Knot in October GAW
-
— Sample entry (counts for Nix’s Time Period 1 entry) —
“Square Knot”, aka “Reef Knot”

To tie this knot, the two ends of a line or cord or bandage are crossed “left over right, then right over left.” (Or visa versa.)
Left over right:

Right over left:

Snugged up and finished off:

This is a type of binding knot and is best used for tying up a parcel or tying off a bandage. My favorite use for this knot is in reefing a sail. While it is one of the first knots people learn, it is actually a pretty crap knot in many ways; however, when tied with a draw loop (a slippery bight) it is useful for reefing a sail. As long as it is under strain or loaded, it does OK.

snugged and sailor-like:

I used the Reef knot to reef a mainsail in a nasty storm once. The shortened sail helped to maintain way and to stabilize the boat, while reducing the chance of a gust carrying off the mast or capsizing the boat. Which is nice.
The Square knot is NOT a bending knot. Do NOT use this knot to join two lines: it is a somewhat weak knot and it can slip easily unless further secured with hitches or weaving. (I used two lines just to make it easier to see how it is tied — don’t do this!)

In the photo sequence above, a proper Square knot was tied, but it got bent over, then slipped out. I hope this photo series demonstrates why the Square knot is NOT a reliable bending knot (i.e. for joining two lines together)….it mostly sucks.
-
A question of clarification, in the step by step description of tying do the drawing/sketches/photos have to be done by you or can you pull pictures from another source as long as you prove you have tied and used the knot?
-
Oh, my... I'll definitely give this a go.

-
@Sos24 said:
A question of clarification, in the step by step description of tying do the drawing/sketches/photos have to be done by you or can you pull pictures from another source as long as you prove you have tied and used the knot?An excellent question....and one that I have pondered.

As long as you can show (1) how the knot is tied, and (2) that you as a participant have actually tied said knot, I think it will qualify. As you mention, an explanation of how the knot is useful is also required. There is no requirement for a participant to have actually used the knot in anger, but it must be clear to the referee (Nix) that the knot is actually useful.

E.g. "The Square knot is reported to be useful for tying off a bandage or in making an improvised touniquet. I've never had to improvise a tourniquet, but this seems like a good thing to know for emergency use."

-
-
@Nix said:
6. Once a specific knot has been used as an entry, it can not be entered again. For example, if Nix enters a “Square Knot”, no one else can enter the square knot. Every entry has to be a knot unique to the thread. The same knot by another name will not be considered a valid entry. For example, if Nix entered the “Square Knot”, a “Reef Knot” does not qualify as a new or unique knot for the thread. (They are the same knot.):-
This will complicate things. I hope no one uses my favorite knots. -
-
-
Uuuu, I like this one a lot.
I love tying and learning new knots. I use to carry a small piece of paracord just to practice.Just two questions...
-
do variations of a knot count as separate knots. For instance a figure 8, double figure 8 aka bunny ears and triple figure 8 should probably count as separate knots although they are tied similarly, right?
-
do we get extra points for knot cosmetics?
Like tying it nicely without overlaps and such.
-
-
Knot puns are knot optional.

The good thing is that there are enough knots for every member to have five entries. Knot that it would matter, since knot many people tie knots.
-
-
@enki_ck said:
Uuuu, I like this one a lot.
I love tying and learning new knots. I use to carry a small piece of paracord just to practice.Just two questions...
-
do variations of a knot count as separate knots. For instance a figure 8, double figure 8 aka bunny ears and triple figure 8 should probably count as separate knots although they are tied similarly, right?
-
do we get extra points for knot cosmetics?
Like tying it nicely without overlaps and such.
Thanks!
More great questions...

- Uhhhh.... I'm knot sure. (I have actually thought about this, and it seems to me that there is a certain degree of subjectivity here.) Some variations do, I believe, constitute a separate and 'unique' knot. In my "Square knot" example, the "Reef knot"....with a slippery bight...does NOT constitute a new knot; it is essentially the same as the non-slippery "Square" or "Reef" knot.
I hate to be vague here, but there is room for variation and improvement. A stopper knot is not that same as a fixed loop knot or a bending knot, even if some of the techniques used to make the knot are similiar. Again, I hate to be vague, and some of this will be subjective (Thank goodness the awl-wise Nix is our referee!
). You can ask the referee (Nix) a question, if there is a question, in the thread. Awl answers to be made publicly.- No! A good working knot is inherently pretty (in Nix's opinion
). If your knot works and is useful and is a knot worth knowing.....cosmetics be damned! Nix isn't pretty and ain't neither is his knots!!! 
Great questions. I can awlready see that you are a formidable contestant!

-
-
I’ll throw out another. Does an series of knots, like a handle wrap, count as a knot?
-

You are testing the limits of my 'expertise'.....

I, a very well established, amateur, knot enthusiast and semi-professional knot contest referee, will say a knot that can be used to create a useful wrap is a "unique knot" and would qualify as an entry in this GAW.
Simply wrapping a string around a bottle or stick will NOT be considered a "unique knot"; however, the knot that secures said wrapping might well be. For instance, I use a particular knot to secure a hank of cordage or webbing. The hank itself is just a wad of cord, but the knot that holds that mess together has a name and a method of tying that can be identified and repeated.

Here's the dreadful secret about being a semi-professional knot contest referee: you are never right, and always wrong in the eyes of someone. I guess that just adds some tension to the game and gives the crowd something to complain about.


-
Your game, your rules.

-
-
The Palomar knot
Great fishing knot for braided Musky Line which can slip using a regular fishing knot




-
-
@SteveC said:
The Palomar knotGreat fishing knot for braided Musky Line which can slip using a regular fishing knot
The Palomar is an excellent knot! I've used it myself many times.

:ahhh HOWEVER, Time Period One (1) has not yet started. The rules state that an entry can only be made during an official time period and cannot be made proactively. (see Rule #7)
This entry will NOT count.
**** booo....boooo....booo ****
-
Knot complete

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
