Knife Snobs?
-
Not back yet?
Ok heres my take. I dig the newer steels too but I'll always have a SAK with me. The truth is, even tho the newer steels can cut the dickens out of everything and keep on cutting, most users of those knives aren't cutting miles upon miles of any medium EVERYDAY other than when testing. I don't care that my SAK will need to be tuned up at the end of hard day. I really don't. I can pair it with blade that can cut miles and miles if needs be.
They might be simply comparing steel to steel. SAK steel is soft and theres no getting around that. In no way will it out perform a newer steel but thats only part of a SAKs story. One cannot simply compare blade to blade when talking SAKs. I do have 2 blades on my SAK ( Explorer Plus ) in addition to a phillips, scissors, awl, flat driver and other implements. I'm not certain steel junkies take into consideration how versatile a SAK is. One has to compare knife to knife, it's just how it works. Nice try tho.
-
Mostly people complaining about the steel.
They want S30V SAKs, S110V SAKs, 20CV SAKs, 154CM SAKs, ...
Obviously forgetting that the SAK was made for the army and needs to be able to be sharpened in a field on a rock... Maybe during a war... Like a 5 year lasting war...
"I need to go home to sharpen my knife!" Right?Also, they're the only type of knife being sold everywhere around the world to the masses who maybe use a pull through sharpener, a grinding wheel or a trashbin.
So I think the; let's call them steel snobs, think they're Victorinox' biggest clients group, which they aren't.
I like a decent, premium steel. So I carry a folder and a SAK. perfect way to keep a knife clean for food and keep one for dirty work.
Would I buy a SAK with premium steel? Probably...
Do I expect Victorinox do create one? - no, I don't see why they should. -
This thread has the best one-liners I've seen in the least amount of real estate.

I've definitely come across a few knife snobs - last month in fact. Every time I've pulled out the SAK in public I've had one of three verbal reactions - in order of increasing frequency. 1. Hey, can you open this for me? 2. Are you supposed to have that thing? 3. Those things are junk! I received a Type-3 reaction last month. My usual response as of late - "have you ever seen one of these things rust?" That usually sends them on their way in deep contemplation with their eyes scrunched up and their neck writhing around as if I asked them to try to lick their own elbow. Forget about engaging them in conversations about blade steel or why they are prying off paper clips with a 4 inch switchblade.
It's ok to like tacticool knives or swords or sneakers or watches or fountain pens, or whatever - but I think one thing that sets us Swiss Army Knights apart is honesty. Admittedly, I don't read the "What did you use your ZT for today?" thread, but if I was reporting in that I used my tiger-striped 5-inch lockblade to change the batteries on my kid's toy, I'd feel pretty silly. We don't repeatedly deploy our Deluxe Tinkers while sitting on the couch - otherwise, we'd have no fingers left. We go through our daily tasks and take stock of what we do each day as a matter of course - and we choose a SAK accordingly - we're honest with ourselves about needing a lock, or a saw, or scissors. If we don't need it, we don't want it. Its a different mindset that obsesses over SAKs - the type that looks at utility over fiddly and fun.
The converse - to SteveC's point - is that a lot of us would say "Why do you have that 9 inch Cold Steel? You don't need that thing! What are you going to do with that? Open your trail mix?
Maybe the difference is that there are some people that like knives, and there are some people who like to use them.
-
@Frailer said:
Long story short: They don’t get it, because they come at knives from a different perspective.The “EDC” movement has grown by leaps and bounds over the past few years. I have a very long daily commute, so I listen to a lot of podcasts, several of which are knife-centric. I’m always amazed when I hear people say they’ve been a “knife guy” for two or three years. These people are frequently about super steels, ball bearing flippers, and “drop shutty” action. They don’t open their knives; they “deploy” them. Repeatedly. All day long. They don’t want to sharpen their knives. And they apparently cut a LOT of cardboard, for reasons that remain mysterious to me.
I became a “knife guy” a little over 50 years ago. Owning a knife was the first step into the community of men. It was a tool to assist in the performance of all the tasks that a man needed to do in the course of the day. And when I was introduced to the Swiss Army Knife as a very young adult the number of things my knife could do increased by an order of magnitude. I am fortunate to own more knives than any one man should, and some of them were—relatively speaking—quite pricey (I do love a good Sebenza), but if forced to restrict myself to only one knife it would be an humble SAK.
I say this without value judgment. I wish those who lust after the current maker-of-the week and the super-est of steels much joy in their hobby. Sincerely. But my priorities are different than theirs.
Lol, deploying a knife, drop shutty, and cardboard cutting...wtf? Too funny. Like you said I try not to judge. I just like using a knife to make life easier but maybe I am too practical about it. If i am going to cut a ton of boxes I get a box cutter with replaceable blades.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
Lol,Hopefully I can be Knighted. Thanks
And so you are, Welcome Sir Steelej1976.
-
Welcome aboard Steelej1976!
-
Congratulations, Sir Steelej1976!
-
Welcome to the Realm!
-
Thanks Everybody!

-
@Frailer said:
Long story short: They don’t get it, because they come at knives from a different perspective.The “EDC” movement has grown by leaps and bounds over the past few years. I have a very long daily commute, so I listen to a lot of podcasts, several of which are knife-centric. I’m always amazed when I hear people say they’ve been a “knife guy” for two or three years. These people are frequently about super steels, ball bearing flippers, and “drop shutty” action. They don’t open their knives; they “deploy” them. Repeatedly. All day long. They don’t want to sharpen their knives. And they apparently cut a LOT of cardboard, for reasons that remain mysterious to me.
I became a “knife guy” a little over 50 years ago. Owning a knife was the first step into the community of men. It was a tool to assist in the performance of all the tasks that a man needed to do in the course of the day. And when I was introduced to the Swiss Army Knife as a very young adult the number of things my knife could do increased by an order of magnitude. I am fortunate to own more knives than any one man should, and some of them were—relatively speaking—quite pricey (I do love a good Sebenza), but if forced to restrict myself to only one knife it would be an humble SAK.
I say this without value judgment. I wish those who lust after the current maker-of-the week and the super-est of steels much joy in their hobby. Sincerely. But my priorities are different than theirs.
Yeah those EDC guys get a little carried away IMO. That being said I do enjoy looking at their gear and it has shaped some of what I carry. I do carry a Streamlight Microstream flashlight (which I know is lower tier to some of the EDC guys). I thought a lot of those guys were ridiculous for carrying a small flashlight on them everyday when they have a phone but after I dropped my phone and cracked it I realized that I couldn't rely on that as my primary light so those guys do have some decent points. Even still my SAK is always going to be my primary knife and probably the only one I carry.
-
[quote author=ElevenBlade link=topic=84255.msg2103250#msg2103250 date=1585083699
Maybe the difference is that there are some people that like knives, and there are some people who like to use them.
[/quote]This, a thousand times ,this.
-
I suppose its the difference between admiring craftsmanship and appearance over utility .
The butcher who actually cuts all day, doesnt care what the materials and handle , and designer etc are , he just needs it to cut and not hurt his hands using it all day, and be easy to touch up on the steel several times a day -
There is a lot of snobbery out there. Photography is full of that sort of nonsense. I once ran into a guy with drool inducing Canon L lenses. He looked at my gear and commented at how poor my lenses were. Man, I was floored and could only dream of such expensive equipment. All that was shattered once I saw his photos. What a waste. He was all about the gear and actually put me down for my much cheaper gear...but could not take a photo to save his life.
SAKs are great knives that are not only functional...but are easy to sharpen. It is a real honest tool.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
...I do carry a Streamlight Microstream flashlight (which I know is lower tier to some of the EDC guys). I thought a lot of those guys were ridiculous for carrying a small flashlight on them everyday when they have a phone but...A pocket flashlight is one of those items you don’t know you need until you carry it. It could be argued that it’s even handier than a knife. You may not encounter something that needs cutting on any given day, but I guarantee you will experience darkness.
For years my flashlight of choice has been the humble Streamlight Microstream. This one has a lot of miles on it.

-
@Frailer said:
A pocket flashlight is one of those items you don’t know you need until you carry it. It could be argued that it’s even handier than a knife. You may not encounter something that needs cutting on any given day, but I guarantee you will experience darkness.For years my flashlight of choice has been the humble Streamlight Microstream. This one has a lot of miles on it.

I like your style Frailer.

-
I've got a couple of those Streamlights myself. Excellent value.
-
I've got a Knife-snob streak in me. However, over several decades of knife use, I've come to the conclusion that knife snobbery is completely unwarranted.
Most days my fancy knives stay at home and it's a SAK that is carried. SAK's are too useful to not carry one. And that usually makes a secondary knife redundant. So, the default pocket knife is the ubiquitous SAK. Appropriately so, says I.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



