ROLR M1
-
Nice and fresh!

For me, usually just stuffing small tools in my pockets, the big semicircle at the handle end would seem like a pointy issue. Does it have any particular function beyond not slipping the hand off?
303 steel is machining friendly, but the downside is that it doesn't heat harden and work hardening will only bring it so far. (For hard gripping 440 or 420 series or even PH stainless steels might be alternatives).
I do like the machining marks, the size and the all steel design. Quite unique!

Edit: I thought I'd actually buy one, but shipping seems to be US and UK only.
-
No I don't think it has any other benefit than keeping your from slipping. I agree on the 303 stainless, I've got a little bit of wear on the teeth. Where are you located and I can ask him.
Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
-
I'm in Norway. If he is in the US the shipping is typically quite high as the US isn't part of the international postal agreement (or something like that).
-
Very interesting and IMO beautiful tool, thanks for sharing it.
I feel like the limited toolset will mean a small audience, particularly as there’s no lock or spring to hold the bit driver in place (not sure about the prybar but I figure the same may go for that?).
For me where something like this falls down is substitutability. With a fully-featured MT that may give me six or seven tools I might find useful, there’s no way I would carry all those individual tools in my pocket or everyday bag. So it has a niche in my carry. With this I have the immediate thought that I could carry a pouch with a Knipex and a separate pry bar and bit driving setup for little more bulk, and it would be more capable.
-
Sorry, misread. Carry on... ::)
-
@fullbreakfast said:
Very interesting and IMO beautiful tool, thanks for sharing it.I feel like the limited toolset will mean a small audience, particularly as there’s no lock or spring to hold the bit driver in place (not sure about the prybar but I figure the same may go for that?).
For me where something like this falls down is substitutability. With a fully-featured MT that may give me six or seven tools I might find useful, there’s no way I would carry all those individual tools in my pocket or everyday bag. So it has a niche in my carry. With this I have the immediate thought that I could carry a pouch with a Knipex and a separate pry bar and bit driving setup for little more bulk, and it would be more capable.
The price will also scare people away. This is around $100. The Knipex 100mm Cobra is around $35.
-
The Cobra is optimized for mass production and sell by the containerload. It is certainly good quality and value for the money.
That said, this is more of a specialized thing, and I'm actually surprised that USD100 is a sustainable price for all that CNC machining from a business viewpoint. Maybe by direct sale?
-
Most buyers (or at least potential buyers) do not care about the business viewpoint. Price, availability, versatility, I care about those. The Knipex pliers have many more positions vs this which has only two. This costs $100, which is very expensive from my viewpoint. I can get a Knipex 100mm Cobra, a mini ratchet with bits, and a small prybar, and still have money for more than this offers. And the Knipex is available. I cannot order this even if I wanted to. And the WorkPro cobras are just fine for me, and cost even less than the Knipex.
If $100 is what the maker has to charge for it to be profitable for him, by all means; he is free to charge whatever he wants for his product. I've seen fidget gadgets with no actual practical use go for hundreds of dollars and people do buy them. This is much more useful than those, and other multi-toolish things we see nowadays.
I think he can experiment a bit with this design. Maybe have the tools pivot from the end of the handle? That way he could have a version with a blade or scalpel holder. Maybe a fixed bit driver? Why not have the curvy handle be the prying tip, and save the pivoting prybar's space for another tool? Or have a pocket-clip on it, with a mechanism to hold the handles closed of course.
-
Yes, there is perfect logic to all of that.
But to me this one isn't in the realm of daily hardworking tools. To me this is more in the Mora knife versus some small series custom knife. You can argue they do the same, and one cost multitudes more, yet there are buyers. Transferring that logic to pliers might be a stretch for many if not most, but that side of the logic is where I'm at.
To me that one is a work of passion as opposed to a product of market research, standards conformity, various three letter optimizations and simulations and slightly boring sensibilities. That is rare to come by in a tools world. I might not necessarily think every part of the design is how I would do it, or agree on the order of priorities, but I respect that a lot of thought have gone into this and that the choices have been made consciously. And it seems functional enough that I find it interesting, and I expect I would discover some more depth to it by having a closer inspection.
That is enough value in itself for me, and in particular this early version. I expect later version will be a bit dulled down, and perhaps more functional, but also with less of this slightly untamed feel.
I know - I might be damaged goods, but as a machining centre user I even read those machining marks with some interest as they say something about the machine and software used. :)
-
@Vidar said:
Yes, there is perfect logic to all of that.But to me this one isn't in the realm of daily hardworking tools. To me this is more in the Mora knife versus some small series custom knife. You can argue they do the same, and one cost multitudes more, yet there are buyers. Transferring that logic to pliers might be a stretch for many if not most, but that side of the logic is where I'm at.
To me that one is a work of passion as opposed to a product of market research, standards conformity, various three letter optimizations and simulations and slightly boring sensibilities. That is rare to come by in a tools world. I might not necessarily think every part of the design is how I would do it, or agree on the order of priorities, but I respect that a lot of thought have gone into this and that the choices have been made consciously. And it seems functional enough that I find it interesting, and I expect I would discover some more depth to it by having a closer inspection.
That is enough value in itself for me, and in particular this early version. I expect later version will be a bit dulled down, and perhaps more functional, but also with less of this slightly untamed feel.
I know - I might be damaged goods, but as a machining centre user I even read those machining marks with some interest as they say something about the machine and software used. :)
I think I understand what you're getting at here. It's a thing one would own because one appreciates its aesthetics, and the ingenuity and craftsmanship that went into it, rather than for purely practical reasons. A source of pleasure and fascination to the discerning tool nerd! To be used on occasion, but perhaps more of a collector's piece than a daily beater.
I don't disparage this, indeed I own several things that fall into the same category in my mind (the Metmo pocket driver, the Windeler modular tool system).
-
Not so sure about the aesthetics, but I do appreciate that the design just went for it.
To me that looks like it is done by someone who made what they wanted, and made few if any adaptations for measly manufacturing considerations. To me that is craft made, but just with a CNC machine and straightforward tool paths. I would be surprised if that is made on heavy robust industrial machining centre. From the pictures that seems to be done by a 3-axis CNC mill and likely a small one by industrial scale. Which would make that a lot of work to make. (Alternatively the parts look like that could be made one shot at a 6+ axis turning centre with live tools - which would make for a quite impressive manufacturing video for marketing..) Without having one hard to tell for sure. Those are things to nerd over I guess. :D
Too bad it is only sold to a small part of the market. As if being a new/ niche product isn't hard enough already.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login