Giants of June / Big Blades Challenge - June 2026
-
I like the big Boker so far. Blade is D2 which I have no real opinion of thus far, although I've had a few D2 knives. I just haven't abused any of them, so I have no idea how well it holds up. I've gotta say that D@ is very, very popular which I usually take as a red flag. But so far they seem to be holding up.
I would prefer no blade coating, as on my Boker lockback soddy in D2. It's actually beginning to develop a bit of patina, which is a point in its favor. But unlike my Boker Strike auto with its somewhat rough textured blade coating, the coating on this one is smooth. That will be advantageous for food prep.
This has a clip as well as a lanyard hole. I generally prefer a lanyard, but it's nice to have options. With a knife this size and being automatic, the clip might be the better way to carry it. It only has a button; no safety lock. But the button is smooth and doesn't stand proud. Maybe it will be ok.
Boker automatics tend to have a soft spring. My old Magnum doesn't, but my Strike does. It's ok on the Strike; just not very fast. I read some reviews that said it was not strong enough on the XXL. Fortunately, BladeHQ (where I bought this one) XXLs are custom built with a stronger spring. It seems perfect to me.
I think I'm gonna like it.
-
The date stamp on my CASE is for 2020. The grater section could very well be just cosmetic. It is surprising how many different companies have produced practically the same model for their line. Best wishes. G

-
@nate j said:
I would call it jimping; I’m not 100% certain of its purpose in this context, but I do have some theories:Enhance grip when choking up on the skinner blade for detail work - I think this is the strongest possibility, though as you say, it’s a fair amount of weight to hold by pinching the blade between one’s fingers.
Enhance grip on knife when clip point blade is open - I find it has this effect, though not sure this is the intended purpose.
Fish scaler - unlikely, due to the short length of the section
Ferro rod striker - Might work for this purpose, but I think the design predates the ferro rod striker craze.
Aesthetics - Never discount the possibility that a design decision was made just to look cool and hopefully sell more knives.
Help prevent knife from sliding out of sheath/pocket - May have this effect, but don’t believe this would be the reason for the design
I think the ferro rod striker idea is the correct one. Yes the basic pattern predates the ferro rod poplularity, but the older ones don't have the serration. That's a new addition.
@IMR4198 said:
The date stamp on my CASE is for 2020. The grater section could very well be just cosmetic. It is surprising how many different companies have produced practically the same model for their line. Best wishes. G

I was just looking at Boker's similar offerings in 1095 steel. Still made in Germany, too. And the price is actually less than a Case. I'm tempted. Very tempted.
-
@WECSOG said:
I like the big Boker so far. Blade is D2 which I have no real opinion of thus far, although I've had a few D2 knives. I just haven't abused any of them, so I have no idea how well it holds up. I've gotta say that D@ is very, very popular which I usually take as a red flag. But so far they seem to be holding up.I would prefer no blade coating, as on my Boker lockback soddy in D2. It's actually beginning to develop a bit of patina, which is a point in its favor. But unlike my Boker Strike auto with its somewhat rough textured blade coating, the coating on this one is smooth. That will be advantageous for food prep.
This has a clip as well as a lanyard hole. I generally prefer a lanyard, but it's nice to have options. With a knife this size and being automatic, the clip might be the better way to carry it. It only has a button; no safety lock. But the button is smooth and doesn't stand proud. Maybe it will be ok.
Boker automatics tend to have a soft spring. My old Magnum doesn't, but my Strike does. It's ok on the Strike; just not very fast. I read some reviews that said it was not strong enough on the XXL. Fortunately, BladeHQ (where I bought this one) XXLs are custom built with a stronger spring. It seems perfect to me.
I think I'm gonna like it.

In my experience with D2, it is a solid enough option. Not stainless though.
-
@BPRoberts said:
Day 3
I get that it's a Capital H Hunting knife, but I don't love the skinner here. In my mind, it's too close to the master clip point. If I get two blades, I like one to be full pointy, and one minimally so (say a sheepsfoot). Given their love of the pattern, I'm surprised Case didn't go all in on a BIG Trapper and give us a spey.Case's stainless is servicable. It doesn't rust without abuse, takes and holds and okay edge, but nothing exciting. Other big American companies like KaBar (CROVAN) or Buck (420HC) manage to make even old school stainless impress. For Case, make mine carbon.
For what it is supposed to do, having a skinner blade for field dressing and skinning, and a clip point blade (perhaps the best all-around blade shape IMO) for everything else makes a lot of sense to me.
They aren’t quite the size of the 65 pattern (and their blades don’t meet the 4” minimum for this challenge), but Case’s 54 pattern Trapper (middle) and 75 pattern Moose (bottom) are both sizeable (over 4” closed) pocket knives with your preferred combination of blades.
I agree Case’s standard stainless steel gets the job done, but is nothing to write home about. I do appreciate the Cases I’ve managed to collect with 154CM, ATS-34, S35VN, and 20CV.
I also agree Buck’s 420HC is probably better than Case’s usual stainless.
KA-BAR’s Cro-Van is actually 1095, however, so not stainless.
Since I got a 65 pattern (SS blades, black canvas micarta slabs) in the pic, we’ll call this my Day 3:

-
Day 3
Here you go, Nate!
[attach id=0 msg=2575190]

-
Roach belly again, ST300, Streamlight 2lx (iirc),Glock 17 gen5. The empty mag holder usually holds my phone.
-
@nate j said:
For what it is supposed to do, having a skinner blade for field dressing and skinning, and a clip point blade (perhaps the best all-around blade shape IMO) for everything else makes a lot of sense to me.They aren’t quite the size of the 65 pattern (and their blades don’t meet the 4” minimum for this challenge), but Case’s 54 pattern Trapper (middle) and 75 pattern Moose (bottom) are both sizeable (over 4” closed) pocket knives with your preferred combination of blades.
I agree Case’s standard stainless steel gets the job done, but is nothing to write home about. I do appreciate the Cases I’ve managed to collect with 154CM, ATS-34, S35VN, and 20CV.
I also agree Buck’s 420HC is probably better than Case’s usual stainless.
KA-BAR’s Cro-Van is actually 1095, however, so not stainless.
Since I got a 65 pattern (SS blades, black canvas micarta slabs) in the pic, we’ll call this my Day 3:
I stand corrected on the Cro-Van. Learn something every day.
I have a 54 or two, but I usually wind up reaching for a 75 Stockman if I'm going to carry in that size (awlthough the Trapper's spey is appreciably larger). The 75 Moose is probably #1 on my Vault wishlist, but I haven't talked myself into putting out the money for one on ebay yet.
-
<u>Day 3</u>
Whipped out my over sized letter opener today. My wife gave me one of these today -
- when I explained why I was doing it.
-
@BPRoberts said:
I have a 54 or two, but I usually wind up reaching for a 75 Stockman if I'm going to carry in that size (awlthough the Trapper's spey is appreciably larger). The 75 Moose is probably #1 on my Vault wishlist, but I haven't talked myself into putting out the money for one on ebay yet.I have a couple 54s as well, but I just never could bring myself to like or carry them. Not sure I can put my finger on exactly why.
The 75 Moose is deeply under-appreciated. It’s slimmer and lighter than the better known 75 Stockman, but arguably gives up exactly nothing in terms of capability.
-
@BPRoberts said:
I stand corrected on the Cro-Van. Learn something every day.I have a 54 or two, but I usually wind up reaching for a 75 Stockman if I'm going to carry in that size (awlthough the Trapper's spey is appreciably larger). The 75 Moose is probably #1 on my Vault wishlist, but I haven't talked myself into putting out the money for one on ebay yet.
I once read somewhere that Case CV, Cold Steel Carbon V, possibly Kabar CroVan and maybe one or two others were the same steel and made by Camillus. I think that is somewhat simplistic but does have some elements of truth.
-
@AzteCypher said:
<u>Day 3</u>Whipped out my over sized letter opener today. My wife gave me one of these today -
- when I explained why I was doing it.

If you don’t earn at least an occasional
and or ::) from the wife, you’re not really living.Glad to see you keeping your “Biggest of the Big Blades” title!

-
Day 4:
Extrema Ratio Lamborghini Reventon.
Originally given as seat [attach id=0 msg=2575213] [attach id=0 msg=2575213] belt cutter in case of a bit of bother for Reventon buyers, they also made some for plebs like me to purchase. Reckon it'll still cut any seatbelt if need be
-
Day 4
I put my Kahlua mug back in action with some coffee. Put in a bunch of sugar, since it was that kind of morning. I saw where people were selling Do a Kahlua mugs as 'vintage collectible.' The things were made in China. Made some cowboy coffee. Boil some water in a pot. Take it off the heat and stir in some coffee. Let it sit an indeterminate time. Cowboys don't carry watches. Use a paper towel to filter grounds as you pour the coffee into the cup. If you don't have a paper towel, then you can add a splash of cold water to the coffee in the pot and most of the floaters will go to the bottom. Sit on your bedroll. Look at the cattle. Listen for a horse to make little worried whickering sounds. That means an Injun is sneaking up on you. Or maybe some cattle thief. Shift your tin cup (cowboys don't carry any other kind) to your left hand and thumb the retaining loop off the hammer of your Colt. Can you imagine what cowboy tea would be like? Sit in your folding camp chair in your pajamas. Your man brings your tea on a proper tray with some chocolate biscuits. You sip a little. Light your pipe. Look at the cattle. Wonder why your bloody horse is complaining. Where did your servant get to? Unreliable man. Look down to see an arrow sprouting from your belly. How did that.....?Best wishes. G
[attach id=0 msg=2575218]
-
I think cowboy tea would be similar to what some people call "grandpa style." Basically, put some tea (preferably one that uses largish leaves) in a mug, splash water on top, let sit, and drink. Once you get half way or so, add more hot water. Repeat as needed.
-
Sounds good. It is mostly sweet tea down here. Cold and almost like Kool-Aid. I like it but very rarely have it. Too much sugar. I'm not sure there is any tea in the house. Maybe some Chamomile.
Best wishes. G

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

