Polite discussion on.........
-
I think a polite discussion of religion is a good thing- if indeed it's possible. Let's give it a shot, but try to keep it civil as this thread will be very closely monitored.
Sorry to have to do this, but we have a good thing going here and I'd hate for anyone to start drawing any more lines between eachother than they have to.
Def
-
I have to agree that "debating" religion may end up being a little touchy. However, I would like to say that I find the topic fascinating. Not the specific doctrine of religion, per se, (that could get ugly) but the evolution of religion through time. Wow, never thought I'd get to use "evolution" and "religion" in the same sentence like that. :)
I love history and have a special interest in how religion has developed. Without going into a lot of detail, and I hope I don't get fried for this, for the most part people have always "believed" in something. Especially when they couldn't understand something. It's so interesting to me how people justified the things they couldn't understand at the time. Sun gods that controlled how the sun moved across the sky during the day. Stars, moons, seasons, love, hate, death, war...the list goes on. I think for a lot of the general "masses" it was comforting to believe that there was an all powerful being (or beings) that were controlling things that they couldn't. When those things began to be explained by science, people shifted their beliefs and put a finer point on them. Hence the emergence of single deity religions. There is all kinds of stuff out there. It could go on and on and on. There's also a very distinct shift from the "idea" of the female deity to that of a dominating male deity as humans and society moved through time, civilizations, war, etc.
Again, don't blast me for this...it's just interesting to me. And there is much much more in between what I've tried to generalize here. It's fun to learn about if you're into that kind of thing.
As for the current state of religious affairs...well I've got my own opinions on that. But I will say, that I'm a Christian. Unlike other parts of my "make up" I CHOSE that. Some people think I'm silly because I find comfort in my personal relationship with the deity that I believe in, some people think that I'm a traitor to homosexuals everywhere because of the "church's" general opinion on that, and some people think I'm betraying Christians everywhere because I'm gay. My response to all of that is that I made a choice to believe because it works for me and feels right for ME. But I'm not about to tell someone else how to believe. Do I understand all of the different beliefs out there? No, I don't. Do I agree with all of them? No, I don't. But if you take radical, fundamentalism out of the equation I believe that people should be allowed to practice their religion. I don't agree with the fact that there are travelling bands of Christian fundamentalists in this country going around telling people that they are un-Christian and hate God because they don't think that all gays, blacks, and anyone not waving a Bible around 24/7 should be taken out and shot or beaten or hung from the nearest, highest tree. Because religion is very personal. If people with the same beliefs want to get together in a building and share and talk about those beliefs with one another I think they should be allowed to do so without being afraid of being persecuted.
One thing that I would like to mention is that this is a very diverse and international forum. There are lots and lots of different people here with varied cultural identities and that should be respected and honored. We all chose to join this forum because we share a common interest in lots of things including the kitchen sink and which tool is best to fix it. :) 99% of my experience on this forum has been informative, inclusive, friendly, and down right fun. I'd just like to ask the people remember that differences make the world go round and make this place a lot of fun.
Okay, I'm done rambling. -
i believe that people should be free to believe whatever they want to believe while they dont mess with other peoples believes and specially while they dont mess with me :) ...........if olny was that easy :-\
-
@Paul said:
I think all religion should be relegated to the status of a hobby. I’m all for people believing in whatever they want, BUT why should I have to lawfully respect what are (IMO) fairy tales and beliefs that belong in the dark ages?You are entitled to your opinion of course, but why should your 'belief' that religion should be reduced to a hobby be of more importance than those who chose to believe in a god/gods? Surely if everyone has an equal right we should be able to believe what we want. And why shouldn't you respect what other people believe, you don't agree with them that's fine, but you should still respect their choice to believe what they want to. Like I (a Christian, and someone who works for a church) have complete respect for you, who obviously doesn't believe, I might think you have made the wrong decision, but you probably think I have made the wrong one too :)
-
I think all religion should be relegated to the status of a hobby. I’m all for people believing in whatever they want, BUT why should I have to lawfully respect what are (IMO) fairy tales and beliefs that belong in the dark ages?
You are entitled to your opinion of course, but why should your 'belief' that religion should be reduced to a hobby be of more importance than those who chose to believe in a god/gods? Surely if everyone has an equal right we should be able to believe what we want. And why shouldn't you respect what other people believe, you don't agree with them that's fine, but you should still respect their choice to believe what they want to. Like I (a Christian, and someone who works for a church) have complete respect for you, who obviously doesn't believe, I might think you have made the wrong decision, but you probably think I have made the wrong one too :)
Behold! The definition of tolerance, which frankly is all we need for everyone to get along just fine!
-
I think too that people should believe whatever they want, just don't force it up to anyone else. Religion is in that way just like food, cars, shoes or whatever "they" want me to buy ::) But that just how I think about it.
What I always find is funny is that for those who believe in a all powerful being or whatever, always seems to feel the need to defend that being if I suggests that it all could be a fairytail. Not so powerful afteral then that it needs your help?
Besides that, why does it seems that we can make jokes about everything but not about religion? Gives to me the impression that the believers are not so confident them selfs about it. Just thinking out loud...The fact that Def said that this thread has to be closed monitored says it all I guess...
Now, I thought to wright down a disclamer here that my post does not have the intention to insult anyone and that I'm trying to add a serious contribution to this discussion but, everybody here are very nice, openminded, polite, mature and cicvilized people and alway use there mouth and not their weapons for a argument. So no disclamer necessary :D That's what I like so much about this place :)
-
I think all religion should be relegated to the status of a hobby. I’m all for people believing in whatever they want, BUT why should I have to lawfully respect what are (IMO) fairy tales and beliefs that belong in the dark ages?
You are entitled to your opinion of course, but why should your 'belief' that religion should be reduced to a hobby be of more importance than those who chose to believe in a god/gods? Surely if everyone has an equal right we should be able to believe what we want. And why shouldn't you respect what other people believe, you don't agree with them that's fine, but you should still respect their choice to believe what they want to. Like I (a Christian, and someone who works for a church) have complete respect for you, who obviously doesn't believe, I might think you have made the wrong decision, but you probably think I have made the wrong one too :)
God point Roadie but I’m uncomfortable with people who allow themselves special treatment and privileges based upon simply what they they* believe* to be true. This type of behaviour can lead us to the kind of atrocities we have just learned about in Ireland, and god knows (pun intended) how many other atrocities throughout history.
-
I think all religion should be relegated to the status of a hobby. I’m all for people believing in whatever they want, BUT why should I have to lawfully respect what are (IMO) fairy tales and beliefs that belong in the dark ages?
You are entitled to your opinion of course, but why should your 'belief' that religion should be reduced to a hobby be of more importance than those who chose to believe in a god/gods? Surely if everyone has an equal right we should be able to believe what we want. And why shouldn't you respect what other people believe, you don't agree with them that's fine, but you should still respect their choice to believe what they want to. Like I (a Christian, and someone who works for a church) have complete respect for you, who obviously doesn't believe, I might think you have made the wrong decision, but you probably think I have made the wrong one too :)
God point Roadie but I’m uncomfortable with people who allow themselves special treatment and privileges based upon simply what they they* believe* to be true. This type of behaviour can lead us to the kind of atrocities we have just learned about in Ireland, and god knows (pun intended) how many other atrocities throughout history.
Paul,
I'm not singling you out, but I have question (maybe 2) :D What do you mean by "special treatment" and having to "lawfully respect" people who have religious beliefs? I don't know about the UK, but other than "techincally" not being allowed to discriminate on the basis of religion is the only "law" on the books in this country. Well, that and the whole free assembly thing. Why should people who have the same beliefs not be allowed to congregate and discuss or worship? I'm not talking about zealots and extremists, I'm talking about people who want to go to their respective houses of worship and worship. Shouldn't they be allowed to do that? What kind of special privileges are you referring to? I'm not attacking, just trying to understand what you mean. Whether other's believe in a deity or not, is really kind of a personal thing. People choose to believe or not and that's pefectly ok. But doesn't everyone have the right to that choice? -
Ok here is what bugs me atheists. Atheists are from my point of view the biggest group when it comes to pushing their beliefs, in fact I would say there is a war in the US between atheists and Christianity look at evolution.
Another thing NO ONE can prove god does or does not exist and weather the stories in say the bible are true or not.
As one who is into science and a Christian I can see both sides of the coin on many things and I find it dumb when people say one can’t have both god and science
-
Special treatment like this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8058224.stmbut do I really have to explain all the atrocities done in the name of god?
-
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.
-
Yud, I don't think atheism is a "belief" as such - Just as bald is not a hair colour.
It is very likely there is no god, but proving so is the same as proving there are no fairies. How do you prove a negative.
Science does not yet have all the answers, but it's an ongoing quest for truth and we must discard what contradicts science don't you think?
otherwise we leave ourselves open to all kinds of hocus pocus. Show me one scrap of evidence for god. -
Atheist here, and I learned long ago that despite how intriguing the subject, and the potential to enlighten or be enlightened, there is simply no real world benefit to engaging in dialogue regarding religion.
Peoples beliefs are very dear them and it's best left alone. The basic beliefs that people build their lives around are the bedrock of their very foundations, so it's no surprise that religious debates get so heated.
I also don't talk about politics either, for completely different reasons..the main one being apathy.
-
Personally, I have a certain degree of difficulty with organized religions. I get a very strong feeling of corporate religion from many of them--and having been raised Roman Catholic, I get an especially strong feeling from them following the pedophile cases here in the US and Ireland.
At a time when they should have been doing everything possible to heal those of the flock wounded by the events, the Vatican went into corporate mode of deny, deflect and declare ignorance of the whole thing. Very sad.
Personally, I think religion and science answer different questions. One answers questions of how things work, the other is more related to the philosophical nature of man and the significance of existence. Related, but really more parallel thought processes.
:-\
-
Me, I'll be quite frankly amazed if this thread doesn't end in tears. I really hope I'm proven wrong but ... :-\
-
TBH I don't care what people believe and if the idea of a "God" makes them happy then good for them. I don't personally believe in God, largely because of the type of person I am and because of my brother, but I'd never judge anyone or treat anyone differently because of what they believe in.
-
@Paul said:
Special treatment like this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8058224.stmbut do I really have to explain all the atrocities done in the name of god?
Whilst these stories (and there hundreds like it) are abhorrent, I don't see how there's any "special treatment" involved. It was a poor practice, certainly not justified on religious grounds, and eventually (obviously a bit late) there is now accountability being placed. I agree that any institutionalised cover-up of scandalous behaviour like that is wrong, but I don't see it as a religious issue per se.
Would muslim girls wearing head-scarves in school classrooms be a better example of your point? Or maybe Sikhs being exempted from the motorcycle helmet laws? I can't think of many examples, but maybe these are the sort of things you were getting at?
My own view on these special cases is "why not"? None of these things affect my lifestyle, and if such concessions allow people to follow their faith and feel better about themselves, what harm does it do? That's what tolerance is about, surely?
I am not a religious person, far from it, but I will always try to respect others' customs regardless of what they are. Forget religion for a moment, that just plain decent isn't it?
@Crouton said:
Atheist here, and I learned long ago that despite how intriguing the subject, and the potential to enlighten or be enlightened, there is simply no real world benefit to engaging in dialogue regarding religion.You see, I think the opposite of that. I didn't used to, but through a quirk of fate, I ended up sharing an office with a devout, practising Muslim just after 9/11. It was a bit uncomfortable at first, particularly as my colleague was a second generation Afghan. We didn't actually have any work to do, so we basically spent 6 months discussing religious philosophies. We were never going to change each other's beliefs (obviously), but I gained a whole new appreciation of what Islam is really all about. And you know what? It's no different to any other religion I've come across, and as has been pointed out already today - the similarities in customs and principles is remarkably similar! I found it absolutely fascinating and consider myself a better person for knowing the things that he taught me, and being able to see things from a different view point.
My friend was a very religious man who spent most of his spare time preaching the "true" values of the Koran, organising charitable events and just being downright nice. He was ashamed of some of the things that make the news done by in his words "not real Muslims". This was a guy who was proud to call himself British and felt that he didn't need to compromise his beliefs at all to be happy here.
I do think sometimes that when we here that someone is "religious", we imagine radical or even fundamentalist attitudes, which 99% of the time simply isn't the case.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Personally, I think religion and science answer different questions. One answers questions of how things work, the other is more related to the philosophical nature of man and the significance of existence. Related, but really more parallel thought processes.:-\
I dissagree, since a natural and ethical existance can be lived without beleif in the supernatural. Our significance of being here is relevant to us but I don't think it has any real significance in the cosmos, and the supernatural certainly has no place in the truth, which is what I hope we all are looking for.
-
See you doubters....
We can keep it polite
up to now >:D he he
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





