Batoning Is Stupid
-
@Etherealicer said:
It is interesting to know, but if you take that as a benchmark you will end up with a thicker, heavier knife.
I mean the Fällkniven A1X (Full tang, 7mm tick, 400g) probably fairs better in batoning test than a Mora Buschcraft (3.2mm tick / 165g). But for the weight of the A1X you get 2 Mora Bushcraft and 4 Bic Lighter.Excellent point, the funny part is I batoned the shxt out of my Mora Bushcraft black(which btw is one of my favorite fixie) just to see whether it could take the abuse, and after an hour of batoning thru fire wood with just very minor roll, that experience has forever changed my perspective on fixed blade.
Chopper aside, so as long we are not mistaking our fixed blade as an axe, I figured many well made fixed blade, even with thin stock, could sustain "sensible" occasional batoning.
-
@Aloha said:
I'm sure there has to be a point when all this batoning started. I have seen/read getting to the inner parts of the wood in the case of wood being we was one reason
. Testing of knives certainly has become the "main" reason tho. When we camp we scavenge for wood. Usually we find all the material needed an no batoning is needed. We have broken down wrist size pieces into pencil sized ones batoning but its no where near hammering a knife thru a log. We make feather sticks for fun to "play" with ferro rods and friction fire starting methods.The need of fire in a situation one can break branches off trees starting at the end and working your way to the trunk. At some point tho a lot of force would be needed. I think if it was raining tinder would be the most difficult to gather rather than the larger pieces. Non makes any sense in the rain if a shelter isn't competed. Making a fire in the rain seems difficult at best.
I think batoning becomes "popular" when "bushcrafting" becomes a household name for the knife industry. Then all the sudden everyone is "batoning" and making feather sticks(myself included
). With that, comes the chopper or the "one tool option" for "outdoor survival". I'm no outdoor survival expert, but I will always remember how big is the More Kochanski's survival kettle, and the kind of tools he would bring with him for winter survival.If there is ever a scenario to survive a couple of winter nights in Boreal Forrest, instead of being a beast knife like Etherealicer mentioned and wasting all the calories bashing in the woods, to me the sensible thing will be bringing relevant tools to make things easy and efficient.
Of course, all those good tips we mentioned should go first, even before we have to resort to this :D
-
@comis said:
Excellent point, the funny part is I batoned the shxt out of my Mora Bushcraft black(which btw is one of my favorite fixie) just to see whether it could take the abuse, and after an hour of batoning thru fire wood with just very minor roll, that experience has forever changed my perspective on fixed blade.Chopper aside, so as long we are not mistaking our fixed blade as an axe, I figured many well made fixed blade, even with thin stock, could sustain "sensible" occasional batoning.
Well... full tang is a rather recent trend. I mean big knives like the Sax and even swords were through-/hidden tang, so were the WW1&2 trench knives, everyday knives where usually skinny and small. The Mora is fashioned after an age old design, from a time when people probably had to rely on their knife far more often.
Machetes seem to be the exception, having a full tang, but they are commonly thinner blades with a lot of flexibility and together with its relatives they dominate the wilder parts of today's world. Workhorses like the blades used to harvest sugar cane (still to this day done by hand) are simple chopping blades with through- or even hidden tang.
I think the secret is a softer steel and sharpening more often. -
@Aloha said:
Fire can be multipurpose however. Lets not forget it can be used as a signal, deterrent to animals, and disinfect water. While I agree with clothing and ones intelligence being important I'd highly suggest one also bring a means of fire. While not number one on the list it certainly should be on the list IMO.I like how this thread varies from the original topic to a bit of a wider spectrum and to come back to the beginning :D
Anyway, agreeing with Aloha here.
Forgive me for sharing my own thread link here too...
/topic/82573Even when not expecting trouble, always pack some items that might solve issues that could arrise. A Mylar and a lighter weigh nothing, and you're better safe than sorry.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Well... full tang is a rather recent trend. I mean big knives like the Sax and even swords were through-/hidden tang, so were the WW1&2 trench knives, everyday knives where usually skinny and small. The Mora is fashioned after an age old design, from a time when people probably had to rely on their knife far more often.
Machetes seem to be the exception, having a full tang, but they are commonly thinner blades with a lot of flexibility and together with its relatives they dominate the wilder parts of today's world. Workhorses like the blades used to harvest sugar cane (still to this day done by hand) are simple chopping blades with through- or even hidden tang.
I think the secret is a softer steel and sharpening more often.That is true. I remember decades ago, friends and I would loosely term any through tang(not rat tail, but something like a Mora Bushcraft black) as 'full tang' or 'through tang'. And I agree with what said about those aged old design, when people actually use them for living and live by them. Maybe it is the modern consumerism or 'more is always better' that leads to many overbuilt designs. I traveled a lot in Asian countries for work and fun, and most of those 'machete'-lookalike work knives are relatively thin stock with full tangs, and handled with nothing but just cordage or thin pieces of wood. I think they are made that way not because of added integrity, merely because it is more cost effective and cost less to actually make handle to fit.
I think it always come back to proven designs/geometry combined with the right kind of material.
-
The widespread knife consumerism and related videos likely had a big impact on batoning. Seems every knife had to undergo a baton session for it to pass the videographers/reviewers test. I did see a while ago that some in the knife community or maybe it was the community that watches these videos, people arguing against batoning. I don't watch all the videos on knives as much but even the ones I did watch seem to stray away from the practice.
I am still of the feeling that it can be done and done in a manner that wont harm the knife. I tend to like 5 inch or less blades. Probably not the ideal knife to baton so its not something I do every time I camp. I'm more of a wedge guy. I also have a hatchet that I use to create the initial opening then work wedges in to split the wood. Thats just my way. Plus I did try to baton thru some Eucalyptus and no way.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Batoning seems like an oddity. I mean where do the logs to split come from? Unless you are camping, but then you can also use a hatchet
Yeah, you could use a chisel (or one of those small wedges made for woodsplitting, but they are usually rather large and heavy). I would guess at least some pry-bars should work too.I poker terms......I see your hatchet, and I raise you Camelthorn (and other Acacia) wood.....
And I laugh while I take your money.

You guys must remember not all the world is covered in nice fluffy soft Pine trees, not all the world harvests and uses wood the same.
Some of you BBQ, we "BRAAI", and you can't braai on gas or any other smurf, you need good hardwood coals beneath your meat. This past Saturday, Zebra fillet over Camelthorn coals under the stars.....you have not lived yet

And the best (and safest) way to split off some smaller pieces to get the fire started........is not an axe!

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I poker terms......I see your hatchet, and I raise you Camelthorn (and other Acacia) wood.....And I laugh while I take your money.

You guys must remember not all the world is covered in nice fluffy soft Pine trees, not all the world harvests and uses wood the same.
Some of you BBQ, we "BRAAI", and you can't braai on gas or any other smurf, you need good hardwood coals beneath your meat. This past Saturday, Zebra fillet over Camelthorn coals under the stars.....you have not lived yet

And the best (and safest) way to split off some smaller pieces to get the fire started........is not an axe!

GG, you meant to tell me I have not been living all these years?
I don't believe you until I see the pictures of such "BRAAI"...

-
That Camelthorn is some hard wood. At 3600+ on the Janka scale its gonna cause issues when trying to cut for sure. Our Eucalyptus at 2700+ is also hard and splitting is an issue.
I wont touch the BBQ comment as I would never speak on another's BBQ/Braai methods
. Suffice to say hard wood is a must for BBQ. Most here in the states consider foods cooked over fire BBQ but thats not quite right. We have a fierce subculture of BBQ from region to region in the US. As to whats "REAL BBQ", here in the US as I'm sure other parts of the world its nearly religion ;).I'm not pit master but I do fancy myself a pretty good at low and slow cookery. South Africa
I'd love to one day have Braai in the motherland of foods cooked this way. -
@comis said:
GG, you meant to tell me I have not been living all these years?
I don't believe you until I see the pictures of such "BRAAI"...

Funny story, I spoiled a video I was making of a spectacular sunset with a comment, I was stunned when I realized I missed the true beauty of the sunset by looking at the small screen.
The braai involved very good friends, very good meat, and I was braai master so sorry, no photos

@Aloha said:
That Camelthorn is some hard wood. At 3600+ on the Janka scale its gonna cause issues when trying to cut for sure. Our Eucalyptus at 2700+ is also hard and splitting is an issue.Janka scale.....cool, I did not know about that!

@Aloha said:
I wont touch the BBQ comment as I would never speak on another's BBQ/Braai methods
. Suffice to say hard wood is a must for BBQ. Most here in the states consider foods cooked over fire BBQ but thats not quite right. We have a fierce subculture of BBQ from region to region in the US. As to whats "REAL BBQ", here in the US as I'm sure other parts of the world its nearly religion ;).I'm not pit master but I do fancy myself a pretty good at low and slow cookery. South Africa
I'd love to one day have Braai in the motherland of foods cooked this way.A wise man indeed
......but come to Namibia, you'll be safer and the meat is better 
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I poker terms......I see your hatchet, and I raise you Camelthorn (and other Acacia) wood.....And I laugh while I take your money.

Actually... I take your money as my argument also applies to hardwood (unless you are trying to tell me there are Camelthorn logs in the wilderness) and even with hardwood the hatchet will do better than batoning with your knife.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Actually... I take your money as my argument also applies to hardwood (unless you are trying to tell me there are Camelthorn logs in the wilderness) and even with hardwood the hatchet will do better than batoning with your knife.My money is safe, you'll just mess up your wrist with your wee hatchet.

The way it works with Camelthron is you gather dead wood by breaking it off the tree. Most likely no need to split wood to start the fire because you can use the small branches at the tip.
I reality, we cannot and should not gather wood where we camp out of consideration for those that follow, so we're back to the big bags of wood we buy at the service station.......and the safest, easiest way to get small pieces for starting the fire....even with a hatchet, is batoning

-
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."
-
@spudley112 said:
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."That's golden, she is wise beyond Yoda. :D
-
@spudley112 said:
Last night a girl walked in on me watching batoning videos. She was all like, "You know they exploit those poor knives just so men like you can be 'entertained'."Funny, but she's wrong

Men are the ones being exploited, we end up on the living room floor in underwear surrounded by a collection of knives able to "span the average log", eating peanut butter from the jar, mumbling "Nutnfancy made me do it"

-
While I enjoy this guy's videos he makes me cringe whenever he batons with a SAK
:ahhh
-
@Noa Isumi said:
While I enjoy this guy's videos he makes me cringe whenever he batons with a SAK
:ahhhHe does explain that you should only baton with the blade at 90 degrees so you don't break the spring. Probably best not to baton anything too large either
-
True
He only does it for small crafts, and it is just to start a wedge, but it still makes me cringe for some reason. -
Not only can the backspring be broken, but the saw is the thinnest tool SAKs have. I've bent two because I slipped while cutting a tree limb (normal use). Messing around, I've been able to split smaller pieces of wood by using the saw to CUT a notch to start a wedge, then carving a wedge, which I would then drive it in with a larger stick or rock.
-
Got caught batoning in the neighbor's yard last night. Now I think I am on the National Batoners Watch list. Btaon my life.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login