MTO Tool Project
-
Hey everyone, this thread needs to be kept out of the public eye so I'm putting it here in the No Life Club. There are going to be some ideas (hopefully) below that could be quite steal-able, and honestly I'd rather we didn't design new stuff for the big guys anymore since they don't like to give us credit.

In short, I think it's high time we started on a project I have been putting off for many years, mostly because to proceed it needed three things that I did not have:
1- A computer capable of handling 3D design software
2- A 3D printer for prototyping
3- Enough skill to start trying to design something worthwhile.In the immortal words of Meatloaf, two out of three ain't bad. I have been working on some preliminary designs for our very own, in house Multitool.org Multitool. I am not a designer, and I am still very much a novice. I'm learning as I am going, and open to any suggestions that anyone has, either in the design itself or in the methods used to get there!
Oh, and I am using Fusion 360.
As you can see, I am at very early stages, trying to refine a plier head- as I speak, the latest iteration is still being cranked out on the 3D printer, but here are the ones I have already been working on. The evolution is chronological from left to right.
The far left one wasn't my first attempt, it was my first in the right scale (don't ask- I didn't measure first and made some VERY small plier heads
) and featured an attempt at removable cutters. It also didn't feature enough clearance in the hinge to open the jaw, which made it very difficult to use.The second one had better clearance and worked quite nicely. Once I had a head that could actually function I realized that the hinge holes for the handles needed to be cut down a bit, which brings us to the third iteration. I decided to start cutting away some excess material to lighten it and maybe make an area for the handles to lock into.
At this point the head was 1 cm thick, and I decided that was a bit too big, so for the next version (the one with the handles) I thinned it down to 8mm thick instead of ten, and also changed the replaceable cutter slot with an anvil style cutter. It was at this point when I attached the handles I have also been working on that I realized the handle hinge pins were a mile apart, and so I started from scratch with the next version, which as you can see, took on a very different shape.
For Number 5 I put the hinge pins a lot closer together, and tried a completely new head design. Internally I referred to the original four head designs as the Dinosaur heads as they kind of remind me of a dinosaur and I kind of like that idea. I can't say as I like it too much, as I believe it is way too small. They also don't really leave a lot of room for the handles, so I started fresh again.
The plier head on the right is very heavily influenced by the SwissTool, which is one of my favorite folding multitool heads. I like it well enough, but I am working on getting all the parts I want into it, while going back a bit to the earlier, more distinctive Dinosaur style shape- perhaps a SwissTool/Dinosaur hybrid?
I'll keep adding to this thread as I develop the idea, but I am very interested in what everyone else has to say. I have some features that (I think) are different from what is out there already, and some ideas that take advantage of some of the good ideas that are out there.... but I still want input from everyone else. This site was built on the strength of it's community, and I want the signature MTO Tool to reflect that as well!
Also, start thinking of a name for it- I have some ideas, but I doubt our Marketing Department would approve.... you know, if they existed!

Def

-
Grant's been showing his work with me as he dips his toes in the multitool designing area. I think we have a lot of promise in a MTO designed multitool and it would make the masses go crazy. We've been in the background for the past few years and we are coming out swinging. I'm willing to call who I need to in order to keep us relevant. I'm seeing how much work this is and it's a lot. But I feel we can rival what competition there is and show people what we are capable of.
-
Great to see that there are plans!

Plier heads are a heavy part of a multitool, so it pays to optimize for weight. A key to that is knowing what forces and knocks it will have to endure at various places, and what features really need to be in which places. The material choice and how it is manufactured will also give some guides and limitations for the design. Once you know that one can do topological optimization to find physical designs that meets all the requirements for the least material/ weight. It is not uncommon to reduce the weight quite substantially. (Same can be done with any other part too of course, but less important for lesser weight parts).
I'm feeling a bit uneasy reading this thread in case we have overlapping ideas. Any way to block me from it? (I wouldn't want anyone to think I ripped any ideas from here).
Edit: Many pliers have a non-round joint and a pivot somewhat asymmetrically placed. In part to bring the plier and in particular the cutting action closer to the pivot, and in part to save weight.
-
I love this idea. Impressive progress too and reminds me of the Leatherman prototype pics.
I have absolutely no machining or 3D printing skills to help there, but will keep checking back to offer design thoughts.
I like the most recent pliers head design. It’s in the right direction. I recently found the larger pliers area on the Spirit was a bit better than a Wave. 5 teeth compared to 4, so that might be something consider. Wave needle nose are a bit better than the Spirit having a deeper groove and more narrow.
Super exciting!

-
@Vidar said:
I'm feeling a bit uneasy reading this thread in case we have overlapping ideas. Any way to block me from it? (I wouldn't want anyone to think I ripped any ideas from here).PM sent. I will refrain from posting anything else for now.... not that there has been a lot of development since yesterday!

Def
-
Def, I'm not even close to being an engineer but I'm excited to see what you're doing!!

-
There are two things I would like to see on a plier based multi. First, I wish there was a set of pliers with a slip joint. The pliers on the multis now are really rather limited. You can do things with a slip joint plier that you could not do with a multi.
Second, I wish someone would make the plier heads lock to the handles when they are open. If anyone has ever tried to cut some tough wire or rope with a multi and had it wedge the jaws shut or partially shut, they know what I am talking about. Pulling the handles apart doesn't open the plier jaws. You have to let the multi hang there while you go fetch something to pry the jaws loose. A latch would fix that. Best wishes. G -
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Def, I'm not even close to being an engineer but I'm excited to see what you're doing!!

I am close to several engineers, and trust me, you aren't missing much!

Def
-
@IMR4198 said:
Second, I wish someone would make the plier heads lock to the handles when they are open. If anyone has ever tried to cut some tough wire or rope with a multi and had it wedge the jaws shut or partially shut, they know what I am talking about. Pulling the handles apart doesn't open the plier jaws. You have to let the multi hang there while you go fetch something to pry the jaws loose. A latch would fix that. Best wishes. GThis is specifically one of the things I want to address. Whether I will be able to progress to a skill level that allows me to do something like that or not is a completely different story.
In the meantime, try SOG's Compound Leverage handles. They work well in reverse too.

Besides, everyone needs a PowerLock! It should be one of the basic rules of MTO!

Def
-
-
-
I am not an engineer or a designer either, because I firmly believe that knowing what you are doing takes all the fun out of something!

The toothed, rounded bit on the plier head is called the Pipe Grip and honestly, I was finding it a bit too difficult to figure out how to design, so I figured I would try this instead. It should work well enough for gripping larger things (apologies to any plumbers we may have here!) like pipes, but also hold bits as you say. It took a few tries to get it sized properly, but I got there in the end.
I am also opting for more of a blunt nosed plier rather than the ersatz needle nose design of so many other multitools. I honestly kind of hate the half assed needle nose design of most multitools. You probably know this story, but others may not.
Years ago I was off roading with some friends in my old Jeep TJ when the wiring on my starter came loose. The only tool I had with me was a Leatherman Blast and so I went to work trying to tighten the nuts holding the wires on. The issue was that the needle nose on the plier was just long enough to touch the opposite contact, and given that I had a very limited area in which to move the Blast, it meant that I had to turn it about 1/8 of a turn before having to reset, and at the end of each turn I hit the other contact and got a shock.
Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap.
I must have done it about 50 times, and at no point was it pleasant.
So, the needle Nose must go.....
Although yes, I do see the irony that my blunt nose is almost the same length.

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I am not an engineer or a designer either, because I firmly believe that knowing what you are doing takes all the fun out of something!
The toothed, rounded bit on the plier head is called the Pipe Grip and honestly, I was finding it a bit too difficult to figure out how to design, so I figured I would try this instead. It should work well enough for gripping larger things (apologies to any plumbers we may have here!) like pipes, but also hold bits as you say. It took a few tries to get it sized properly, but I got there in the end.
I am also opting for more of a blunt nosed plier rather than the ersatz needle nose design of so many other multitools. I honestly kind of hate the half assed needle nose design of most multitools. You probably know this story, but others may not.
Years ago I was off roading with some friends in my old Jeep TJ when the wiring on my starter came loose. The only tool I had with me was a Leatherman Blast and so I went to work trying to tighten the nuts holding the wires on. The issue was that the needle nose on the plier was just long enough to touch the opposite contact, and given that I had a very limited area in which to move the Blast, it meant that I had to turn it about 1/8 of a turn before having to reset, and at the end of each turn I hit the other contact and got a shock.
Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap. Crank, zap.
I must have done it about 50 times, and at no point was it pleasant.
So, the needle Nose must go.....
Although yes, I do see the irony that my blunt nose is almost the same length.

Def
I don’t think I had heard that story before! It’s kind of humorous now. Probably was not at the time.
Without firsthand experience, it would seem that a LM Crunch style plierhead would be the best for wrenching out of all MTs. I can’t say for sure though because I didn’t get a crunch when they were available
. -
Not as much as you’d think, because the handles require a lot of space to lock the head on, and I didn’t have anywhere near that level of clearance.
What I needed was a wrench, which would have required a lot less space for its own handle, which would have allowed for more tightening on each turn (less cranks) and wouldn’t have been touching the other contact.
Unfortunately there aren’t any decent Multitool wrenches readily available (although e SpydeRench may have been a contender) so since then I have always carried a wrench roll and ratchet set in my Jeep.
Def
-
The first post in this thread shows the wrench roll and ratchet set I usually carry in my Jeep.
/topic/74233
Def
-
I used to carry a large metal toolbox in my old truck. I believe that I had almost enough that I needed in an emergency. Must have weighed a hundred pounds.
6 vehicles later all my tools are carried in a 15 inch tool bag and weighs in at less than 20. Heaviest thing I have these days is a stubby bottle jack.I can relate to the blunt nose vs the needle nose issue.
MT makers add them to their tools to increase the tool count. -
I wonder how swapping to blunt nose would effect the room available for tools on a butterfly design. I know on the sliders that they can fit in the handle better, which is nice. Would that make it easier to make, for example, a longer screwdriver on a butterfly?
-
At this point my bluntnose is about the same length as the ersatz needlenoses, so I may have to come around on that. Or shorten the pipe gripper, cutters or flat gripping area.
But yes, less space wasted on the plier head equals more space for other things.

Def
-
...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login