Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • World
Skins
  • Light
  • Dark

Collapse

NodeBB

Knot in October GAW

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved The Break Room
778 Posts 1 Posters 26.9k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • NixN
    NixN
    Nix
    wrote on last edited by
    #312

    @enki_ck said:
    Ralf, I think we could be having a discussion on this one. We call that knot a figure 6 knot here. And yes, it's a very tight knot, the only problem I see with it if abseiling on it is that the strands are loaded against the direction of the knot and you are essentially "breaking" the knot when you put it under load if abseiling on a single strand of rope if I understand correctly how you described the descent on a single rope. :think:
    A water knot like you use to make a webbing sling would load the rope better, but would probably be more prone to slipping out. However I don't have experiance with double rope techniques and trust you climbers know your stuff better than us dirty underground dwellers and our SRT 👼

    :iagree: enki, you've echo'ed my very first thoughts.

    I've always avoided the overhand because, once loaded, it can be hard to untie. As pictured above, the load on the two joined strands would be pulling the knot apart. I don't know about the overhand, but with a Figure 8 I have been taught to never tie two lines together with a Figure 8 like this when the load will be along both lines. No tonly is the knot being pulled apart, but it is also much weaker (I've seen testing on this.)

    To the contrary, a water knot (which has knot been entered in the contest so far..... :whistle:) is a relatively strong knot, and might be preferred for joining two tapes.

    I have to defer to Huntsman's experience here, but for anything other than a simple loop, the two-strand overhand scares me.

    Still...it is a knot! And can be useful! It counts!

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • NixN
      NixN
      Nix
      wrote on last edited by
      #313

      @ReamerPunch said:
      Nice monkey fist! :like:
      I made one too. I finished it with a Friendship knot.
      I was thinking of entering the monkey fist in here, but decided against it. I could argue it is useful, as a weight, fidget, or for self defense, but it is mostly decorative.

      The knot I tossed out there is knot a Monkey fist..... :whistle: (bet ya a beer that Sos24 knows what it is....)

      And I could argue that both our knots are useful..... :pok: They didn't come about by accident! 😄

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • NixN
        NixN
        Nix
        wrote on last edited by
        #314

        @ReamerPunch said:
        A slipped constrictor knot is just as tight as a regular one, but much easier to untie. :tu:

        :iagree: Super-useful knot to know!

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • NixN
          NixN
          Nix
          wrote on last edited by Nix
          #315

          Huntsman's post prompted me to do a little research into the Overhand knot when used as a bend between two lines.

          Thanks, Huntsman! :salute:

          Wiki has a nice article about this knot here: Offset Overhand Bend

          In that article, I was reminded that this knot has been called the "European Death Knot" or EDK because its use has been associate with several climbing deaths.

          I think that is why my alarm bells started going off when I saw Huntsman's entry. :ahhh

          I checked with my favorite mountaineering book, sure that it would confirm my perception that this is a dangerous knot to use; however, I was wrong!

          From <u>Mountaineering, The Freedom of the Hills</u>: (They call it the "Double Overhand Knot" .)

          The double overhand knot is useful as a rappel knot in icy conditions or for rappels where the knot might catch when the rappel rope is retrieved.

          I was surprised by this!

          What does Ashley say about the overhand?

          [The single overhand] is very secure but very weak, reducing the strength of the rope in which it was tied by perhaps as much as fifty percent. It also jams is difficult to untie, often injuring the fiber. For these reasons it should be tied only in small material that is not to be employed again, and where there is a considerable margin of strength.

          The overhand bend, also called Thumb Knot and Openhand Knot, ranks higher than the Sheet Bend in security but is among the weakest bends. It is used in joining the ends of rope yarns by which hams, bacon, and bananas are hung.

          OK....I sense some controversy.....

          Doing a little more looking around on line, I came across a climbing website that reviewed the "European Death Knot": In Defense of the European Death Knot

          The European death knot is more correctly referred to as the offset overhand bend. Quite simply, it is an overhand knot tied using two lengths of cordage. It is used as a method to connect two ropes for use in rappelling.

          There are a few reasons why the EDK is a sound choice. The main argument for the EDK is that it is low-profile and asymmetrical. What this means is that it is less likely to snag in cracks or over edges, and has a tendency to turn inward to present the flat side of the bend to the rock edge. This reduces the potential for stuck rappel ropes when compared to other alternatives.

          Additionally, the EDK is easy to tie, easy to untie (under normal loads), and easy to inspect. This cannot be said with much conviction for the other variations. For use in multiple rappels, it offers a significant time saving factor.

          Let’s talk about correct tying [of the EDK].

          Here are the important points:
          • Leave sufficient tail—30-50 cm is ideal
          • Dress and pre-tension the EDK
          • A backup can be tied in the form of a second overhand above the initial knot. This increases the knot profile, but Moyer states that it maintains asymmetry and makes the knot harder to capsize.
          • Don’t use the EDK for tying sling/webbing/cordelette anchors. Moyer suggests the Tape/Water Knot or the Double Fishermans.
          • CHECK YOUR KNOTS. Inspect your buddies. Complacency=bad juju.”

          So, on balance, it would appear that Huntsman is right. It is a practical knot for some applications. Especially where the knot may need to slip over a ledge or edge. However, it is also a weak knot. One source I found stated the *reduction *in line strength was 65%! That is a serious weakening of a line. Ashley's advice to have a "considerable margin of strength" would seem to be very well founded.

          I'll confess that I remain highly prejudiced against the double overhand bend. Maybe it was an instructor sergeant threatening us with death if we ever survived using it and he found out. Maybe it's just a general dislike of a knot that jams so easily. Maybe because I know stronger knots that, while they may be slower to tie, are more confidence inspiring.

          The overhand knot is my least favorite knot. I can only think of one, maybe two, specific knots that incorporates the overhand knot where the overhand knot makes some sense. Otherwise, I avoid it.

          Great knot entry, Huntsman! I really enjoyed learning more about this knot....and maybe I'll give it a little more slack (heheheh) now that I've researched it a bit. :tu:

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • NixN
            NixN
            Nix
            wrote on last edited by
            #316

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • HuntsmanH
              HuntsmanH
              Huntsman
              Global Moderators
              wrote on last edited by
              #317

              Hi Guys

              Thanks for all the feedback - and for the research and quotes Nix :tu: :salute:
              I really don't like that name EDK - Sent shivers up my spine!!!! :-[

              I know/see what you mean about the design of the knot meaning that it is pulled apart when in use

              The thing about an abseil is that the load on the knot is pretty gentle (ie the weight of the climber), steady and constant - not like a fall - So maybe this is another reason why the knot is OK for this use!
              Oh and just to be clear we would always ab. down a double, not single, rope.

              So what about the Fig. 8 then ? ???

              I have tried to show in the sequence below - How a Fig 8 - Can roll over itself and eventually disappear !! 😮

              I have only shown this on a single (not interweaved) Fig 8. - I think it would be highly unlikely to happen in an interweaved Fig. 8 - And especially if it has been loaded.

              So the series of images below are probably more of a demonstration why you need a long tail, a stopper knot and should pre-tension a knot! !!
              The stopper knot (which is also an overhand knot - Hey hey!! 😉 ) of course would prevent this happening!!

              One more post coming about when I would use a Fig 8 in an abseil!!

              Also something I have learnt in this thread is how knots weaken the rope and how different knots weaken the rope by different amounts - Interesting
              So thanks guys :tu:

              Hey and you are a caver Nicola? - Fantastic - :tu: I have done a little caving ........ loved it 😄
              There is a lot of limestone in the UK and the caves are great!!

              Fig 8 roll.JPG

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • NixN
                NixN
                Nix
                wrote on last edited by
                #318

                @Huntsman said:
                I have only shown this on a single (not interweaved) Fig 8. - I think it would be highly unlikely to happen in an interweaved Fig. 8 - And especially if it has been loaded.

                I've seen recommendations to add stopper knots to figure 8 knots. I've used Figure 8 knots to abseil/rappel and for climbing harnesses and have never had an issue, and after testing Figure 8's I don't see a problem.

                However, the earlier words of advice hold true for me:

                1. tie a neat knot, 2) dress it properly, and 3) pre-tension your knots.

                Also, an offset figure 8 knot is not recommended! From what I've read, an offset overhand is preferred to an offset Figure 8 for a number of reasons. But the Offset Figure 8 is a bad idea, too.

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • HuntsmanH
                  HuntsmanH
                  Huntsman
                  Global Moderators
                  wrote on last edited by Huntsman
                  #319

                  Hello again,

                  I don't do much climbing these days ...... sadly 😢 - So am really enjoying this opportunity to talk about it a bit !! 😄

                  So when you abseil you should always tie the bottom (open) ends of the rope together - I would use a Fig 8 to do this - with a bit of a tail of course! -
                  This keeps it neat and tidy and means the rope lengths on either side of the attachment point stay equal lengths.
                  But most importantly: - It prevents you dropping off the end of the rope when you get to the bottom - Believe it or knot several climbers have died by knot doing this.

                  Here is a great shot of a climb (series of abseils) where I used an overhand knot at the top end of the rope and a Fig 8 at the bottom end.
                  It's the Old Man of Hoy - Off the North coast of Scotland in the Orkney Islands
                  Nowhere is it more evident of the need for a stopper knot at the bottom than on this descent.
                  You can see the bottom abseil says 'free abseil'....

                  If you have regular 50m ropes - When you get to the bottom of the rope you will be dangling in mid air - still about 10m off the ground!!
                  Hopefully you did not drop off the end of the rope as you had your Fig 8 stopper knot there!!! :tu:
                  So what do you do about that ???

                  If you know about this - ie you researched the route before the climb
                  [list type=decimal]

                  • When you climb **up **the Old Man you leave a fixed tether rope from The Haven to the Gallery - So when you do the ab. you put the tether rope through your waist carabiner and abseil slightly diagonally back to The Gallery

                  • If you use 60m ropes you get right to the bottom

                  • If you did knot know about this - ie It happened when you were doing a route for the first time ......... Maybe my next knot will help you!!

                  Old Man Hoy Route.jpg

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • NixN
                    NixN
                    Nix
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #320

                    :like:

                    (Figure 8 is my favorite stopper knot. I was taught to use the Figure 8 as a stopper as a wee tiny sailing lad and have ne'er felt the need to change course. 😉 )

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • Sos24S
                      Sos24S
                      Sos24
                      Global Moderators
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #321

                      @ReamerPunch said:
                      I went through this again. :like:

                      I already knew the bowline, hangman's knot, single and double fisherman's, clove hitch.
                      I have learned and am able to tie from memory the Alpine Butterfly, the handcuff knot, break-away lanyard, single and double constrictor.

                      I am impressed with the constrictor knots. Talk about tight. wow. :ahhh I wish someone had taut me these earlier.
                      Tightening it reminds me of the movie Anaconda. It really looks like the cord is alive. Thanks, Sos24! :salute:

                      And we have three more sets of knots coming! Can't wait! :cheers:

                      Glad you like the constrictor knots.

                      I’ve used the slip constrictor for tying-down items before a big storm

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • ReamerPunchR
                        ReamerPunchR
                        ReamerPunch
                        Global Moderators
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #322

                        I have decided on my next knot, and it's pretty special. :cheers:

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • HuntsmanH
                          HuntsmanH
                          Huntsman
                          Global Moderators
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #323

                          T - 1 :tu:

                          Or post yesterday if we are on Nix's clock >:D

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • ReamerPunchR
                            ReamerPunchR
                            ReamerPunch
                            Global Moderators
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #324

                            It'll be the 15th in 2.5 hours here. :pok:

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • pfrsantosP
                              pfrsantosP
                              pfrsantos
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #325

                              Thanks for the warning. Was waiting until the weekend to post my next one.

                              :facepalm:

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • NixN
                                NixN
                                Nix
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #326

                                @Huntsman said:
                                Or post yesterday if we are on Nix's clock >:D

                                :rofl:

                                :twak:

                                :rofl:

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • NixN
                                  NixN
                                  Nix
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #327

                                  :ahhh

                                  So....it is 15 October 2020....JAFA time.....

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • NixN
                                    NixN
                                    Nix
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #328

                                    ATTENTION!!! ATTENTION!!!

                                      *Time Period Two (2) is now closed!*
                                    

                                    Time Period Two (2) is now closed!
                                    I say again, Time Period Two (2) is now closed!

                                    ATTENTION!!! ATTENTION!!!

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • NixN
                                      NixN
                                      Nix
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #329

                                      ATTENTION!!! ATTENTION!!!

                                        *Time Period Three (3) is now Open!*
                                      

                                      Time Period Three (3) is now Open!
                                      Time Period Three (3) really is now open!

                                      ATTENTION!!! ATTENTION!!!

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • NixN
                                        NixN
                                        Nix
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #330

                                        😄

                                        I have my spoiler knot picked out..... >:D

                                        But haven't taken my photos yet....! :ahhh

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • NixN
                                          NixN
                                          Nix
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #331

                                          To celebrate the end of Time Period Two, I'm going to change the rules again.

                                          So far, I think I've offered the winner of the GAW a difficult choice to make from among a string of three very different fixed blade knives. This week, I'm going to throw another twist into that choice and add a folder. Let's see if this throws someone for a loop.......


                                          Left to right: BRK Vidarr, BRK Bravo 2, ML Knives EDC, BM Contego

                                          Choosing one of these four knives seems like a tough task. :dunno:

                                          Let me make it a bit easier:

                                          The Contego is an awesome knife. I can scarcely believe I'm offering it as part of the GAW contest. It was designed by the now famous Warren Osborne.

                                          A native of Australia, Osborne moved to Texas, where he resided in Waxahachie for many years. He was a full-time knifemaker and sold his first custom knife in 1980. In his trademark cowboy hat and cowboy boots, Warren was a fixture at knife shows and BladeSports International (BSI) cutting competitions.

                                          Warren passed away far too young, but he left behind a legacy of brilliant knife designs.

                                          This Contego is a Benchmade knife made with Benchmade quality. It is a beast of a knife with a full 4" (10.2 cm) blade made from CPM-M4 steel. The blade shape may not be for everyone, but I think it is particularly useful and functional. Hey, it was designed by a legend who knew what he was doing. The scales are G-10. The Axis lock is buttery smooth and the heavy blade flicks open without a thought. That big piece of M4 has some real inertia when it gets going and carries open or closed (watch those fingers!) with little effort.

                                          Now, let me make the choice a bit harder:

                                          While the Osborne is a practical knife, I think it was designed as a 'tactical' knife. This gives it a few drawbacks. For one, it is big. It carries reasonably well in a pocket with that slightly worn pocket clip. I don't like pocket clips in general, but this knife definitely benefits from a pocket clip. I would say that the ergos of the Contego are excellent (and for my big hands they are); however, that G-10 is very aggressively textured. That may be practical in some situations, but it means the knife isn't all warm and cuddly to hold. (Comparing the sandpaper-like texture of the Contego to the smooth feel of a BRK is like night and day!) I actually used some very fine sandpaper to knock down some of the really sharp bits. (I don't think you can tell from looking at it.)

                                          Another drawback to me is the small pointy glass-breaker that sticks out of the pommel. Again, a nice tactical touch, but I find that it pokes me from time to time. Not a big deal, but I usually find myself, after carrying it for a day, thinking I'd like it better without that sharp bit of carbide sticking up.

                                          While the M4 steel is an amazing knife steel, it isn't the easiest to sharpen. I don't think I've ever sharpened this knife, but I have some experience with other M4 knives.

                                          So: a bit big, a bit pokey, a bit heavy, a tricky steel, and a worn pocket clip. Probably why I don't carry it often. :dunno:

                                          Still....it is an Osborne....and a Benchmade..... 😮

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0

                                          Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                          Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                          With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                          Register Login

                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Popular
                                          • World