Bloody customs!
-
wow Ben that really sucks. I hope you get it sorted out,
don't delay and go get your other stuff buddy! -
Ben have you appealed this mad decision there is a procedure for doing so,
my guess is if it's plain that you can purchase the knife here legally,then it would follow that it's legal to import.
And before anyone suggests it's ok for dealers to import illegals then I'm sorry they are not above the law guys, in fact their shipments get more scrutiny in customs

so What I'm saying is if you can prove you can purchase it here, then you may have a case

I don't know if this was helpful but! if you appeal you have nothing to lose by doing so

-
Its daft but I have to say I don't think Ben has much of a chance. I'd cut my loses in order to get the other items from them.
Taking them to court would cost. They're not likely to capitulate in the face of such action as its not like going up against an individual or a company, they have tax payers money to cover their legal expenses. There is also no guarantee that the court would find in Ben's favour.
I'd forget about the media being useful. Its a knife... do I really need to say any more in the current climate?
It sucks :(
-
@Neil said:
Its daft but I have to say I don't think Ben has much of a chance. I'd cut my loses in order to get the other items from them.Taking them to court would cost. They're not likely to capitulate in the face of such action as its not like going up against an individual or a company, they have tax payers money to cover their legal expenses. There is also no guarantee that the court would find in Ben's favour.
I'd forget about the media being useful. Its a knife... do I really need to say any more in the current climate?
It sucks :(
Well Neil maybe I was talking aloud ;) if it were me I would take it all the way as that knife by definition is not a gravity knife per sa :D
After all I can just go to heinnie's and get this which is very similar http://www.heinnie.com/g8kXxc432774/Knives/Gerber/Gerber-Firestorm/p-92-144-1033/
But that's just me I don't give up too easily when it comes to a wrong doing

All I can say customs have gone flipping mad these days but the good news is they don't always get away with it in court >:D
-
I'm all for standing behind a principle and running with it.. if you've got the cash upfront to do so :-\
-
Here's an example of their madness :D
I got this last year for a fun knife to play with although it had been opened by customs it's in my possession >:D
The thing is I think they looked at it and couldn't decide if it were a bird or a knife
dim wits :D

Anyway I hope you get it back Ben here's hoping they come to their senses sooner rather than later

-
@Neil said:
I'm all for standing behind a principle and running with it.. if you've got the cash upfront to do so :-\No cash upfront needed what I would do is collect as much info as possible before entering court and in the likely outcome being in my favour costs would go to them oh! wait I mean tax payers ;)
-
I'm all for standing behind a principle and running with it.. if you've got the cash upfront to do so :-\
No cash upfront needed what I would do is collect as much info as possible before entering court and in the likely outcome being in my favour costs would go to them oh! wait I mean tax payers ;)
Is that the likely outcome though? I'd hope so but I wouldn't want to bet my solvency on the fact. The defence that everyone else is selling them might not win the case. The prosecution standing there with the knife in question and flicking it open might be all the magistrate needs to find in their favour :(
I'm not saying your wrong and I'm certainly not arguing against the principle of what you're saying. I'm just saying that having to explain to my family why we're selling the house is not something I'd personally risk :D
I have heard of cases that have been successfully appealed but they seem to be a minority. Once they've drawn their line they normally stick with it :(
-
Benner
Is their a "knife" related organization in the UK that could get behind the issue at hand and request letters from other knife ornersand also storm any hearings that may be held?
-
I'm all for standing behind a principle and running with it.. if you've got the cash upfront to do so :-\
No cash upfront needed what I would do is collect as much info as possible before entering court and in the likely outcome being in my favour costs would go to them oh! wait I mean tax payers ;)
That's all very well and good, but the process of appeal starts off with you stating your legal representation which I would do if I was loaded and didn't have a family to think off but I have to be realistic. This is a £40ish knife which is not worth the risk. As much as I hate it, it just isn't.
As far as challenging is concerned, I have explained in my letter about it being available to buy here in the UK and that it can also be fixed under warranty here too, but TBH I know I am wasting my time. I have left it saying that if they still see fit I will forfeit it but that I need that other stuff back. My focus now is not losing more than I have to.
-
Is their a "knife" related organization in the UK that could get behind the issue at hand and request letters from other knife ornersand also storm any hearings that may be held?
TBH, I don't know. But like I said above, to start off the appeal you need the name of your legal representative. They also only give you one month to do all this so the pressure is on there as well.
Basically, they have me by the short and curlies and are holding my other stuff to ransom in a way.
-
Ben - FWIW I agree with you. Unless you can find a knife collecting solicitor through one of the knife forums that would take the case on for free, it would be a huge gamble.
I think I would pursue the free options (CAB, your MP etc) though.
-
I'n not making a big thing of this but! where does it say you need legal representation?
A quote from HM customs:
2.12 Do I need legal representation in court?
No. You don't have to be legally represented in court but you may want to instruct a solicitor (normally at your own expense) to act on your behalf.
That said I do understand "Ben" that it's a big hassle gathering info and conducting your own defence, and it's that where they have us shafted as most would rather not attend court in the first place and yes! a lawyer is out of most peoples reach anyway >:(
-
The letter states that to appeal they need the name of my legal representative sent to them by post within 30 days.
-
That is true, but you can do yourself a whole lot of damage representing yourself. There's a reason why solicitors get paid all that money.
Ben - have you tried the CAB? They like a good confrontation with the authorities!
-
should have had it sent in parts :P
-
@DaveK said:
That is true, but you can do yourself a whole lot of damage representing yourself. There's a reason why solicitors get paid all that money.Ben - have you tried the CAB? They like a good confrontation with the authorities!
TBH, my main focus has been to get that other stuff back so to be quick I have already sent the letter I have discussed above. I am pretty much just going to see what comes of that and go from there.
-
Yeah on the good side we are gathering info on ways to beat their ignorance of what is legal and what aint :D
I would like to get sent a cheap slip joint knife and for fun:sealed in a wooden box with gorilla glue then wound a few times in duct tape placed in another cardboard box then wrapped a few times with parcel tape and finally placed in a bubble mailer,just for some customs fun >:D
-
should have had it sent in parts :P
Yeah on the good side we are gathering info on ways to beat their ignorance of what is legal and what aint :D
I would like to get sent a cheap slip joint knife and for fun:sealed in a wooden box with gorilla glue then wound a few times in duct tape placed in another cardboard box then wrapped a few times with parcel tape and finally placed in a bubble mailer,just for some customs fun >:D
I know you were joking, but if my experience does help someone else out it would ease the anger a little. :D I know John would feel the same as well.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
