Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
@jnoxyd said:
Hi Kamakiri! I think it would be great if you could share your dating of the tools, backsprings and back tools changes between 1973-1983.Best thing I can say is that I’m working on it. :D
I don’t have anything planned specifically for backsprings though. I’ve avoided somewhat writing what was supposed to be the first chapter about my philosophy and methods...which really should go first, but perhaps easiest to write last.
I also don’t want to have the issue as ulli pointed out about updates. Lack of editing ability makes posts rather final.
There is also somewhat the issue of credibility. Like in the example of the “1973” knife for sale, would I really have to point out over a dozen things to ‘show’ that it’s c.’76? I can also just ‘prove’ it’s not ‘73 with as little as the tweezer. Seriously, would that be enough?

One chapter/topic I conceptualized would be titled “Stare ‘till it hurts”. It would only contain pictures and stipulated dates...nothing else. Like the catalogs, I’m not sure how many would appreciate the topic.
I just gotta figure out what I’ll post next. Or if I’m going to do a bit more on the catalogs with the Hoffritz ones.
@jnoxyd said:
A lot of small changes have been made and you need to have a large number of samples for comparison. Not all of us have as many 1970s knives as you do, I'm sure.Yes, nobody else is this <u>stupid</u>! ;)
Sad thing is that I’m not done. Like ulli said, there’s always something new to learn.
@jnoxyd said:
Well, especially for me, please, your opinion on awl dating in the period from 1973 to 1985. Many thanks!Don’t thank me yet! I posted about awls in my intro thread covering that timeframe. Albeit with some omission errors...and yes it needs updating and refinement. It’s planned for more detail as a separate thread/chapter in my ‘70s series.

-
@Sterg said:
Well my Elsener Zug or INOX Y D arrived today. I’m more than a little concerned that the Elsener Zug is engraved with a pen and not a stamp. If I had a keener eye I wouldn’t have bid on it. I’m hoping that someone can verify that Victorinox would have done this when they reconditioned the knife. The description on the auction said it was at Victorinox. Either that or the Zug retailer would have done that before the knife was sold. The INOX YD stamp looks legit as does the rest of the knife. The blades look reprofiled and reconditioned with a high polish. It’s smooth as glass open and closing, nickel silver liners and old looking scales. What’s everyone’s thoughts?Thats a really cool knife, you dont have to be concerned about it. I dont know any victorinox knife with a lacking front tang stamp. So your knife is factory made, or the knifemaker elsener zug assembled them and engraved the knives with his name. That was common those days. Value I would estimate $50-80 $.
Dübendorfer was a small company from Bassersdorf: "The purpose of the company is gravel and concrete deliveries, building material recycling, industrial waste disposal, dump service and transport, management of real estate, trade in miniatures. "
Had a history over 100 years, that ended in 2012.I have a similar knife, but instead of inoxyd it has a victoria switzerland stainless stamp on the back.

-
@ulli said:
Thats a really cool knife, you dont have to be concerned about it. I dont know any victorinox knife with a lacking front tang stamp. So your knife is factory made, or the knifemaker elsener zug assembled them and engraved the knives with his name. That was common those days. Value I would estimate $50-80 $.
Dübendorfer was a small company from Bassersdorf: "The purpose of the company is gravel and concrete deliveries, building material recycling, industrial waste disposal, dump service and transport, management of real estate, trade in miniatures. "
Had a history over 100 years, that ended in 2012.I have a similar knife, but instead of inoxyd it has a victoria switzerland stainless stamp on the back.
Thanks for that info ulli. I put $102 dollars on the auction not expecting to win. I won. So I overpaid a little. I don’t feel too bad because I like it. I’m just learning about SAKs so I’ll chalk it up as a lesson learned. You have some nice examples.
-
Ulli, what is this pattern? Officers or a bartender/waiter?
-
@Sterg said:
Thanks for that info ulli. I put $102 dollars on the auction not expecting to win. I won. So I overpaid a little. I don’t feel too bad because I like it. I’m just learning about SAKs so I’ll chalk it up as a lesson learned. You have some nice examples.I think you paid a fair price for a knife you like. I like it too and if I didn't have one that is similar, I would have likely paid the same.
Some folks on this forum have the luxury of being in the collecting arena so long they know how often a particular knife will come up for sale/bid.
Like you, I don't have all that time/knowledge experience so I have to go with what I like. Enjoy that one in good health.

-
@FolderBeholder said:
I think you paid a fair price for a knife you like. I like it too and if I didn't have one that is similar, I would have likely paid the same.
Some folks on this forum have the luxury of being in the collecting arena so long they know how often a particular knife will come up for sale/bid.
Like you, I don't have all that time/knowledge experience so I have to go with what I like. Enjoy that one in good health.

Thank you. The knife definitely has a quality feel about it.
-
Not really sure this would help regarding the “1973” knife, but the attached pic has a comparison against two knives that are between ‘73 and ‘76. One is closer to ‘73 and the other, of course, closer to ‘76.

-
More comparison...Two Grands Prix variants one ‘73 and the other c.’74.

-
Okay...I guess the tang size and comparison doesn’t convince. 
@kamakiri said:
I can also just ‘prove’ it’s not ‘73 with as little as the tweezer. Seriously, would that be enough?
Perhaps the tweezer might. They change in between the dates in question.
The knife in question has the latter style and the scale to fit it. Makes sense?




-
So I’m guessing that the silence equals acceptance regarding the “1973” knife? The tweezer was enough proof?

Is there anyone who sees what I mean about one of the 2.7mm parts running out from the blade layer? Lots of views, but no comments.
I understand that the blade layer change alone doesn’t prove that the knife isn’t ‘73 or c.’73. But there are other tools and more importantly what I call ‘construction’ that makes the knife later. And the knife in question does not have the same construction in both parts and protocol for other Champion knives that are ‘74 and well into ‘75. So from both parts and construction/assembly the knife can not be ‘73 or c.’73.
To me, it seems to fit with Victorinox needing to take the time to figure out how or that they want to use the rest of the remaining 2.7mm parts. The solution is not unlike how knives were built when the ‘bird head’ spacers were thicker than 1mm ones used since the ‘60s.
-
Closer comparison might help see the thickness difference?

This time with the blades open. “1973” knife is on the top in both crops.


-
Not my knife, but I think a good example of a knife that I can say 100% is c.‘73 production.






-
@kamakiri said:
Not my knife, but I think a good example of a knife that I can say 100% is c.‘73 production.

Any guesses on the part that actually gives me the highest confidence regarding Chronology? And no, it’s not the clip point. That’s my only hint. These pictures are surprisingly good in that respect. Normally, I would need the knife in hand to see the needed details.
-
Obviously, 1973 was the only year they made half scissors as a cost cutting measure

-
I fail to see how a half scissors can be a cutting measure

-
Not my knife, but this is an example of another clip point that is certainly not c.’73
Notice that it doesn’t have a ‘Victoria era’ backspring like noted previously in the thread.
Note the VSSR/OS tang stamps.
I hope this is clear enough proof of what I’ve been saying.



-
Are this:

Vintage enought ?
Cheers!
Marcelo from Argentina
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
