Rust issue, not only leatherman
-
@Micky d said:
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do. Every LM I've had, from Micra's to Charges has needed to be inspected daily for rust, then cleaned and oiled, which is fine until your too tired or haven't got time to do it, but I have been happy to leave my Vic's dirty in the knowledge that it won't dothem any harm :)
But that's my opinion based on 18 years of pocket tool use, of nearly every major brand :)
Oh come on, that's way too exaggerated. I also have a micra made in 1999 in my pocket that undergone the same trip and treatment as the wave and powerlock, and has zero speck of rust, simply because it has no rough unpolished surface.
I sense the vic fans getting defensive. :D
Not at all, I recognise LM's for what they are :), but I really did find that my LM's rusted at an altogether unacceptable rate, partly that's down to my apparently Nurglite powers, and partly due to the fact that it was in my belt pouch whilst riding motorcycles, so while not exposed to direct water, it certainly collected some moisture :-\
And so I spent almost everyday having to wipe it down, and then wiping off the surface rust around the pivots and between the tools, whereas I had to saw several branches off of a sycamore tree today, and I've not even bothered to clean the saw blade, and probably won't get around to it till tommorow, but I know despite the sap (it's still very much alive) they'll be no corrosion :)
-
Seems like someone did a rust test a while back on here. Do i need to call Jamie and Adam, Grant, Kari, and Tory for a Mythbuster?
Mmmmmm Kari...... :D >:D
-
you know what, that actually sounds like a good idea, weve seen them using MT, at least i know id like to see them try that just for the sake of it :D
-
Anything I'd had from new of either brand hasn't rusted, but I've seen plenty of old neglected ones looking like cr*p. I don't put them through the kind of abuse that leaves them filthy or damp really o it's never been a big issue for me. Now I have a dedicated alox harvester for the allotment use, we shall see if that copes!
-
@Buzzbait said:
In the immortal words of Shakespeare, "What's in a name? That which we call a rose."I can see which one is the rose.
And which one works for a living, and which one is a shelf queen. A picture of one tool with rust the other without doesn't mean anything.
Funny all the vic fans just look directly over SOG mentioned, and the conclusion of it basically comes down to surface finish rather than brand/steel, and turned this into leatherman vs. vic.
-
I am a big LM fan and love their tools and have carried them for years, but I have to admit that there tools do rust more than other more polished tools. Not only that I have found that their newer tools rust more than their older line up. These 3 tools, LM Wave w/ KicK phillips driver, LM Charge AL, and Vic Spirit w/pocket clip are my most carried tools. I use them hard in and around cleaning chemicals at work and get good results with all three of them. I have to say that I have gotten really bad at cleaning them after using them. When I decide to use a different tool I usually just throw them in the tool box and pick up another. For that past 2 weeks or so I have been carrying a LM Pulse so this thread made me dig out these three tools and take a look at them. This is what I found.
LM Wave




LM Charge AL




Vic Spirit

Beautiful Spirit rust free yes? No..... but still not as bad as the LMs



-
@jzmtl said:
And which one works for a living, and which one is a shelf queen. A picture of one tool with rust the other without doesn't mean anything.Both work for a living. The Micra has been attached to the outside of my backpack for the last year or so. The Swisschamp is new. I do have a Vic Huntsman that was clipped to my backpack for 5 years before the Micra. It looks as good as my new Swisschamp.
-
@prime77 said:
I am a big LM fan and love their tools and have carried them for years, but I have to admit that there tools do rust more than other more polished tools. Not only that I have found that their newer tools rust more than their older line up. These 3 tools, LM Wave w/ KicK phillips driver, LM Charge AL, and Vic Spirit w/pocket clip are my most carried tools. I use them hard in and around cleaning chemicals at work and get good results with all three of them. I have to say that I have gotten really bad at cleaning them after using them. When I decide to use a different tool I usually just throw them in the tool box and pick up another. For that past 2 weeks or so I have been carrying a LM Pulse so this thread made me dig out these three tools and take a look at them. This is what I found.LM Wave




LM Charge AL




Vic Spirit

Beautiful Spirit rust free yes? No..... but still not as bad as the LMs



Great pictures mate

-
Great post jzmtl
The whole " Leatherman Rust , Vics don't " thing is starting to wear a little thin so its nice to see some other brands catching the rust flu :D For the record I have got a Swisstool to rust and it was right near the springs in the handle and was really difficult to remove :( Lets not forget Gerbers , they rust very easily too .dunc
-
Lets not forget Gerbers , they rust very easily too .
Compared to Gerbers, Leathermans are virtually rustproof. :D :D :D
indeed...when I had a suspension, it rusted within a week, never taken around water either...
-
That's probably because the Suspension design was inspired by the suspension bridges in Oregon and we all know how bridges and water/moisture always go together. ::)
-
Lets not forget Gerbers , they rust very easily too .
Compared to Gerbers, Leathermans are virtually rustproof. :D :D :D
My gerber I used to have did rust and the E4 Squirt also.
-
Funnily enough neither my MP600 or Diesel have rusted, nor has my Clutch for that matter :)
-
Lets not forget Gerbers , they rust very easily too .
Compared to Gerbers, Leathermans are virtually rustproof. :D :D :D
My dad's Gerber has rust and it's spent almost all its life sitting indoors in its box -it's certainly never got wet :(
-
My BO Gerber Scout has hardly a lick of rust on it, and it is the multitool that I use specifically for fishing. The BO coating must be very good.

-
Lets not forget Gerbers , they rust very easily too .
Compared to Gerbers, Leathermans are virtually rustproof. :D :D :D
::) ::)
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






