Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
Most interesting!
I would not surprised if many of the firms operated out of the same buildings. Just changed names and listed ownership staying one step ahead of investors of banks.
-
<u>Day 3</u>
Used my Colonial Bremco Barlow to cut up a left over hot dog for the doggos.

-
Day 3
Queen Drake Well commemorative Barlow
https://www.queencutleryguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Drake-Barlow-1972.-11-24-2020.pdf


-
@LoopCutter said:
Day 3[attach id=0 msg=2586775]
BARLOW stamped on the bolster,
The Ideal U.S.A. On the tang.A pawn shop find a while ago.
This definitely was a $1 knife on display by the register.
The liners are just a tad larger than the scales and the back pin is broken on the back side, so the scale slides.Ideal reminds me of a novelty company that makes throw away stuff.
Surprising is that pull is at least a 7.5 or 8 on both blades and yet a solid seal closing.
Does that speyish shape on the master look original, or aftermarket?
-
@ AC - a list, that is dangerous during challenge month.
Two items worth note; IDEAL is not worth the your time to buy. The one I have is of poor quality, was maybe z prize a carinval or county fair.
The QUEEN knives.
The original QUEEN CUTLERY knives are very good quality if you encounter.
Since, SMKW. Has owned the NAME. MADE THE KNIVES IN CHINA, likely same facilities as ROUGH RYDER. BUT WITH 440C steel. The are well made, my BARLOW is the only I found after I realized the build quality.
Then a few years ago, SMKW pulled the QUEEN BRAND back to the USA, and search for knife shops to produce quality Queen brand slipjoints. Prices double or tripled at that point. It now appears BEAR & Sons are making the SMKW QUEENS, and possibly are be coached on their complete product line. -
@BPRoberts said:
Does that speyish shape on the master look original, or aftermarket?Appears original, no discoloration and back edge finish same from pivot to point.
[attach id=0 msg=2586818]
[attach id=1 msg=2586818]


-
@LoopCutter said:
@ AC - a list, that is dangerous during challenge month.Two items worth note; IDEAL is not worth the your time to buy. The one I have is of poor quality, was maybe z prize a carinval or county fair.
The QUEEN knives.
The original QUEEN CUTLERY knives are very good quality if you encounter.
Since, SMKW. Has owned the NAME. MADE THE KNIVES IN CHINA, likely same facilities as ROUGH RYDER. BUT WITH 440C steel. The are well made, my BARLOW is the only I found after I realized the build quality.
Then a few years ago, SMKW pulled the QUEEN BRAND back to the USA, and search for knife shops to produce quality Queen brand slipjoints. Prices double or tripled at that point. It now appears BEAR & Sons are making the SMKW QUEENS, and possibly are be coached on their complete product line.Thanks for the good info LC, good to know. I'll have to pay attention to Bear and Sons then, though I do prefer something with a few miles on it.
-
@AzteCypher said:
Thanks for the good info LC, good to know. I'll have to pay attention to Bear and Sons then, though I do prefer something with a few miles on it.I really like the looks of the Bear & Son Large Barlow. It's available in 1095 carbon steel too, which I also like.
They have a public sale event at their factory every November. The factory is about 100 miles from me. I'm planning on trying to make it this year. Maybe I'll be able to snag one of those Barlows, in carbon steel and stag handles. -
@AzteCypher said:
Thanks for the good info LC, good to know. I'll have to pay attention to Bear and Sons then, though I do prefer something with a few miles on it.The best person ask for help is STEVE. HE has shared links to oldies and goodies I have hunted.
And old original QUEEN is on my radar., maybe more a regional thing. And, I will admit the BARLOS pattern is not top of my list. Only can say the Case Crossroads are tempting. Only thing holding me back is to many choices now.
-
This is sounding expensive...


-
@AzteCypher said:
This is sounding expensive...

You are the one making a list!
I just sitting here, minding my own business and offering FREE comments

-
@LoopCutter said:
Day 3[attach id=0 msg=2586775]
BARLOW stamped on the bolster,
The Ideal U.S.A. On the tang.A pawn shop find a while ago.
This definitely was a $1 knife on display by the register.
The liners are just a tad larger than the scales and the back pin is broken on the back side, so the scale slides.Ideal reminds me of a novelty company that makes throw away stuff.
Surprising is that pull is at least a 7.5 or 8 on both blades and yet a solid seal closing.
Love how you mention Novelty Company. I’ve seen a few of their knives online where the design tempts me, but I know better than to buy.
Worked from home today and got some much needed catching up. Got a package from Vixino and the Barlow helped me free it's brethren. Quick look at the Baby Bronto which gets released today. This is cool to me because with a design of my own being produced by them I get a feel of what they're capable of quality wise.
That is very cool.
@LoopCutter said:
A DAY 3 +[attach id=0 msg=2586792]
Looks good paired together…


-
@AzteCypher said:
<u>Day 3</u>Used my Colonial Bremco Barlow to cut up a left over hot dog for the doggos.

Bet that made the doggos happy
@WECSOG said:
I really like the looks of the Bear & Son Large Barlow. It's available in 1095 carbon steel too, which I also like.
They have a public sale event at their factory every November. The factory is about 100 miles from me. I'm planning on trying to make it this year. Maybe I'll be able to snag one of those Barlows, in carbon steel and stag handles.I too like the looks of the Bear & Son. I have been debating between one of theirs and a Queen from an online site.
For the “Powers that be” does a beer tender Barlow count for this challenge?

-
Day 3

Today I carried this no-name Barlow from Pakistan with a polished horn handle. I cut these flowers with it! (Please be kind to my arrangement skills lol)
I have the box around here somewhere; it shed no more light on its origins than "Barlow from Pakistan". It's a heavy knife for its size, with decent steel. I'll be interested to see how it retains an edge.
-
Day 03 🤠

-
-
Day 3
A little bit of cutting duty today but nothing fancy, so took a glamor shot on the walk.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


