The Cigar Thread
-
During the past few days I had a partagas P2 (my current favourite) and two Tierra Tropical (Vegas de Santiago) - small and large, solid sticks, good flavour and burn and cheap
-
RP Edge, Sumatran, best Edge I have had in a long time, closer to the original ones.
Cohiba Siglo V, really nice smooth spice, generally the bigger Cohibas taste better than the smaller ones.
-
I'm a fan of the RP Edge also. One of the few cigars I will buy a box of.

-
Smoked a few cigars the previous week, Rocky, Upmann, Vegas De Santiago etc, but the most enjoyable/memorable one was the Flor de Oliva Presidente.
I am not keen on the other Oliva brands, I do not dislike them but do not care much for them, but the Flor de Oliva has been a favourite of mine for years, especially in the bigger sizes - really good flavour, smoke and reasonably cheap (I remember when they used to be really cheap, around 2005..)
-
Smoked several during the past several days.
I enjoyed the El Rey Del Mundo Robusto Larga (not Cuban, but a solid tasty choice), and the NUB (made by Oliva, so there are two Oliva products that I would buy), especially the 560 Nub, which is too big to be a real member of the NUB line., in Habano, sweet at the beginning and strong at the end, as well as the series P, my current favourites.
-
Got some lanceros.
My father No 4
Really, really bad. This is not a cheap cigar but I had to stop smoking halfway through. Bitter.
Good burn....... -
Alec Bradley medalist Toro
I have never smoked a bad Alec Bradley, I think.
Pleasant, sweet flavour, decent smoke though not amazing -
Rocky Patel 20th anniversary Lancero.
Not bad, the first half was a bit boring but the second half was tasty and spicy
-
@dks said:
Rocky Patel 20th anniversary Lancero.Not bad, the first half was a bit boring but the second half was tasty and spicy
Ultimately, every cigar smoker should enjoy them however they wish. Personally though, I’ve never understood people only smoking a cigar half (or even just a third) of the way, and then discarding the rest. For one thing, it seems like a waste of good tobacco. For another, as you experienced with this one, sometimes the best the part of a cigar is in that second half. I always smoke mine down to the nub, unless I am rudely interrupted.
-
I am cheap. If I paid for a whole cigar I am smoking all of it. It must be really nasty for me not to nub it.
-
Tried an El Baton and a Rocky Patel 55... both smoked fine but had very little flavour. Definitely not worth the money
-
The problem with buying singles, to try expensivish cigars, is that I can only make a judgement on that single cigar. If I do not like it I just never buy it again (anything over 10 Euro)
No idea how long it has been in storage or how brilliantly it was stored.
When I buy boxes/bundles I can smoke a couple every few months, generally have an idea of how fresh they were, and wait for them to hit their peak before smoking them.
Some are best out of the box, like flor de Oliva and most Olivas, some, Cubans, need a few months and some bundles, Habanos Fuerte come to mind, take a decade.I have some RP that were OK fresh and brilliant after 5 years. RP edge, I have smoked several and bought boxes and are not as hood as they used to be, though still OK.
My comments, on singles especially, just refer to that specific cigar I smoked and to my, reasonably experienced, taste buds.
They should not discourage anybody from trying them.
-
RP Royale colosso size, pretty decent, OK flavour, definitely got more tasty in the last third, good burn.
-
San lotano requiem, Decent flavour, excellent burn, nothing exciting.
-
Rocky Patel Cameroon Juniors
A decent short smoke, good burn, no distinct flavours
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login