*U"@~i^% H¬ll
-
That's a dangerous stance though Ben, as whilst it's obviously true, it doesn't make it acceptable. Where do you draw the line at toeing the line, even when the rule is unjust and there for debatable reasons?
Obviously we have to comply with law or face the consequences, that doesn't make the "law" right though does it, and what use is the right of free speech if you can't say you don't like it?
Personally it pisses me off that:
- The local supermarket won't sell me a video game with a '16' rating for my 15 year old son;
- That the chemist won't let me buy more than x painkillers when I can actually be trusted not to take an overdose;
- etc, etc.....
How on earth is that a "dangerous stance"? :D This isn't a law where there is some ambiguity, this is actually one that is pretty damn simple really and the good old people that do the roads even give you multiple signs with a nice red ring around them so you know what the speed is. And who says that it's wrong? Do you know the road he is on about? Are you the car speeding expert? No, you know neither. All we (us at MTO) know is that Paul has been caught doing 36MPH is a 30 zone. Seems pretty cut and shut that if he had oboeyed the law (silly or not) he would not be in this situation.
Paul, that was not some dig at you BTW. :D
You reckon? I read recently, (but unfortunately can't find the article right now), that 15% of charges arising from cameras are thrown out of court. Apparently, this number would be more than double, if people realised that you can actually contest these things, and that something like 30% of the notices issued wouldn't stand up in court.
Since these cameras were first introduced in the UK, the guidelines have been changed several times in an attempt to make things safety measures as opposed to nice little earners for the authorities. The speeds recorded are often inaccurate for a variety of reasons, the positioning of cameras often isn't legal, the visibility of the cameras is often contrary to the guidelines etc.
I'd say that a 1 in 3 chance that the ticket you just got is actually accurate shows that things are very ambiguous!
-
Well I'll make it simple for you Dave, if you see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH. :D
-
@Benner said:
Well I'll make it simple for you Dave, if you see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH. :DAnd if I do, and get a picture through the post a few days later saying I was doing 36?
You may be able to recall your exact speed for every mile you drive, but I've done 20,000 miles so far this year!
-
Well I'll make it simple for you Dave, if you see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH. :D
And if I do, and get a picture through the post a few days later saying I was doing 36?
You may be able to recall your exact speed for every mile you drive, but I've done 20,000 miles so far this year!
But this was about Paul's thread where he said that he was, so where's the argument there?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I sensed that you had recently been caught for doing something. How could I tell? :D
I agree, it is a bit sneaky at times but you know what there is a very very simple way of avoiding all those problems. Just don't speed. It really is that simple. If you speed and get caught then you have accepted to take that gamble and should accept the consequences.
If speeding cameras were really about public safety, then fines would be much higher. As it is, most are willing to gamble, such that most of the time, they don't get tagged. Raise the fine to 1000 GBP and you'd see an end to speeding. Until then, it's all about revenue generation.
In the US, there have been locales where this has been proven in court. Based on the nature of the contracts signed with the company installing/maintaining the cameras, the systems were set for maximum revenue generation (ie set to trigger too early by fractions of a second at redlight cameras or deliberately miscalibrated with speed cameras).
In the State of Virginia, 20 mph over the limit is a felony with high fine ($1000 to start I think) and an automatic court appearance (essentially careless driving). They were serious about speeding and did the right things to stop it. Handing out 60 GBP tickets is just the price of admission to the show, not a real deterrence.
JMO
I never said it was about safety did I?
All I said was to not get stung by the law for speeding, don't speed. That had nothing at all to do with the safety of it or whether I thought the restrictions in place are correct.If that's the case, just turn it into a tollway and let the drivers have at it. :D
-
Well I'll make it simple for you Dave, if you see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH. :D
And if I do, and get a picture through the post a few days later saying I was doing 36?
You may be able to recall your exact speed for every mile you drive, but I've done 20,000 miles so far this year!
But this was about Paul's thread where he said that he was, so where's the argument there?
You've lost me. You were talking about the lack ambiguity in the law, and then helpfully advised me that sticking to the speed limit would be fine.
I gave you a scenario where that doesn't apply, as supposedly in about 30% of cases in the UK.
The argument (if that's what you want to call it), is that you seem to think the system is flawless ("if you see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH.") and I think you're being very naive.
-
What I was saying was that Paul said he was speeding and then got caught. If you look back you saw that as a suitable excuse to call police "fascist b*****ds" because he was caught for doing something which he knew was illegal. If there was some ambiguity in what he said then I could see the frustration, but there wasn't. Now I know I'm only, as you said yourself, naive, but that is a perfect example of the "cut and shut" example that I stated above.
-
@Benner said:
What I was saying was that Paul said he was speeding and then got caught. If you look back you saw that as a suitable excuse to call police "fascist b*****ds" because he was caught for doing something which he knew was illegal. If there was some ambiguity in what he said then I could see the frustration, but there wasn't. Now I know I'm only, as you said yourself, naive, but that is a perfect example of the "cut and shut" example that I stated above.OK, I know you don't really need me to do this, but:
- The "fascist b******s" statement wasn't exactly serious, and I'd be amazed if you didn't realise that;
- The conversation had long moved away from Paul's comment, onto the wider subject of "safety" cameras and the legitimacy of them. You could argue that we'd drifted slightly off topic, but I think that would be a first around here!
-
Firstly, most of us use emoticons to express opinions and you used nothing so anyone could have taken that any way. May I suggest using something to show you're joking in the future, especially if it is about the old bill. ;)
Secondly, I was personally talking about Paul, and if you look back my whole 30MPH comment had a :D after it, so I'm surprised that you didn't know I was joking. :D
-
@Benner said:
....I was personally talking about Paul, and if you look back my whole 30MPH comment had a :D after it, so I'm surprised that you didn't know I was joking. :DNo you weren't:
@Benner said:
I agree, it is a bit sneaky at times but you know what there is a very very simple way of avoiding all those problems. Just don't speed. It really is that simple. If **you **speed and get caught then **you **have accepted to take that gamble and should accept the consequences.@Benner said:
Well I'll make it simple for you Dave, if **you **see a sign with a big 30 in the middle of it, you can only do up to 30 MPH. :DDoes the use of the emoticon here mean that you believe the afore-mentioned is always the case in a faultless system, or not

@Benner said:
...most of us use emoticons to express opinions and you used nothing so anyone could have taken that any way. May I suggest using something to show you're joking in the future, especially if it is about the old bill. ;)I would have thought that having met me in the real world a couple of times, in addition to knowing each other through this forum, that there was no way that you could have thought I wasn't joking. But if you need a small yellow picture - it's no bother ;)
-
Oh dear. :D Think what you like mate, makes no difference to me and I'm getting bored with repeating myself.
-
@DaveK said:
I would have thought that having met me in the real world a couple of times, in addition to knowing each other through this forum, that there was no way that you could have thought I wasn't joking.** But if you need a small yellow picture ** - it's no bother ;)That's rather jaundiced. :D
-
:D :D
-
Liver failure?
-
Noun
jaundice (uncountable)
(pathology) A morbid condition, characterized by yellowness of the eyes, skin, and urine, whiteness of the feces, constipation, queasiness, loss of appetite, and general languor and lassitude. It is caused usually by obstruction of the biliary passages and consequent damming up, in the liver, of the bile, which is then absorbed into the blood. Other causes include increased hemolysis and any liver disease. The discoloration is caused by accumulation of bilirubin in the body; bilirubin is normally excreted in bile to give feces their normal yellow-brown coloration.;)
-
Where's Mike to start the "Does the emoticon dude have liver failure or is he Jaundiced?" poll? :D
-
Oh, my last post didn't post!
It was a crap joke anyway!
-
Oh, my last post didn't post!
It was a crap joke anyway!
That never stopped Neil. :D
Go on
:DThe moment has gone, but in response to:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Liver failure?
Noun
jaundice (uncountable)
(pathology) A morbid condition, characterized by yellowness of the eyes, skin, and urine, whiteness of the feces, constipation, queasiness, loss of appetite, and general languor and lassitude. It is caused usually by obstruction of the biliary passages and consequent damming up, in the liver, of the bile, which is then absorbed into the blood. Other causes include increased hemolysis and any liver disease. The discoloration is caused by accumulation of bilirubin in the body; bilirubin is normally excreted in bile to give feces their normal yellow-brown coloration.;)
I posted:
Oh sorry, I should have said : Liver failure? :D

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login