Alec Baldwin
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
It's called acting, right?Again, it would be wrong of me to be too judgmental about Baldwin. His role in the movie may well be in perfect harmony with his principles. The movie may have been anti-gun. However, Hollywood seems rife with those who would do one thing to get paid and say another when they want to have a certain public persona.
I think I said that I don't hold Baldwin responsible for the negligent discharge and killing--assuming he is ignorant about his props--and I don't expect him to be an expert. I do think that if someone handed me a vial of small pox, I would ask what I had to do to ensure that I didn't cause a whole new pandemic.
Yes, sure, we need bad guys in movies and actors to play those bad guys. And hopefully they do a good job and portray complex characters. But I would have a hard time with an actor who espoused a belief in human rights and then took a role in movie that promoted Neo-nazism. It is one thing to help color a historical event for everyone's education, entirely another to promote a malevolent social system for money. And I do think there is lot of TV and Film that glorifies gun use.
Without knowing what the movie was about or how the gun theme would be portrayed, I shouldn't jump to conclusions. But I can't help but notice that many actors seem to make a living promoting that which they would decry.
And I do feel sorry for Baldwin. I'm sure this event will haunt him.
(And in case there is some confusion, I'm a firearms owner.)
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
First of all, I'm wondering what good could come from this topic.This is one of the topics in which opinions tend to differ the most between one side of the Atlantic versus the other.
And I can only speak for myself, but I'm always very doubtful about sharing my opinion in such topic, since that never seems to end well, sadly enough. And on top of that, it's quite hard to do in a language that is not your own, a poor choice of words, a nuance gone wrong, and things my take a turn for the worst by one simple linguistic misunderstanding.But should fear of being bullied stand in the way of politely voicing ones opinion on something? If so, we are in more trouble than I thought..
.
Am I right to assume that an outspoken anti-gun celebrity is someone who has actively shown his doubts or concerns about gun laws, and/or screening measures for becoming a gun owner not being strict enough?And if so, why would a person who believes a modern day society should be more careful about who it allows to become a gun owner, not be able to act in a movie that's situated in another time period, when things were "different"?
So, no more Westerns, no WW1, WW2 (or any other war) movie for any actor who thinks it's weird that you can buy a firearm, but not a beer...
I guess an actor who's actively lobbying for more traffic safety shouldn't be in a movie that has a car chase in it?
If people are unable to see the difference between real life and what happens in a movie, that's one more reason to do something about gun laws I guess...
Should you expect Alec Baldwin to be a gun expert?
If so, you should also expect Denzel Washington to be able to fly a large passenger plane, Jeremy Renner to diffuse a bom, Hugh Laurie to diagnose your illness and Robert Downey Jr. to solve any mystery (or create a flying suit...)
It's called acting, right?
And "don't point your firearm at anything you don't intend to shoot"? In all other circumstances that is so true, but when trying to create a realistic gun fight on the big screen... That's the same as saying you should never use your handbrake while driving your car, also very true, except when you're participating in the WRC Rally of Monte Carlo...
Mr. Baldwin is an actor, not a gun expert, that's why they (movie studios) employ someone to make sure all the weapons are safe for their intended use, this person is getting paid for just that, making sure each gun is safe to be used by someone who has absolutely no gun training whatsoever.
If he pointed the gun on the victim as a bad joke, that's stupid, very VERY stupid... But in the end, still the responsabilty of the person in charge of gun safety on the set, he (or she in this case, if the info I read is correct) should assume that every person on the set is a complete idiot and act accordingly, that's her job, that's what she's paid for...
And to be clear, I'm not an anti-gun nut. As I've told here in the past, if I lived on the other side of the Atlantic, I would most likely be a gun owner as well. But over here, it's simply not worth the hassle. And with life being as expensive as it is over here these days, one has to make choices (so I went for a Gibson Les Paul, that I can enjoy every day, without having to jump through all the hoops 😉).
Too many rules or restrictions can be a pain, but not enough rules or restrictions can also be a problem. There has to be a golden mean...
Just my 2 cents, as always.
You made some interesting points but your post is replete with misconceptions and inaccuracies.I'll do my best to answer some of your questions and correct any misconceptions.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Am I right to assume that an outspoken anti-gun celebrity is someone who has actively shown his doubts or concerns about gun laws, and/or screening measures for becoming a gun owner not being strict enough?Our Constitution ensconces the right to own firearms in our Second Amendment. "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." A militia is all able bodied men in every village,town and state.
In order to change the Constitution there would need to be 3/4 of all states to vote for that change.
In order to buy a handgun in this nation you need to be 21 years of age, fill out the proper paperwork,provide proper identification and wait for the FBI to check all local,state and federal law enforcement agencies to determine that you are not a criminal.
Baldwin has shown utter disdain for private ownership of firearms as he and other elites hire armed body guards for their own personal protection.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
And if so, why would a person who believes a modern day society should be more careful about who it allows to become a gun owner, not be able to act in a movie that's situated in another time period, when things were "different"?No one really cares what he does for a living but criticizing law abiding citizens for exercising their Constitution rights,while hiring body guards, is the height of elitism and hypocrisy.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
So, no more Westerns, no WW1, WW2 (or any other war) movie for any actor who thinks it's weird that you can buy a firearm, but not a beer...I guess an actor who's actively lobbying for more traffic safety shouldn't be in a movie that has a car chase in it?
If people are unable to see the difference between real life and what happens in a movie, that's one more reason to do something about gun laws I guess...
I don't know how you drew these erroneous conclusions from the comments so far.No one is suggesting any such actions.We are,however,pointing out his hypocrisy when he makes films using firearms.If he really believed in what he espouses,he might have a moral imperative to avoid films where firearms are used.Apparently money trumps any such objections.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Should you expect Alec Baldwin to be a gun expert?We should expect this man to have used common sense gun safety procedures and he did not.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
If so, you should also expect Denzel Washington to be able to fly a large passenger plane, Jeremy Renner to diffuse a bom, Hugh Laurie to diagnose your illness and Robert Downey Jr. to solve any mystery (or create a flying suit...)This statement is nothing more than a strawman argument.No answer is needed.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Mr. Baldwin is an actor, not a gun expert, that's why they (movie studios) employ someone to make sure all the weapons are safe for their intended use, this person is getting paid for just that, making sure each gun is safe to be used by someone who has absolutely no gun training whatsoever.Again,anyone with a modicum of common sense and concern for other human beings would have employed basic gun safety.Baldwin possesses none of these attributes as he has proven,many times,that he is an elite.Unfortunately a woman had to die because of his arrogance and stupidity.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
If he pointed the gun on the victim as a bad joke, that's stupid, very VERY stupid... But in the end, still the responsabilty of the person in charge of gun safety on the set, he (or she in this case, if the info I read is correct) should assume that every person on the set is a complete idiot and act accordingly, that's her job, that's what she's paid for...Once again,the ultimate responsibility lies with the person who cocked the hammer and pulled the trigger while pointing the muzzle at another person.
@Top-Gear-24 said:
And to be clear, I'm not an anti-gun nut. As I've told here in the past, if I lived on the other side of the Atlantic, I would most likely be a gun owner as well. But over here, it's simply not worth the hassle. And with life being as expensive as it is over here these days, one has to make choices (so I went for a Gibson Les Paul, that I can enjoy every day, without having to jump through all the hoops 😉).Too many rules or restrictions can be a pain, but not enough rules or restrictions can also be a problem. There has to be a golden mean...This is exactly the strategy the members of the ruling class are attempting,that is,make it so difficult that some citizens give up in despair.We have thousands of gun controls laws on the books at local,state and the federal level.We don't need more but we do need for the existing laws to be vigorously enforced.
Thanks for insightful post.I hope I have cleared up misconceptions about our nation and our founding documents,as well as any notion there aren't enough laws concerning firearms.
PS: Law abiding,gun owning citizens of this nation, thwart anywhere from one half million to two million crimes every year.
-
@Nix said:
...
I do think that if someone handed be a vial of small pox, I would ask what I had to do to ensure that I didn't cause a whole new pandemic.
...If someone you hired to make sure everything goes safe, handed you a vial with a label saying small pox, but ensuring you it contains water, you shouldn't have to worry about it in my opinion.
If you went on and poored that vial into someone's coffee, you're an a** for sure, but not a killer. If you follow the script and drop it as it said in the script, you're totally free of blame in my opinion.
I'm a gun enthusiast myself, with a healthy dose of respect for any type of weapon.
Because of my interest in them, I've taken the time and effort to learn the basics about them, like learn how to check and make sure they are not loaded, and "safe" to handle. Even though I don't own any guns myself.
Should actors do the same? Probably, but they rather hire someone instead of learning the basics themselves. Is this laziness, stupidity, a bit of both? In my opinion yes, yes it is.
Is it illegal? I bet that hiring a gun expert to make sure everything is safe, is very legal, and that this person is the one who will, rightfully, gets a sh*t storm of questions about this tragedy.
Edit after reading Toolguy's post:
I'm not here to change your Constitution, or take away your right to own firearms, that is of no interest to me, and certainly not my battle.
But a well regulated militia? Let's not kid ourselves, for every well regulated militia there are 10 groups who shouldn't be allowed to own a nail gun (which also needs proper training and safety measures, just to be clear).
And we can't deny the fact that, if we compare numbers, your side of the Atlantic scores a bit worse when it comes to gun related incidents.
You can patronize me all you want (yes, I know the tone), but the facts are there. Yes, we had our share of terrorist attacks here (I will not get into the origin of these terrorist organisations, or this topic goes out of control in a heartbeat), but should we have a look at school shootings, or gun related incidents between family members?
And the way people who have another point of view get treated in these discussions is always the same, patronized, ridiculed, and mostly being called ignorant, just as Toolguy's answer showed, once again.
If I was a celebrity speaking out about gun laws, in a country containing such a large group of gun carrying people with such a fanatical point of view about it, I would hire bodyguards as well, that's not being a hypocrite, that's just common sense where I come from.
Anyway, it's not my intention to chance anything in this matter, but if you can hit me with your "truth", I can do the same.
And there will probably be (NRA sponsored) studies that show this or that, but frankly, I'm done here...
We've got enough problems over here for me to fight, rising taxes, the hollowing out of our awesome social system, the rise of extreme right political parties... so what happens over on your side should actually be of no concern to me.
That's me signing off for this topic.
Best of luck
. -
I like Mr. Baldwin. I really do feel sorry for him. I feel more sorry for the victim however. If one believes in justice, then it will run its course, and figure out what happened, when, and with whom.
Now can we get back to talking about multi-tools?
-
@Chako said:
I like Mr. Baldwin. I really do feel sorry for him. I feel more sorry for the victim however. If one believes in justice, then it will run its course, and figure out what happened, when, and with whom.It will be interesting to see how that plays out.
Most accidents involve a chain of events and decisions that lead to the bad outcome. Already there are suggestions of negligence by multiple parties. While no one party might be fully culpable, in the end a woman was killed. Justice.....hmmmm...how many times do we suspect there is a "fall guy" who takes the blame for a group cluster-foul-up?
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
If someone you hired to make sure everything goes safe, handed you a vial with a label saying small pox, but ensuring you it contains water, you shouldn't have to worry about it in my opinion.I know you've signed off, but I'll respond anyway.
I'm not sure it is quite that clear cut.
If you handed me a weapon and said, "it's safe" I would check anyway. (This actually happened two days ago. I was in the sporting goods store and was handed a pistol that was "safe", I checked anyway. Because that what I was taught.)
Now, Baldwin doesn't seem like a firearms enthusiast. So, should we expect him to be able to check that the firearm he is handed is "safe"?
Maybe. He does this for a living. He probably does have some responsibility to know when a weapon is safe. He should insist on learning this.
But let's say that we should not have that expectation. We should expect that he relies on experts for all his decisions. OK. Isn't it fair to ask if he double checked with the expert? Could he have asked, "I don't how to be sure. Can you show me right now that it is safe?" That doesn't sound unreasonable to me.
Anyway, this is all speculation, in hindsight, without the facts. So I'll shut up, too. ;)
-
I'm not here to change your Constitution, or take away your right to own firearms, that is of no interest to me, and certainly not my battle.
But a well regulated militia? Let's not kid ourselves, for every well regulated militia there are 10 groups who shouldn't be allowed to own a nail gun (which also needs proper training and safety measures, just to be clear).
Our Constitution is the law of the land.As stated a "well regulated militia is every able bodied man in every village,town and city.The law decides who can own a firearm and I don't care who you think who should own a nail gun.And we can't deny the fact that, if we compare numbers, your side of the Atlantic scores a bit worse when it comes to gun related incidents.
**You don't know anything about crime in my country.Fifty percent of the murders are committed by one minority group who comprise 13% of our population.Most of their weapons are stolen and beyond the reach of gun laws.
**
You can patronize me all you want (yes, I know the tone), but the facts are there. Yes, we had our share of terrorist attacks here (I will not get into the origin of these terrorist organizations, or this topic goes out of control in a heartbeat), but should we have a look at school shootings, or gun related incidents between family members?
You must have special powers when you claim to recognize something that doesn't exist.I didn't mention any terrorist attacks,you did.
Once again blaming crime on an inanimate object is foolhardy at best.Place the blame where it belongs,on the criminals who commit these acts.And the way people who have another point of view get treated in these discussions is always the same, patronized, ridiculed, and mostly being called ignorant, just as Toolguy's answer showed, once again.
When truth and logic is used then small minded people resort to name calling.Pointing out the ignorance of some members statements is nothing more than being honest.Call it what you will but name calling it is not.If I was a celebrity speaking out about gun laws, in a country containing such a large group of gun carrying people with such a fanatical point of view about it, I would hire bodyguards as well, that's not being a hypocrite, that's just common sense where I come from.
**I'm glad you don't live here because we don't view law abiding citizens as "fanatical".No one has ever threatened Baldwin,so your supercilious claim is not common sense, it's nothing but a pathetic attempt at slandering legal firearm owners.
**
Anyway, it's not my intention to chance anything in this matter, but if you can hit me with your "truth", I can do the same.
**You haven't spoken truth yet just false claims and suppositions that I've proven are false.
**
And there will probably be (NRA sponsored) studies that show this or that, but frankly, I'm done here...
**The NRA was formed post Reconstruction to ensure the second amendments rights of its citizens.I'm glad you're done.Unfortunately you were done before you started this diatribe couched as a post.Your attack on one of the few national organizations that work endlessly to thwart the fanaticism of people who want to end the personal gun ownership our of citizens are what we've come to expect from Communists in this country..Theses same people want only the military and police to possess weapons.We,in this nation,call, that a police state. **We've got enough problems over here for me to fight, rising taxes, the hollowing out of our awesome social system, the rise of extreme right political parties... so what happens over on your side should actually be of no concern to me.
**Good,get to fighting those extreme right wingers.LOL
**
That's me signing off for this topic.Best of luck
.
[/quote] -
Absent the surfacing of some pretty conclusive evidence to the contrary, I’m going to assume this was a tragic accident, albeit one that could have been prevented were it not for the negligence and incompetence of multiple people.
One life lost, others forever impacted. I’ve never agreed with Mr. Baldwin’s politics, and he may have acted foolishly, but I’m sure the result wasn’t what he intended, and I take no joy in seeing him in this situation now.
If there is any silver lining in this, perhaps it will be that it may prompt a serious review of (and new standards for) how firearms and ammunition are handled on movie sets, and what training, qualifications, and experience are required for armorers and others.
-
@cbl51 said:
And this was NOT an accidental discharge. A single action revolver has to be manually cocked to be ready to fire.Exactly. It was a negligent discharge.
I did some digging in an attempt to determine exactly what sort of firearms they were using. While my efforts to get that information were not successful, I learned a little more about the incident and the chain of circumstances and events leading up to it. Apparently the armorer questioned her qualifications for the job, but accepted it anyway. I don't doubt for a nanosecond that an investigative team will find that every link in the aforementioned chain was weak.
-
@Farmer X said:
I did some digging in an attempt to determine exactly what sort of firearms they were using. While my efforts to get that information were not successful, I learned a little more about the incident and the chain of circumstances and events leading up to it.I've seen reports that it was a Colt Dragoon model, which I understand is black power, wadding and ball rammed from the forward end, and a percussion cap on the back. Not exactly easy to accidentally load ***that ***live...
However, the reports further assert that the set weapons were also being used off-set for recreational target shooting between takes. If true, that would explain how a live round ended up being loaded in an on-set weapon.As for the responsibility - Some films will not allow actors to mess with certain safety-related things, even if they do know what they're doing, because there is a dedicated 'expert' on set whose sole job (and legal responsibility) it is to do those checks.
I wouldn't trust an actor to do this stuff anyway, as they'll be too focussed on their methods and getting into their zones to properly do the various safety checks on guns and cars and blades and whatever else. -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Come on guys, we can get through a topic like this without name calling...I think you may have set the tone there Grant:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I think that there is a chain of responsibility that goes beyond a Prima Donna trained monkey.@Grant Lamontagne said:
... someone I think is just another Hollywood phony wind bag.Do you really feel sorry for him? Or are you enjoying the irony? Most of your posts put him down in some way.
Are you just throwing a dead cat on the table and letting others be your attack dogs because you don't have the guts to say what you really want to?I hope not, I would be very disappointed if this was the case. And embarrassed as a member of MTO.
-
If we can't keep it civil I will have to be forced to lock this one. We hardly if ever lock them but the tone of this from many have not been what we expect from MTO

If any of you think about posting something else that isn't with our normally friendly tone then please go away for a bit and come back when you aren't posting as emotionally

Also no politics, we do not have many rules and I know anything gun related can be for political but again this is one of our few rules

Remember over all that this is a tragedy that will likely scar some individuals and changed some persons family no matter the outcome of the arguments and we need to respect that as well

-
@toolguy said:
I'm not here to change your Constitution, or take away your right to own firearms, that is of no interest to me, and certainly not my battle.But a well regulated militia? Let's not kid ourselves, for every well regulated militia there are 10 groups who shouldn't be allowed to own a nail gun (which also needs proper training and safety measures, just to be clear).
Our Constitution is the law of the land.As stated a "well regulated militia is every able bodied man in every village,town and city.The law decides who can own a firearm and I don't care who you think who should own a nail gun.And we can't deny the fact that, if we compare numbers, your side of the Atlantic scores a bit worse when it comes to gun related incidents.
**You don't know anything about crime in my country.Fifty percent of the murders are committed by one minority group who comprise 13% of our population.Most of their weapons are stolen and beyond the reach of gun laws.
**
You can patronize me all you want (yes, I know the tone), but the facts are there. Yes, we had our share of terrorist attacks here (I will not get into the origin of these terrorist organizations, or this topic goes out of control in a heartbeat), but should we have a look at school shootings, or gun related incidents between family members?
You must have special powers when you claim to recognize something that doesn't exist.I didn't mention any terrorist attacks,you did.
Once again blaming crime on an inanimate object is foolhardy at best.Place the blame where it belongs,on the criminals who commit these acts.And the way people who have another point of view get treated in these discussions is always the same, patronized, ridiculed, and mostly being called ignorant, just as Toolguy's answer showed, once again.
When truth and logic is used then small minded people resort to name calling.Pointing out the ignorance of some members statements is nothing more than being honest.Call it what you will but name calling it is not.If I was a celebrity speaking out about gun laws, in a country containing such a large group of gun carrying people with such a fanatical point of view about it, I would hire bodyguards as well, that's not being a hypocrite, that's just common sense where I come from.
**I'm glad you don't live here because we don't view law abiding citizens as "fanatical".No one has ever threatened Baldwin,so your supercilious claim is not common sense, it's nothing but a pathetic attempt at slandering legal firearm owners.
**
Anyway, it's not my intention to chance anything in this matter, but if you can hit me with your "truth", I can do the same.
**You haven't spoken truth yet just false claims and suppositions that I've proven are false.
**
And there will probably be (NRA sponsored) studies that show this or that, but frankly, I'm done here...
**The NRA was formed post Reconstruction to ensure the second amendments rights of its citizens.I'm glad you're done.Unfortunately you were done before you started this diatribe couched as a post.Your attack on one of the few national organizations that work endlessly to thwart the fanaticism of people who want to end the personal gun ownership our of citizens are what we've come to expect from Communists in this country..Theses same people want only the military and police to possess weapons.We,in this nation,call, that a police state. **We've got enough problems over here for me to fight, rising taxes, the hollowing out of our awesome social system, the rise of extreme right political parties... so what happens over on your side should actually be of no concern to me.
**Good,get to fighting those extreme right wingers.LOL
**
That's me signing off for this topic.Best of luck
.I believe you lost sight at the beginning that TG was not against gun ownership.
Attack on The NRA? All I see is an implicit doubt that any NRA studies/findings would be objective. That seems to me to be reasonable. There are a great many "facts" that are presented by people/groups across the political spectrum that become suspect when examined in full instead of the narrow viewpoint in which they are presented.
To me, TG was asking some reasonable questions for someone who does not live in the US. Certainly there was no diatribe on his part.
-
@Poncho65 said:
If we can't keep it civil I will have to be forced to lock this one. We hardly if ever lock them but the tone of this from many have not been what we expect from MTO
If any of you think about posting something else that isn't with our normally friendly tone then please go away for a bit and come back when you aren't posting as emotionally

Also no politics, we do not have many rules and I know anything gun related can be for political but again this is one of our few rules

Remember over all that this is a tragedy that will likely scar some individuals and changed some persons family no matter the outcome of the arguments and we need to respect that as well



Besides, we should save our vitriol for those who deserve it:
Tennessee hillbillies -
Exactly ::) :D
-
Liking or using guns is a world wide hobby and this is an international forum, so opinions here will vary more than if this was a US based/owned forum. Opinions are given based on members' experience and not just based on the internal US politics. Many of us here own several guns, personal, or as part of being in the military. Others do not see the need for guns and do not have any interest in them. It is allowed.
For all we know this event may end up making gun ownership stricter, in some countries, rather than just increasing gun safety in films.
Had to post here :)
-
@Fuzzbucket said:
The only explanation I can think of, is that historical firearms were sourced in a rushed haphazard manner by Props and then somehow weren't examined by the Armourer. It sounds like a chaotic set.@Tasky said:
I've seen reports that it was a Colt Dragoon model, which I understand is black power, wadding and ball rammed from the forward end, and a percussion cap on the back. Not exactly easy to accidentally load ***that ***live...
**However, the reports further assert that the set weapons were also being used off-set for recreational target shooting between takes. If true, that would explain how a live round ended up being loaded in an on-set weapon. **As for the responsibility - Some films will not allow actors to mess with certain safety-related things, even if they do know what they're doing, because there is a dedicated 'expert' on set whose sole job (and legal responsibility) it is to do those checks.
I wouldn't trust an actor to do this stuff anyway, as they'll be too focussed on their methods and getting into their zones to properly do the various safety checks on guns and cars and blades and whatever else.That
. This to me is the only scenario that seems plausible to me explaining the presence of a live round on set... Malicious intent aside that is. -
I should have said personal attacks or name calling will not be tolerated from anyone period.
@Poncho65 said:
If we can't keep it civil I will have to be forced to lock this one. We hardly if ever lock them but the tone of this from many have not been what we expect from MTO
If any of you think about posting something else that isn't with our normally friendly tone then please go away for a bit and come back when you aren't posting as emotionally

Also no politics, we do not have many rules and I know anything gun related can be for political but again this is one of our few rules

Remember over all that this is a tragedy that will likely scar some individuals and changed some persons family no matter the outcome of the arguments and we need to respect that as well


-
@Fuzzbucket said:
And Brickies, I can't stand Brickies.They are the worst aren't they

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login