Argument at Zuckercorp
-
@BPRoberts said:
I agree that I think of LMs as more "rough and tumble" than Vic, but I will awlso point out that Vic has much better corrosion resistance....farm equipment grease, oil, etc means corrosion is taken care of :D
-
Here hold my beer!
Both are good, but nothing is perfect.

-
This is the kind of back and forth I also see on Reddit. I like the “on drugs” part. I must be on drugs then

I like how here at MTO everyone just gives and honest opinion about their experience without the drama. And we get the bonus doggy or old car pics in the threads.
Someone ought to make a hybrid of the Wave and Spirit. That’s what I could really use.
-
Perspective. It's all relevant. A humble SAK is, even down here, more acceptable than a Charge, with its oho blade with that pointy tip.
There are other categories of comparison to consider. Compactness, price, needs, toolset. Quality of course. Victorinox is synonym with quality for me. Even second hand SAKs are perfectly acceptable. Some of my Leatherman tools, even brand new, had some issues here and there.
I am a fan of both, though. I normally carry a Manager on my keys, a Deluxe Tinker in my pocket, and a Rebar in my pouch, and I carry other LM tools, including my Charge AL and G10 on occasion. Lots of tools are just fine for edc. I'm carrying mainly Roxon for this month's challenge. -
There is time and place for both tools.
Charge has better blade steel, its smaller than SwissTool, has Diamond file and Bit Drivers, replaceable cutters, needle nose pliers, Serrated blade (all SwissTool models doesnt have it)
SwissTool is larger pliers, all tools accessibility on outside, better scissors ( all models doesnt have scissors), combotool, stronger flatheads what can be used on prying (not recommended), Awl.
Also maybe one of most important thing that SwissTool has over Charge, it doesnt bite you when squeezing

Only Tools Matters
-
You are right Antti, but it doesn't say Swiss tool, it says any Victorinox and that makes a huge difference. The Spirit, for example, addresses many of your comments.
I have many Charges, and many more Victorinox products and I would refer you all to my thoughts on my very first Charge, the XTi way back when:
/topic/1513
TL:DR version- I wasn't impressed by the unnecessary tool duplication and the fact that you paid a premium for a tool that eats itself.

You paid extra for the titanium handles that:
A- were not structural, so provided no strength benefits
B- did not cover much and so didn't offer any corrosion protection
C- was only a small portion of the tool and so there was no weight reduction benefits
D- would get ground away every time you opened and closed the file.From that perspective, the Wave is the better choice.
Def
-
I don't like rust, so I avoid Leatherman.
Victorinox Spirit, ftw
-
Oh dear. One of the reasons I’m not on Facebook anymore to be fair. Was in a few groups but people get very passionate which is great. It’s when it comes with anger
-
@Antti Lammi said:
There is time and place for both tools.Charge has better blade steel, its smaller than SwissTool, has Diamond file and Bit Drivers, replaceable cutters, needle nose pliers, Serrated blade (all SwissTool models doesnt have it)
SwissTool is larger pliers, all tools accessibility on outside, better scissors ( all models doesnt have scissors), combotool, stronger flatheads what can be used on prying (not recommended), Awl.
**Also maybe one of most important thing that SwissTool has over Charge, it doesnt bite you when squeezing
**

Only Tools Matters
This, more than any other reason, is why I no longer own a Wave (or any other LM with the same design). Literally bit me twice so hard to give me a massive blood blister. Despite the reputation I've never managed that with any Gerber or Vic.
However my preferences in no way invalid or supersede anyone else's.
-
I can only parrot the sentiment already said. both have their place, their positives and negatives. all I can say is that I'm sorry I missed the G10 Charges
-
@G-Dizzle said:
I trust Leatherman more in adverse contions because the tools are easier to open. The nail nicks on my Victorinox Spirit can be difficult. I think the tight tolerances actually hurt it in that respect. In an office environment it is fine, just don’t want to get in a position when I can’t open the tool I want in the cold/rain/etc.Other than that, the fit and finish and quality on the Vic is better than leatherman, and I like the tools as much or better. I think the vic is a better tool overall. Just can be hard to open at times.
This is interesting, and different than my experience. I find the spirit's tools easier to open, with the possible exception of LM's OHO blades (I've not yet tried one of the OHO spirit models). Every LM I've had, the inside tools were nail breakers to open. I also did not like the regular swisstool as it was hard to get to the nail nicks. The spirit's curved handles addresses that issue for me.
Glad we all have different options available to suit our needs!
-
Perhaps I was an odd exception to the rule, but I carried several different PB multis and SAKs during my two deployments, and I never had any issues with corrosion. All those tools were exposed to salty ocean air. On the other hand, a feeler gauge in the Power Plants shop rusted pretty badly, and had to be replaced. I don't think it ever saw any use.
-
@Farmer X said:
Perhaps I was an odd exception to the rule, but I carried several different PB multis and SAKs during my two deployments, and I never had any issues with corrosion. All those tools were exposed to salty ocean air. On the other hand, a feeler gauge in the Power Plants shop rusted pretty badly, and had to be replaced. I don't think it ever saw any use.There must be a lot of variability in LM tools. I now have a couple I use in all sorts of conditions wet, sweat, mud, and grease, and do not clean them really ever… no rust.
-
I've never had any rust on any of my Leatherman's' and I've carried one since the early 1990's.
-
@gustophersmob said:
This is interesting, and different than my experience. I find the spirit's tools easier to open, with the possible exception of LM's OHO blades (I've not yet tried one of the OHO spirit models). Every LM I've had, the inside tools were nail breakers to open. I also did not like the regular swisstool as it was hard to get to the nail nicks. The spirit's curved handles addresses that issue for me.Glad we all have different options available to suit our needs!
It could be my tool specifically, or that it doesn’t get enough use. It did not use to be like this, it got tighter over time. May need a good cleaning, although I have oiled it multiple times trying to help it.
-
Just about every Leatherman I have owned has developed rust- normally just small spots, but one went really badly.

/topic/37952
Def
-
Must just be the poutine because I don't drink coffee!
I make up for it with twice as much poutine though....
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





