Leatherman FREE T4 vs Victorinox Pioneer X and Super Tinker
-
So the Super Tinker was the winner. I had expected as much, although I would have guessed by a bigger margin. Lots of functions on that SAK. Had I substituted a Climber it would have opened up the lead (the phillips didn't really add any points over the Pioneer X and the can opener).
The Pioneer X tied for second/third. I would have guessed it would be last just due to the minimalist tool set it inherits from the Pioneer/Soldier.
Also tied for second/third place is the Leatherman FREE T4.It was pretty much a horse race to the end. As the T4 is new, I want to talk about it a little. Leatherman has had knives for some time, but the T2 and T4 are the first that really rival the 91/93 SAKs. And a pretty good attempt. In fact, with a couple of minor improvements, the T4 could win this match up. It has a couple of features that a lot of people have been wanting in a SAK or SAKalike: OHO blade, locking blade (in fact ALL the tools on the T4 lock), deep pocket carry clip, better blade steel. Fix the issues with the reamer and the scissors and Leatherman has a real winner here.
-
Great review and photo’s!

-
OHO and lockable blades might be a plus for some people in the states, but not even here you can carry that combo legally in every city/state. In some countries this is even illegal. So for me this is not an advantage.
You also give the SAKs zero points for not having a file and the T4 a full point for having it. On the other hand the ST gets only half a point for having the multipurpose hook and zero for having an additional small blade.
I get that the ST might be the closest to the T4 when it comes to tool loadout. I don‘t think there is a SAK with exactly the same tools, but then the added features should also be considered to make this test as accurate as possible.Just my 2 cents

-
@SirVicaLot said:
OHO and lockable blades might be a plus for some people in the states, but not even here you can carry that combo legally in every city/state. In some countries this is even illegal. So for me this is not an advantage.You also give the SAKs zero points for not having a file and the T4 a full point for having it. On the other hand the ST gets only half a point for having the multipurpose hook and zero for having an additional small blade.
I get that the ST might be the closest to the T4 when it comes to tool loadout. I don‘t think there is a SAK with exactly the same tools, but then the added features should also be considered to make this test as accurate as possible.Just my 2 cents

I don't mean to be mean, smiller - but I have to agree with SVL.
In my immediate area, there are jurisdictions where the locking blade is illegal, and as SVL said, the OHO might be illegal in some urban areas nearby too. So, it's not an advantage for me either.
I also noted the discrepancy with the file, as I am decidedly anti-file.
As you enjoy New Years Eve, I wonder if you'll change your mind on the bottle opener, The space where you would catch the edge of the cap (where you fit the 1/4 inch bit) may be a bit small, and therefore fiddly on the cap.
Anyway - nice job on the review otherwise.

-
I understand your point on the OH and locking, but in those areas where either or both of those features are illegal then you might as well just rate the whole T4 as a zero. Your mileage may vary.
BTW I did give the Super Tinker a bonus half point for the small blade.
-
Sorry I missed that.
But why a half point? It is a tool the PX and T4 do not have at all.Don‘t get me wrong, I appreciate you putting the effort in to do this review and I like reading your opinion about it. But when you grade it, my OCD (or whatever it is) insists that every tool is treated equally

-
@smiller43147 said:
I understand your point on the OH and locking, but in those areas where either or both of those features are illegal then you might as well just rate the whole T4 as a zero. Your mileage may vary.BTW I did give the Super Tinker a bonus half point for the small blade.
That's definitely a valid argument. See, In my head, I was just not giving the bonus half-point... not giving the whole thing a zero. Where I live, what I'm (potentially) doing with the MT makes a difference, as does what jurisdiction I am. If I have my car packed with camping gear I can carry different things than if I'm just roaming around running errands. (this is my laymans understanding of the laws) So when I tally pros and cons on my MTs SAKs etc, I have a line item for "legality if I inadvertently carry it". Case in point, my Victorinox One Hand Trekker - it gets all the boxes for all the things, except for that geographic versatility.
So in other words, I do apologize for derailing the proverbial train on which your rather well-designed comparison and review sits.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
As you enjoy New Years Eve, I wonder if you'll change your mind on the bottle opener, The space where you would catch the edge of the cap (where you fit the 1/4 inch bit) may be a bit small, and therefore fiddly on the cap.OSU football (vs Clemson) tonight (go Buckeyes) so you don't have to wait. The cap lifter worked just fine. Catches the edge just fine.
So did a Pioneer X. I suppose that means the two SAKs should get another point each..jpeg)
-
Great points everyone and very well thought out and interesting review Smiler. I say you all get 2 points for participation.

-
smiller43147, thanks for writing this comparison up, it's interesting to see them compared up close.
I was at Cabela's and REI last month, and had the opportunity to play with both T4 and K4. I had the feeling T4 was some kind of SAK iteration with OH and lock functions, but with penalty of heavier weight and larger size. I ended up walking away with the K4 which I think it's more interesting offering of the two.
-
@smiller43147 said:
OSU football (vs Clemson) tonight (go Buckeyes) so you don't have to wait. The cap lifter worked just fine. Catches the edge just fine.
So did a Pioneer X. I suppose that means the two SAKs should get another point each.
-
I have to ask, is the T4 an answer to a question that no one had asked?
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I think the LM Signal was the answer to a question that nobody had asked. They invented an excellent backup outdoor MTI do think that people ask for a good knife based MT.
I was hinting to the fact that the T4 is trying to be something that is already well covered by Victorinox. There isn't really a gap in the market for it.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I think the LM Signal was the answer to a question that nobody had asked. They invented an excellent backup outdoor MTI do think that people ask for a good knife based MT.
Good point.
Are there any besides the Spyderench tools??
And even those aren't available on every street corner. -
The pocket clip on the T4 makes it the winner overall!
-
Even though SAKs are good tools, there is always room for improvement. So I appreciate LM‘s attempt to step out of their comfort zone and try something new. I also get that on your first try you don‘t get it all right.
The issue for me is, that the tools they delivered are questionable at best.It feels like the T4 was designed by a hipster that used a hammer once in his life. Now he thinks he can design a tool. It doesn‘t feel like people that use MT‘s everyday had any say in the outcome. Bulky design, plastic inserts, ridiculous short file that cannot decide if it wants to be a nail file or metal / wood file, an awl that with a screwdriver tip ( ??? ), scissors that „hang up“ during continues cutting, and so on.
It just feels like it could have used another year of R&D, but someone decided to throw it in the market, slap a price on that is nowhere justified and see what happens. The T4 costs $60 on LM‘s website. For that amount I can get an Evo S557, a Deluxe Tinker (-$10), or a Ranger (-$7). All of which have far more tools and utility. Heck, for $10 more you can get a Rebar!

LM, I had such high hopes for the T series. What happened?

-
@SirVicaLot said:
I can only hope that was :sarcasm:
It is not!
Enjoy!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login