First Pliers-Based Multi-Tool?
-
The more I look at all these suggestions, the more I'm thinking a pocket clip would be a must for me.
So, non-humongous with pocket clip - Curl, Bond, Skeletool, etc. I like that there's a ratcheting driver attachment that can work with some of the models too. Not that I would be likely to carry one with me but I could tuck it away in a convenient drawer/bag/etc.
-
My thinking on this is evolving as the thread goes on here...

But it occurs to me that the knife blade is probably the least important aspect to me of a multi-tool of this type since I'll virtually always have a SAK on or near me as well. I don't think I've really seen blade-less ones though.
-
There is a bladeless Rebar and there was a bladeless Fuse

The choice gets harder the more options that are considered

I did make my suggestions based more on the home owner/dad stuff comment

The Ratchet Driver is an excellent addition along with a LM bit kit

-
@Poncho65 said:
I did make my suggestions based more on the home owner/dad stuff comment
The Ratchet Driver is an excellent addition along with a LM bit kit

Your suggestion of the Curl is currently winning me over, actually. I'm likely to get much more use out of it in "home owner/dad" mode than I am doing IT work. A lot of that is via software/virtualized these days and when it's not, I've got specialized tools close by.
My main motivation to try out something like a Leatherman is an unplanned need for pliers, etc. My Deluxe Tinker has very nice pliers, for what they are, but they are much more "super tweezers" than they are pliers, really.
Speaking of which, no one has suggested a Gerber, SOG, or.... whatever else there is out there. Is Leatherman the top of the heap when it comes to quality?
-
I’m a fan of lightweight PBMT’s and also usually pair them with a SAK
Obviously this all comes down to personal preference but ultimate lightweight is Skeletool with a very different blade to a SAK, so not redundant IMO.
For something that’s got a bit of everything I like the Rebar and also agree with the suggestion of a Bond or PST, but Rebar gives you that bit more for very little extra weight
A second hand Juice (I like CS4 best) also a great choice

-
It’s already been said but Bond or Skeletool are both good lightweight pliers based tools with a pocket clip and ratchet drive compatibility.
If you are willing to add just a little bit of weight the Wave or Charge bring more to the table and are very good tools.
-
So, I’ve been spending some time researching the great suggestions you all have made and, uh…
I think the question is not which one I should buy. It’s more which one should I buy first. :D
You know, for science reasons.
-
That's the spirit! My suggestion is make a list of the functions you want, or don't want, then search for the multitools that match your listed functions. If you don't need a wood saw, for example, then you can save weight by getting a tool that doesn't have a wood saw.

-
That's a good suggestion.
My requirements for a PBMT are actually pretty minimal. I want good pliers and phillips driver(s) that are better than the average SAK (the SAKs with in-line phillips drivers are fairly large, the 2D phillips/can opener and Tinker-style back phillips have well known limitations, etc.).
Otherwise, I'm not too fussed about what the other tools are. Especially since I don't intend for a PBMT to be the only tool in my pocket or anything.
This flexibility makes decisions easier in some ways, but harder in other ways. For example, how many extra tools (adding to bulk/weight) that I'm not super likely to use do I want to carry around? I'm not sure. I find the Skeletool pretty attractive for its minimalism, but it also has the smallest pliers of any non-keychain tool Leatherman makes. If they were more substantial I would probably buy it... I think.

My other source of some uncertainty is the bit exchanger situation. In some ways that's pretty cool. But... Leatherman (not sure about other brands) uses a proprietary size/shape for their bits. I'm not sure how excited I am about being "stuck" in a non-standard, proprietary system like that. Maybe it's not that big of a deal? I'm new to these tools, so I don't really know. Obviously, some models don't have the bit exchanger, so there's that to consider.
There are other things that are just total "unknowns" for me. Like, whether I want outside opening tools or tools that are only on the inside of the pliers handles. I know that I don't particularly care about one-hand opening stuff one way or the other (I wouldn't use SAKs if I did...). But as far as tools on the inside versus the outside of a tool goes, well, I have no idea!
Don't mind me - I'm just overthinking things as usual!
-
Overthinking things is why we are all here.
As far as the proprietary bits that only matters for the actual exchanger. If you have the regular or ratchet extension you can use regular 1/4” bits.
Still feel like the Bond would be great for you. The combination of solid first gen Pliers and 3D Phillips in a simple package.
-
I recommend Bond or Rebar also Victorinox Spirit is an option but more expensive than Bond/Rebar.
Only Tools Matters
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Overthinking things is why we are all here.As far as the proprietary bits that only matters for the actual exchanger. If you have the regular or ratchet extension you can use regular 1/4” bits.
Still feel like the Bond would be great for you. The combination of solid first gen Pliers and 3D Phillips in a simple package.
Wait... the Bond has a 3D Phillips? How did I miss that?!?
Hmmm.... I guess what you give up with the Bond is the ability to use the ratcheting bit driver but... I could live with that.
-
@marlowe221 said:
There are other things that are just total "unknowns" for me. Like, whether I want outside opening tools or tools that are only on the inside of the pliers handles. I know that I don't particularly care about one-hand opening stuff one way or the other (I wouldn't use SAKs if I did...). But as far as tools on the inside versus the outside of a tool goes, well, I have no idea!All other things being equal, what I would call outside opening tools (i.e. tools that are exposed when the MT is in the closed/folded position) are much quicker to use than inside opening tools (i.e. tools that are hidden inside the handles when the MT is in the closed/folded position).
This is because the process is shorter…
To use outside opening tools:
- Draw MT
- Open desired tool
- Use tool
- Close tool
- Replace MT
To use inside opening tools:
- Draw MT
- Open MT
- Open desired tool
- Close MT
- Use tool
- Open MT
- Close tool
- Close MT
- Replace MT
So if speed is a consideration (either because you want to able to deploy the tool quickly in an emergency, or because you will use it frequently and the time saved on each use will add up), then outside opening is the way to go. If you only access those tools occasionally and you’re not concerned about quick emergency access, then outside vs. inside opening tools probably isn’t much of a factor for you either way.
-
@marlowe221 said:
Wait... the Bond has a 3D Phillips? How did I miss that?!?Hmmm.... I guess what you give up with the Bond is the ability to use the ratcheting bit driver but... I could live with that.
They do sell an adapter for the 3D Phillips that makes it a 1/4 inch driver and that will allow you to still use the ratchet driver
;) -
This is the LM Bit Adapter
It is shown here with a ST300 but works with all the square shank 3D Phillips by Leatherman and on a few others that aren't actually designed for it either 

It comes in regular stainless as well as the black oxide that is featured here

-
Vic Spirit X. I've carried one for work for the last 10+ years. Inbetween, tried a LM Wave, LM Rebar and Gerber MP400, but keep going back to the Vic.
-
How do you do it :ahhh I can never get along with the Spirit and when I try, I am always glad to go back to something else and to not be carrying it :ahhh

-
@Poncho65 said:
How do you do it :ahhh I can never get along with the Spirit and when I try, I am always glad to go back to something else and to not be carrying it :ahhh
Wait wut?
The Spirit is my favorite stand-alone tool. The outside opening, tool selection and build quality. What is it that you don’t get along with?
-
@marlowe221 said:
Wait... the Bond has a 3D Phillips? How did I miss that?!?Hmmm.... I guess what you give up with the Bond is the ability to use the ratcheting bit driver but... I could live with that.
Also lose locking tools if that matters to you.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Wait wut?The Spirit is my favorite stand-alone tool. The outside opening, tool selection and build quality. What is it that you don’t get along with?
Just doesn't feel as good to use and I really can't seem to tell that the build quality is as superb as everyone says

If I was going MT only then I would either go with a Charge or a Rebar with added scissors

And why couldn't the Spirit have the regular SAK scissors like a Swisstool does
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login