Argument at Zuckercorp
-
@SteveC said:
I've never had any rust on any of my Leatherman's' and I've carried one since the early 1990's.My original Leatherman Supertool from the 90s is great. it's been used hard. I've left it out in the rain, it lives in a drafty uninsulated garage, it's rarely oiled..and not a speck or rust on it. I wish current LMs were like that..
It could be worse though.. it could be a Gerber.
-
I've never had a significant rust problem with LM, nor do I find the Vic Spirit particularly slippy when wet. :D
-
Comparison photos incoming
1




-
2




-
3




-
4


-
The Charge is much thicker/chunkier than the Wave and the Victorinox Spirit X.
The pliers on the two leatherman models both open significantly wider than the Vic. The Vic’s pliers have a positive “click” upon opening and are free moving. Opening both Leatherman pliers feel mushy and require a bit of effort to open and close once deployed.
The Charge blade is s30v and OHO, so is more premium than the Vic and Rebar. There is nothing wrong with either the vic or rebar blades, however. They will both be easier to sharpen than the Charge. Since the rebar is a closed construction, you will have to use the blades with the tool half open to take full advantage of the blade length.
The Charge serrated blade has a gut hook/seatbelt cutter. The Rebar is a standard sheepsfoot serrated blade. This Vic does not have a serrated blade. You can get models that do. I personally enjoy a serrated blade, but I know many people don’t care for them. A Spyderco Sharpmaker is the best way that I have found to sharpen serrations.
The saws on all three models are serviceable. The Vic saw feels a little smaller in use, but is a Victorinox saw. It will have great bite.
The Charge file is diamond on one side and cut on the other. The diamond portion is a nice touch. The cut portion does not seem as sharp as either the Vic or the Rebar, possibly from use. The Rebar has the most aggressive file on the flat sides. The Victorinox has the more agressive sawing edge. However, the Vic’s file is thicker, meaning that the rebar may still do a better job of “sawing” with the file.
Drivers: The Charge has a large and small bit driver and a thin/wide flat head. The Rebar and Vic have dedicated drivers. I have found that dedicated phillips and flat head drivers are far superior than a bit driver, IF the screws that you are working with fit. The leatherman adds more versatility if you carry a bit kit. If not, the Vic/Rebar drivers are better. Between the two, the rebar may grab better because it is less polished, but the Vic drivers are great.
Prying: Vic wins with the extremely thick bottle opener. The Rebar/Charge are serviceable
Can openers: they are all fine. They open cans. The leatherman offerings incorporate a wire stripper, but the Vic has an answer for that coming later.
Scissors: The rebar has none. The Vic scissors do not open very wide, but cut well. They are somewhat small. The Charge scissors open as wide as you would like, but are also small.
Awl: the Vic awl incorporates a hook but has no sewing hole. The Rebar awl has no hook but has a sewing hole. I think I would take the sewing hole over the hook if given the choice. The Vic awl is thinner than the Rebar. The Charge does not have an awl.
Vic’s extra cutting tool: Victorinox incorporated a chisel/box opener, wire stripper into the Spirit model. This is a great tool for all the things you don’t want to use your blade on. This is executed very well and is way better than the wire stripper on the leatherman models IMO.
The Charge has a little rust, but it doesn’t really bother me. It’s a tool.
Overall, I think the Vic is the highest quality tool with the best design and most functional implements, the Charge is the most convenient tool with the best materials, and the Rebar is the most rugged tool. If the Rebar had scissors, it would be a candidate for best multitool on the market in my opinion. I like the closed design, but others will not. I normally carry a dedicated OHO folder, so I don’t feel like my MT has to have one. If I did not, I would feel otherwise. I also feel that the Rebar is the most forgiving as far as opening the smaller tools. I haven’t had it stick on me to my memory.
All three are great tools, and I could carry any of them as my primary MT and be fine. If I were carrying just a MT and no other knife, it would be the Charge. When I want to carry a premium MT with arguably the most functional implements, it would be the Victorinox Spirit X. When I want simplicity and the enclosed feature, I carry the Rebar.
-
Rusty Spirit
.jpg)
.jpg)
-
Since we have no idea what this Spirit went through to get to this state, this means very little to be honest.
As many others here I own my fair share of multitools from different brands, and my tools are all stored in the exact same way, at the exact same location. And I know I have to check my Leatherman collection at least twice a year to make sure they are still fine, using a special little brush to remove any little brown dots that may have formed, and oiling them up again.
Never had to do this with my Victorinox Collection, I used to check them at the same time when I checked my Leatherman tools, but now I find myself only checking them once every 2 or 3 years or so, and I never found any rust on them anyway. Does this mean they don't rust? No, they do.
I bought an old, heavily used Swisstool which was so dirty that I left it in a bucket of water with some soap, hoping to soak the dirt of, but I forgot to take it out and about 3 or 4 days later, when I finally took it out, part of the water was gone and the Swisstool had been exposed to water and air, and it had developed rust, especially around the pivots, and on the ribbed pieces used to unlock the tools. It did come of, but yes, they do rust.
Do I believe Leatherman tools to be inferior to Victorinox tools? No, in fact, I've been carrying my Wave + for a couple of years now as daily carry, along with my Swisschamp. Why these two? Well, together they cover just about everything I come across, and more importent, both were purchased locally and are still available at the same shop, so dealing with warranty, or even replacing them would be very easy to do.
I absolutely love the BO Charge Plus I bought on Ebay USA (I actually bought two, with the help from a member here ;)), but replacing that one over here would be quite impossible, so I choose wisely when to carry it, and when not to carry it.
I believe we are spoiled with so many capable tools, so much that we can actually nit-pick on every weak point they might have, even though each tool could deal with 99% of the stuff we throw at them.
When I go hiking and it might get humid and wet, I carry a Spirit or Swisstool (mostly because they are quite rust resistant, and they don't have any loose parts, like bits or mini screwdrivers that could get lost). I carry them along with my Swisschamp, and when the hike is remote enough, I'll throw in my stainless Mora Garberg.
When I have to do some chores around the house/garden, the Supertool 300 is by far my favorite, followed by the Surge.
Oh, and compared to my Tops Knives Tanimboca Puukko fixed blade in 1095 steel, Leatherman tools are very rust resistant. I swear I've seen that Tanimboca Puukko rust while just looking at it (yet I absolutely love it, I just need to grease it up regularly :D).
Apologies for my long, incoherent rambling...
-
Appears to be. It’s not a big deal, it’s not rusting out. Some leathermans seem to be less corrosion resistant than Victorinox. Steel with a bead blast finish is going to attract rust in my experience. I polished a Cold Steel Espada that was bead blasted because I couldn’t have it in my pocket without it rusting.
-
@G-Dizzle said:
Appears to be. It’s not a big deal, it’s not rusting out. Some leathermans seem to be less corrosion resistant than Victorinox. Steel with a bead blast finish is going to attract rust in my experience. I polished a Cold Steel Espada that was bead blasted because I couldn’t have it in my pocket without it rusting.boom. nailed it.
-
The original statement seems to disregard that a critical feature of multi-tools is exactly weight and volume, and that is a gradual thing. To make a pointed point you could just as easily say that except for weight and volume a multi-tool can't compare to a set of dedicated tools.
I usually prefer a SAK when I don't need a plier simply because I can carry it in any pocket without issue. The same can't be said for the big Leathermans or Victorinox Spirit or Swisstool. I would also give tool finish/ quality check as a plus for Victorinox, but that is just based on the products I got from both.
-
It's one thing to have a preference.
It's another to belittle others for their preference.
Unless they prefer Schrade. Then it's okay to judge them harshly.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
It's one thing to have a preference.It's another to belittle others for their preference.
Unless they prefer Schrade. Then it's okay to judge them harshly.
Def
hey wait… 
I’ve been going back and forth between a Spirit and Wave for my outdoor work this past week. It really is a matter of preference. And, I keep thinking I prefer a Spirit!
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
It's one thing to have a preference.It's another to belittle others for their preference.
Unless they prefer Schrade. Then it's okay to judge them harshly.
Def

Both are great quality tools and have their benefits.
I love the Spirit for a combination of ergonomics, all tools being accessible from outside, and the chisel tool.That being said I can recognize that most Leatherman seem to be better for hard use and better knife blades.
-
Most of you have never had to field repair a leaky old tractor and it shows.

When I was evaluating the Vic Spirit for farm EDC, I was battling algae in fuel tank (side note: Biodiesel can be quite plague-y). Pull the line, isolate the plug, blow the line (cans of compressed air are a lifesaver) and put it all back together.
That super shiny Vic finish is so slick with a bit of diesel on it, that it made it quite a chore to tighten hose clamps and tighten bolts. Add to that, trying to open the nail nicks for the drivers, and you have an unnecessary frustration. The rougher finish on a Charge is much more forgiving and the bit drivers are easier to deploy with slippery fingers
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




