Polite discussion on.........
-
@nuphoria said:
So, are people with faith happier than those without?Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
That's a very good point, and a good scientific point too. Course' just because something is nice dosen't make it true. It may be a grown up version of the "imaginary freind" thing.
People of faith don't seem more happier to me, if anything the more devout their beliefs the more bloody miserable they are.
-
So, are people with faith happier than those without?
Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
That's a very good point, and a good scientific point too. Course' just because something is nice dosen't make it true. It may be a grown up version of the "imaginary freind" thing.
I think it probably is for a lot of people - whatever works is good in my book though, as long as it doesn't mean you justify harming others as a result.
We non-believers could of course be wrong about it all, and I'm prepared to keep my eyes and ears open to any possible truths. -
I like to think of it in a different way:
I think one can observe the world around them and apply different models for different situations. In one instance, a Scientific model seems most appropriate. In another, some other philosophical/religious model works better. It's not an either/or situation, but more of an overlapping of perspective.
Afterall, let's not forget the in reality, the physical world just exists. Although the Scientific model explains it well, there is NOTHING about the physical world that dictates that it has to. Our scientific principles may only apply to our tiny little corner of the universe.
Heck, news from my daughter (in the land of quantum physics) is that we really live in a higher degree multidimensional universe (not just 4). The various models for this are some of the projects of CERN. (That whole "black hole" hoopla is apparently related to this particular discussion).
IMO, the Scientific Model is a highly useful tool for explaining how the physical world works, but is still just a tool.
-
Yes, the quantum world is a very strange and interesting world indeed. The LHC should give us some good stuff!
Somebody once said (can't remember who) " All there is is physics and opinions" I kinda like that - but that's just my opinion.
-
Science is a tool but then are worship, churches and bibles etc aren't they?
In fact, you could argue that religion itself as a construct is a tool; a means of surviving the unanswered mysteries of our universe. It's far to easy to go start raving bonkers when you try to reason it all through without believing in a higher power!
-
@nuphoria said:
So, are people with faith happier than those without?Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
LOL! Not at all. I was just saying that maybe the reason that people don't feel they have to prove their faith to those who ask them to is because they are happy just have faith and not worry about the details. And I'm talking about lay-people...not hardcore theological academic types. They worry about all the details! But they are also more open to accepting inconsistencies. Which is odd, if you think about it. And I'm not talking about zealots and extremists. What brought up that particular thought was that poll about how man was created. Some people just want to remain blissfully unaware so they don't have to prove their point to anyone. They just say "Cuz God said so". I don't agree with that, necessarily, but that's probably why.
I"m personally in the camp that believes that creationism and evolution coexist...as to which came first...well, people neither side of that particular coin are going to like my answer. :) -
@nuphoria said:
Science is a tool but then are worship, churches and bibles etc aren't they?In fact, you could argue that religion itself as a construct is a tool; a means of surviving the unanswered mysteries of our universe. It's far to easy to go start raving bonkers when you try to reason it all through without believing in a higher power!
Absolutely. Pretty arrogant for any specific religion to state that they know the TRUE intentions of God, eh? Highly unlikely to be some guy with a white beard and flowing robes too. And why a humanoid form? All highly unlikely.
-
So, are people with faith happier than those without?
Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
That's a very good point, and a good scientific point too. Course' just because something is nice dosen't make it true. It may be a grown up version of the "imaginary freind" thing.
People of faith don't seem more happier to me, if anything the more devout their beliefs the more bloody miserable they are.
Actually I am probably 1 of the happier ppl you will meet so you have no foundation in that
If you want to talk about religion then perhaps you should do less judging and more listeningJust throwing that out there
-
I wanted to apologize. I think I may have stuck my foot in my mouth and I didn't mean to. All I meant by the not having to prove your happy thing was that some people are happy or content to follow whatever they have been raised to believe and that's enough for them. I didn't mean to imply at all that non religious people are the only happy people...just that they don't feel the need to prove anything to anyone. That often leads to a rather narrow view of life, but it works for them. I don't agree with it, but unless it's being directed at me, I'm not going to tell them differently. I can get my dander up about a whole lot of things and religion is one of them. But usually if that happens I''m shouting just as loudly as the other guy...telling him/her that hate, bigotry, condemnation, and segregation are not the primary message of Christianity. But those instances are few and far between. Generally speaking I can have a very meaningful conversation with someone even if they don't agree with me or vice versa.
So, I'm sorry if my point wasn't made clear. I understand that Paul and others may think that any religion is just another myth that in 1000 years (assuming humanity is still here) is going to be regarded as obsolete, but beautiful traditions. I'm not right, I'll concede that.
-
So, are people with faith happier than those without?
Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
That's a very good point, and a good scientific point too. Course' just because something is nice dosen't make it true. It may be a grown up version of the "imaginary freind" thing.
People of faith don't seem more happier to me, if anything the more devout their beliefs the more bloody miserable they are.
Actually I am probably 1 of the happier ppl you will meet so you have no foundation in that
If you want to talk about religion then perhaps you should do less judging and more listeningJust throwing that out there
I can only give my opinions based on my observations: if you're saying you are very religious and very happy, fine, just say that and don't tell me how to think.

ps your sig is not an American Indian quote I take it?
-
Not judging here either, even though I have had a fairly broad education on the subject and it's what works for me. :)
I was raised by non-believers but in a Jewish family so took part in a lot of that. I spent 6 years at a Catholic school and came out unscathed from that too. I have held hands with pagans in stone circles, meditated with Buddhists, listened to the Jehovas at Kingdom Hall, living with a Christian partner and countless other interesting experiences - none of it is for me on a seriously committed level, that's what I do know.
I was under the impression this was a debate of our thoughts and observations, not an exercise in telling people what to do. We only have our individual experiences to draw upon and they are unique to each of us are they not?
-
So, are people with faith happier than those without?
Or maybe there's a catch 22 there as perhaps people who are unhappy might be more likely to desire faith in something.... just throwing it out there :)
That's a very good point, and a good scientific point too. Course' just because something is nice dosen't make it true. It may be a grown up version of the "imaginary freind" thing.
People of faith don't seem more happier to me, if anything the more devout their beliefs the more bloody miserable they are.
Actually I am probably 1 of the happier ppl you will meet so you have no foundation in that
If you want to talk about religion then perhaps you should do less judging and more listeningJust throwing that out there
I can only give my opinions based on my observations: if you're saying you are very religious and very happy, fine, just say that and don't tell me how to think.

ps your sig is not an American Indian quote I take it?
I do have American Indian heritage not alot but some
I am not telling you how to think but I have never pushed my beliefs on this forum not once it is a way of life for me as your belief or lack thereof is your way of life seems to me you are taking offense to ppl telling of there faith and beliefs and your the person who started the thread to have a polite discussion and would seem you have been anything but that too my beliefs as I have said nothing of yours out of the way
-
@GraysonK said:
I wanted to apologize. I think I may have stuck my foot in my mouth and I didn't mean to. All I meant by the not having to prove your happy thing was that some people are happy or content to follow whatever they have been raised to believe and that's enough for them. I didn't mean to imply at all that non religious people are the only happy people...just that they don't feel the need to prove anything to anyone. That often leads to a rather narrow view of life, but it works for them. I don't agree with it, but unless it's being directed at me, I'm not going to tell them differently. I can get my dander up about a whole lot of things and religion is one of them. But usually if that happens I''m shouting just as loudly as the other guy...telling him/her that hate, bigotry, condemnation, and segregation are not the primary message of Christianity. But those instances are few and far between. Generally speaking I can have a very meaningful conversation with someone even if they don't agree with me or vice versa.So, I'm sorry if my point wasn't made clear. I understand that Paul and others may think that any religion is just another myth that in 1000 years (assuming humanity is still here) is going to be regarded as obsolete, but beautiful traditions. I'm not right, I'll concede that.
@nuphoria said:
Not judging here either, even though I have had a fairly broad education on the subject and it's what works for me. :)I was raised by non-believers but in a Jewish family so took part in a lot of that. I spent 6 years at a Catholic school and came out unscathed from that too. I have held hands with pagans in stone circles, meditated with Buddhists, listened to the Jehovas at Kingdom Hall, living with a Christian partner and countless other interesting experiences - none of it is for me on a seriously committed level, that's what I do know.
I was under the impression this was a debate of our thoughts and observations, not an exercise in telling people what to do. We only have our individual experiences to draw upon and they are unique to each of us are they not?
If either was for me I have taken no offense to anything said by either was just putting out my POV as well :D
-
Hello All
A few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.
AL
-
@Poncho65 said:
If either was for me I have taken no offense to anything said by either was just putting out my POV as well :DPartly for you, but certainly not meant to chastise or offend in any way, just to try and keep this rather precarious thread on track! ;)
It's a tall order when we are fundamentally unlikely to agree on actual beliefs, although most people are more than capable of having this conversation without causing offence :)
-
@american lockpicker said:
Hello AllA few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.
AL

-
@american lockpicker said:
Hello AllA few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.
AL
Thanks for that ALP. :)
-
@american lockpicker said:
Hello AllA few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.
AL
So, because you found out you know a single Muslim online, you've decided you don't hate them all?
As long as you're still comfortable being a homophobe and causing offence with those opinions, that makes everything OK then.I'm only posting this comment publicly as you decided to go that way with yours which opens it to public debate in my mind. Sorry if the mods disagree with that - I won't be mentioning this subject again.

-
Hi all! I've done a bit of religion/philosophy discussion online, and I have to say this one has been rather civilized so far.
Here's four points I've learned along the way... And IMO the best discussions happen between people who have taken these ideas to heart; especially whichever two would naturally be offensive to hear.1)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
2)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
3)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science.
4)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
