting 18g stranded wire with them. The saw has 4mm or so of uncut length for teeth and the two rows of teeth are not even. Phillips driver is among the worst I've seen.
I will take pics later to better show what I received.The scissor design is O.K. I must say, but the QC of them is terrible on my example. Like a set of PowerPint scissors, but that have poor cutting geometry and pivot tolerances.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Sorry guys. As is came from the factory, it is closer to the junk end of the scale than to the cheerful end.Scissors are pure smurf crap(barely cut paper), fit and finish are about 50% of the heavy duty 4.5" version. Pliers have so much play that I have trouble cutting 18g stranded wire with them. The saw has 4mm or so of uncut length for teeth and the two rows of teeth are not even. Phillips driver is among the worst I've seen.
I will take pics later to better show what I received.The scissor design is O.K. I must say, but the QC of them is terrible on my example. Like a set of PowerPint scissors, but that have poor cutting geometry and pivot tolerances.
Oh my goodnesssssss..... Thats a nightmare to hear.. I rarely hear you make such bad feedbacks.... It must be really really terrible.. I should had gone with amazon.....

-
Plus side? Pliers are spring loaded and open wider than the HD version. Another bad side is the 4" tool is 10.5oz. That is not a joke, it is a 4" tool over 10oz.

-
Here we go. Hopefully the pictures can convey the serious step down of quality from the HD WorkPro.
See the weight. 10.582oz..


Top is HD WorkPro.
Bottom is 4" WorkPro.
Note the finish quality is a step down.

Phillips. Note the deformed tip.

Flat blade and bottle opener. Note the better angles on the HD.

LG flat drivers. Pretty much the same.

Awls. Both decent.

Can Opener. Stripper was removed from the implement.

Saws. Note the poorly finished teeth on the 4".

Files. The HD has 3-sides and the 4" had two sides. Both are cut well enough. The 4" file is a bit more aggressive, but not cut as cleanly.

Plain edge blade. Pretty much the same, but sized differently for each tool. The 4" isn't polished like the HD, but has a stone'wash-like finish. Both are sharp enough.
*Note HD has a serrated blade, but the 4" version replaces that with scissors.

Pliers. The HD pliers are not sprung, but the 4" pliers are. The spring could move mountains it is so strong. Some like it and some don't. The 4" model pliers open wider than the HD pliers.



Scissors. I pictured them with the old style WorkPro 4" tool scissors since the HD doesn't have scissors.

Scissors showing grind and spring. Note the bad geometry. Spring setup is acceptable.

-

What a shame.
The HD really shines in comparison.Do you think Workpro's quality has dropped altogether? Will the new HD ones be total junk?

-
@ReamerPunch said:

What a shame.
The HD really shines in comparison.Do you think Workpro's quality has dropped altogether? Will the new HD ones be total junk?

I would hope not, but if their new 4" model is any indicator, the quality is likely to be inferior to that of the OG HD.

Will hope that isn't the case, and I keep hoping I got a dud, but as many QC oversights that are visible, the outlook isn't great. :ahhh
-
I am even more excited to receive it now. Really have to see and feel the quality.. Was not really impress with the HD as its a real brick to handle.. Was hoping that this might be a little more manageable..
-
Funny thing is, the 4" WorkPro is over 10oz. Just a few ounces less than the larger one.

I hope your example is better. But, that said, I can't see the inherent quality issues being much improved.
Then again, we also rarely agree on how well a tool functions. So you may really like the 4" Workpro.

-
@gerleatherberman said:
Funny thing is, the 4" WorkPro is over 10oz. Just a few ounces less than the larger one.
I hope your example is better. But, that said, I can't see the inherent quality issues being much improved.
Then again, we also rarely agree on how well a tool functions. So you may really like the 4" Workpro.

Some minor differences.. :D But generally I think we still are on the same side of the fence.

-
True true.

After some thought on the 4" version, I do realize now that I was comparing a $20 tool(4") to a $40 tool(HD). Perhaps a revisit to the 4" WorkPro, with the much lower cost as a consideration, would be a good idea.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
True true.
After some thought on the 4" version, I do realize now that I was comparing a $20 tool(4") to a $40 tool(HD). Perhaps a revisit to the 4" WorkPro, with the much lower cost as a consideration, would be a good idea.
The price was quite the opposite on my side.. The HD was actually cheaper than the 4in. I really like the 4in form factor, even for other brands. To me that would be the ideal size. Recently bought a few C&C but they are all rather pretty big. Guessing they have to have the bulk to make up for perhaps the lower quality material. Nevertheless, we probably know how they will turn out even before receiving them. Just keeping the fingers crossed that there will be some Cheap & Quality..
-
@Sam Lim said:
The price was quite the opposite on my side.. The HD was actually cheaper than the 4in. I really like the 4in form factor, even for other brands. To me that would be the ideal size. Recently bought a few C&C but they are all rather pretty big. Guessing they have to have the bulk to make up for perhaps the lower quality material. Nevertheless, we probably know how they will turn out even before receiving them. Just keeping the fingers crossed that there will be some Cheap & Quality..That is so weird that the HD costs less than the 4" over there. May be a popularity thing? Big giant MTs seem to sell best in the US(surprise..haha), so that may be why the pricing is different.

-
The 4in version is now $16 on Amazon now. I still have not receive mine from the other source!

-
@Sam Lim said:
The 4in version is now $16 on Amazon now. I still have not receive mine from the other source!
$16 changes my perspective on the tool a bit, as it gets the tool closer to the $10 tool territory if you account for for the shipping and taxes included in the sale price.
Sorry to read your 4" WorkPro hasnt arrived yet, Sam! Hopefully soon! :ahhh
-
Pretty happy to report it did arrive in my mailbox today when I reach home. But very sadly, I would agree with pretty much all of GLBM's observation. And I would like to emphasise on the handling of this tool. Its really really blocky, its the same thickest as the HD. And the weight of this thing, it's unbelievably heavy for a tool of this size..
But on the plus side, it looks really pretty when placed side by side with the older brother. Much akin to a wave and a surge.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
