Polite discussion on.........
-
@american lockpicker said:
Hello AllA few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.
AL
So, because you found out you know a single Muslim online, you've decided you don't hate them all?
As long as you're still comfortable being a homophobe and causing offence with those opinions, that makes everything OK then.I'm only posting this comment publicly as you decided to go that way with yours which opens it to public debate in my mind. Sorry if the mods disagree with that - I won't be mentioning this subject again.

-
Hi all! I've done a bit of religion/philosophy discussion online, and I have to say this one has been rather civilized so far.
Here's four points I've learned along the way... And IMO the best discussions happen between people who have taken these ideas to heart; especially whichever two would naturally be offensive to hear.1)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
2)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
3)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science.
4)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science. -
Sorry for the double post. :ahhh
-
Human beings of any an all faiths have about equal propensity to let their stupid show .
Chris
-
Human beings of any an all faiths have about equal propensity to let their stupid show .
Chris
I already apologized for the double post. I wish you'd let it go.
:D ::) >:D

-
@american lockpicker said:
@american lockpicker said:
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.
In case you missed it.
It wasn't missed ALP. It's just that after so many prejudicial comments and opinions from you since you've been here, we wonder about your sincerity. Are you really sorry? Have you really changed? It will take more than an apologetic post or two to convince anyone. :-\
-
@american lockpicker said:
@american lockpicker said:
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.
In case you missed it.
It wasn't missed ALP. It's just that after so many prejudicial comments and opinions from you since you've been here, we wonder about your sincerity. Are you really sorry? Have you really changed? It will take more than an apologetic post or two to convince anyone. :-\
Not to seem like ganging up on you ALP, but they are right. If you have changed then it will be obvious.
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
Hi all! I've done a bit of religion/philosophy discussion online, and I have to say this one has been rather civilized so far.
Here's four points I've learned along the way... And IMO the best discussions happen between people who have taken these ideas to heart; especially whichever two would naturally be offensive to hear.1)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
2)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Religion.
3)Terrible things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science.
4)Wonderful things have been added to human history in the name of Atheism/Science.You incorrectly class atheism and science as one belief tool. Although they are compatible, some believe that religion and science are also compatible.
And, I can not think of any examples of “bad things done in the name of atheism” or science for that matter: but plenty of bad things done in the name of religion.Question: If a person does a good thing (or does not do a bad thing) just because he/she beleives in a god - and thinks along the lines of a nice reward or punishment - is he/she not being selfish?
Why not do good for the sake of good, and not seek a pat on the back from god?
-
@Paul said:
You incorrectly class atheism and science as one belief tool. Although they are compatible, some believe that religion and science are also compatible.
And, I can not think of any examples of “bad things done in the name of atheism” or science for that matter: but plenty of bad things done in the name of religion.Question: If a person does a good thing (or does not do a bad thing) just because he/she beleives in a god - and thinks along the lines of a nice reward or punishment - is he/she not being selfish?
Why not do good for the sake of good, and not seek a pat on the back from god?
Eugenics. You can thank me for that one later.

-
Question: Is there any time in the history of man in which religion had a legitimate place in society?
Question: Do you think that science is entirely altruistic?
Science, like religion, can be beneficial to mankind or harmful depending on who is practicing it. And one person's "good deed" may not be interpreted as such by another.
And a random kind of question: Do you think there would be any different cultures out there if it wasn't for religion? So many of the world's cultures are very much based on their religious histories.
Incidentally, I'm not arguing that everyone should be or is "religious". Not at all. I'm just saying that religion is very important to some people for a variety of reasons and that for the most part it doesn't hurt anyone. For the most part. I will be the first one to agree that horrible things have been done in the name of various religions. Christianity in particular. Heck I just watched a documentary on the "Witch's Hammer" and I'm appalled the things that occurred. But while I hate those things, I did not do them. Nor do I believe that any deity would condone such violence and hatred. I hate the bigotry and hatred of this country's past, its present, and most likely the future. I'm a target of a lot of it. And while the people participating in that bigotry tell me that God hates me, I don't hate God. I can't. Maybe it's a psychological need to feel that I'm loved by an omnipotent being in the face of so much hate. It just works for me. Science is not making it go away. -
@american lockpicker said:
@american lockpicker said:
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.
In case you missed it.
It wasn't missed ALP. It's just that after so many prejudicial comments and opinions from you since you've been here, we wonder about your sincerity. Are you really sorry? Have you really changed? It will take more than an apologetic post or two to convince anyone. :-\
Not to seem like ganging up on you ALP, but they are right. If you have changed then it will be obvious.
I will need time to change it won't happen over night.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
You incorrectly class atheism and science as one belief tool. Although they are compatible, some believe that religion and science are also compatible.
And, I can not think of any examples of “bad things done in the name of atheism” or science for that matter: but plenty of bad things done in the name of religion.Question: If a person does a good thing (or does not do a bad thing) just because he/she beleives in a god - and thinks along the lines of a nice reward or punishment - is he/she not being selfish?
Why not do good for the sake of good, and not seek a pat on the back from god?
Eugenics. You can thank me for that one later.

And to add to that, there have been some (truly) awful things done in some communist states to stamp out religion in favor of the state-approved atheism, and there's no excuse for that. The major communist countries of the 20th century also provide ample refute against the idea that atheism, or the absence of religion, will cause free speech and free thinking to flourish.
(I will add that I am in no way defending religion when it has been wrong, or taking away from the beneficial things that atheism/science has brought)
And I agree that lumping Atheism & Science together is too broad to have much meaning. So is lumping all Religion together. The point of my "four points" is essentially that people who react against them are usually operating in an US/THEM mentality, and not ready to see anyone else's side yet. It's a starting point to really realize that your "side" has done wrong, and the other side has done right.
-
@american lockpicker said:
@american lockpicker said:
[quote author=american lockpicker link=topic=15483.msg293732#msg293732 date=1259605709]
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.In case you missed it.
It wasn't missed ALP. It's just that after so many prejudicial comments and opinions from you since you've been here, we wonder about your sincerity. Are you really sorry? Have you really changed? It will take more than an apologetic post or two to convince anyone. :-\
Not to seem like ganging up on you ALP, but they are right. If you have changed then it will be obvious.
I will need time to change it won't happen over night.
[/quote]OK - I saw your posts last night before I went to bed, and decided to think about whether I should reply or not. Bob is spot on with his assessment ALP, but I'll add something too.
I think that you recognise that religious intolerance and homophobia offends people, but I'm not convinced that you actually understand what's actually *wrong * with that kind of thinking. You won't get away with pretending that you have seen the light, people will see through it, trust me.
Even the words you chose to apologise have little caveats in there:
@american lockpicker said:
Since this is related to another thread I would like sincerely apologise about my comments about homosexuality I made an attempt to be neutral on it and failed miserably. I'm sorry that I offended you Nuphoria or anyone else.... and ...
@american lockpicker said:
A few days back I made some comments of about a people of a certain faith, since then I discovered that one of my friends on another forum is of that faith. I would like to admit I was wrong when I judged everyone who is a muslim based on the actions of a small radical minority. I should not have done that. While its not easy to unlearn prejudices I am now willing to start now. I still don't like radicals of any religion(including my own) and that won't change but from now on I will try to be more tolerant as they do not represent everyone who shares some of the same beliefs that they do.It's not a question of being neutral, or unlearning anything, it's about being tolerant. Nobody is asking or expecting you to convert to Islam or become a homosexual, and you in turn should not expect people to relinquish their faith or keep their sexuality "in their own homes", as you put it on the other thread. There's nothing to learn, and no process of change over time. You either get it, or you don't.
Personally, I hope you do now get it, because bigotry in any way, shape or form cannot be justified. I consider people who think that way to be well below civilised people on the evolutionary scale. Scum in fact.
I do appreciate that you have made some attempt to apologise, even if I'm a little sceptical, but I'm a white, non-religious, heterosexual - I wasn't on the receiving end of your comments!
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
And to add to that, there have been some (truly) awful things done in some communist states to stamp out religion in favor of the state-approved atheism, and there's no excuse for that. The major communist countries of the 20th century also provide ample refute against the idea that atheism, or the absence of religion, will cause free speech and free thinking to flourish.Having spent first 21 years of my life in one of the above-mentioned states, I would lilke to add my perspective on the subject. Oppression of the religious freedoms of individuals notwithstanding, I strongly believe that suppression of religion in the former USSR was a progressive thing. Social advancements (immediate women's suffrage, etc.), scientific research, and industrialization that followed the 1917 communist revolution were, in my opinion, quite beneficial to the development of society.
The problem is that communism, for all practical purposes, is also a religion, but with one critical flaw. Rather than exploiting the "human nature" with the carrot and stick approach of the "traditional religions", the idea of communism relies on the collective and individual concience and morals to be developed to a level which was (and still is) not practical for any group of people larger than a family. Deterioration of the communist religion resulted in the fall of the USSR, and the vacuum was promptly filled by the "traditional" religions. It is actually quite comical to see all the former Russian communist leaders visiting church nowadays.
-
And to add to that, there have been some (truly) awful things done in some communist states to stamp out religion in favor of the state-approved atheism, and there's no excuse for that. The major communist countries of the 20th century also provide ample refute against the idea that atheism, or the absence of religion, will cause free speech and free thinking to flourish.
Having spent first 21 years of my life in one of the above-mentioned states, I would lilke to add my perspective on the subject. Oppression of the religious freedoms of individuals notwithstanding, I strongly believe that suppression of religion in the former USSR was a progressive thing. Social advancements (immediate women's suffrage, etc.), scientific research, and industrialization that followed the 1917 communist revolution were, in my opinion, quite beneficial to the development of society.
The problem is that communism, for all practical purposes, is also a religion, but with one critical flaw. Rather than exploiting the "human nature" with the carrot and stick approach of the "traditional religions", the idea of communism relies on the collective and individual concience and morals to be developed to a level which was (and still is) not practical for any group of people larger than a family. Deterioration of the communist religion resulted in the fall of the USSR, and the vacuum was promptly filled by the "traditional" religions. It is actually quite comical to see all the former Russian communist leaders visiting church nowadays.
When you look at how capitalism is now in the USA would you say that its still preferable to communism or that both systems have their flaws and we need something completely different or what? If a mod has a problem with this delete it and I'll use PM.
-
Nope, I'd like to hear Alexei's thoughts on that question too. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
