The Cigar Thread
-
They're great Nate. I've had them and really enjoy them when I've got a lot going on.
-
Rocky Patel B52 - definitely better than the current edge line, good burn, straight tobacco flavour
-
Villa Zamorano Expresso.
a very small but tightly packed and long lasting (I think I got nearly an hour) cigar.
Good flavour, for the price
-
Love the Patels. I'll have to try the Villa.
-
Back to the good old Partagas P-2.
My current favourites, smooth, chocolatey, sweet, nice aroma and taste, good burn
-
a couple during the weekend
Arturo Fuente Brevas Royal Maduro cheap and nasty. there are way better options
Don Luis Secretos Del Maestro BHK 52 OK, but not worth buying again
-
After trying various options, this is what I generally have in my car.
From left to right:
-
Romeo Y Julieta Minis (Natural) - about a ten minute smoke
-
Victor Sinclair 55 Series Cigarillos (Maduro) - about a twenty minute smoke
-
Punch Bolos - about a thirty to forty minute smoke
So, I have several options depending on how long I'll be driving. If I know I'm going to be in the car for an hour or two, I'll try to grab a full-size cigar, but I don't regularly keep them in the car.

-
-
Just had a very nice Upmann... time to get some more :D
-
My creative cutter...it works as well as any cutter I've used.

-
@Barry Rowland said:
My creative cutter...it works as well as any cutter I've used.Good work, Barry!
I have always cut my cigars with a knife; the idea of carrying around a dedicated cigar cutter that serves no other purpose has never been appealing to me. I've used SAKs, Stockmen, Buck 110s...as long as the blade is quite sharp and the user has a basic level of skill and knowledge of how to properly cut a cigar with a knife, I would agree that the cut should be at least the equal of what could be achieved with a dedicated cutter, if not superior.
-
Had an Alec Bradley prensado on Saturday. I generally like their cigars but this was barely OK. It only had their signature flavour profile, a bit, in the last third.
Had a Partagas Serie P No.2 yesterday, my current favourite. Solid.
-
I have to try one. I've not come across those yet.
-
@dks said:
Had an Alec Bradley prensado on Saturday. I generally like their cigars but this was barely OK. It only had their signature flavour profile, a bit, in the last third.Had a Partagas Serie P No.2 yesterday, my current favourite. Solid.
That's disappointing that you got a dud.
I'm generally a fan of both Alec Bradley and Partagas.

-
Alec make a good stick. I don't know if there was an issue with the particular cigar or if they wanted a different flavour, not to my liking. It burned fine.
-
La Rica serie 2000, burns well, tastes of tobacco, nothing else
-
@dks said:
La Rica serie 2000, burns well, tastes of tobacco, nothing elseJust the way I like them. I despise flavored cigars.
I also don't really understand the reviewers who say things like, "This cigar has notes of leather, coffee, and chocolate." To me, tobacco tastes like tobacco, coffee tastes like coffee, chocolate tastes like chocolate, and I don't know what leather tastes like.

-
some cigars will have a sweet or creamy taste, naturally, and be smooth or rough, with hints of other flavours.
They are very similar to Whisky.
How many flavours you can distinguish or enjoy depends on the individual, what you know, what you like, how many cigars you are smoking (not enough or, too many in a day). whether you are smoking at a suitable rate, taking time to look for the flavours, whether you keep the smoke in your mouth for a while, exhale through the nose too...
You also have to consider the strength, nicotine, you like
Tobacco flavour is good, if it is smooth. If it is rough then it will not be too pleasant.
I watch some online reviews of cigars and whisky and on many occasions I do not get any of the flavours they get. Different reviewers will get different flavours, especially the more muted ones.
-
Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro
Reminds me of Onyx cigars, from decades ago.
Decent flavour, sweet, good burn. A lot of tar for an aged cigar.
Not bad but you can get similar flavour for half the cost
-
@dks said:
Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua MaestroReminds me of Onyx cigars, from decades ago.
Decent flavour, sweet, good burn. A lot of tar for an aged cigar.
Not bad but you can get similar flavour for half the cost
Some people rave about those Aging Room cigars, but the ones I've had I thought were only just OK...

-
@nate j said:
Some people rave about those Aging Room cigars, but the ones I've had I thought were only just OK...
They do well in cigar aficionado. Maybe I am just not capable to detect certain special flavours in them...
Also, maybe the blend changes slightly after a cigar gets popular, to satisfy the large demand, so they may not taste as good as the originals.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login