Polite discussion on.........
-
The most horrific religion in history is Communism.
True Believers deny that Communism is a religion, but consider how well that description fits the facts.
Supposedly based on scientific analysis of economics and history, it is in fact a Faith Based belief system premised on an overly simplistic worldview, promising to deliver Paradise on Earth.
Its Great Prophet was Marx.
Its Great Messiah was Lenin.
Its Apostles were Stalin, Mao, Castro, Pol Pot, etc. who worked to spread the True Faith far and wide across the globe.
Like most religions, it needed a Great Satan in opposition to everything good: Capitalism.
The Communist Religion killed more people during the 20th Century than all previous religious wars in all of history combined. Exact numbers may never be obtainable, but historians generally agree that somewhere between 50 and 100 Million people were killed by Communist wars, mass executions, forced relocations, purposeful famines, destructive labor camps, and other means.
Communism crushed the basic human freedoms of hundreds of millions of people who fell under its sway. It also retarded progress, locked countless millions into poverty, and produced massive environmental degradation that still persists in Eastern Europe.
Yet, despite this lamentable record, there are still plenty of True Believers.
.
-
"it needed a Great Satan in opposition to everything good: Capitalism."
I'll agree with that capitalism is very bad its ruining the USA.
-
now we jump to politics :D
Capitalism is a good idea in theory and so is Communism
now people on the other hand, people is f**ked up :-\
-
Sooo... I can't touch this topic with but a ten foot pole for various reasons... but I've been noticing for several years now that faith can often become ignorance, which leaves the human condition stagnant. I'm not saying you can't believe in a higher power... it just shouldn't get in the way of science, of which you learn by observing facts (a most sensible system is it not... why do people call it into question?), is all... :D
And as much as I'd like to call communism a relgion it is not. From its creation it was never meant to be such, and the only reason the system doesn't work is because of humanity.

And a shoutout to Poncho65... no offense, but that video was stupid. :D :P
Instead of getting me to think it got me rolling my eyes a lot. ::)EDIT: I forgot my disclaimer! If you've ever been offended by my posts, or thought of me as a bigot or racist - I have a simple explanation. I do not hate you for your race, creed, color, or beliefs. I merely think that humans are morons. :D
It's the only belief that's proven itself to me time and time again... sadly. :(
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
No, you're making the mistake that philosophy can have only one right answer--like science. How you define good and evil is purely subjective based on your belief system (with or without a God). Same as a Buddist, Hindu, Catholic etc. You may reject their belief system for defining morally right or wrong, but equally, they can reject yours with similar validity. There is no proof of morality. It is subjective, and ever changing.Nah, Neither philosophy or science have one right answer as you assert, as both subjects evolve - unlike faith which is blind and static. Good and bad are of collective (not subjective) significance with a good Darwinian explanation.
We could have our wires crossed here and be saying similar things.......not sure of you point
-
This thread has stayed pretty civil , on most other forums it would have turned pretty nasty .
Chris
-
@Paul said:
Nah, Neither philosophy or science have one right answer as you assert, as both subjects evolve - unlike faith which is blind and static. Good and bad are of collective (not subjective) significance with a good Darwinian explanation.We could have our wires crossed here and be saying similar things.......not sure of you point
This is simply wrong. Science has singular answers. When an answer is incomplete, it is modified to a BETTER answer, replacing the previous answer. That is a cornerstone of the scientific method and is a corollary of Occam's Razor.
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different.
...and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Nah, Neither philosophy or science have one right answer as you assert, as both subjects evolve - unlike faith which is blind and static. Good and bad are of collective (not subjective) significance with a good Darwinian explanation.
We could have our wires crossed here and be saying similar things.......not sure of you point
This is simply wrong. Science has singular answers. When an answer is incomplete, it is modified to a BETTER answer, replacing the previous answer. That is a cornerstone of the scientific method and is a corollary of Occam's Razor.
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different.
...and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
You said it WAY better than I did. :)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different....and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
Morals can come from philosophy or religion - agreed, but you seem to be saying that these are one and the same thing?
Phlosophy is based on reason and inquiry while religion discourages it. -
I'm gone for a couple of days and the whole place erupts into a religious/political argument. I must be the ducktape that holds this place together. :D :D
Anyway, I'm not going to delve into politics and economics. If you want to see how capitalism VS communism compares look at the 20th century and see who won. ;) ;)
I do want to address a few things though. One, that "religion is stagnant and blind". 1st of all you're assuming that being religious means ignoring science. Quit assuming. I'm religious but I certainly don't think the world is flat or that the sun revolves around the Earth. God gave us brains and I'm sure he wants us to use them.
And "religion is a hobby and can't be proved"? Well atheism can't be proven either. However, if you open your eyes and look at near death experiences, ghost sightings, ESP and other "paranormal" things, there IS evidence of things existing that science CANNOT account for. Now whether you want to accept that evidence is quite a different story. But it IS there.
However, to suggest that what I believe is fairy tales just because it can't be proven scientifically proven(regardless of the fact that YOUR stance can't be proven either) is insulting. Quit being arrogant and assuming you're "smarter and more enlightened" than religious people. Arrogant atheists are as annoying as self righteous religious people. That is a funny way to start a "polite" conversation.
One last thing. As far as you don't think you should have to lawfully respect my beliefs? Well yes, that is the basic concept of FREEDOM. You do what you want and I'll do what I want. I'll respect your beliefs and you respect mine. I certainly don't agree with your beliefs but I would fight and die to protect your right to believe that way. It's wrong for ANYONE to force their religious(or non-religious) beliefs on anyone. Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Atheist etc etc.
The next 2 paragraphs are what I believe. I do not feel the need to force them on you nor do I feel the need to defend them. If you want you can skip them.
I consider myself a Christian but that's misleading. I was raised Catholic and over the years I have been Protestant, agnostic, "generically religious" and even flirted with other things. I guess I would classify as a Christian Universalist. I don't believe in Hell. I believe that the concept of an "eternal microwave" was NOT taught by Christ and the early church. That all came from bad translating and pagan concepts into the Christian church.
The concept of the eternal microwave and hypocritical Christians are the two biggest problems that most non-religious people have with God. I've never met anyone who has a problem with what Jesus taught, it's what his followers have taught that they have a problem with. And that's a shame. Jesus came to save the world, not divide it.
-
But religion is practiced by people who can't help but inquire and reason, even about their religion. At one point in time, yes religion played a major role in controlling others, but it was done by those in charge who didn't know any other way to control their people except to tell them that they had an immortal soul and then scare them into believing that if the didn't follow the rules set forth by their leaders then they risked their souls burning forever. (I'm speaking of Christianity here because I'm most familiar with it) While it's true that some still try to control their congregations through scare tactics, by and large people started questioning, reasoning, and discovering for themselves what they want to believe.
Well said, DTT. And welcome back. I hope all is well. :)
-
I agree with "It's wrong for ANYONE to force their religious(or non-religious) beliefs on anyone." 100%.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different.
...and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
Morals can come from philosophy or religion - agreed, but you seem to be saying that these are one and the same thing?
Phlosophy is based on reason and inquiry while religion discourages it.Depends on the religion, now doesn't it? Seems to me you attribute all negative aspects to theist based philosophies--religion if you will (essentially) and all positive aspects to Non-theist philosophies. Sorta prejudicial viewpoint, I'd say...
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different.
...and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
Morals can come from philosophy or religion - agreed, but you seem to be saying that these are one and the same thing?
Phlosophy is based on reason and inquiry while religion discourages it.Depends on the religion, now doesn't it? Seems to me you attribute all negative aspects to theist based philosophies--religion if you will (essentially) and all positive aspects to Non-theist philosophies. Sorta prejudicial viewpoint, I'd say...
"prejudicial" ?.. No.... Skeptical yes.
You say "Depends on the religion, now doesn't it?"
I would say we don't have the scope to go into all the details of all religions, but it's fair to say religions generally are dogmatic and discourage free thinking and claim to have ALL the answers. I've already said that morals can come from religion which makes a nonsense of your "all negative" comment. All I'm saying (AGAIN) is faith heads seem to think they have a monopoly on all that is good and that they themselves show arrogance with the holier than thou attitude.
Just what exactly are you saying Mr Whippy?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Multiple philosophies can and do exist none of which is more or less correct--just different views of the same event. Example: One cannot credibly say that a Hindu's view of right and wrong is more correct than a Muslim's view of it or an atheist's view of it. Both are valid, but different.
...and to further the point, in the wild, when one of a pack of wolves attacks (and possibly kills) another member of the pack, there is no moral value placed on it by other members of the pack. It is simply a fact--and in general the pack continues on. That humans place a moral value on the same act, but with different moral meanings depending on situation, is indicative of morality's subjective nature.
Morals can come from philosophy or religion - agreed, but you seem to be saying that these are one and the same thing?
Phlosophy is based on reason and inquiry while religion discourages it.Depends on the religion, now doesn't it? Seems to me you attribute all negative aspects to theist based philosophies--religion if you will (essentially) and all positive aspects to Non-theist philosophies. Sorta prejudicial viewpoint, I'd say...
"prejudicial" ?.. No.... Skeptical yes.
At least you recognize you come to this discussion with a strong bias--and therefore your opinion is not impartial.
-
I hope my english is good enough to make me understood.
You know, here in Italy we live next door with the Pope, Church has voice, hands and pockets in law, school, government...
They asked to make a consultation fail -it was about assisted procreation- and they made it fail.I'm Atheist after 15 years grown Catholic, since when I began asking "why?".
I couldn't find answers involving a god -whichever- to the questions the world gives us, first of all "why bad things happen to good people?"
I've also tried to answer with faith only... and I found it also difficult. It is so difficult "you must believe in God because God wants so".
Religions were written by men for men. In many cases, MADE UP from previous myths.
Mayans ripped hearts for their gods, and they were GOOD people, at their eyes. Menads had orgies, that is a bit (a lot, I suppose, choice given) better, but the same...
Did you know that women have soul for one vote in a council, after many consultations, just because one of the voters fall ill?
That there are much more than 4 gospels, and the 4 we read now were chosen and sorted from an emperor that got baptized only in his death bed?
I really know better the inconsistencies in the bible, but, just to be fair...
did you know that the muslim prophet had a wife 9 years old?Then I look at what religion did to people, in history. Inquisition (nobody expected it), persecutions, books erased from human knowledge, WARS, one after another...
I know also that religion did some good. But it's no good that could not have been done from a person with only a good empathy and common sense.
I mean... what religion was Gandhi's? did it matter?I do not believe in god.
I believe there will be no hell, or no heaven (and I do not want an heaven where I'm so high I CAN'T be sad). We have just one dance, and it's better for us to dance as good as we can.
I believe that when two people love each other, there's no problem about their shape, sex, colour of whatsoever.
I believe that science was given to help us, so welcome to staminals, assisted procreation and so on. "Walk for a mile in my shoes..."
I believe that a man is the sum of its experiences, lives in his brain and is master of his life. I accept, even if I don't please them, euthanasia and abortion, because they are NOT easy choices.
I believe that we are basically good, because we share other people's joy, and there's no worst mistake than believing to be better than someother, even if God said so, because this make us think that OUR joy is more important of their's.
I believe that we learn and we teach from each other, and if something of what I believe in will be passed to my sons, or to my friends, because it was good and strong and joyful, well, I'll become immortal with them.Red button for me?
-
Imagination and Scepticism work well together.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


