*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
@BPRoberts said:
I want to reiterate my desire for Case to expand the “47” size line for Trappers and other patterns. The conventional wisdom that a 3ish inch blade on a 4ish inch handle is ideal for a pocket knife is correct. Small/light enough to disappear in the pocket, handle easily, and be nonthreatening (and not count as a “knife” for a lot of legal purposes) and large enough to get the job done. I don’t think Case has anything else in their lineup at this size, and it’s a shame.I don't recall if you own a Copperhead, but the frame is the same length as the 47, with a slightly longer main blade.
-
I think this is my 5th Challenge-inspired purchase. This time there isn't an individual to "blame"... this one goes out to all of you that posted yellow Cases. The yellow handles have such a classic look, you awl made me want one in my collection
Thanks a lot
and thanks a lot 

Yellow Trapper, good combo there.
-
Day 30
Really enjoyed this challenge.
Plan to add a Traditional to all my carry set ups. A joy to use and just have on hand.
Here is a picture of the other side of my stag GEC.

-
GECs are something else, aren't they? -
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Just a fun pic. My No. 12 and No. 8.That No. 12 is massive!

@NutSAK said:
It seems that many of us have these and respect them, the #18.
I sure am glad I decided not to get rid of mine!@Rich_SD said:
[The yellow handles have such a classic look, you awl made me want one in my collection
Thanks a lot
and thanks a lot 
You are most welcome!

An astonishing collection!

@GA1dad said:
The Dean51 Traditional Challenge ( Case Badge )
I'm gonna close out this challenge with one of my favorites,, a cigar jack. So light and easy in the pocket today.
@BPRoberts said:
I want to reiterate my desire for Case to expand the “47” size line for Trappers and other patterns.They seem to have locked the Muskrat, which was on the 47 frame, in the vault. If so, that was (in my opinion) a bad move.
An update for the giveaway is again in order. If your username is in bold, I have seen your Day 30 post. Most everyone got theirs in before I did!
1. SteveCOpted out
2. Barry RowlandOpted out
3. LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
4. NutSAK (Case badge)Opted out
5. nate j - GEC badge
6. Adam5 - Case badge
7. Sos24 - Case badge
8. MTSAK - Case Badge
9. comis - Case Badge
10. David
11. GA1dad - Case Badge
12. Alan K. - Case Badge
13. Gareth - Case Badge
14. BPRoberts - Case Badge
15. HarleyXJGuy - Case Badge
16. SAK Guynot participating in challenge (?)
17. Farmer X - Case badgeIneligible / Eligible for Canoe
18. Rich_SD - Case BadgeOpted out
19. MichaelGT83 - Case Badge
20. McStitchy
21. RF52Day 30
Since yellow synthetic seemed rather popular in this challenge, here's a double shot of it. More thoughts (and a little bonus) coming tomorrow.
[attach id=0 msg=2432011]

-
Catching up from the weekend trip to the cabin.
Day 29:
I had to work the dad magic and get all of our junk loaded into the Suburban in the morning. We got on the road and then stopped for lunch and a few groceries. So we didn't end up getting to the cabin until late afternoon. Luckily, the pond wasn't covered in scum and weeds, and the kids didn't take long to want to go fishing. My 4yo son was able to catch his first fish totally on his own. And it happened to be a 17.5" Brook Trout! Beat my personal best by almost 4"! Then my 6yo
daughter caught her first totally on her own as well! We had to keep them to have for dinner when we got home. The Copperhead made quick work of cleaning them back at the cabin. We ended up being the only ones at the cabin this evening because everyone else got delayed until Saturday.
-
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







-
Day 30
My two GECs used for this challenge.
Overall, they are perfectly capable pocket knives, and both exhibit the near flawless F&F GEC is known for. However, I’m really looking forward to carrying and using some of my other knives after two months of challenges. And, as the rust spots on the JOTS attest, stainless steel pocket knives are really a better fit for me than carbon steel.
Many thanks to NutSAK and Farmer X for the generous GAWs, but please consider me opted out. Don’t tell my wife I admitted this (and I’m positive it won’t stop me from buying more), but frankly I have too many knives to be able to carry any but a relative few favorites. Would love to see the GAW knives go to folks who will really use them.
Thanks for a fun challenge, all!


-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







Looks like a great time was had by all!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







Oh man, that looks like an awesome trip.

-
Now that the Case challenge is over, I'm going to enjoy some of my other trads for a while. Starting with this "Foreign" made penknife. The knapped, stone blade is less pocket friendly. ;)

-

Nice photo!

-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







Awesome!

-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







Outstanding!
-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.







That sure looks like a great weekend!
And good catch with those fish (fishes?)
Sent fra min M2002J9G via Tapatalk
-
@MTSAK said:
Day 30
We had a blast at the cabin. My kids played with their cousins and are totally worn out. I got the tent tore down and everything loaded before it got hot. The fishing was amazing. We never caught a Brookie under 14". Wylie's ended up being the biggest that we measured. Made a pit stop at my parents' to stay the night again so we didn't have to drive 6 hours home. Got cleaned up and visited all evening. Forgot to take a picture earlier, so I snapped a quick picture and my usual edc lately. Not for my own personal use, though [emoji28] I've included a few other photos from the weekend as well.Great pictures and an awesome time by the looks of it !
-
@MTSAK said:
Catching up from the weekend trip to the cabin.
Day 29:
I had to work the dad magic and get all of our junk loaded into the Suburban in the morning. We got on the road and then stopped for lunch and a few groceries. So we didn't end up getting to the cabin until late afternoon. Luckily, the pond wasn't covered in scum and weeds, and the kids didn't take long to want to go fishing. My 4yo son was able to catch his first fish totally on his own. And it happened to be a 17.5" Brook Trout! Beat my personal best by almost 4"! Then my 6yo
daughter caught her first totally on her own as well! We had to keep them to have for dinner when we got home. The Copperhead made quick work of cleaning them back at the cabin. We ended up being the only ones at the cabin this evening because everyone else got delayed until Saturday.
Looks like a great trip. Congrats to the kids (and you) on the catches!
-
I can see why. The setting looks like Heaven on earth to me!

@nate j said:
Many thanks to NutSAK and Farmer X for the generous GAWs, but please consider me opted out. Don’t tell my wife I admitted this (and I’m positive it won’t stop me from buying more), but frankly I have too many knives to be able to carry any but a relative few favorites.You're opted out. I'll touch on the "too many knives" thing in a subsequent post.
@Gareth said:
The knapped, stone blade is less pocket friendly. ;)That's definitely a sheath carry. :D Very cool!
And here is the updated giveaway eligibility list. Just waiting on Sos24 to post a Day 30 photo.
1. SteveCOpted out
2. Barry RowlandOpted out
3. LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
4. NutSAK (Case badge)Opted out
5. nate j - GEC badgeOpted out
6. Adam5 - Case badge
7. Sos24 - Case badge
8. MTSAK - Case Badge
9. comis - Case Badge
10. David
11. GA1dad - Case Badge
12. Alan K. - Case Badge
13. Gareth - Case Badge
14. BPRoberts - Case Badge
15. HarleyXJGuy - Case Badge
16. SAK Guynot participating in challenge (?)
17. Farmer X - Case badgeIneligible / Eligible for Canoe
18. Rich_SD - Case BadgeOpted out
19. MichaelGT83 - Case Badge
20. McStitchy
21. RF52Edit: thanks to whomever awarded me the badge!
A bonus entry is still forthcoming, some time after my phone's battery charges fully.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login