Rust issue, not only leatherman
-
-
<sigh> Can we just right YMMV and BUSTED on a big metal platter and drop it on the head of this thread from some 1000 feet high? Please?

-
I think that's the last thing we should do noth. The reply is going to be so full of holes, many of us are going to get a real kick out of it.
-
here we go...DaveK is in now... :D
-
I am frankly quite surprised. I've had so many corrosion issues with Leatherman tools over the last 15 years, and so few issues with Victorinox tools over the same period of time, it's hard to believe that I'm using the same brand of tools as some of you. This is coming from an avid outdoorsman, who lurks where the water is.
-
::)
-
@Leatherman123 said:
::)Tbh, I've no problem with Buzzbait's post - he's simply recounting his own experience. If everyone did that I don't think there'd be half as many arguments.
My experience has been different, no problem.
-
Yeah, I have no problem either. Did he use a water displacement product afterward? :) The main cause for LM's getting surface rust is because of improper maintenance.
-
Not the rust discussion AGAIN! ::)
I think the only other thing that gets mentioned (that could vaguely be considered "on topic" on a multitool forum) these days is how wonderful half a dozen people think the Spirit is.
Some of us on here own (literally) hundreds of multi tools, so probably have a better idea about the differences between tools than most. You can spot them quite easily - they're the ones who tend to either stay away from or dismiss these stupid (and often exaggerated) posts.
Some of us can't afford to own hundreds of multitools :(
I wouln't say the Spirit is the best multitool out there but for me personaly it is the best one , like the Charge is for you .
Dunc
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do.
I'm sorry, I only just saw this and I'm pretty sure it is the biggest load of b****cks I have ever read. What a ridiculous statement.
Do you want to rethink it?
No I don't because as I've stated many, many bloody times I have had problems with them, they did all rust in the time I had them (even the Core and I only had that for 4 weeks!) I've got a new PST sitting at home, and I know damn well when i use it, it'll rust, I'm not particularly bothered by it, as it'll only be used very ocationally, but if I was using it everyday it'd be a different story :'(
I know my opinion clashes with your's Dave, but them's the facts as I see and have experienced them, they do require more care and attention if you plan on using them as a regular edc as I've sadly proved to myself on plenty of occations, how many of you LM fans swear by various lubricants?
As I've said before (endless amounts of times) I've had all the major brands, and have edc'd a fair cross section of what's out there, and as corrosion resistance is so important to me (seeing as I'm out in all weathers either working, cycling ect) the Swiss do work best for <u>ME</u>
I hope that's cleared it up ::)
-
Hey look at this banana!

-
ITS PENUT BUTTER JELLY TIME!
PENUT BUTTER JELLY TIME!
PENUT BUTTER JELLY
PENUT BUTTER JELLY.....you know the rest :D -
They aren't as good at dancing though. :D
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do.
I'm sorry, I only just saw this and I'm pretty sure it is the biggest load of b****cks I have ever read. What a ridiculous statement.
Do you want to rethink it?
No I don't because as I've stated many, many bloody times I have had problems with them, they did all rust in the time I had them (even the Core and I only had that for 4 weeks!) I've got a new PST sitting at home, and I know damn well when i use it, it'll rust, I'm not particularly bothered by it, as it'll only be used very ocationally, but if I was using it everyday it'd be a different story :'(
I know my opinion clashes with your's Dave, but them's the facts as I see and have experienced them, they do require more care and attention if you plan on using them as a regular edc as I've sadly proved to myself on plenty of occations, how many of you LM fans swear by various lubricants?
As I've said before (endless amounts of times) I've had all the major brands, and have edc'd a fair cross section of what's out there, and as corrosion resistance is so important to me (seeing as I'm out in all weathers either working, cycling ect) the Swiss do work best for <u>ME</u>
I hope that's cleared it up ::)
Nope - not cleared up at all. Read my quote again, where you say:
**
It' not just a question of rust though**, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do.So, excluding your personal, (and really quite unique) experiences of rusting by looking at Leatherman tools, which frankly are extreme even amongst other people arguing the case for Vic, tell me where you get the idea that that " LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do".
You made the statement, so I'm assuming you can back it up. You know what I think of your "experiences" with rust, so let's look at the question I actually asked.
For the record, I performed the first "maintenance" on my Charge the other day after 2 years of daily carry and a hell of a lot of use. I washed it, dried it and it's good to go again. Same as I do with my SAKs when they need it. I genuinely don't understand your point about swearing by lubricants - I use oil when a tool needs it - what's your point?
@Dunc said:
Some of us can't afford to own hundreds of multitools :(
I wouln't say the Spirit is the best multitool out there but for me personaly it is the best one , like the Charge is for you .Dunc - maybe I didn't make my point well. I personally think that if you think the Spirit is the best tool out there - good for you. It's the continual, perpetual statement of dubious facts and let's be honest, fantasies of some that's boiling my p**s. As far as I can recall, you have never done that and are generally a lot more balanced in your arguments. I'm truly sorry if you thought I was having a go at you - I wasn't at all.
Just another thought whilst I'm here briefly - whilst I completely disagree with ducktapehero's opinions of the Spirit v other tools at the beginning of this thread - I 100% agree with his annoyance that some people seem to delight in pointing out rust on Vics too. Pettiness is pettiness, regardless of whether it's in support of my argument or against it - I'm totally consistent about that.
-
Like I say (again) my Core, Supertool, Micra and Sideclip needed a thorough cleaning after having used them, also after being exposed to moisture (not direct water) the individual tools would regularly rust around the tang and there would be surface rust inside the tool handles too, which would rapidly turn into pitting if ignored for a couple of days.
And it's not as if I can't look after my tools, you won't see any rust on my fixed blades, even the very crude carbon steeled jobbies, and some of those have had a very hard life :)
So as i say again, I've no problem with LM's, but there rough finish, and lack of corrosion resistance just doesn't workout for me, and you can't say I've not given it a go, as I've owned about 6 LM's over the years :)
-
In best Rodney King voice
Can't we all just get along?
-
@Leatherman123 said:
Yeah, I have no problem either. Did he use a water displacement product afterward? :) The main cause for LM's getting surface rust is because of improper maintenance.Heck no. When you're out in the field for a couple of weeks at a time, cleaning all of your gear with WD40 every day just isn't practical. The best it gets is a dry rag, and maybe some sun if you have any that day. After a few of these trips, you tend to dump the gear that doesn't hold up, and move to gear that does hold up with only the most minimal maintenance possible. For me, both my Vics and my BO Gerber have proven to work very well with practically zero maintenance.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

:D