Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
@chapel976 said:
sure thing - https://imgur.com/a/tqXgXDaThanks for the follow-up!
Below are some of my Master Craftsman knives produced close to your wife’s knife. I think it clearly fits between my 1st and 2nd knives (left to right).
The first is ‘65-‘66 and has the 29TAM (angled teeth, machined finish) and to T&T.
The second I believe is ‘69-ish and maybe even early ‘70s. It’s my observation that shackles were in use past ‘68 for some models.
The third is late ‘71.
After reviewing your pictures and comparing against my knives (including other Champions in this date range) I still think yours is c. ‘68.
Thanks so much for posting your pictures. They really help me refine my chronology of the ‘60s production and when the Master Craftsman models gained the Toothpick & Tweezers.




-
-
@kamakiri said:
Unrelated, but looking through some 84mm boxes, I did find the ‘63 SAC knife with the conical awl...Interesting
And 50 years later this:
https://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Wenger+RangerWood+161 -
@jnoxyd said:
The main question is why didn't they make a wide enough line of cheap Elinox knives in 1950s-1960s?I’ve been meaning to get back to the root of your question...but I keep getting sidetracked looking through the collection.
Bottom line is that I don’t think you’re missing much, if any from your list. (Aside from the ESSR variants which I think LeaF covered better than I could)
Anyway...My theory is that there weren’t really reasons, needs or niches to ‘fill’ with Elinox model ‘construction’. The main niches in my view are price related. If you look at the prices in the misc. US ‘60s catalogues, I find it hard to price theoretical additional Elinox models where they wouldn’t cannibalize sales of main line products. Especially, if you consider that they might be built with minor defect parts and not just cheaper process parts. Meaning that if Elinox part bins were primarily filled with mildly out of toloerance parts, they would likely be the high volume parts. Certailnly starting with parts found in a modern Spartan...plus scissors, wood saw, then what? Like a long nail file was a labor intensive part that didn’t belong in an Economy model...it commanded a whopping ~$4 of retail price premium. Metal files being case hardened, would be pretty useless as out of tolerance items...because they should have been tossed/recycled prior to hardening.
The theory continues and as manufacturing quality and costs improve, there is less need to dispose of such parts. My guess is that this shift happened broadly through the ‘70s and coincided with what we see in reduced Elinox model availability. Broader main line use of other manufacturing processes originally used for Elinox lines like tumble polishing seem pretty clear.
Once most parts were tumble polished, there was very little supply of parts for or diverted to the Elinox bins. Or so it seems to me, as it all coincides with my chronology. Machining and finishes are important parts of my study. Understanding how these two processes change through time allow me to put dates to almost any part of any knife as seen be member elsinox’s blind test for the UPP stamped can opener. This is also why I can date many knives looking at them closed. Mostly machining changes for the ‘50s as everything is hand polished all the way through and into the ‘70s where nothing is.
The theory also supports the reason for fewer 84mm Elinox knives. Fewer main line part production leads to proportionally fewer rejects for the Elinox bins.
Thanks, jnoxyd, for always asking such excellent questions and bringing up excellent topics.

-
Thanks Kamakiri for the answer!
Indeed, I also do not see much sense in producing a cheap line using 50x-60x technologies. Scissors in the Elinox series look terrible without usual manual polishing, non-oxidized liners have cracks (to be honest, even in the main series they are a problem), the absence of a file on the phillips hardly gives a strong price reduction, etc. Interestingly, they did not abandon the idea of inexpensive series and released the Economy line without obvious degradation (hot stamping instead of a metal emblem, no tools in the scales, a corkscrew without a groove, what else?).
And yes, Huntsman Economy exists ;). What other 3-4 lines Economy knives do you have?


-
@jnoxyd said:
Thanks Kamakiri for the answer!
Indeed, I also do not see much sense in producing a cheap line using 50x-60x technologies. Scissors in the Elinox series look terrible without usual manual polishing, non-oxidized liners have cracks (to be honest, even in the main series they are a problem), the absence of a file on the phillips hardly gives a strong price reduction, etc. Interestingly, they did not abandon the idea of inexpensive series and released the Economy line without obvious degradation (hot stamping instead of a metal emblem, no tools in the scales, a corkscrew without a groove, what else?).
And yes, Huntsman Economy exists ;). What other 3-4 lines Economy knives do you have?


Lol. Pulled one of those out too.
I think time for the tumble polish is reduced for most parts. Or I’m just seeing the out of tolerance QC culls.
I have these as c. ‘79


-
Was busy taking this apart last night. Gotta love 70+ year old grime!
.

-
I'd say!
-
@jnoxyd said:
What was a reason? Every parts look good [emoji848]Parts have some damage and wear. Most of it could be ‘fixed’ to some degree for functionality...and also a bit for cosmetics. At the very least these aspects can be improved without taking it apart.
I didn’t make a list when I decided to take this one apart, because I’m still not 100% certain about restoring it. Some of the pros for taking it apart:
Parts. I bought it for parts, which aren’t that great. Decent shape for some but all need a fair amount of work to look ‘good’.
Already missing original shackle. So less concern about parting out an incomplete knife.
Cleaning. Hardly a reason, but I don’t like the ‘spa’ treatment...and never do that with vintage knives.
Practice. Before I do some other crab claw knives that need disassembly without scale damage, I thought it better to do one with lower value.
And the big one. Smashed liner ends. These could be improved a bit assembled, but I wanted to try an ‘agressive’ or intensive restoration on them. Now I know I’ll never make the look new, but the intent is to make them look far less used and abused. See pics below.The plate width of the outer liners essentially doubled. ~0.7mm -> 1.35mm and 1.40mm. Sure, I could have ‘fixed’ it with a file, but I got to the last pic with zero material removed.
I hope that explains some of my crazy!
.




-
Yes it was worth doing. Hope you are going to use nickel silver rods for rivets [emoji6]
-
@jnoxyd said:
Yes it was worth doing. Hope you are going to use nickel silver rods for rivets [emoji6]
Of course! And for the shackle too.I turn down the pins myself to 2.25mm from 3/32” stock ~2.37mm. I can re-use the long pin and 4th pin since they came out without material removal.
I’m going to try for the earlier style of shackle lugs that went into the early crab claws. Probably not the right style, but I haven’t made of that type before. Those usually go with the scales that have the nail relief for the corkscrew. This one is later than that and should probably have the ‘flatter’ style lug.

-
Great plan! Let us see what happens, please.
-
Kamakiri, looking forward to seeing how this project goes!

-
Here are some of my latest finds (I've already shown the Richartz Solingen from Germany on the far right in another thread)

- Victorinox 234 Bgl. (Spartan).
I suppose it's from late 40's early 50's...





- Wenger ? (Commander)
Measuring 82 mm, but I can't find not much more information to date it. Apparents rivets and can opener type claw "army style"



- Unknown brand.
Measuring also 82mm, really nice and every blades are closing like a gator ;)




I let the gurus of vintage sak telling more... ;)

- Victorinox 234 Bgl. (Spartan).
-
Looks good [emoji106]
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


