Silly question
-
My trusty old Tilley hat is on it's last legs and needs to be retired. Tilley says that when the hat wears out, let them know and they will replace it, free. There is a Tilley dealer within two miles of my house, and across the road from where my wife works, so that's not a problem. This is in fact my second Tilley, as I've already worn one out. I average 4-5 years before needing to replace them.
My question is, I have worn this hat for 4-5 years, and it's a replacement for the original that I bought a decade ago. So, should I just get a replacement as per the "warranty" or should I consider it money well spent and buy a new one? Tilleys aren't the cheapest hats out there, but I think over ten years- hell, even over five years!- they don't owe me anything.
And, my first one was white, my second was grey. Should I stick with grey or go back to white?
Def
-
i say, if you feel like it was money well spent you buy another one, that way you will be supporting the guys that delivered you such a great product

IMHO
-
I didn't know they had a warranty like that.
I'm not allowed to have one (wife says I look like an idiot with one).
Buy a new one and get the worn out one replaced, then you'd have one of each colour.
-
Keep it. As said above you get to support the company plus if you keep it every time you look at it you'll remember all the fun you had in it.
-
LOL! they have one of the best warranties out there, even if you lose it, they will replace 1/2 the cost of a new one

that being said, they are not suppose to wear out! I mean of course everything wears out but I'm a little shocked
Grant's hat doesn't last/look longer, even wilderness people say it lasts! maybe the boss rolls with the swine! :D
(not counting us)I say have them replace it, it's what they brag about and what we all want from a good maker, lifetime service, and
like you said, they ain't cheap!how did your white one hold up to dirt and stuff? I like grey a lot but I'd go with my environment and what kind
of dirt gets on it and go with that, you have experience now so you know best ;) -
@Black Rose said:
I didn't know they had a warranty like that.I'm not allowed to have one (wife says I look like an idiot with one).
Buy a new one and get the worn out one replaced, then you'd have one of each colour.
That sounds like the perfect answer to me.

-
Don't they let you keep the original one for 'sentimental' reasons as well as replacing it?
I actually thought that they let you have a replacement at half price - but that might be different in Canada as they are made there.
Whatever you do, consider one of the new hemp hats which look ace, or get a Khaki one as that's what all the cool people have ;)

-
See, now that's the great thing- when you get your worn out one replaced, they use a permanent market to put a giant "R" inside the crown of the old one, and you walk away with it and a new one. Either way, you keep the old one too.
I don't mind buying anew one, but I think that there's probably $1.00 worth of materials and maybe $3.00 worth of labor and I spent $60 or so on the hat- which means I spent $56.00 on the piece of mind knowing it would be replaced. I suppose you could say I pre-purchased hats for the rest of my life!
Looking at it that way, it kind of rankles my Scottish genes to go and pay for another lifetime's worth of hats when I haven't even finished the life I'm in! :D
Def
-
The way I see it is that companies will only offer these warranties if it's worth their while.....
I woudl claim what was rightfully mine.
-
That's the hat? That's pretty much exactly the kind of hat for which I've been looking. XD
Just not the price. :o
-
You get to keep the old hat? That's some warranty. :o In that case just get it replaced.
BTW at what point do you/they reckon the old one is worn out enough to be replaced?
-
Worth every penny and then some Sazabi....
Tell me any other article of clothing that can survive repeated trips through and elephant's guts and has been proven and I'll be impressed!
*"Elephant trainer Michael Hackenberger of the Bowmanville (Ontario) Zoo, had his Tilley Hat snatched from his head and eaten by an elephant. Three times. Michael later would find and pick up his Hat, wash it thoroughly, and wear it. He had declined to accept a new Tilley Hat in order that we may have his well-traveled Tilley for our museum. (We were secretly pleased!)" Alex Tilley, Ontario
"In the spring of 1991, I bought my Tilley in Waterton Park. For eight months I enjoyed it thoroughly. Then someone broke into my truck and took fishing gear and my dear Tilley Hat. In September 2001, I had a call from a railroad worker who said he had found my Hat in a rail car. My name and phone number were still in the Hat. Too bad this Hat can't talk. Like the proverbial cat, this Tilley came back." Don Fraser, Alberta
"My husband was going fishing. He put one foot on the edge of the boat and one foot on the dock, did the splits and went into the water. He was going down for the third time, when his brother came down the hill, saw the floating Tilley Hat, then saw his brother's hand. He ran, jumped in and pushed him up. Thanks to the Tilley Hat I still have my husband." Cecile Nöel, Ontario
"Never thought I would ever spend over $60 on a cotton hat. Also, never thought I would be writing you a letter telling you how glad I am that I did. It is absolutely the most comfortable and effective sun hat I have ever had. First, it is comfortable; second, the wide brims bent down in front and back shield both my eyes in front and my neck in back. Alex Tilley did a good job designing it." William F. Homer, Illinois
"During a recent trip to Tanzania I encountered a local gentleman who approached me wearing a Tilley Hat, but upside down on his head. When I suggested to him that it might be better the other way up, he replied: But my dear fellow, I'm not wearing it. I'm carrying it." David Francis, United Kingdom
"One of our customers described to me the following: A friend of mine was walking alone along a beach in Jamaica, wearing a Tilley Hat. Approaching him came a woman also wearing a Tilley Hat. 'It was the entrée to a glorious week-long affair' he told me." Alex Tilley, Ontario
"Best darn fishing Hat I've ever had (in over 40 years of fishing)! Would rather lose a fish than part with my venerable old Hat." Bill Wong, Ontario
"It's the best damn sailing hat in the entire world!" Yachting Know-it-all, Donald M. Street
"The Tilley Hat has lent me a subtle air of insouciance and élan which has hitherto eluded me." Johathan Willetts, Connecticut
"Since wearing the Tilley Hat, I've lost three strokes off my handicap." Harry Mannis, Toronto
"I was robbed of my autographed Tilley Hat at gunpoint... I must say that other than fearing for my life, I was extremely upset in losing my new hat... please send me a new 7-5/8 ASAP." Bob Chapman, Idaho*
Def
-
@Gareth said:
You get to keep the old hat? That's some warranty. :o In that case just get it replaced.BTW at what point do you/they reckon the old one is worn out enough to be replaced?
I would say that it is up to the wearer... but I would imagine if I walked in with one in immaculate shape and demanded a replacement they'd probably tell me where I could stuff my current one first.
Mine has a hole in the front large enough to put your thumb through. My last one was written off when I took it out of the washer and stretched it over my knee (as per the instructions!) and my knee went through it.
Def
-
Personally, I'd be buying another. Like you said it owes you nothing so I'd be investing in yet another one of their products.
-
Buy a new one, because it's the gentlemanly thing to do based on your reasoning.
Mike
-
That's what I was thinking- of course this one isn't in need of replacement YET.... just getting close.

Def
-
I'd leave the hat and go directly to sorting the hair mate. :P :D
-
:D :D
-
-
I saw it as one of those examples where I could get away with saying it as I am equally as bad. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login