Free P4 pliers stiffness after moderate or heavy use
-
True locking tapers are typically a lot less than the 30o shown, but over the years I have found that stuff can have a nasty habit of jamming up when you don't want it to, at or around 30o. I've had it with cutting tools (taper drills and bore forming tools), taper gibs, self aligning bushings etc. A real pain in the well padded area!
If the void is drilled with an indexable insert U drill, there's a good chance that the face transition is less than 30o anyway. If they use an indexable insert stepped drill, which would be the most efficient way to drill out the castings, it's likely to have a TPMT insert for the counterbore, set around 15 to 18 degrees. That would fit these symptoms perfectly.
That's what happens when you gear your production facilities around production efficiency, rather than what the component actually needs. Seen it far too often.
-
@Max Stone said:
Well...after 3 days of on-and-off ‘exercise’, including pressing some automotive abrasive into the pivot, I get beautiful free swinging pliers...until I squeeze them, and they bind up again.
There’s clearly an engineering geometry issue at play here. Not something I’m going to be able to fix, so it’s going back the shop. :-[
They can send it in for warranty. Hopefully I don’t get it back whacked, but I get one that works.
Have done a video here https://youtu.be/NFsneeJLltc showing that I need over 500g of pressure to close the pliers when they bind, and that after a wiggle, they are free again. Not acceptable Leatherman.

No smurf, this sucks!
I had mine right in front me on the table, and just can't help but to give it a firm hand-shake squeeze, and guess what--I just joined the club and now it won't move freely. ::) Can't imagine what's gonna happen if I give it a real squeeze or need it to cut something.
I gave my old Charge the same squeeze, it binds a little bit but I guessed I have used it enough it frees right up after moving the handles couple of times.(or maybe the handle is heavier?)
Gave many times harder a squeeze to Victorinox Spirit and Swisstool, until the handles bow inward, no binding whatsoever.
I once said somewhere that this tool is not well thought thru, and only focusing on the aesthetic or appearance, I hate to be right on this. Even cheaper tools from 20+ years ago can do better.

-
@comis said:
No smurf, this sucks!I had mine right in front me on the table, and just can't help but to give it a firm hand-shake squeeze, and guess what--I just joined the club and now it won't move freely. ::) Can't imagine what's gonna happen if I give it a real squeeze or need it to cut something.
I gave my old Charge the same squeeze, it binds a little bit but I guessed I have used it enough it frees right up after moving the handles couple of times.(or maybe the handle is heavier?)
Gave many times harder a squeeze to Victorinox Spirit and Swisstool, until the handles bow inward, no binding whatsoever.
I once said somewhere that this tool is not well thought thru, and only focusing on the aesthetic or appearance, I hate to be right on this. Even cheaper tools from 20+ years ago can do better.

#PSTclub4Life
(Disclaimer: my only LM is a Kick.)
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
True locking tapers are typically a lot less than the 30o shown, but over the years I have found that stuff can have a nasty habit of jamming up when you don't want it to, at or around 30o. I've had it with cutting tools (taper drills and bore forming tools), taper gibs, self aligning bushings etc. A real pain in the well padded area!If the void is drilled with an indexable insert U drill, there's a good chance that the face transition is less than 30o anyway. If they use an indexable insert stepped drill, which would be the most efficient way to drill out the castings, it's likely to have a TPMT insert for the counterbore, set around 15 to 18 degrees. That would fit these symptoms perfectly.
That's what happens when you gear your production facilities around production efficiency, rather than what the component actually needs. Seen it far too often.
I think every knife/tool maker may eventually come to that point when you get large enough, just a matter of choice between greed vs customer satisfaction.
-
So I returned my P2 to the retail store today as a warranty claim. The Leatherman distributor will collect it next week from the store to action.
Out of interest, I asked the salesman if we could test the P2 and P4 they had in their display cabinet.
Guest what...after a squeeze they both locked up nice a tight. The salesman’s eyes went large and he said he’d show the distributor when he came in.
Seems the problem is not so isolated... ???
-
This is disgraceful, Leatherman should be ashamed that they let these tools out to the public. Someone must have known about this problem

-
My P2 is on it’s way back to the importer. I’ve asked for a Wave as a replacement but they told me that’s not possible. I guess the replacement P2 will be sold unused, I’m done with this.
Makes you wonder, I have an old PST that I’ve used fairly hard for three decades and it still functions fine. Newer isn’t always better.
-
I'm not sure what to think
. If as it seems LM is content to lean on their warranty then this is really unfortunate. Makes you wonder how many have to come back for them to fix problem and not lean on warranty
. -
A fair amount of users will never crank down on them so hard that they’ll bind the pliers, so the number of returns could be limited. Either way, it’s disappointing.
-
and yep 
-
@nitram said:
A fair amount of users will never crank down on them so hard that they’ll bind the pliers, so the number of returns could be limited. Either way, it’s disappointing.I am not too sure about this, after seeing Max's video, I just seriously just give it a firm hand shake, and it starts to bind a little. I have absolutely no doubt if I were to use it to cut something like a nail or wire, even well within its capacity, it will bind for sure. Though as a collector, I do have many pilers to choose from for that task, but it kinda sucks to know this expensive tool is not up to par like other brands.
-
I pulled out an example of each of my newer Leathermans yesterday. My newest the Charge plus showed symptoms of this when squeezed tightly but eased back off with some wiggle of the handles. My next newest, the Wave did not do this. Neither did my Rebar , Blast or Kick.

-
I don't have a Free Series Tool but I have several LMs. None have experienced this binding. Yes some were tight when I got them but they loosened with use, not tightened.
I'd imagine a fair amount of users will not rouble themselves with returns, thats just how some are. Then there are those who merely collect so they'll never user the tool. I'm sure there are those who carry but very lightly use the tool. This is more accurately why I wondered how many will actually be returned.
Everyone who has one go now a give it a "hand shake" and see if yours binds up. Then send it in so LM can hopelfully address the issues.
-
@Aloha said:
I don't have a Free Series Tool but I have several LMs. None have experienced this binding. Yes some were tight when I got them but they loosened with use, not tightened.I'd imagine a fair amount of users will not rouble themselves with returns, thats just how some are. Then there are those who merely collect so they'll never user the tool. I'm sure there are those who carry but very lightly use the tool. This is more accurately why I wondered how many will actually be returned.
Everyone who has one go now a give it a "hand shake" and see if yours binds up. Then send it in so LM can hopelfully address the issues.

... and tell them that if they send a replacement, to test it first by squeezing the pliers, before sending another tool with exactly the same issue... ::)
Has anyone taken this problem to them on social media yet?
-
Sad all this about the "P" series.
Out of LM's, I had a Gerber Flik for ten years. I used it contless times to cut stainless steel wire for welding. Zero problem. Hope that LM solve this problem ASAP
Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
-
Reading thru this thread is like watching a horror show. Luckily the only Free I have is a T4. The email LMT rep told the customers how to fix / try to fix the tool themselves is beyond F**k up. The proper thing they should do (for now) is to offer free return for warranty and a nice voucher as a gesture of good will.
-
Is it possible the problem is with the elongated toggle pivot in the handles? They seem to have the ends cut similar to a bone shape, and when squeezing tightly could the be displacing the pressure into the bottom of the pliers where the separate jaws attach to the handles?
-
Not sure I follow you stugumby

Mine now back with the LM rep, and with national lockdown, who knows when I see it (or replacement) again.
-
WOW
Where to even begin
I don’t own any of these newer models but lockdown boredom has had me spending way too much time web surfing.But having just read this thread, hand on heart I will steer clear of these models.
I can’t quite understand why leatherman don’t simply outsource the plierheads to “proper” tool makers. All LM pliers suck
Leatherman are best just stamping out parts and assembling. Clearly after 30years They still can’t get the heads right.
The irony for me is that the main difference between SAK and MT is the the addition of the plier head.
If that’s not upto the job...what’s the point?I never use MT’s- tho’ edc a Gerber Balance at work for the screwdrivers and tweezers the rest of the tool is utter smurfe.
None of LM’s carry tweezers (wood/steel splinters)
I think LM really ought to pull the stops out and finally deliver a “real tool” it’s a bit embarrassing TBH
God knows their prices are already high enough to expect better.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
