Why I don't like backside tools.
-
You're right, cbl51.
Here, prompted by the backside Philips on a 111mm SAK breaking, Mr. Whippy tested a Tinker. The backside Philips on it broke with less than 10 Nm of torque on it. That's about 7.4 ft-lb.
/post/416821Then he did the same test with the screwdriver on the Bottle opener. It started twisting by 20 Nm of torque (14-15 ft-lb) and broke at 30 Nm (20-22 ft-lb).
/post/417176
Important to note that the metal tip broke, not the tang, liners or the pin. :o -
@Rich S said:
IMHO, you and son were pushing the awl and phillips beyond their limits. I also sharpen the awl on my Tinker (works just fine). None of the SAK tools are meant to replace full size screw drivers, etc. I love my Tinker, but also have a newish military style scout. I doubt it's tools would stand up for full size tools either, just MHO. To each his own preference.Rich
I wasn't using the tinker for anything that I hadn't done similar jobs with the issued camillus MIL-K knife or the pioneer. The fact that my Wenger SI has lasted over 25 years used in similar situations, just means to me that the backside tools are not as string as the main tools. I've never had a problem with a pioneer or even a celidor recruit. YMMV, but the backside tools are a flaw. If they put a backside driver, they should make sure it stands up to use beyond very light use.
-
@Don Pablo said:
You're right, cbl51.Here, prompted by the backside Philips on a 111mm SAK breaking, Mr. Whippy tested a Tinker. The backside Philips on it broke with less than 10 Nm of torque on it. That's about 7.4 ft-lb.
/post/416821Then he did the same test with the screwdriver on the Bottle opener. It started twisting by 20 Nm of torque (14-15 ft-lb) and broke at 30 Nm (20-22 ft-lb).
/post/417176
Important to note that the metal tip broke, not the tang, liners or the pin. :oThank you sooooo much for that info!!!
The fact that the tinker took less than half the torque of the bottle opener/driver is amazing.
-
I've used my 25+ year old Tinker for all sorts of things, but it doesn't replace full size tools, and has served me well. Everyone has their own personal ways of using their knives.
Rich
-
Nice write-up as always CBL.
It seems that your early experience with the in line awl sealed the deal for you. I had a couple of 91mm SAKs in the beginning of my story and I never got a lot of use out of the backspring tools, so I never took them to the limit. It wasn't until years later when I got an Alox Soldier that I started using an awl... at all.
After that, I backtracked and started using the 91mm awl with caution. I'm always careful with torquing tools after separating the liners on the Soldier by removing a staple. (not to worry, it's back to normal)
My gripe with backspring tools is more about usefulness and decision inertia. The parcel hook hasn't been useful to me, and if you ask me to decide between the Phillips and the corkscrew - I choose the can opener.
-
Although I love the Tinker and have very pleasant memories of carrying one everyday in high school, I must agree that it is of limited utility. The reason most often cited is the reach/angle, since it's at 90 degrees to the long dimension of the SAK. But I also find it ironic that it's this very T-handle design that makes it possible for it to be over-torqued. I have occasionally had to put an open ended wrench on the shaft of a real screwdriver to loosen a stuck screw, and one time, my up-until-then-trusty Craftsman screwdriver actually shattered.
I always prefer a corkscrew, since at the very least you can use it as a docking station for the micro-screwdriver, and it also has uses for pulling avocado pits and opening pickle jars, not mention its namesake use which we use on a weekly basis in my house.
As others have said, different strokes for different folks. Thanks for posting CBL51.
-
I have never had a backside tool fail, but I also don’t use them that much.
In actual use, even the backside phillips isn’t as useful for me because of its location in the middle instead of an end. There frequently isn’t sufficient room.
In some ways I like the 93mm SAK sleek look a feel with no back tools, but I hate the limited offerings and that I loose the scales tools. At a minimum they need a Farmer-X.
-
I don't like backside tools either. Many make the knife more uncomfortable to hold, are hardly useful or even unusable (my opinion). This is also a reason why I like the 93mm series so much.
-
Vic has made a variety of Pioneer-X models, why not put an inline Phillips??
Look at the Alox Mini-Champ, Vic could do it.
Rich -
My vote is for in line Phillips. That Phillips on the back is hard to work with and the SAK is always getting in the way of turning. You get about 1/4 turn then need to reposition the thing for another bite on the screw. Backside tools make for a slippery grip. The things round out the SAK and you do not get as tight of a grip on the SAK. Just my opinion. I usually usually don't use the back side tools, which is why I carry a Wenger, limited back side to awl, and corkscrew.
AJ
-
I’m not to fond of the backside tools, when I was 12 my grandfather bought me my first sak, a champion, and of course being a kid you gotta try all tools out and one of the first things I did was use the corkscrew, only thing was I drilled it into a tree, and not being so soft of a wood wasn’t to smart, it snapped the tool right at the base, well, you learn..
anyway after joining here I learned about the alox side of sak and I like them better, no backside tools and even better I like the metal.. just they don’t have all the goodies that the larger ones have, so I had one custom made buy one of our own, again no backside tools but I got that Philips! Yet now victorinox is putting out the FarmerX this year and it’s pretty close to what I had made, just no Philips, so maybe next year? Guess we’ll see..
JR -
@Sos24 said:
I have never had a backside tool fail, but I also don’t use them that much.In actual use, even the backside phillips isn’t as useful for me because of its location in the middle instead of an end. There frequently isn’t sufficient room.
In some ways I like the 93mm SAK sleek look a feel with no back tools, but I hate the limited offerings and that I loose the scales tools. At a minimum they need a Farmer-X.
Ask and ye shall receive, it being released later this year I believe

-
I'm also firmly in Carls camp regarding back tools. I much prefer the smooth feel and find the backside tools much more fiddly to use than the utility they provide.
The inline dedicated all on the Pioneer is vastly better at drilling/ reaming for my uses than the reamer/awl on tinkers/Spartans etc . But then again I've never needed to sew heavy duty stuff together, so for someone else it may be their go to tool. That said the small blade is the one tool I miss most when carrying the Pioneer
Regarding breaking tools, I would be so bold as to venture that most of us know damn well when we are asking much more of a tool than it is designed for. My take is that you are of course free to do so, but never forget that when you throw your money on the table, you dont everytime get it back, and you went into it knowing that.
It'd be a boring word if we were all the same eh?
-
Largely agree with the OP. I do like to have a corkscrew at hand, though. I only have SAKs with the back side Phillips for their handling comfort. IME the tip of the can opener works just fine except in cases of extreme torque (apply too much and the tip twists before the pin does) and where deep access is needed. And the back side awl is a miserable thing compared to the 93mm one. I can see a way of improving it a little - at the cost of the nail nick.
The only thing I wish for on the Pioneer is a small blade in addition to the awl and openers. I find the Pioneer's blade too thick and wedgy sometimes. It's even thicker along the spine than the 111mm blade. The 58mm blade on my keyring is too flexible for my liking.
@Storm said:
I'm also firmly in Carls camp regarding back tools. I much prefer the smooth feel and find the backside tools much more fiddly to use than the utility they provide.
The inline dedicated all on the Pioneer is vastly better at drilling/ reaming for my uses than the reamer/awl on tinkers/Spartans etc . But then again I've never needed to sew heavy duty stuff together, so for someone else it may be their go to tool. That said the small blade is the one tool I miss most when carrying the Pioneer
Regarding breaking tools, I would be so bold as to venture that most of us know damn well when we are asking much more of a tool than it is designed for. My take is that you are of course free to do so, but never forget that when you throw your money on the table, you dont everytime get it back, and you went into it knowing that.
It'd be a boring word if we were all the same eh?
Agreed and well said!
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Largely agree with the OP. I do like to have a corkscrew at hand, though. I only have SAKs with the back side Phillips for their handling comfort. IME the tip of the can opener works just fine except in cases of extreme torque (apply too much and the tip twists before the pin does) and where deep access is needed. And the back side awl is a miserable thing compared to the 93mm one. I can see a way of improving it a little - at the cost of the nail nick.The only thing I wish for on the Pioneer is a small blade in addition to the awl and openers. I find the Pioneer's blade too thick and wedgy sometimes. **It's eventhicker along the spine than the 111mm blade. **The 58mm blade on my keyring is too flexible for my liking.
Agreed and well said!
I hadn't noticed this. I need to pay attention to it's performance in kitchen duties.
Being overly thick can be problematic - it's been noted that Bushcraft fixed blades will break an apple in two, rather than slice them.
If I could get a small blade on a 93mm.... Oh the places I could go.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
If I could get a small blade on a 93mm.... Oh the places I could go.You and me both brother !
(although I think there'd be more than just us two fizzing at the bung for such a knife
) -
On a day-to-day basis I find the back tools (and scale tools) just add too much versatility and capability to a SAK to pass up, though I strongly prefer the corkscrew over the backside Philips.
However, if I were headed somewhere (especially for an extended period of time) where a replacement SAK might be difficult or impossible to come by (and or an "every ounce counts" situation where I might not have a backup handy), I might very well accept less versatility in exchange for the increased ruggedness of the 93mm line.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
If I could get a small blade on a 93mm.... Oh the places I could go.I might be missing something here, but I'm assuming you are aware of the current 93mm models with the electrician's blade or the pruner blade, as well as the now discontinued Pioneer Settler with the small spear/pen blade?
-
Yup, gimme a 93mm any day of the week. The 91mm’s just feel flimsy. I carry a 58mm for the scale tools.
-
@nate j said:
I might be missing something here, but I'm assuming you are aware of the current 93mm models with the electrician's blade or the pruner blade, as well as the now discontinued Pioneer Settler with the small spear/pen blade?I am aware of them, but I'd be after the small, and more importantly thin blade of the 91mm range as it's such a wee scalpel compared to the big chunky 93mm main blade. The hang up for me would be that I make extensive usage of the small screwdriver tip on the can opener for my Phillips screw needs . Cant have the cake and eat it I suppose
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
