Show your slip joint's thread!
-
I had ordered a couple Rough Rider slips a few days back and they arrived yesterday. These two were bought on a whim really. I like red bone, and I like smooth bone.....Red Smooth Bone is even better. And these two were sitting at $9.00 a piece with Free Shipping so I said what the hell. Glad I did! I've been a fan of RR's since their release, you can't beat the quality for the money.


The Stockman is their medium size one at 3 1/2" closed. The Trapper is fullsize at 4 1/8" closed. They both have RR's 440A stainless blades with matchstriker pulls, grooved nickle/silver bolsters, nickle/silver Horseshoe shield, brass liners and pins, and gorgeous Red Smooth Bone scales.


Fit and finish on both are exceptional, especially given their $9.00 price tags. Very little to fault either over. Both have virtually gap free fit all around, nice polish on the blades and bolsters, all blades have even grinds and very sharp edges, both knives sport relatively stout backsprings, both knives have pins polished flush to the scales, and there is no perceivable blade play on any of them.
The Stockman does have a slight hairline gap between the mainblade's backspring and the brass liner, up towards the pivot end about a 1/4" long. Faint and doesn't effect anything, very minor.....

The Trapper is seamless in it's backspring fit.......

......though the Trapper does have a tiny blemish. On the shield side scale there is a small nick in the bone next to the center pin. A very minor cosmetic issue.
All in all great slipjoints for the money, and two prime examples of what the RR's can be. And at this price point.....unmatched quality for what they are.
2xTap

-
Well, you got that for a steal....$38.00 for a NIB anything from GEC is a bargain at it's best.
So which Tidoute #73 did you get, Jack or Scout, and what handle material?
2xTap
It's a Scout model. Bocote wood scales. The only other wooden scale slipjoint I have is an old "tested" stamped Case that was my Grandpa's knife. I always liked wooden scales on a knife and at 38 bucks I couldn't pass it up. I'm still eye balling some #53's though. Just waiting for a deal on something that I "have to have".
By the way 2xTap I love reading your posts on knifeforums in The Slip Joint. I've been a member there for a while now but just lurk and never post.
-
GMArthur,
A Bocote #73 Scout for $38.00.......I'd of jumped on it too. You got that one at a great price. Look forward to seeing pics of it.
Glad you enjoy my ramblings over there. Feel free to jump in anywhere over there and post. It's a good forum with good people who all enjoy the same thing. The more the merrier.......we all have fallen to the "Dark Side" so join on in!

2xTap
-
Perhaps this is blasphemy but does anyone have/like the OHO Case....I like the looks of them....
-

This one and a friend is up in the swap shop at the moment. Perhaps someone has an interesting USA made slippie they'd like to swap? Just a thought, it'd be nice to play with something a bit different.
-
You'll never, ever break one either

-
I got one of those. :D
-
Managed to get some pics done of a few in my recent haul............
Rough Rider Fancy Congress in Mother of Pearl with Abalone shield:

Rough Rider Large Stockman in smooth Yellow Delrin:

Rough Rider "Man Series" Large Stockman in Blue Smooth Bone:

Rough Rider Large Stockman in Mother of Pearl with nickle/silver spacers:

Marble's "Global Series" Jumbo Trapper in Brown Stag Bone:

I got a few more I still need to take pics of. Great quality knives for the money here!

2xTap
-
Well I received my Tidioute #73 yesterday. I have to say that this is by far the dullest knife that I've ever handled. I honestly have spoons in my kitchen that are sharper. I'm starting the process of trying to put an edge on the blades. My sharpening ability is such that I can maintain an already established edge very well by freehanding, but when starting from scratch where basically no edge bevel exists I'm having a hard time.
I do have to say that from my first impressions of this GEC slipjoint I doubt I will get another from this company. It's a shame as I was looking for a nice single blade with a stag handle. I like GEC's stag much better than what Case offers, but at least the Case knife would be able to cut something. If I manage to get an edge on the blades I will post up some pics of my success. If not then I'll take it in to the machine shop at work and use the belt sander to try and put an edge on it. I will post pics of the destruction that causes as well.
-
Well, I'll throw in a couple more of mine. This is my Kissing Crane Congress, and a Rough Rider Sawcut Bone Stockman. As you can see, the Stockman is...large... :D

-
@GMArthur said:
Well I received my Tidioute #73 yesterday. I have to say that this is by far the dullest knife that I've ever handled. I honestly have spoons in my kitchen that are sharper. I'm starting the process of trying to put an edge on the blades. My sharpening ability is such that I can maintain an already established edge very well by freehanding, but when starting from scratch where basically no edge bevel exists I'm having a hard time.I do have to say that from my first impressions of this GEC slipjoint I doubt I will get another from this company. It's a shame as I was looking for a nice single blade with a stag handle. I like GEC's stag much better than what Case offers, but at least the Case knife would be able to cut something. If I manage to get an edge on the blades I will post up some pics of my success. If not then I'll take it in to the machine shop at work and use the belt sander to try and put an edge on it. I will post pics of the destruction that causes as well.
Maybe yours missed quality control ???
I'd shoot them an email mate, and see if they sort it out for you :)
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Well I received my Tidioute #73 yesterday. I have to say that this is by far the dullest knife that I've ever handled. I honestly have spoons in my kitchen that are sharper. I'm starting the process of trying to put an edge on the blades. My sharpening ability is such that I can maintain an already established edge very well by freehanding, but when starting from scratch where basically no edge bevel exists I'm having a hard time.
I do have to say that from my first impressions of this GEC slipjoint I doubt I will get another from this company. It's a shame as I was looking for a nice single blade with a stag handle. I like GEC's stag much better than what Case offers, but at least the Case knife would be able to cut something. If I manage to get an edge on the blades I will post up some pics of my success. If not then I'll take it in to the machine shop at work and use the belt sander to try and put an edge on it. I will post pics of the destruction that causes as well.
Maybe yours missed quality control ???
I'd shoot them an email mate, and see if they sort it out for you :)
I did email them. However there was so many things wrong that I just began fixing the knife myself. I was planning on the knife being a user so I'm not that picky about the little fit and finish issues. I cannot stand getting a dull knife though. If your in the knife manufacturing business and can't put at least a solid working edge on your knives you won't last long. I've gotten a few Cases that had wire edges or might not have been as sharp as I would like them, but at least they could cut something and only needed a touch up. I don't have a diamond benchstone so I've been working on sharpening up a single blade on the #73 for hours and I'm not there yet. I will see what reply the folks at GEC send me, but I really think I'll stick with Case from now on.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Well I received my Tidioute #73 yesterday. I have to say that this is by far the dullest knife that I've ever handled. I honestly have spoons in my kitchen that are sharper. I'm starting the process of trying to put an edge on the blades. My sharpening ability is such that I can maintain an already established edge very well by freehanding, but when starting from scratch where basically no edge bevel exists I'm having a hard time.
I do have to say that from my first impressions of this GEC slipjoint I doubt I will get another from this company. It's a shame as I was looking for a nice single blade with a stag handle. I like GEC's stag much better than what Case offers, but at least the Case knife would be able to cut something. If I manage to get an edge on the blades I will post up some pics of my success. If not then I'll take it in to the machine shop at work and use the belt sander to try and put an edge on it. I will post pics of the destruction that causes as well.
Maybe yours missed quality control ???
I'd shoot them an email mate, and see if they sort it out for you :)
I did email them. However there was so many things wrong that I just began fixing the knife myself. I was planning on the knife being a user so I'm not that picky about the little fit and finish issues. I cannot stand getting a dull knife though. If your in the knife manufacturing business and can't put at least a solid working edge on your knives you won't last long. I've gotten a few Cases that had wire edges or might not have been as sharp as I would like them, but at least they could cut something and only needed a touch up. I don't have a diamond benchstone so I've been working on sharpening up a single blade on the #73 for hours and I'm not there yet. I will see what reply the folks at GEC send me, but I really think I'll stick with Case from now on.
At least with Case the qualities assured :)
And I agree, they should of at least put a decent edge/bevel on it ::)
-
I did get a nice prompt reply from GEC this morning. They said I could send the knife in with a note describing the problem(s) and they would take care of it for me. This is good. It's nice they stand by their product. I'll probably work on the edge a bit more tonight and if I can't get it where i want I'll send it in and let them have a go at it.
-
@GMArthur said:
I did get a nice prompt reply from GEC this morning. They said I could send the knife in with a note describing the problem(s) and they would take care of it for me. This is good. It's nice they stand by their product. I'll probably work on the edge a bit more tonight and if I can't get it where i want I'll send it in and let them have a go at it.Keep us updated please mate

-
GMArthur,
Sorry to hear your first GEC had problems......that is not normal from them. Of all the ones I own I have not had any F&F issues with them. Matter of fact all the ones I own have had a superb level of fit and finish. As to their edges, they don't come with wide beveled super thin edges. All of mine have usable edges but not razor sharp.
Like in your case I have heard from others that theirs have come dull, or at least not as sharp as they expect. It's a shame it came the way it did, hopefully they will get it squared away promply for you.
Mike,
You mention with Case how their quality is assured. Well, not quite. Case has had some issues over the years with subpar knives getting out. Just like any company sometimes lemons get through. They have good customer service and most problems get rectified, but they are far from perfect.
I own somewhere in the ballpark of a couple hundred Case knives, I have a few with some issues. Nothing major, but they all don't come perfect. One of my most recent Case acquisitions that arrived late last week actually has a gouge in one of the bone scales......looks like a mess up during the jigging process.
Granted, these are the exceptions and not the rule.....but it does happen even with the best companies.
2xTap
-
I'm going to mail out the knife to GEC tomorrow. It would probably be faster to just drive it to them as I only live a couple of hours away, but I'm lazy :-\
I've had bummer knives from many companies. It's how the company handles the customers concerns that matters. If the knife comes back with a decent user edge and they can fix the spring issues then I'll be happy. As far as the knife goes though, I love the design. It's a great size with really useful blade shapes. I think for a hunter this model is the tops. If they can get me straight I'm sure the knife will see many a field dressing. It's a shame as I'm going bow hunting this weekend. Looks like the Case stockman gets the job again. I'll be sure to post here when I get the knife back.
This thread has been derailed. Nothing new here at MT.org. We now say goodbye to the whiner and his slipjoint problems. Feel free to carry on with your regularly scheduled posting. Show your slippies!
-
Just a quick update in case anybody still cares.
The good news - Superfast turnaround over at GEC. I think it took 3 days total to get my knife back from the day I mailed it.
The bad news - I guess that nobody over at GEC can get an edge on my knife either. It was returned to me with a note saying "blades have been sharpened". I was unable to cut paper or my thumb with either blade and believe me I was really trying to see if it could cut my thumb.
So I guess if you don't mind sharpening your brand new knife GEC would be fine. For me it's not acceptable. There are too many quality knife manufacturers who will ship me a sharp knife to be hassled with buying dull ones. I'll post this knife for trade on a couple knife forums and see if I can't find a Boker Copperhead or Case Saddlehorn which are next on my list.
-
It's a shame to hear that. For me the very least a knife can do is be able to cut things, otherwise can you really call it a knife?
-
What are your thoughts on Hen and Rooster ? I ask because I really like this one :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool:
Dunc
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login