SAK-A-Like / Off Brand Challenge - September
-
Day 3 of 30
Today decided to take Armbar, opened few letters with blade and used scissors to trim my fingernails but gotta admit armbar scissors aint good for it.
[attach id=0 msg=2542785]

-
Gary, I've had good luck with the "Reserve" Rough Ryders, but only so so with the "regular" ones. While they're kissing cousins, I think the Marbles are a bit nicer than most Rough Ryders.
-
Day 3
The blue half Scout (Camillus) strike out will be carried again today, because I like it.
Was it a prototype? Or, a custom employee built with extra parts?
Oh well I like it.And, I included with it my first SAK-a-like classic. An employer recognition award from 1975, my 2nd year, for some special accomplishment. My name is engraved on the other side. I pocket toted this for many a year and opened envelopes, boxes, and other packages as well as freeing toys from packages for kiddos that arrived after ‘75, as that was year the promise I publicly made to my new bride, wow 50 years ago!
[attach id=0 msg=2542788]

-
I think everything I had was a Rough Rider with an I in Rider. I did have Marbles. That was a good paracord job on the Buck. It improved the looks of that thing a lot. Probably the feel in hand also. Best wishes. G

-
I used to see Camillus and Kabar knives with the tang stamps defaced or removed. Most were just ground off with a grinder. All of the emblems were pried off the handles (if they had any). My cousin had a bunch. I am reluctant to tell anyone just how many he had, because nobody would believe me. They are all rejects. Sometimes it is easy to tell why they were rejected, and sometimes it is hard to say. I couldn't see anything wrong with lots of them, other than being filthy.
The Camillus you have looks a lot like a Cub knife. The World Scouts have their knives that same purple color. It could have been a World Scouts knife that never got the blade stamp or emblem. Just a guess.
Best wishes. G
:( -
Pretty much describes this example
[attach id=0 msg=2542793]
[attach id=1 msg=2542793]
[attach id=2 msg=2542793]


-
I haven't run into one struck out like that before. Very interesting.
-
The pictures for Day1 (un)
Et voila: First : my todays EDC (Swizza S09, Vic Swisstool Spirit X, Vic Minichamp
Second what I did whit the Swizza:
Oh and i did also use this Rimer things to open a Pack of Dymo Label Writer Labels..

-
Day 3
used the scissors on the Armbar Slim Cut to open a snack at work.

-
Day 3: A good blade and fantastic lockup! Great turnout everyone!

-
Day 4???
You move to OZ of New Zealand? -
@nate j said:
Day 2The Gerber Armbar Slim Drive (henceforth GASD) on cigar duty.
Thus far:
I give the concept an “A”. The idea of a fairly slim, light, and compact tool that contains a blade and some decent screwdrivers (in this case, a bit driver with a single bit that is flat on one end and Phillips on the other), plus the obligatory bottle opener of course, is a good one.
I give the execution a “C”. F&F isn’t terrible, but not on par with Vic standards.
The blade is supposed to be OHO (my example is quite stiff, but may loosen up with use) and features a liner lock. I also don’t like coated blades and don’t feel the wharncliffe blade shape is the best option for general EDC, but these last two are really personal preference.
The bit driver strongly retains the bit thanks to what appears to be a rare earth magnet; good job by Gerber on this, as nothing ruins the experience of a tool with removable bits faster than bits that fall out/get lost. The bit driver is also pretty well centered in the tool, which makes it much more pleasant to use than MTs with offset drivers. A second bit with some different tips might have been nice, but I’m betting the included double-ended bit will handle the majority of screws most folks will encounter.
One oversight, IMO, is that the bit driver does not lock open. I would much rather have a blade that doesn’t lock and a screwdriver that does (e.g. TL-29) than a blade that locks and a screwdriver that doesn’t (as the GASD has).
I haven’t tried the bottle opener, but as this is possibly the easiest tool to build of any commonly found on MTs, I’m willing to assume it opens bottles. I don’t like the tool opening mechanism though; apparently, the only way to open it is by applying pressure to the ridges on the back of the tool. There is no nail nick or other more positive means of opening that I can see. Like the blade, the bottle opener on my example is quite stiff, but may loosen with use.
Overall, I think most users (including yours truly) would be better served by spending the extra $10 for a Vic Explorer.
Nice write-up on your assessment so far. I'm using a Gerber Armbar Slim Cut (GASC) for the challenge, so I might as well volley some thoughts back at you.
I've had varying luck with using the one hand opening on the blade, but I must admit I like having the option. I like it much better than the OHO method on the Vic Trekker because theres no worry that if I lose my grip, the blade snaps back on me. It's not smooth by any means, but if you think of it like a friction folder (which it basically is) then you can get on with the idea a little easier. I'll admit it ends up being a two handed operation sometimes - especially when disengaging the lock. But so far i'm enjoying the capability.
As for the blade shape, I do like this sheepsfoot quite a bit theres definitely an advantage of having the tip angled downward instead of forward for some tasks.
Now then - before this challenge started, I was searching online for another contender for a SAK similar - and I noticed that other brands that have locking tools do not put a lock on the bit driver. That lead me to think - could it be that the tang of the bit driver does not lend itself to a locking mechanism as easy as the tang of other more 2-D tools? Maybe. At least thats the thought I had once I noticed the same issue with other tools.
-
Here I found a pic of the off brand sak the kid got me,,
JR
-
Day 3
So I got bored at work... and now it cuts a lot better.Also added a spare fob I had hanging around.
One thing to note is the bale is short and tight so it rubs on the scales when pushed to the back of the knife..jpg)
-
Great job everyone!
<u>Day 3</u>
Brought out the Pradel from it's hibernation. It's mostly a shelf queen but figured I'd give it a few days worth of use.
I used the can opener in an unintended fashion. It worked perfectly to peel off the edge of the registration sticker on our SUV. Also used the blade to cut open some allergy med for my son. Need to see if I can find a tin can tomorrow to try out the can opener. I may use work gloves when operating the can opener based on previous experience.


-
@ElevenBlade said:
Nice write-up on your assessment so far. I'm using a Gerber Armbar Slim Cut (GASC) for the challenge, so I might as well volley some thoughts back at you.I've had varying luck with using the one hand opening on the blade, but I must admit I like having the option. I like it much better than the OHO method on the Vic Trekker because theres no worry that if I lose my grip, the blade snaps back on me. It's not smooth by any means, but if you think of it like a friction folder (which it basically is) then you can get on with the idea a little easier. I'll admit it ends up being a two handed operation sometimes - especially when disengaging the lock. But so far i'm enjoying the capability.
As for the blade shape, I do like this sheepsfoot quite a bit theres definitely an advantage of having the tip angled downward instead of forward for some tasks.
Now then - before this challenge started, I was searching online for another contender for a SAK similar - and I noticed that other brands that have locking tools do not put a lock on the bit driver. That lead me to think - could it be that the tang of the bit driver does not lend itself to a locking mechanism as easy as the tang of other more 2-D tools? Maybe. At least thats the thought I had once I noticed the same issue with other tools.
EB!I can get mine to OHO, but it’s not a quick process, and I have to push so hard that I’m a bit concerned I’ll fillet my thumb if it slips. Just not very well done IMO, though like I said, maybe will loosen with enough use.
With regard to blades locking and bit drivers not locking, the cynic in me says it’s faulty safety nanny logic: Closing a blade on one’s fingers could cause significant injury, while closing a bit driver on one’s fingers is unlikely to. Therefore, the blade gets a lock and the bit driver doesn’t.
Of course, this ignores the facts that a folding knife (even without a lock) will never close on one’s fingers if used properly, while a properly used bit driver might fold in use without a lock. -
Day 3
LionSteel Jack 2
M390 steel, Ti bolsters, and this version has G-10 slabs

-
I have an Armbar Scout and several electrician's knives. (One is a Camillus with an X deeply gouged into the tang stamp.) At least one of the electrician's knives will make an appearance.
Day 3
My Swiza is actually a D04. Here it is with its blade in the open position.
[attach id=0 msg=2542850]
And here I am exerting pressure on its cross.
[attach id=1 msg=2542850]
Pushing the cross disengages what is essentially a liner lock. My initial thought was that such a setup is gimmicky, but I do suppose it is a little safer than a straight liner lock. Are these modern knives with "button locks" employing a similar setup?
(I'll save my thoughts on the various locking mechanisms for a future post.)[attach id=2 msg=2542850]
For those tempted by a Swiza, this may give you pause: Knife Center sells a new D04 for $61. That's twice what they sell a Tinker for, and a few bucks more than a Picnicker. My preliminary assessment is that you'd have to really like the shape, the sorta rubbery scales, and/or the supposed dishwasher safety to justify such a price premium.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

