Show your slip joint's thread!
-
I can't be right in the head either as that sounds reasonable to me.
-
Princess Pollywog,
In the $100 range is quite reasonable actually for an American made slipjoint using 154CM or Damascus steel. Try to get the same thing from a custom maker and then it gets expensive. Crazy! If you only knew.........I've got tens of thousands of dollars wrapped up in my knife collections. $100 to $150 for a well made American pocketknife that will last a lifetime or two is nothing.
As to Case's Tru-Sharp stainless.....yeah, some of the patterns are expensive like the Gunboat Canoes. But it is alot of knife with alot of steel. And these aren't just some stamped out knives......alot of hand operations go into these.
And their Tru-Sharp stainless is actually 420HC Stainless.......the same steel used in many Buck Knives, the same stainless used in many Schatt & Morgan's and Robeson's from Queen, and the same steel used by Great Eastern Cutlery in the new Cripple Creek SFO's. With the right heat treat it's a good steel......I know, I have been using it for years without a problem.
2xTap
-
Here's a pretty one.


-
@2xTap said:
Princess Pollywog,In the $100 range is quite reasonable actually for an American made slipjoint using 154CM or Damascus steel.
No, it's not. :D
Until you give me proof to show me otherwise, I'm prone to believe the material costs are actually pretty dang low per knife.@2xTap said:
As to Case's Tru-Sharp stainless.....yeah, some of the patterns are expensive like the Gunboat Canoes. But it is alot of knife with alot of steel. And these aren't just some stamped out knives......alot of hand operations go into these.Not $80's worth. Not even $60, $40, or $20. Okay, maybe $20's worth.
@2xTap said:
And their Tru-Sharp stainless is actually 420HC Stainless.......the same steel used in many Buck Knives, the same stainless used in many Schatt & Morgan's and Robeson's from Queen, and the same steel used by Great Eastern Cutlery in the new Cripple Creek SFO's. With the right heat treat it's a good steel......I know, I have been using it for years without a problem.2xTap
I'm fine with any kind of blade steel on a pocket knife as long it's not aluminum :D ... as long as the heat treat is good. But you can get pocket knives in so called "premium" steel elsewhere for much cheaper. Or crappy 400 series stainless ones from China with decent fit and finish for half a ten.
-
@ducktapehero said:
Here's a pretty one.

I love rehandled SAKs. I saw one with Stag and bolsters that was to die for.
-
Princess Pollywog,
Material costs might be low, but that is just part of the cost.....then you got the cost of manufacture which is not cheap here in the USA, and then you pay for the brand. In the matter of Case we are talking about the most collected brand of knives. And knives that generally don't lose value.
Value of any knife or brand is a subjective thing........but as to their proof of value on the market all you have to do is look at the market. Regular production case pieces can be had at reasonable prices. But when you get into their SFO's and limited run items the collector market forces the prices through demand. Add in age and you can often see the prices slowly climb.
The question is..........can you show me a knife of equal or better quality that will have a similar collector value for whatever inexpensive price you see better than that of a Case?
Good luck! :D
2xTap
-
Case is owned by zippo isn't it? So if zippo can sell stamped sheet metal for $30, why can't case sell their 420HC knife for $100? :P
-
Case is owned by Zippo.
2xTap
-
@2xTap said:
The question is..........can you show me a knife of equal or better quality that will have a similar collector value for whatever inexpensive price you see better than that of a Case?Alas, was I looking for a collector piece? Do I care about resell value? I'm just saying, there are many knifes that can be had for cheaper of equal or better quality. I'm saying the cost is NOT reasonable for the labor and parts put into it. It's not. That's why I don't buy Case.
If I was a collector, of course it'd be different.
Disregarding "collector value" and only considering manufacturing costs and labor... I cannot in my right mind say any Case knife is worth its value.
'Cept maybe a soddie.@jzmtl said:
Case is owned by zippo isn't it? So if zippo can sell stamped sheet metal for $30, why can't case sell their 420HC knife for $100? :PI get along fine with BIC lighters and fake cheapos. :P
-
Sorry to jump in on this discussion, but I'm curious to see what you regard as being of equal quality but much cheaper. Got any links?
-
points at SAKs :D
Sorry, I'm on satellite now, a bit hard to go knife browsing, will post some links when I get home. If I remember.
-
@Princess Pollywog said:
points at SAKs :DThis is not meant as a bash to Vic or Wenger as I am a fan of both, and they do build a good quality tool but you are comparing Apples to Oranges. There is a reason why most Vic's and Wengers cost so little. The average 91mm Vic is made of their standard stainless which is usable but softer than the 420HC that Case uses on most of their runs. Vic also uses a much thinner blade stock on many of their blades than Case uses on most of their slips (this does vary by pattern), most SAK's are scaled in essentially plastic that is stamped out like cord wood where most Case slippies are done in Jigged and Dyed cattle bone, most of your SAK's are lined in thin Aluminum stampings where most Case knives are lined in polished brass (or Nickle/Silver, depends on run), all production SAK's come un-bolstered where most all production Case slippies come bolstered in polished Nickle/Silver.
But all of this varies extremely with Case as they do so many different runs that add much more expensive handle materials, blade steels, finishes, different inlay shields, etc. And Case specializes in Traditional pocketknives, not multitools.
Outside of that there is also the History and Tradition, of which I won't get into in this thread.
But if we break this down and try to compare on equal footing we would have to take something like one of Case's Workman Series Scout Knives which has some tools in it...................
............and go with a Vic Soldier, which has the same tools/blade set-up. And then there ain't much of a price difference. I picked up my Case Workman Series Scout for only $26.00 NIB.
2xTap
-


I won this thing on auction about 2 weeks back for a song.....really dirt cheap. Thing is, the knife I recieved was not the knife that was listed. Both are similar but the one listed was a different pattern. I emailed the dealer I got it from and have yet to receive a reply......I ain't sweating it for I would of got this one too had it been listed as well. And as this knife was had so cheap, and it's just as nice, I'm happy either way. Odd how that worked out!
Anyway, the knife that was listed was a 2003 Robeson Shuredge Large Barlow "Demonstrator" in Red Smooth Bone. The knife I got was this one, a 2002 Robeson Shuredge Coke Bottle "Demonstrator" in Red Smooth Bone. Similar run just different pattern and older.......and like I said, I ain't sweating it! :D

These were a limited run of "1 of 100" and have the "Demonstrator" tang stamp. From what I have gathered these were reproductions of older Sales Sample knives.
And it's a big'un! My own measurement has this puppy at 5 3/16" from bolster to bolster. And it is hefty too with some thick blade stock, large slabs of bone, and long bolsters. Blade is a long Clip, fully swedged with long matchstriker pull and made from 420HC Stainless. Bolsters and shield are nickle/silver, and liners and pins are brass. Scales are smooth bone dyed in a beautiful shade of Red.

Fit and finish is excellent, but with two small faults which I will get into in a bit. Blade has half-stop, but opens and closes smoothly without any play. Backspring is stout, and it rests flush with the blade opened or closed. Scales fit to the bolsters and liners seamlessly, and the pins are flush to the scales. One fault here is in the backspring area. Liner and backspring fit is seamless up until you get to the pivot end on the non-shield side bolster.....here there is a small tiny gap, barely a hairline between the backspring and liner. It's tiny as hell but something I noticed.

The other fault is the edge. This is the first Queen-built knife I own that came dull out of the box. The edge is ground clean and even, but the bevels look to be at about a 40-45 degree angle, very steep making the edge quite blunt. Easily rectified if this was to be a user, as it is going into the collection it's no big deal.
Outside of that this thing is flawless, and mirror polsihed throughout. It's a looker! It came mint with it's original box but had no paperwork. The box itself is very clean and mint as well......either way it was a steal for only $56.99!!!!

2xTap
-
@2xTap said:
This is not meant as a bash to Vic or Wenger as I am a fan of both, and they do build a good quality tool but you are comparing Apples to Oranges. There is a reason why most Vic's and Wengers cost so little. The average 91mm Vic is made of their standard stainless which is usable but softer than the 420HC that Case uses on most of their runs. Vic also uses a much thinner blade stock on many of their blades than Case uses on most of their slips (this does vary by pattern), most SAK's are scaled in essentially plastic that is stamped out like cord wood where most Case slippies are done in Jigged and Dyed cattle bone, most of your SAK's are lined in thin Aluminum stampings where most Case knives are lined in polished brass (or Nickle/Silver, depends on run), all production SAK's come un-bolstered where most all production Case slippies come bolstered in polished Nickle/Silver.But all of this varies extremely with Case as they do so many different runs that add much more expensive handle materials, blade steels, finishes, different inlay shields, etc. And Case specializes in Traditional pocketknives, not multitools.
Outside of that there is also the History and Tradition, of which I won't get into in this thread.
But if we break this down and try to compare on equal footing we would have to take something like one of Case's Workman Series Scout Knives which has some tools in it...................
............and go with a Vic Soldier, which has the same tools/blade set-up. And then there ain't much of a price difference. I picked up my Case Workman Series Scout for only $26.00 NIB.
2xTap
Not to jump the thread, either, but I just wanted to say I grabbed up one of the Case Scouts a while back, just to counterpoint my SAKs. Lovely knife, but one problem. The screwdriver is a b**** to get out of the knife! All of the other blades work find, but the screwdriver will not come out unless I use a something like the screwdriver on a SAK to lift it out. I've tried cleaning, oiling, etc. I'm to the point of waving a dead chicken over it... I'm almost annoyed to the point of selling it, but I really don't want to. It's such a nice knife! :-\
-
This is not meant as a bash to Vic or Wenger as I am a fan of both, and they do build a good quality tool but you are comparing Apples to Oranges. There is a reason why most Vic's and Wengers cost so little. The average 91mm Vic is made of their standard stainless which is usable but softer than the 420HC that Case uses on most of their runs. Vic also uses a much thinner blade stock on many of their blades than Case uses on most of their slips (this does vary by pattern), most SAK's are scaled in essentially plastic that is stamped out like cord wood where most Case slippies are done in Jigged and Dyed cattle bone, most of your SAK's are lined in thin Aluminum stampings where most Case knives are lined in polished brass (or Nickle/Silver, depends on run), all production SAK's come un-bolstered where most all production Case slippies come bolstered in polished Nickle/Silver.
But all of this varies extremely with Case as they do so many different runs that add much more expensive handle materials, blade steels, finishes, different inlay shields, etc. And Case specializes in Traditional pocketknives, not multitools.
Outside of that there is also the History and Tradition, of which I won't get into in this thread.
But if we break this down and try to compare on equal footing we would have to take something like one of Case's Workman Series Scout Knives which has some tools in it...................
............and go with a Vic Soldier, which has the same tools/blade set-up. And then there ain't much of a price difference. I picked up my Case Workman Series Scout for only $26.00 NIB.
2xTap
Not to jump the thread, either, but I just wanted to say I grabbed up one of the Case Scouts a while back, just to counterpoint my SAKs. Lovely knife, but one problem. The screwdriver is a b**** to get out of the knife! All of the other blades work find, but the screwdriver will not come out unless I use a something like the screwdriver on a SAK to lift it out. I've tried cleaning, oiling, etc. I'm to the point of waving a dead chicken over it... I'm almost annoyed to the point of selling it, but I really don't want to. It's such a nice knife! :-\
You could send it to me if you are annoyed so much :D
-
Here's another I just got.................


I am always on the hunt for mint Case Classic's on the cheap. These things, depending on pattern, have been bringing big money on auction. I have bid on so many over the years only to lose out on them as they go up in the stratosphere on bids. This is only the third Classic I've managed to win on auction, and got for under $100.00! I was bidding on another, a different pattern of Whittler.....and in less than a day that one jumped from $76.00 to nearly $200.00!!! Suffice it to say I didn't win that one!

This one is a #94 pattern Whittler (not to be confused with Case's other #94 patterns, the Gunboat and Cattleman) manufactured in 1991, I believe by Queen Cutlery.....as many of the Case Classic patterns were. It is a Cigar style "Splitback" Whittler at 4" closed. Blades are flat ground 1095 Carbon Steel with nickle/silver bolsters and shield, and brass liners and pins. Scales are jigged Tan Bone.
As mentioned the blades are 1095 Carbon Steel, flat ground, and mirror polished. The Spear mainblade as well as the Spey and Pen secondary blades all sport swedges, with the mainblade having a long pull. Edges are clean and evenly ground on all, and will shave arm hair. Fit throughout the knife is solid and virtually seamless, and all metal surfaces are mirror polished. Backsprings are stout and on all blades sit flush with them opened or closed.
The two secondary blades have half-stops but the mainblade doesn't. And as I also mentioned this one is a "Splitback" Whittler. For the uninitiated this means all 3 blades operate off of just two backsprings. The secondary blades cam off of their own backsprings and are separated by a wedge-shaped brass spacer which angles the two backsprings down together where the mainblade cams off of both at the same time. This is an old-school way of doing it, very classic........

The only fault I can find with this knife is a slight uneveness in the wedge were it sits at it's thinnest spot between the backsprings, and some surface blemishes caused by the previous owner. Some slight rub marks on the blades from opening and closing them......caused by the fact that the blades sit so close together when closed that if you don't pull the blades straight out they will touch a bit on opening. You can see some of this on the blades in the pic below..........

Outside of that this thing is flawless. It came in it's orginal box but had none of it's original paperwork.....this might be why I got it fairly cheap. All and all a great slippie to add to the collection.

2xTap
-
-
A case to get one soon
I have a sod buster JR and honestly guys they're top notch 
-
Awesome stuff 2 Tap mate

-
Here's some more eye-candy for you!


Well, I finally got around to ordering the other Left-Hand #23 Pioneer from Great Eastern Cutlery. This one, like my other, was ordered from Mike at CollectorKnives.net. It arrived yesterday and aside from the color of bone is exactly like my other in every way, even down to the slight hazy mirror polish of the blades.
It's 4.5" in the closed position, sports 440-C stainless blades, nickle/silver bolsters, and brass liners and pins. Blades are cleanly ground and arm-hair shaving sharp, and both blades have half-stops which are typical of this pattern from GEC. Scales on this one are called Green Mountain Bone. And for those who might not know, the reason these particular #23 pattern Pioneers from GEC are called "Left-Handers" is because of the position of the blades. On a regular #23 pattern Pioneer the Clip and Spey blades are on opposite sides as opposed to this one. That's the only difference.
These were produced in 2007 and only 50 were made of each. This Green Mountain Bone one I have is serial number #16 of 50.
Fit and finish is virtually flawless, and seamless throughout. Blade spines meet to the backsprings even and flush, backsprings are stout, blades have zero lateral play, scale/bolster/liner/backspring fit is as good as it gets, overall it's an exceptional piece.

Here's a pic of both of them together, the River Blue Bone on top and the Green Mountain Bone on bottom.........

The more GEC's I get the more I am impressed with them. While I am a huge fan of Case and Queen Cutlery and own many flawless examples from each....I have to say I am of the belief that these GEC's are the best built production slipjoints to be had outside of customs.

2xTap
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





