Polite discussion on.........
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Personally, I think religion and science answer different questions. One answers questions of how things work, the other is more related to the philosophical nature of man and the significance of existence. Related, but really more parallel thought processes.:-\
I dissagree, since a natural and ethical existance can be lived without beleif in the supernatural. Our significance of being here is relevant to us but I don't think it has any real significance in the cosmos, and the supernatural certainly has no place in the truth, which is what I hope we all are looking for.
-
See you doubters....
We can keep it polite
up to now >:D he he
-
@yud said:
Ok here is what bugs me atheists. Atheists are from my point of view the biggest group when it comes to pushing their beliefs, in fact I would say there is a war in the US between atheists and Christianity look at evolution.Another thing NO ONE can prove god does or does not exist and weather the stories in say the bible are true or not.
As one who is into science and a Christian I can see both sides of the coin on many things and I find it dumb when people say one can’t have both god and science
This is the closest I think anyone has come to my personal views, with the exception that I am a filthy heathen, not a Christian, although I was baptized Catholic and did attend religious studies throughout school. I was also an English major and an amateur historian, plus as a voracious reader, I have read many different holy books, and interpretations of those books. Which means precisely nothing when it comes to the weight and/or importance of my opinions, it just means that I can usually carry on a decent conversation with just about anyone on this topic.
To me, the most important passage in the Bible is
Psalm 37:39-40 “The salvation of the righteous is from the
Lord; he is their refuge in the time of trouble. The Lord
helps them and rescues them; he rescues them from the
wicked, and saves them, because they take refuge in him.”This one is most commonly interpreted as "The Lord Helps Those Who Help Themselves" which is what I consider to be the foundation of everything I do. I could sit here and pray that something happens, or doesn't happen, and hope that God, whether He exists or not, will help, or I can get up off my arse and do it myself. I find that accomplishes a lot more than waiting for Him to do it!
While I don't personally believe there is a God, I don't necessarily disbelieve either. If God exists, as the Good Book says, then by it's own admission, there is no way we could understand, or interpret His designs, which makes me lose a certain amount of ground on organized religion. We have even less possibility of understanding Him than an amoeba has understanding the complex ecosystem of the jungles of South America. From that perspective, the Church, being a creation of Man, is flawed and could be headed in exactly the wrong direction. I draw a definite line between God and the Church for a variety of reasons.
Of course that doesn't mean the Church is wrong- any organization that makes an effort to improve the lives of others is a good thing in my book. And, while I personally cannot hold much faith in the writings of the various Apostles, I can be sure that whatever God wants of us, He wants us to do it together. Otherwise, what kind of God would He be? Certainly not the type of God we have been led to believe He was anyway.
I also feel that the decline of Western Civilization has a lot to do with the fact that most folks simply don't go to church or have any faith. Again, while I personally have no interest in Church or organized religions, I do feel that the sense of unity that was instilled in people made society into the type of place where you could let your kids play in and around the neighborhood with little worry about their safety, or leave your doors unlocked. There is a major set of values that is missing from the world today, and much of that can be attributed to the Godlessness of the average person.
Lastly, there is the issue of faith. People have managed to accomplish things based on faith that they wouldn't have been able to otherwise. Faith gives one the strength to get up in the mornings despite depression or other problems and gives people the energy to achieve things. Whether this is God working through/with them or whether it's their way of positive affirmation makes no difference as whatever they intended to do was done. "God" at that point is a matter of interpretation, and each person should be free to interpret these things in whatever way they see fit- because none of us has God whispering in their ears, telling us what is right and wrong.
I hope that didn't offend anyone. I debated posting it as I'd really hate to stir the pot for no reason.
Def
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Personally, I think religion and science answer different questions. One answers questions of how things work, the other is more related to the philosophical nature of man and the significance of existence. Related, but really more parallel thought processes.
:-\
I dissagree, since a natural and ethical existance can be lived without beleif in the supernatural. Our significance of being here is relevant to us but I don't think it has any real significance in the cosmos, and the supernatural certainly has no place in the truth, which is what I hope we all are looking for.
What you consider "truth". Things such as beauty, truth, morality don't have a scientific explanation. Their significance lies in philosophy, of which religion plays a role. ("Good", "bad", "right", "wrong", "beautiful", "ugly", etc all have a moral/philosophical dimension and whether you choose to use a recognized religion or not, they can be fairly and legitimately described in a religious framework--and still have proper meaning)
Your choice to exclude classic religious constructs in your consideration of these dimensions is legimate, but no moreso than someone who wishes to express them in a Native American relgious construct, for example.
-
I consider myself being an atheist. Or, even more, an agnostic. I believe in the Superman theory. Short version:
If I had the power to timetravel, and hand a Superman comic to some poor sheperds some hundred or even thousand years ago, play some magic tricks and leave, they will believe in me being divine and when I get back to my time there would be a Superman religion. It would have millions of followers for I gave those sheperds some miracles and someone to follow.
Yes, that is stupid, but imho not more stupid than real religions believing in human-born gods, elephant gods, giant arcs for all animals, gardens full of virgins or whatever. If there is no proof I do not believe in it. Sorry, I do not want to make jokes about anyones religion, I respect every religion. I just do not believe myself.
Religion tends to determine people to follow a path to achieve a better live or paradise or whatever you call it. I do not want to be determined, I want to believe in free will.
[tt]No offend mates, just my 2 cents.[/tt] -
@Mr. Whippy said:
Your choice to exclude classic religious constructs in your consideration of these dimensions is legimate, but no moreso than someone who wishes to express them in a Native American relgious construct, for example.With respect I'm not sure I understand your statement here ???, but here goes:
My exclusion of religion in this point is known as 'Occam's Razor' (look it up) and is only used to emphasise that religion is not necessary for an ethical and moral life. Nor is it necessary to appreciate art, love, philosophy, beauty etc. In fact religion stifles values like learning and free thinking by claiming it is "the truth" and therfore claiming more than it can possibly know or justify. On the other hand science does not claim to know everything - that is it's strength - but it works within a framework without fairies goblins and other nonsensicle beliefs in the search of truth.
PS
Have you noticed that people very often offer "no offence" to the religious, as if they feel they have to apologise for thier stance on the supernatural. Never had a religious person apologise to me for thier beliefs in god. -
For any type of religion the following is true....
"For believers - no proof is necessary, for doubters - no proof is enough"
Now I myself am a humanist. I believe in the good of "people" and that most people are basically good and want to "live and let live".
However, I have seen too many "evil" acts to fully believe this. I have seen in my job the best that people can do, and also the worst in people.
Sometimes, some are just born bad.
Now when it comes to sectionalising people into Jew, Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Sikh, Budhist, Straight, Gay, transgendered, tall, short, dark brown to light beige and every colour in between......you can stuff it all as far as I am concerned.
I look at THAT person, and attempt to understand THEIR intention and THAT is how I judge a person (not that my judgement means much
)religion has inspired man to do his very best, and his very worst. (Man being "humans" and not a gender specific noun).
Just my thought,
Nick
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Your choice to exclude classic religious constructs in your consideration of these dimensions is legimate, but no moreso than someone who wishes to express them in a Native American relgious construct, for example.
With respect I'm not sure I understand your statement here ???, but here goes:
My exclusion of religion in this point is known as 'Occam's Razor' (look it up) and is only used to emphasise that religion is not necessary for an ethical and moral life. Nor is it necessary to appreciate art, love, philosophy, beauty etc. In fact religion stifles values like learning and free thinking by claiming it is "the truth" and therfore claiming more than it can possibly know or justify. On the other hand science does not claim to know everything - that is it's strength - but it works within a framework without fairies goblins and other nonsensicle beliefs in the search of truth.
I know Occam's Razor quite well. It is, however, one of the cornerstones of the scientific method--not of philosophy. Again, you do others who view the world as something more than a scientific model a disservice.
There is no adequate scientific explanation of the concept of beauty, or right/wrong or morality. These are not in the realm of the scientific method. They are in the realm of philosophy. However you choose to define good/evil, it cannot be supported by scientific modelling. Once you place moral value on something, it steps out of the scientific model and into a philosophical one.
In this respect, you have a belief system that defines good/evil (beauty/lack of it , etc) which may or may not include a god or supernatural being. Regardless, you cannot make a scientific claim on your belief system to be more right or less right based on Occam's Razor (or Ockham's Razor), than someone else who's morality is based on a monotheistic or polytheistic system.
Again, I have strong adherence to the scientific model of the physical world, but I do not for one minute think that the scientific model fully explains the human experience. (Unless you consider civilization a cruel hoax in the same fashion as religion).
-
A nice thought it is too Flash, but I imagine one tiny morsel of proof of god would satisfy alot of doubters!
-
@Paul said:
A nice thought it is too Flash, but I imagine one tiny morsel of proof of god would satisfy alot of doubters!would it?????or would it be put down to some unknown as yet natural phenomenon.
Electricity 200 years ago would have made you a God amongst mortals, but for a few who would question it.
Remember the ultimate MAN...James Tiberius Kirk, who in the final frontier questioned God....and then went on to prove what other believed blindly in their faith to be God to actually be a hoax. ;)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Your choice to exclude classic religious constructs in your consideration of these dimensions is legimate, but no moreso than someone who wishes to express them in a Native American relgious construct, for example.
With respect I'm not sure I understand your statement here ???, but here goes:
My exclusion of religion in this point is known as 'Occam's Razor' (look it up) and is only used to emphasise that religion is not necessary for an ethical and moral life. Nor is it necessary to appreciate art, love, philosophy, beauty etc. In fact religion stifles values like learning and free thinking by claiming it is "the truth" and therfore claiming more than it can possibly know or justify. On the other hand science does not claim to know everything - that is it's strength - but it works within a framework without fairies goblins and other nonsensicle beliefs in the search of truth.
Again, I have strong adherence to the scientific model of the physical world, but I do not for one minute think that the scientific model fully explains the human experience. (Unless you consider civilization a cruel hoax in the same fashion as religion).
I think you could be making the common mistake of filling the gaps in science with god/religion by default. Philosophy and science are compatible though - indeed crucial.
-
@Paul said:
I think you could be making the common mistake of filling the gaps in science with god/religion by default. Philosophy and science are compatible though - indeed crucial.No, you're making the mistake that philosophy can have only one right answer--like science. How you define good and evil is purely subjective based on your belief system (with or without a God). Same as a Buddist, Hindu, Catholic etc. You may reject their belief system for defining morally right or wrong, but equally, they can reject yours with similar validity. There is no proof of morality. It is subjective, and ever changing.
-
Well said Grant!
People find their "reason" in different ways. Some in hard science, some in philosophy, and some in religion. I agree that religion is a fascinating topic. Granted, there are many many civilizations who began around a "religion" and then changed and evolved often against the rules of the Church. But IMO, Church and religion are two different things.
With regard to the report in Ireland, I fail to see the "special treatment". And I'm pretty sure that the people who committed those horrible crimes did not ask either the church or the public for permission. But those crimes were committed by humans in a church. Not a religious belief. And all religions everywhere have followers that can and should be called corrupt and hipocritical. But judging a whole religion on the basis of a few isn't logical.
I'm not a conventional Christian according to most of the church's where I live because I listen to and respect other points of view. I was practically kicked out of church as a teenager because I dared to ask my pastor "how do we as Christians know that we are right when there are more than a dozen other religions out there that believe that they are". When speaking of atrocities committed in the name of a god, Christianity, Islam, Judaism, polytheistic Greeks, Egyptians, Romans, don't have a leg to stand on when condemning others for those acts. If you take religion out of the equation completely, humans are still humans. They act in very predictable ways to all kinds of things. And I personally believe that if you take religion away completely, if there were no knowledge of it at all that, even today eventually it would surface again in some form or another. People exercise their free will everyday. Free will is the most precious gift that we were given, according to Christianity. Does it bite us in the butt at times? Oh yeah! But we are all still free to exercise it.
And here's a question, not to prove any point I'm trying to make but just because: If there is no religion at all, if there never was...what would constitute right or wrong? Good or evil? How would the rules that we live by in any society be established? If there is no concept of religion is there a concept of right or wrong? It seems to me that humans are hardwired to believe in something otherwise we wouldn't have a reference for what is right or wrong. We would simply be acting on animal instinct. The ability for our minds to reason and question is how religion evolved in the first place. I think. -
@GraysonK said:
And here's a question, not to prove any point I'm trying to make but just because: ** If there is no religion at all, if there never was...what would constitute right or wrong? Good or evil? How would the rules that we live by in any society be established? If there is no concept of religion is there a concept of right or wrong? It seems to me that humans are hardwired to believe in something otherwise we wouldn't have a reference for what is right or wrong. We would simply be acting on animal instinct. ** The ability for our minds to reason and question is how religion evolved in the first place. I think.Precisely. ;)
-
This makes an untrue assumtion: that religion has a monopoly on "right and wrong" ...it does not.
Do you honestly believe that we would of wiped ourselves out if it wasn't for religion?
People with 21st century weapons and religious beliefs in the 14th could well wipe us out though. >:(
-
@Paul said:
This makes an untrue assumtion: that religion has a monopoly on "right and wrong" ...it does not.
Do you honestly believe that we would of wiped ourselves out if it wasn't for religion?
People with 21st century weapons and religious beliefs in the 14th could well wipe us out though. >:(
No...
I believe you are defining philosophy as having to be devoid of a theistic basis. What KGrayson and I are saying is, morality is subjective and can be derived of a theistic or atheistic basis. Both are valid, since both are subjective. It is what the group decides is pertinent to them which selects belief system--not an inherent rightness or wrongness of concept.
-
@Paul said:
This makes an untrue assumtion: that religion has a monopoly on "right and wrong" ...it does not.
Do you honestly believe that we would of wiped ourselves out if it wasn't for religion?
People with 21st century weapons and religious beliefs in the 14th could well wipe us out though. >:(
Actually, that wasn't the assumption I was making. I was asking if there was another source. I honestly hadn't ever thought of it before. I'm open to the idea that right or wrong isn't founded in religion, but was asking where then it comes from. Out of legitimate curiousity not mockingly or challenging any of your established thought.
I also didn't say or mean to suggest that we would have "wiped ourselves out if it wasn't for religion". I said that we seem to be hardwired to explain things or live by rules that we have no or very little understanding of where those "rules" come from.
You seem to have no problem acknowledging the existence of religion in past centuries...is it merely this one in which you wish that it would be done away with completely? If religion is so wrong according to scientific construct then were did it come from? And why has it lasted so long? And why do people continue to practice it when they've had the option for centuries to do away with it? Humans in positions of power, yes, have used religion as a way of controlling the masses and in some cases (sadly) still do it today. People with 21st century weapons would have wiped each other out anyway regardless of religion in centuries well before and after the 14th. -
While i'm against organized religion i feel that there is something that binds all of creation. There is something to whole evil and good battle that has been going on since man walked the earth. It's a shame that religion and war are usually in the same sentence.
Until i figure out what that "something " is i tend to steer clear of the collection plate.
Funny thing is i have southern baptists on my moms side and LDS on my dads side. Man did i hate church as a kid. Bunch of geezers tellin me i'm goin to hell in a handbasket.
-
What color is your handbasket? Mine's blue with red flames up the side... :D
Def
-
just as bald is not a hair colour" true but it can be a style
I can not show you that god is there, if you can't see him I can't make you, sorry.
Proof is hard since to me since to me life its self is proof, no one that I know of has come up with a way to make life or even how it could be done so that to me is proof
sorry I've got to go I'll pick this up later
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login








