Day by Day...a Journey down the 91mm Range
-
Nice one again!

Your cons are the reason I pass on it. I would be more afraid of breaking it in the outdoor environment, dropping it, etc.
-
Yes, that is a concern. But I’ve had Swatches and they’re tough little plastic watches, so it would probably do a respectable job of holding up given it has so much Swatch DNA. But as I only have one, I don’t expect to use mine for EDC.

-
Nice write-up again, Max!

-
This has been such a fun and educational thread for me - awesome work Max!
It has got me thinking about how, almost counter-intuitively, so many of these models seem to have their own special character that you only really discover when you handle and use them day to day. I mean you'd think that with a limited number of permutations based on a small number of different tools there would be a certain sameness to the range, and choosing between knives would be a simple, utilitarian matter. But it certainly doesn't feel that way.
Part of it, I'm sure, is the well thought out system of naming that Victorinox have, which creates a certain personality for the knife right away, and makes it easy to think and talk about the models...it's much more inviting to get involved in a discussion about the relative merits of the Explorer and the Super-Tinker than if they were the V91.42 and the V91.36. No slouches when it came to marketing, these Elseners!
But there is more to it than that I think. Partly down to an effect I first noticed when I was a watch nut many years ago, that small differences you would think are insignificant in objective terms, a couple of millimetres here or a few grams there, can create a huge difference in subjective experience when they apply to these small objects that we share our personal space with on a daily basis. The 4mm difference in thickness between a Climber and an Explorer isn't much, but it's a world of difference in the hand or the pocket.
-
Great write-up and pics of the Swiss Champ Super Timer Max!

-
Thanks VICMAN, Rapidray and Sir Vic

And fullbreakfast, you raise an interesting topic of individuality which is certainly stronger on some SAKs than others, with the name contributing to this. Like watches, SAKs are very tactile and personal items, so it’s not surprising that some are held in higher regard.

Day 27
Victorinox products are generally designed for everyday use. But like many brands, they have realized there’s good business to be made by targeting enthusiasts and collectors.
And while there’s nothing stopping you carrying a limited edition Victorinox Damascus pocket knife for EDC (and people do), the size of the very large SAKs, with 10-15 layers, do tend to limit them to collectors (that, and the price).
But there appears to be one 91mm Victorinox that has a little bit of an identity crisis. Is it for general use, or for the collector? This is the 11-layer Swiss Champ XLT.
Victorinox realized, shortly after launching the CyberTool family in 2000, that they could add the newly-released bit driver to the Swiss Champ and create a super Swiss Champ. But in an unusual decision, Victorinox decided to add a further two layers, one for the Pharmaceutical Spatula and another for a pair of less common short blades, a Pruning and an
Electrician's blade.So Victorinox may have missed an opportunity to upgrade the Swiss Champ with just one extra layer, similar to what they did with the Champion, when they added the inline Phillips and magnifier as a mid-life upgrade from six to seven layers.
But there’s a simple explanation. Victorinox had just released the Swiss Champ XL a year before the CyberTool, and I suspect that as sales were poor on this product, they decided to swap out the golf-specific divot repair tool for the more useful bit driver.
There’s also the need to space products and prices to avoid unnecessary sales cannibalization. A Swiss Champ with a bit driver could put CyberTool L (CT-41) sales at risk and even threaten the Swiss Champ. But I still think they missed an opportunity.
As a side note, it’s common for the XLT to be referred to unofficially as the CT-50, for its 50 functions and tool relationship with the CyperTool family. Maybe if they dropped a couple of questionable layers, they could market it as a 9-layer CyberTool XL?
Pros:
- A Swiss Champ with a bit driver
Cons:
- Unnecessarily extra layers come along for the ride
Bottom line:
The XLT should not be seen as a collector’s SAK, but as a Swiss Champ with an added bit driver, ready to be carried in a bag or glove compartment to tackle any range of tasks...even to handle pharmaceutical products.



-
That is some interesting history! Great review for sure!

-
Pharmaceutical spatula? I thought that was an oar!

-

Good one! -
Love thos thread and the descriptions.
-
The XLT is definitilvely a user...
-
Good review and great pics of the XLT Max!

I have an XLT, but it is just a shade too wide for the size of my hands for it to be comfortable in use.
The size of the SwissChamp is the largest that is comfortable for me.
-
Thanks Rapidray, Sos, VICMAN, fullbreakfast, ulzhan, TXSAK.

The XLT is in that grey zone. I have carried and used mine (more out of curiosity), and while it is a little more bulky in the hand, it’s nothing like the XAVT which is definitely in the collectors corner. I am sure that a good percentage of XLT’s get bought and used, and not put on a shelf...
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Max, on your Expedition Lite knife, is the housing of the light part grey or clear? Mine is grey, but I understand there is a clear housing on some. Someone here on MTO posted a photo of the clear housing and I've wanted it ever since.Still waiting for the Expedition Lite to land. But it seems Victorinox switched to a clear LED housing on the XAVT when they dropped the grey magnifier in favour for the Wenger wrench.
Clear housing is cool as it lights up when the LED is on...not sure why this change hasn’t migrated to all other ‘Lite’ models. Maybe just an inventory issue on the housing?


-
Nice shot of the lite

-
@fullbreakfast said:
Do you find it easy enough to use the tools with such a fat knife? I've always thought 43mm wide would be too much of a handful for me, even though I always wanted a SAK with a coke spoon attachment...No Problem. I am used to it and it works. Have a XLT for EDC.
-
I recently got a NIB oldish (v2 mag.) XLT for 130 Euros with every intention of pocket carrying it occasionally when hiking. Now, while I find it can be carried with a P-7 clip reasonably well, I suddenly have scruples using it on account of the high price.
An unexpected dilemma: I wanted the XLT to be prepared for all eventualities but am now afraid I might feel guilty if it deteriorates in the process. Yet deterioration is of course inevitable when a multittool sees action and gets you out of a pinch. I had an old Swisschamp (which sadly I lost) that could testify to that, but it served me well and I never gave a second thought to using it whenever I felt the need.
While this dilemma might not exist in case of a Swisstool given that there just aren't viable cheap alternatives (I wouldn't really know, I am not a pliers guy), I have become very aware since owning the XLT just how unlikely it is I will ever encounter a hiking situation in which the XLT would save the day whereas a normal SC (or even a Ranger, for that matter) would not. And at less than half the price at that (or a quarter of the price in case of the Ranger...).
Has anyone encountered the same dilemma and can give me any compelling reasons why I should not keep the XLT as a pristine shelf queen and take the SC (or the still reasonably priced CT41) on my hikes instead?
(Edit: just to dodge the inevitable joke, I should add I don't take drugs...)
-
Doubt a bit driver is very useful on a hike. The two extra blades are likely superfluous to the existing large/small blades. I would reckon the 'champ all the way. Use the extra weight/space for a fire starter, knife sharpener, or light.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login