Victorinox Swisschamp v Leatherman Juice Pro
-
Great comparison! It really is surprising how these tools, that initially seem very different, can be so closely compared.
One thing I'd like to point out is that the pliers of the champ (or any other SAK) can be manipulated into much closer quarters, such as inside a crowded computer case. I've used them with the plier partially folded into the knife (at a 90 degree angle to the handle) to change jumpers on the backs of hard drives. This could not have been accomplished with the Juice. So, there are rare occasions when the somewhat limited pliers of the SAK are beneficial.
An even more direct comparison could be made between the Juice Pro and the Cybertool 41. The phillips driver of the champ is great, and better than that of the Pro, but it wouldn't even be a fair comparison to the bit driver of the CT41.
-
-
Well written, even handed right up!
Thanks mate I enjoyed reading that

-
Very good write up. One question though, is there much difference in price? To my mind the only thing that lets the Juice range down badly is the blade shape. I know it works well but I just find it ugly, it's purely an aesthetic thing but I'm not sure I can get past it. ::)
-
Since the Pro was a limited edition, it might be somewhat harder to locate, so I took the next nearest model, the XE6.

Def
-
I've just read this back in the cold (sober) light of day, and I think it pretty much captures what I was trying to say - thanks for the encouragement guys

Terry - good point about the dimensions of the pliers. I bet there are other "restricted access" situations where the Vic's pliers could be preferable too.
Def - Yes - I went with the Pro purely because it was a closer match than the XE6, although I think the pro was slightly cheaper as it was only sold through Costco - not 100% sure on that though.
When I started, I thought I'd maybe come up with a clear favourite, but no - I still can't really choose between them. I guess they're just about different enough to be more or less useful depending on what you need at the time.
It was fun thinking about it though!
-
-
@Defender said:
SwissChamp= $49Since the Pro was a limited edition, it might be somewhat harder to locate, so I took the next nearest model, the XE6.

Def
Guess I was lucky. I bought my Juice Pro NIB for only $40 back in 2004. I thought it was a little expensive at the time but looking back, I guess it was a good deal after all. It's a great little tool. By the way nice job Dave.

-
I had forgot about this thread until I started looking for Juice Pro related stuff great read Dave albeit the praise a little late
I just got a Pro and now I guess I need a Swisschamp so I can compare them myself 
-
-
-
@Styerman said:
Good writeup . well reasoned .Chris
Cheers.
@Poncho65 said:
I had forgot about this thread until I started looking for Juice Pro related stuff great read Dave albeit the praise a little late
I just got a Pro and now I guess I need a Swisschamp so I can compare them myself 
If you have any ideas about collecting SAKs, then I would suggest that you absolutely have to get yourself a Swisschamp poncho!
-
Excellent comparisons. These are the kinds of comparisons I make myself when comparing two tools. This is also why I enjoy mt.org so much.
Great unbiased review that's what I like.
It's clear to me that the Juice line is "inspired" by the swiss knives, and I'm ok with that. For me if given the choice between the two I would have to go with the Juice pro because it has larger pliers suited for heavier duty work. For someone who didn't need substantial pliers the Swisschamp is clearly a great value.
-
Good writeup . well reasoned .
Chris
Cheers.
@Poncho65 said:
I had forgot about this thread until I started looking for Juice Pro related stuff great read Dave albeit the praise a little late
I just got a Pro and now I guess I need a Swisschamp so I can compare them myself 
If you have any ideas about collecting SAKs, then I would suggest that you absolutely have to get yourself a Swisschamp poncho!
I know I just need to find 1 that is at a great price like my Juice Pro

-
Great comparison Dave
Well done for opening those bottles just for us 
And yes, everyone needs a Swisshchamp - it's almost compulsory isn't it?!
I don't carry mine but my Juice KF4 is certainly getting lots of pocket time at the moment as all the tools on it are great really.I don't like the Juice scissors personally so carrying another tool with scissors on like a Rambler or a Micra suits me fine.
-
-
Graet review

My Swisschamp and my CS4 are probably the two tools that I find most useful. I find I carry the swisschamp more than the CS4. I really like the magnifying glass , just for looking at interesting rocks and things rather than any practical use, and I find the pen useful. Also it might just be my particular tool but I can get the blade on the champ much sharper than the one on the Juice. That said I really like the Juice series and mine has seen a lot of use - as has already been said for heavy plier action, the Vic can't compete.
-
-
I agree. For an extra two ounces I would rather carry around a Charge with locking blades, removable bits, and a cutting hook!

-
Great review. I enjoyed it a lot. I don't own a SAK, nor to I plan on it..but it is nice to see what they are capable of doing. I was rather impressed with yours.
Now I don't have a charge yet. I guess I might as well add one of those on the future list of acquisition.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login