Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE NOTIFICATIONS 0 MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Vintage SAK Owners Club

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
1.7k Posts 1 Posters 177.2k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
  4. Vintage SAK Owners Club
Vintage SAK Owners Club
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Huntsman Offline
    Huntsman
    Global Moderators
    Posts: 5,781
    Huntsman Offline
    Huntsman
    Global Moderators
    wrote on last edited by
    #1299 Quote Reply

      Hi Folks

      Just caught up on the last four pages of this thread - Amazing discussions and knowledge as always :salute:
      Particularly interested in all the discussions around Bear, Hoffritz, SABI, Forschner and the US Vic imports etc
      And of course all the old SAKs goes without saying!!

      The Chief moderators and Grant prefer us never to alter any previously posted content - And certainly not without the permission of the OP.
      With that said - MiniChamp's suggestion is a very sensible proposition.

      So I could add the latest Ulli TS image to the very first post in his thread - with his permission - Shall I ask him? (I did that for my dating spreadsheet recently)
      Max if you want I could also add it to your first post in the Tang Stamp project - Let me know

      :cheers:

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Max Stone Offline
        Max Stone
        Posts: 5,982
        Max Stone Offline
        Max Stone
        wrote on last edited by
        #1300 Quote Reply

          Yes, makes sense to include it. There are some dates on Ulli’s table that don’t align 100% with the Wiki page, but as you’ve stated before, dating SAKs is not an exact science. :cheers:

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Reinier Offline
            Reinier
            Posts: 10,743
            Reinier Offline
            Reinier
            wrote on last edited by
            #1301 Quote Reply

              @MiniChamp said:
              I didn't realize that my response sounded grumpy. It was not my intention. Sorry.

              OK I apologize, I probably misread your post. :cheers:

              1 Reply Last reply
              • ulli Offline
                ulli
                Posts: 230
                ulli Offline
                ulli
                wrote on last edited by
                #1302 Quote Reply

                  @Huntsman said:
                  Hi Folks

                  Just caught up on the last four pages of this thread - Amazing discussions and knowledge as always :salute:
                  Particularly interested in all the discussions around Bear, Hoffritz, SABI, Forschner and the US Vic imports etc
                  And of course all the old SAKs goes without saying!!

                  The Chief moderators and Grant prefer us never to alter any previously posted content - And certainly not without the permission of the OP.
                  With that said - MiniChamp's suggestion is a very sensible proposition.

                  So I could add the latest Ulli TS image to the very first post in his thread - with his permission - Shall I ask him? (I did that for my dating spreadsheet recently)
                  Max if you want I could also add it to your first post in the Tang Stamp project - Let me know

                  :cheers:

                  I m happy if I could help. I stopped uploading newer version of my tang stamp sheet, because people always take the one on page 1 (approx. 7000 download) and not the newest one (approx. 1000 downloads) and some use the sheet without permisson on their pages.
                  Tang stamps are just one tool to date knives. I really like the tang stamp project on the other thread. I would stick on the mainly and regular used stamps. Because on knives before 1950, there are so many variants, around 5 versions of the VICTOR-INOX crossbow stamp. I dont think that would help people much when they just want date a knife in a timerange of some years.
                  MT is a really good place to bring people together, to share the knowledge, but I m not sure if its the perfect place for content based on facts and evidence. I m not sure if you know what I mean. Its a platform for discussions, for sharing. My intention with the tang stamp sheet was not to bring a perfect product that is 100% correct, because almost every day I see and learn something new. And thats the way I like it, to create something as a base for discussions. Thats very common in science. If you buy today a book in biology, in 5 years its worth nothing, because its already too old, not accurate, because now in 2020 people know much more than in 2015. But the problem with online content like here on MT is, that you cant replace old content with new content. So I see old tang stamp sheets everywhere, on online auctions, on homepages, most time with a claim that its 100% correct.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • jnoxyd Offline
                    jnoxyd
                    Posts: 1,226
                    jnoxyd Offline
                    jnoxyd
                    wrote on last edited by jnoxyd
                    #1303 Quote Reply

                      Hi Ulli! You're right, I'm tired of fixing guys using old versions of your date sheet and reminding them that it's not good to share this cool sheet without the name of the creator. However, could you please post the most recent version with a proper title with your name.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • Max Stone Offline
                        Max Stone
                        Posts: 5,982
                        Max Stone Offline
                        Max Stone
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #1304 Quote Reply

                          Thanks Ulli for your comment/feedback. I hope that by adding your most recent table to these threads and to the updated Wiki tang page, we can steer people to this version. I do believe (and have stated before) that the Wiki tang page should follow the general format and content of the rest of the Wiki, which has a bias towards more recent models. Winding the clock back before 1950 becomes a lot more challenging for content and data, and almost deserves its own Vintage section that would require a lot of work. I think that threads like this one are of more value for those with an interest in vintage SAKs and willing to share/discuss information. :salute:

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • ulli Offline
                            ulli
                            Posts: 230
                            ulli Offline
                            ulli
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #1305 Quote Reply

                              @Max Stone said:
                              Thanks Ulli for your comment/feedback. I hope that by adding your most recent table to these threads and to the updated Wiki tang page, we can steer people to this version. I do believe (and have stated before) that the Wiki tang page should follow the general format and content of the rest of the Wiki, which has a bias towards more recent models. Winding the clock back before 1950 becomes a lot more challenging for content and data, and almost deserves its own Vintage section that would require a lot of work. I think that threads like this one are of more value for those with an interest in vintage SAKs and willing to share/discuss information. :salute:

                              I think I better give you a link to the sheet. There the size is not restricted and I can be sure its always the newest version.

                              404 Not Found

                              favicon

                              (elsinox.com)

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • Max Stone Offline
                                Max Stone
                                Posts: 5,982
                                Max Stone Offline
                                Max Stone
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #1306 Quote Reply

                                  Thank you Ulli - I have updated on the Wiki. Huntsman will need to update the threads on the forum. :hatsoff:

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • kamakiri Offline
                                    kamakiri
                                    Posts: 3,215
                                    kamakiri Offline
                                    kamakiri
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #1307 Quote Reply

                                      @ulli said:
                                      MT is a really good place to bring people together, to share the knowledge, but I m not sure if its the perfect place for content based on facts and evidence. I m not sure if you know what I mean. Its a platform for discussions, for sharing. My intention with the tang stamp sheet was not to bring a perfect product that is 100% correct, because almost every day I see and learn something new. And thats the way I like it, to create something as a base for discussions. Thats very common in science. If you buy today a book in biology, in 5 years its worth nothing, because its already too old, not accurate, because now in 2020 people know much more than in 2015. But the problem with online content like here on MT is, that you cant replace old content with new content. So I see old tang stamp sheets everywhere, on online auctions, on homepages, most time with a claim that its 100% correct.

                                      Sadly, you are right. This is the problem with static unchanging sources of info.

                                      It is one of my main challenges in improving the chronology data available here and ultimately in the Wiki.

                                      Like the “1973” Hoffritz Champion for sale above which is actually c.’76. It would be nearly impossible to correct such errors because they feel that they have done ‘extensive research’ on the matter. I know, because I’ve tried.

                                      The tang stamp updates, both yours and the wiki, will go a long way toward making it better.

                                      My thanks to all who have participated in the wiki update. And especially to Max for taking the lead and listening to all the input. Excellent.

                                      Not to say that it is or I am done with some of the refinements I need to get to, but it really is a huge milestone for the wiki regarding more accurate chronology.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • Max Stone Offline
                                        Max Stone
                                        Posts: 5,982
                                        Max Stone Offline
                                        Max Stone
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #1308 Quote Reply

                                          :cheers: kamakiri, and the Wiki will continue to be developed to be a valuable resource :salute:

                                          And I saw what you did, good signature :D

                                          Screenshot 2020-11-25 211507.jpg

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • MiniChamp Offline
                                            MiniChamp
                                            Posts: 224
                                            MiniChamp Offline
                                            MiniChamp
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #1309 Quote Reply

                                              @kamakiri said:
                                              Like the “1973” Hoffritz Champion for sale above which is actually c.’76.

                                              Why do you think that it's c.’76? It seems to have a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring/corkscrew/main-blade-shank combination. I don't recall encountering before any claims that such SAKs were produced after 1974.

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • kamakiri Offline
                                                kamakiri
                                                Posts: 3,215
                                                kamakiri Offline
                                                kamakiri
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #1310 Quote Reply

                                                  @Max Stone said:
                                                  :cheers: kamakiri, and the Wiki will continue to be developed to be a valuable resource :salute:

                                                  And I saw what you did, good signature :D

                                                  :D Imitation is a sincere form of flattery! ;) I like the way you worded that. Better than I would do. :tu:

                                                  @MiniChamp said:
                                                  Why do you think that it's c.’76?

                                                  I know it’s c.’76. There are perhaps a dozen things that confirm it. The seller’s pictures are very good, and it’s very easy to see what I need to see.

                                                  There are more obscure reasons like the similarities to a Hoffritz Super Knife I own...aside from one part that does not exist before ‘76 or ‘77. And I have lots of main line Champions produced on either side of this date range.

                                                  @MiniChamp said:
                                                  It seems to have a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring/corkscrew/main-blade-shank combination.

                                                  Are you 100% certain about that? I suggest looking at the pictures again. More cost effective than spending $400+ for it.

                                                  @MiniChamp said:
                                                  I don't recall encountering before any claims that such SAKs were produced after 1974.

                                                  Well, now you have. But I’m pretty sure we skirted the topic of your changeover theories in this time frame before. I’ll eventually get to the proof in the “dating in the ‘70s” series, assuming I don’t croak before then.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • MiniChamp Offline
                                                    MiniChamp
                                                    Posts: 224
                                                    MiniChamp Offline
                                                    MiniChamp
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #1311 Quote Reply

                                                      @kamakiri said:
                                                      I know it’s c.’76. There are perhaps a dozen things that confirm it. The seller’s pictures are very good, and it’s very easy to see what I need to see.

                                                      You are not really answering the question. Clearly, if you think that this SAK is c.’76, it's because of some "things" that you see in the pictures. The question is: What are those mysterious things?

                                                      Are you 100% certain about that?

                                                      I'm never 100% certain about anything, but I do believe that the attached image shows a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring. If I'm wrong, then surely you have an appropriate post-Victoria-era SAK with a 2.4mm spring that looks like this one. Can you show images of such a SAK?

                                                      Well, now you have.

                                                      Well, now you got me confused. Are you claiming that I'm wrong about this particular SAK having a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring or that SAKs with such springs were produced at least until 1976 (or both)?

                                                      I’ll eventually get to the proof in the “dating in the ‘70s” series, assuming I don’t croak before then.

                                                      I'll be extremely happy if you will ever start providing some sort of evidence to support your claims. Until then I tend to consider them as being quite questionable.

                                                      254674039171-spring.jpg

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • kamakiri Offline
                                                        kamakiri
                                                        Posts: 3,215
                                                        kamakiri Offline
                                                        kamakiri
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #1312 Quote Reply

                                                          Let me not answer that with another question:

                                                          If you were Victorinox and you ran out (intentionally as part of the 2.7mm phase out) of one of those parts, but not other components in this layer, what would you do in order to use those other parts?

                                                          Regarding c.’76, there’s actually relevant info even in the cropped picture that you posted.

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • kamakiri Offline
                                                            kamakiri
                                                            Posts: 3,215
                                                            kamakiri Offline
                                                            kamakiri
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #1313 Quote Reply

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              You are not really answering the question.

                                                              Yeah, that’s intentional. Incorrect suppositions are difficult to answer.

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              Clearly, if you think that this SAK is c.’76, it's because of some "things" that you see in the pictures. The question is: What are those mysterious things?

                                                              Going through all the pics, I counted 19. But you only really need the one to prove the point. And two are the most relevant parts to this discussion. Both are visible in the crop you posted.

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              I'm never 100% certain about anything, but I do believe that the attached image shows a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring. If I'm wrong, then surely you have an appropriate post-Victoria-era SAK with a 2.4mm spring that looks like this one. Can you show images of such a SAK?

                                                              You were pretty certain that the 84mm double cut file didn’t exist. This is like that. You’ve been looking at something you didn’t know existed. And are making all sorts of incorrect statements and assumptions about it.

                                                              And yes, I am able to show another knive that would prove the point just the same. But without explanation, it wouldn’t matter one bit.

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              Well, now you got me confused. Are you claiming that I'm wrong about this particular SAK having a 2.7mm Victoria-era spring or that SAKs with such springs were produced at least until 1976 (or both)?

                                                              Now I expect you to get really confused. My answers to both questions above are ‘No’.

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              I'll be extremely happy if you will ever start providing some sort of evidence to support your claims. Until then I tend to consider them as being quite questionable.

                                                              Lol. All there in the pics. Even in the crop you posted. Clear as daylight.

                                                              Found where we kinda discussed this before:

                                                              @MiniChamp said:
                                                              Hard to be certain, IMO. I do believe that transitions involving multiple parts tend to be relatively sharp. When they changed the thickness of the main blade shank from 2.7mm to 2.4mm, for example, this also involved changing the spring and the corresponding backside tool (corkscrew or Phillips SD). I think that you will never find a pre-3 variant of the backside Phillips SD on a SAK with a 2.4mm main blade shank, because they never made such variants that would fit. When a transition involves a single fully interchangeable part, however, the older parts tend to keep getting used in overlap with the new ones.

                                                              There are actually two non-interchangeable types of variant 3 of the backside Phillips SD. The first appeared towards the end of the Victoria era and has a 2.7mm shank. I expect that it was used in some overlap with both variant 2b and variant 1b (because they were all interchangeable). The second has a 2.4mm shank and was introduced along with the corresponding main blades (this should be the only square backside Phillips SD that you will find along with these newer blades).
                                                              I happen to have a similar Grand-Prix. The only difference is that mine has the older big-gap scissors. I believe it to be from "around 1973." For me this essentially means 1972-1974. I tend to be skeptical about anyone's ability to date SAKs with an error margin of less than a year (except, maybe, a small number of very special cases). Nevertheless, I'm curious how you would date the two Victoria craftsmen in the attached image (sorry about the quality). I believe them to be from "around 1973" as well. Both have the same standard-gap scissors with a black spring. The only differences are as follows: The upper one has the can-key Phillips (variant 3) and a scraper on the cap-lifter. The lower one has a file on the Phillips (variant 1b) and no scraper on the cap-lifter.

                                                              This is like the 84mm double cut file on the Philiips.

                                                              Basically, take everything you think you know, and just throw that out. Look at the auction pictures again. Pretty much prove everything you say in the above two posts to be flat out wrong. Or buy the knife and see for yourself.

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • Sterg Offline
                                                                Sterg
                                                                Posts: 79
                                                                Sterg Offline
                                                                Sterg
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #1314 Quote Reply

                                                                  Well my Elsener Zug or INOX Y D arrived today. I’m more than a little concerned that the Elsener Zug is engraved with a pen and not a stamp. If I had a keener eye I wouldn’t have bid on it. I’m hoping that someone can verify that Victorinox would have done this when they reconditioned the knife. The description on the auction said it was at Victorinox. Either that or the Zug retailer would have done that before the knife was sold. The INOX YD stamp looks legit as does the rest of the knife. The blades look reprofiled and reconditioned with a high polish. It’s smooth as glass open and closing, nickel silver liners and old looking scales. What’s everyone’s thoughts?

                                                                  F23E4E13-6398-418A-A297-52FA3826D1E3.jpeg

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • Sterg Offline
                                                                    Sterg
                                                                    Posts: 79
                                                                    Sterg Offline
                                                                    Sterg
                                                                    wrote on last edited by Sterg
                                                                    #1315 Quote Reply

                                                                      Another shot...

                                                                      BB82E836-31CB-48AC-B639-A2C2A2220083.jpeg

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • Sterg Offline
                                                                        Sterg
                                                                        Posts: 79
                                                                        Sterg Offline
                                                                        Sterg
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #1316 Quote Reply

                                                                          Here’s a shot of the stamp on the other side. This looks legit.

                                                                          F62AD190-A391-40EC-B1DF-B3AD62DDF0BE.jpeg

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • kamakiri Offline
                                                                            kamakiri
                                                                            Posts: 3,215
                                                                            kamakiri Offline
                                                                            kamakiri
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #1317 Quote Reply

                                                                              @Sterg said:
                                                                              What’s everyone’s thoughts?

                                                                              I do think you’re right that it’s engraved. I have been under the assumption that it is ‘normal’. But I do not have many knives as such and in general prefer tangs stamped with dies like the INOXYD one.

                                                                              AFAIK, It’s all legit.

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • Sterg Offline
                                                                                Sterg
                                                                                Posts: 79
                                                                                Sterg Offline
                                                                                Sterg
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #1318 Quote Reply

                                                                                  @kamakiri said:
                                                                                  I do think you’re right that it’s engraved. I have been under the assumption that it is ‘normal’. But I do not have many knives as such and in general prefer tangs stamped with dies like the INOXYD one.

                                                                                  AFAIK, It’s all legit.

                                                                                  Thanks kamakiri. The inoxyd stamp is on the same knife so I think the blade is legit also. I also prefer stamped tangs. It does look like it was rebuilt professionally so it leads me to believe Victorinox did the work.

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 64
                                                                                  • 65
                                                                                  • 66
                                                                                  • 67
                                                                                  • 68
                                                                                  • 84
                                                                                  • 85
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
                                                                                  4. Vintage SAK Owners Club
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0